Bou and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

Bou and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2781 (22 December 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/6113

Re:Mr Chanphanna Bou

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

Date:22 December 2017  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

MIGRATION – cancellation of visa – substantial criminal record – failure to pass character test – violent and repeat nature of offending – unacceptable risk of reoffending – risk to the Australian community established – where Australian community would expect application to be refused –  best interests of minor children in Australia – decision affirmed

Legislation

Migration Act 1958

Cases

Taulahi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 177; (2016) 246 FCR 146
Akpata v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 65
Uelese v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 348; (2016) 69 AAR 8 Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583

Re Waits and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] AATA 1336

Secondary Materials

Ministerial Direction No 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

22 December 2017

  1. Mr Chanphanna Bou seeks review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 20 September 2017, to cancel his visa under section 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act). The delegate found that Mr Bou did not pass the character test by virtue of sections 501(6)(a) and 501(7)(d) of the Act, as a consequence of his criminal convictions and imprisonment.

  2. The hearing was conducted on 18 December 2017. The Applicant was represented by Mr Guy Gilbert SC of counsel, instructed by Bardo Lawyers. The Respondent was represented by Mr Tal Aviram, a solicitor from Clayton Utz.

  3. For the reasons that follow, I have decided to affirm the decision under review.

    BACKGROUND

  4. Mr Bou was born in Cambodia on 23 July 1985 and is a citizen of that country. He arrived in Australia on 16 July 2000[1] and is currently 32 years of age. He held a Class AH Subclass 101 Child Visa from arrival in Australia until it was cancelled on 20 September 2017.

    [1] G Documents numbering 93 pages and hereafter referred to as Exhibit R1, p.34.

  5. On 4 August 2017 Mr Bou received a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation of his visa (the Notice),[2] referring to and enclosing a copy of a National Police Certificate dated 21 June 2017. That certificate details a number of criminal convictions as follows:

    [2] Exhibit R1, pp.30-32.

COURT

COURT DATE

OFFENCE

COURT RESULT

Dandenong Magistrates’ Court

02 Nov 2016

Contravene Family Violence Final Intervention Order – Intentionally Cause Harm / Fear.

Possess heroin.

Contravene Community Correction Order.

Breach re 11/01/2016.

Threat to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bou and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2781
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned Mr Bou, a Cambodian citizen whose visa was cancelled by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on the grounds that he had a substantial criminal record. Mr Bou sought review of this decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, arguing that the delegate had failed to properly exercise the discretion available under section 501(2) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) by not taking into account all relevant circumstances as guided by Ministerial Direction No. 65.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the delegate had properly exercised the discretion under section 501(2) of the Act. This required the Tribunal to consider whether Mr Bou passed the character test, and if not, to then apply the considerations outlined in Ministerial Direction No. 65 to determine whether to exercise the discretion to cancel his visa. The Tribunal was mandated to comply with this Direction pursuant to section 499(2A) of the Act.

