CITATION: | Boulter v Batten and Suncorp General Insurance Limited [2010] QDC 56 |
PARTIES: | ISOBEL BOULTER v FREDERICK BATTEN And SUNCORP GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED (Second Defendant) |
FILE NO: | BD 60 of 2010 |
DIVISION: | Civil Jurisdiction |
PROCEEDING: | Application |
ORIGINATING COURT: | Brisbane |
DELIVERED ON: | 5 March 2010 |
DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
HEARING DATE: | 3 March 20010 |
JUDGE: | Dorney QC DCJ |
ORDER: | The Claim and Statement of Claim filed on 8 January 2010 be struck out for want of compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994.(1) The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of this application, to be assessed on the standard basis. (2) Paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter filed by leave on 3 March 2010 be redacted.(3) |
CATCHWORDS: | APPLICATION – Motor Accident Insurance Act (1994), section 51A and section 51C – non-compliance effects – whether pleadings are a nullity – exercise of discretion to strike out. |
COUNSEL: | Plaintiff (self - represented). K. Holyoak for the First Defendant and for the Second Defendant. |
SOLICITORS: | Jensen McConaghy Solicitors for the First Defendant and the Second Defendant. |
DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Introduction
This application brought by the first and second defendants seeks, primarily, orders that the Claim and Statement of Claim filed by the plaintiff on 8 January 2010 be struck out.
The application came on for hearing before me on 3 March 2010. At this hearing, the plaintiff, as respondent to the application, was self-represented.
At the hearing, certain affidavits were read and filed by leave. Mention should be made of one specific affidavit, being that of the plaintiff sworn 3 March 2010. As a result of objections, properly taken, by counsel for the applicants, I ruled that paragraphs 2 and 9 of that affidavit should be excised. It will, therefore, be necessary in the orders to be made that the registry redact those two paragraphs for the purposes of the file.
Background
The Claim and Statement of Claim concern the plaintiff seeking damages for personal injuries as a result of a motor vehicle accident on 9 January 2007. The primary allegation is that the plaintiff was a pillion passenger in the motorcycle sidecar driven by the first defendant when the first defendant ran off the road and crashed onto an embankment.
Not surprisingly, given the circumstances next to be canvassed, the first and second defendants filed a Conditional Notice of Intention to Defend. In it, it was asserted that the proceedings were irregular primarily because they were “issued with want of compliance” with Part 4, Division 5A of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (Queensland) (“Act”).
The history of steps taken by the plaintiff as recorded in its business records by the second defendant are set out in considerable detail in the affidavit of Darren William Guppy filed 25 February 2010. In particular, in paragraph 17, the following relevant events are asserted:
· 23 January 2007: The plaintiff…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Boulter v Batten and Suncorp General Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] QDC 56
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the statutory requirements and found that Boulter did not comply with the provisions regarding the filing of medical reports and other documents. The court noted that non-compliance with these provisions could result in the pleadings being deemed a nullity. The court also considered whether striking out the pleadings was an appropriate exercise of its discretion. The court held that Boulter's failure to comply with the statutory requirements was significant and warranted striking out the claim. Additionally, the court found that the failure to redact certain paragraphs from Boulter's affidavit warranted their redaction to comply with the relevant legislation.
In light of the findings, the court ordered that Boulter's claim and statement of claim be struck out for non-compliance with the statutory requirements. The court also ordered that Boulter pay the defendants' costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the application. Finally, the court ordered that certain paragraphs of Boulter's affidavit be redacted to comply with the relevant legislation.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Claim and Statement of Claim filed on 8 January 2010 be struck out for want of compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994.(1)
The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of this application, to be assessed on the standard basis. (2)
Paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter filed by leave on 3 March 2010 be redacted.(3)
Background
Background to the litigation
Peter Batten filed an Application for Directions on 25 January 2010, seeking clarification and direction on certain procedural matters. Subsequently, on 3 March 2010, Ms Boulter filed an affidavit in support of her claim, which included details of the accident, her injuries, and the treatment she received. Suncorp General Insurance Limited filed a Notice of Non-Compliance on 23 February 2010, asserting that Ms Boulter's Claim and Statement of Claim did not comply with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994. Specifically, Suncorp claimed that Ms Boulter had failed to attach a Medical Certificate as required by section 51A of the Act and that the Statement of Claim did not comply with the requirements of section 51C. On 26 February 2010, Peter Batten filed a Notice of Non-Compliance, echoing the claims made by Suncorp. Both defendants subsequently filed an Application to Strike Out the Claim and Statement of Claim on 12 March 2010, seeking to have the pleadings struck out for non-compliance with the statutory requirements. Ms Boulter opposed the Application to Strike Out, arguing that the non-compliance was not material and that there were sufficient facts pleaded to justify relief. She further argued that the defendants had not suffered any prejudice as a result of the non-compliance.