The Tribunal found that Mr Bou did not pass the character test due to his substantial criminal record, which included multiple terms of imprisonment totalling 12 months or more. In considering the exercise of discretion under section 501(2), the Tribunal weighed various factors, including Mr Bou's criminal history, his lack of memory regarding some offences, his ongoing struggles with anger management and substance abuse, and his limited ties to Cambodia. Countervailing considerations included the impact on his mother and children, and his expressed desire to cease drug use and alcohol consumption. However, the Tribunal ultimately determined that the primary considerations of protecting the Australian community from the risk of further violent conduct and the expectations of the Australian community outweighed these other factors.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to cancel Mr Bou's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I have decided to affirm the decision under review.BACKGROUND Mr Bou was born in Cambodia on 23 July 1985 and is a citizen of that country. He arrived in Australia on 16 July 2000[1] and is currently 32 years of age. He held a Class AH Subclass 101 Child Visa from arrival in Australia until it was cancelled on 20 September 2017. [1] G Documents numbering 93 pages and hereafter referred to as Exhibit R1, p.34. On 4 August 2017 Mr Bou received a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation of his visa (the Notice),[2] referring to and enclosing a copy of a National Police Certificate dated 21 June 2017. That certificate details a number of criminal convictions as follows:[2] Exhibit R1, pp.30-32. Mr Bou was invited to respond to the Notice and did so via a Personal Circumstances Form dated 11 August 2017 (Personal Circumstances Form).[3] After considering his response, a delegate of the Minister decided to cancel Mr Bou’s visa, notifying him of the decision on 11 October 2017.[4] [3] Exhibit R1, pp.50-60.[4] Exhibit R1, pp.10-13. By application dated 16 October 2017, Mr Bou asked the Tribunal to review the delegate’s decision, submitting that:the delegate failed to exercise the discretion available to him under s501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 by failing to take into account all relevant circumstances as guided by Ministerial Direction no. 65. LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 501(2) of the Act provides for the Minister or their delegate to cancel a visa if the Minister reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test, and the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test. The Tribunal’s jurisdiction to review such decisions is provided for at section 500(1)(b) of the Act. The term character test is defined at section 501(6) of the Act. A person does not pass the character test if any one of the 11 sets of circumstances detailed in that section applies to them. A delegate of the Minister has cancelled Mr Bou’s visa on the basis that he has ‘a substantial criminal record,’ within the meaning of section 501(7)(d) of the Act, in that he has been ‘sentenced to 2 or more terms of imprisonment, where the total of those terms is 12 months or more.’DIRECTION No. 65 If an applicant does not pass the character test, this enlivens a discretion under section 501(2) of the Act whether or not to cancel the person’s visa. Guidance in exercising the discretion is found in Ministerial Direction No 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA (the Direction). Section 499(2A) of the Act mandates that the Tribunal must comply with the Direction (see Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583 at 591, per Katz J). Paragraph 6.1 of the Direction sets out the following objectives:6.1 Objectives(1) The objective of the Act is to regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, and presence in, Australia of non-citizens.(2) Under subsection 501(1) of the Act, a non-citizen may be refused a visa if the non-citizen does not satisfy the decision-maker that they pass the character test. A non-citizen may have their visa cancelled under subsection 501(2) if the decision-maker reasonably suspects that the non-citizen does not pass the character test, and the non-citizen does not satisfy the decision-maker that they pass the character test. Where the discretion to refuse to grant or to cancel a visa is enlivened, the decision-maker must consider whether to exercise the discretion to refuse or cancel the visa given the specific circumstances of the case.…(4) The purpose of this Direction is to guide decision-makers performing functions or exercising powers under section 501 of the Act, to refuse to grant a visa or cancel a visa of a non-citizen who does not satisfy the decision-maker that the non-citizen passes the character test, or to revoke a mandatory cancellation under section 501CA of the Act. Under section 499(2A) of the Act, such decision-makers must comply with a direction made under section 499.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Bou, his mother, his godmother, and the biological aunt of his step-brothers (a close family friend) submitted statements and gave oral evidence at the hearing as follows: (a)Evidence of Mr Chanphanna Bou. (i)I have had regard for Mr Bou’s Statutory Declaration, which was taken into evidence.[9] He also gave oral evidence at the hearing with the assistance of a Cambodian interpreter and was cross-examined. [9] Statement of Mr Chanphanna Bou dated 24 November 2017 (Exhibit A1).(ii)Mr Bou said he had never worked since arriving in Australia and receives a Disability Support Pension. He submits that he has not returned to Cambodia since 2000 and apart from his grandmother and approximately 5-6 aunts and uncles, has no other relatives there. He submits that he has not been in contact with his Cambodian relatives or school friends, whose contact details he has lost. Mr Bou stated that his grandmother is almost 80 years of age and ‘couldn’t do much’ because of her health. When asked if he could live with her if returned to Cambodia, Mr Bou replied: ‘only her – I don’t have anybody else,’ but he expressed concern that if he ‘became sick, who can look after me?’ (iii)Mr Bou was taken through his criminal history, but often responded that he was unable to remember due to his epilepsy or the passage of time. When asked about a violent incident he was involved in requiring police attendance in January 2008, he stated: ‘I don’t know what I did – I went out with my friends – I forgot what I did.’ When asked if he could remember repeatedly punching his mother in the face and head during that incident, Mr Bou replied ‘I can’t remember that.’ When asked if he had taken up a knife during this incident, he responded: ‘it was a long time ago, I don’t remember.’ Mr Bou was also unable to recall many of the circumstances relating to his offending in 2011 and 2015, but was able to recall an incident in June 2015, when he chased his stepfather from the house with a meat cleaver. He stated: ‘Yes I remember that, but I didn’t chop him, I just chased him.’ Mr Bou was also taken through his breach of a Family Violence Safety Notice in late 2015, responding that he had breached it because ‘I missed my mum and I wanted to see her and see my daughter and son.’ When asked why he stopped attending court-ordered sessions linked to his Community Corrections Order (CCO) after only a few meetings, he replied ‘I can’t remember.’ In relation to an incident in September 2016 where he was heard yelling aggressively at his mother while holding a machete, Mr Bou responded: ‘I just wanted the whole family to be quiet.’(iv)Mr Bou was asked why he wasn’t released from prison when eligible for parole in December 2016, responding that he couldn’t read English and had not been told about bail applications. When it was pointed out to him that his parole application was in the Corrections Victoria file, Mr Bou agreed he had applied for parole with the assistance of ‘Legal Aid.’ Mr Bou also agreed that Corrections Victoria had recorded his involvement in verbal and physical aggression on a number of occasions while imprisoned, and that he had been assessed by prison authorities as being a high risk of re-offending. In response to questions about an incident on 6 June 2017 where he struck another prisoner in the head while holding pool balls, Mr Bou responded: ‘If I don’t do that he’ll hit me. I can’t just stand there – he’s the one who said something to make me angry – teasing me…they tease me all those Aussie people.’ (v)Mr Bou submitted that ‘living in prison is like living in the dark…if I don’t protect myself they will keep attacking me or bullying me.’ When asked if he had gotten angry and decided to hit the other prisoner, Mr Bou responded ‘yes,’ contending that ‘all those problems in prison making my anger getting worse…’. When asked why he had become angry in prison, Mr Bou said he wanted to come out and see his family, but in prison he couldn’t do anything. When asked if he felt angry often, Mr Bou responded: ‘yes, when someone comes to try and talk to me, but I try and close my mouth and not talk.’ Mr Bou submitted that he had not completed any rehabilitation courses relating to drugs, alcohol or anger management in the past.(vi)When asked about reports from his general practitioner about non-compliance with epilepsy medication, Mr Bou stated that he sometimes forgot to take it, but now took it daily.[10] In response to questions about his alcohol use, Mr Bou initially said he only drank occasionally and ‘not until drunk.’ In response to subsequent questions, however, he agreed that his consumption of alcohol in the past had resulted in a pattern of alcoholic blackouts. When asked why he had denied alcohol problems while in prison, he stated ‘they didn’t ask me about alcohol.’ When it was pointed out that Corrections Victoria had noted on 8 November 2016 that Mr Bou ‘denied any history of problematic alcohol use,’ Mr Bou responded: ‘I forget – it was a long time ago.’ [10] General Practitioner reports contained within Exhibit A11.(vii)Mr Bou was also referred to a St Vincent’s Hospital discharge summary, which states: ‘’…displays some anger when discussing his victims. Says that he has trouble managing his anger but will try to do so.’[11] Mr Bou acknowledged the report and his inability to control his anger while in prison, but stated: ‘now I don’t have any trouble controlling my anger anymore. I know how to control it.’ In relation to conflict with his three step-brothers, Mr Bou said he felt no anger towards them and even though plans were in place to keep him separated from his step-brothers, he claimed not to ‘have any problems’ with them.[11] Exhibit A11, p.31. St Vincent’s Hospital discharge summary dated 11 September 2017.(viii)Mr Bou said he had no contact with his former wife and that arrangements to see his children were coordinated by his mother. He said he had not seen his children for ‘over two weeks,’ since they had visited him in the detention centre. When given an opportunity to describe his relationship with his children, Mr Bou responded: ‘I like to ask them what they like to play and I play with them.’ In response to questions, Mr Bou was ‘not sure’ if his former wife had formed another relationship. He ‘forgot’ what grade his children were at in school or when he last took them to the movies, or what they saw. He was ‘not sure’ about the financial contribution he made to the living expenses of his children. If allowed to remain in Australia, Mr Bou said he would stop taking heroin, would only drink alcohol occasionally, avoid contact with his step-brothers, change ‘past mistakes to do good things,’ and see his children more frequently.(b)Evidence of Ms Mary Bou. (i)A Statutory Declaration from Ms Mary Bou, the Applicant’s mother, was taken into evidence.