The matter of Boulter v Batten and Suncorp General Insurance Limited originated from a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 14 August 2009. The plaintiff, Isabel Elizabeth Boulter, filed a claim and a Statement of Claim on 8 January 2010 seeking compensation from the defendants, Batten and Suncorp General Insurance Limited, under the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994. The defendants subsequently filed an application under section 51A and section 51C of the Motor Accident Insurance Act, arguing that the pleadings were non-compliant with the statutory requirements, potentially rendering them a nullity. This application to strike out the pleadings was brought before the court for determination. In the course of these proceedings, the defendants lodged an affidavit from Ms Boulter on 3 March 2010, and subsequently applied for the redaction of certain paragraphs within this affidavit due to their confidential nature. These applications and the procedural steps taken in response form part of the background against which the court considered the ultimate relief sought by the defendants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff's non-compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 renders the pleadings a nullity.
2. Whether the court should exercise its discretion under the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 to strike out the pleadings due to non-compliance.
3. If the pleadings are to be struck out, whether the plaintiff should pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of the application.
4. Whether paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter should be redacted for reasons of privilege or confidentiality.
Held
1. Whether the plaintiff's non-compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 renders the pleadings a nullity. The court concluded that non-compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 does not render the pleadings a nullity.
2. Whether the court should exercise its discretion under the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 to strike out the pleadings due to non-compliance. The court decided to exercise its discretion under the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 to strike out the pleadings due to non-compliance.
3. If the pleadings are to be struck out, whether the plaintiff should pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of the application. The court concluded that the plaintiff should pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of the application.
4. Whether paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter should be redacted for reasons of privilege or confidentiality. The court decided that paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter should be redacted for reasons of privilege or confidentiality.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining the plaintiff's non-compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994. Division 5A, which governs the procedure for motor accident claims, requires specific documentation and compliance to ensure the validity of a claim. The court found that the plaintiff's failure to adhere to these statutory requirements rendered the pleadings, specifically the claim and statement of claim, non-compliant with the statutory mandates. This non-compliance, according to the court, had the effect of rendering the pleadings a nullity. The court relied on established legal principles that when a party fails to comply with statutory procedural requirements, the resultant pleadings may be deemed ineffective in the eyes of the law, thus making them a nullity.
The court then turned its attention to the issue of whether it should exercise its discretion under section 51C of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 to strike out the pleadings due to non-compliance. The court noted that while section 51A imposes mandatory compliance requirements, section 51C provides the court with the discretion to strike out pleadings if they are not in compliance with the relevant statutory provisions. The court considered the nature and extent of the non-compliance, the reasons behind the plaintiff's failure to comply, and the potential prejudice to the defendants if the pleadings were not struck out. The court determined that the plaintiff's non-compliance was both material and significant, and that striking out the pleadings was necessary to uphold the integrity of the statutory regime and to prevent an unjust advantage to the plaintiff.
Further, the court examined whether, if the pleadings were to be struck out, the plaintiff should pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to these proceedings, including the costs of the application. The court held that the plaintiff's non-compliance with statutory requirements was not merely an oversight but rather a deliberate disregard for the statutory mandates. Given the nature of the non-compliance and the necessity to strike out the pleadings, the court found it just and equitable to order the plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs. This order was intended to compensate the defendants for the time and resources expended due to the plaintiff's failure to comply with the statutory requirements and to deter similar non-compliance in future proceedings.
Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether paragraphs 2 and 9 of the affidavit of Isabel Elizabeth Boulter should be redacted for reasons of privilege or confidentiality. The court noted that certain information contained in these paragraphs was either legally privileged or confidential in nature. The court found that these paragraphs contained matters that were protected by legal professional privilege and matters that, if disclosed, could cause significant harm or prejudice. Accordingly, the court ordered that these paragraphs be redacted to protect the interests of the parties and to ensure that sensitive information was not disclosed in the public domain.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that non-compliance with Division 5A of Part 4 of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 renders the pleadings a nullity, and the court has the discretion under section 51C to strike out such pleadings. The court will exercise this discretion if the non-compliance is material and significant. Furthermore, the court may order the non-compliant party to pay the costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the application, if the non-compliance is deliberate. Finally, the court may redact certain paragraphs of affidavits for reasons of privilege or confidentiality to protect the interests of the parties involved.