[12] She also gave oral evidence at the hearing with the assistance of a Cambodian interpreter. Ms Bou is a 59 year old woman who lives with her three male children aged 23, 25 and 27. They are all employed and assist their mother financially with rent, expenses and with requirements like attending medical appointments. She submits that her health has deteriorated in recent years, resulting in the payment of a Disability Support Pension since October 2014. Ms Bou currently suffers from a serious illness requiring chemotherapy.[13] Although Mr Bou does not live with his mother and step-brothers, Ms Bou contends he is ‘the only child that has constantly and unwaveringly provided…emotional and material support.’ As a consequence she has ‘become extensively reliant upon’ him and ‘cannot live without him.’[14] She states that Mr Bou visits her home frequently to complete daily household chores like cleaning and tidying the house, and gives her $150-200 fortnightly from his Disability Support Pension. She submits that since Mr Bou’s detention she has experienced great emotional distress with ‘suicidal thoughts every night’ at the prospect of his absence from her life, stating: ‘If he goes back I will be very stressed, depressed…I will kill myself.’[15] Ms Bou worries about her son’s physical and psychological health if returned to Cambodia due to the absence of medical, social and financial support, fearing his epilepsy will be left untreated and he will become homeless. Ms Bou states that her elderly mother lives alone in a commune a little outside of Phnom Penh, supported by a neighbour, nephews and nieces who visit occasionally. She sends money to her mother at times, describing her as ‘very frail and alone.’ She submits that the 5-6 aunts and uncles referred to by Mr Bou are her mother’s younger siblings. She considers that if her son is returned to Cambodia, contact will be difficult as it is unlikely he could regularly access a mobile phone or the internet. [12] Statutory Declaration of Ms Mary Bou dated 23 November 2017 and bundle of medical documents from Monash Health (Exhibit A2).[13] I note in this regard a bundle of medical documents from Monash health, including appointments with the Oncology Outpatient Clinic.[14] Ibid, paragraph 7.[15] At paragraph 11 of her Statutory Declaration, Ms Bou states: Without his constant presence and support in my life, I want to hang myself.(ii)If her son is allowed to remain in Australia, Ms Bou submits that she has made arrangements for him to live in the spare bedroom of her friend, Ms Hung Song, who is Mr Bou’s godmother, until other rental accommodation can be arranged. She submits that after being released on bail, Mr Bou previously lived with Ms Song, her husband and their son, who helped him ‘gain some insight into his behaviour.’ Ms Bou believes that if her son receives ‘continuous medical assistance’ and lives with Ms Song, he is less likely to re-offend. She submits that is partly because he will be ‘separated from his three step-brothers, thereby preventing any provocation...’[16] Ms Bou contends that her other three sons, who are currently employed, will assist with the bond for separate rental accommodation for herself and the Applicant. Ms Bou’s sons did not attend the hearing and when asked about their relationship with the Applicant, she replied: ‘I haven’t heard them talking.’ When asked if she was concerned that Mr Bou would become angry again with his step-brothers, Ms Bou responded: ‘Yes, that’s what I’m afraid of,’ contending it was best that she lived in separate accommodation with Mr Bou away from his three step-brothers. She said that their combined DSP payments were sufficient to pay the rent on a separate, small apartment and the two of them would look after each other.[16] Ibid, paragraph 21.(iii)Ms Bou attests to the close relationship between her son and his two children, stating he was ‘committed to seeing his children every weekend,’ taught them about Cambodia’s history and instilled values in them ‘such as being responsible, hardworking and honest.’ She submits the children have felt Mr Bou’s absence since his imprisonment and detention, contending they ‘need the constant presence of both their mother and father.’ She stated at the hearing that a member of her family collected Mr Bou’s children every Friday after to school to facilitate his access visits and that she coordinated those arrangements with Mr Bou’s former wife. Ms Bou said she had not taken the children to visit their father in jail, but had done so at the detention centre.(iv)Ms Bou said that she loves her son very much and expressed her commitment to look after him and ensure he receives all of the support needed to live a stable and peaceful life.(c)Evidence of Mr Mandy Ear and Mr Veng Hong Ear.(i)An undated statement from Mr Mandy Ear, the Applicant’s step-brother was accepted into evidence.[17] He submits in his statement that it makes him sad to see Mr Bou separated from his two children. He says his mother is so distressed by her son’s situation that she cries every day. He states ‘please don’t take away my brother he has not done anything bad to hurt anyone.’(ii)A statement from Mr Veng Hong Ear, another step-brother of the Applicant, was accepted into evidence.[18] He submits in his statement that the Department of Immigration should release Mr Bou from detention, because if he is returned to Cambodia, their ‘family life will not be normal.’ He contends that Mr Bou has never harmed anyone in the community, but that they sometimes argue, which Mr Ear attributed to Mr Bou’s epilepsy and stress.(iii)The Applicant’s step-brothers were not available for cross-examination. Their statements are of a very general nature and their assertion that Mr Bao has never hurt anyone in the community is clearly erroneous. I therefore place little weight on their evidence.(d)Evidence of Ms Hung Song. (i)A Statutory Declaration from Ms Hung Song, the Applicant’s godmother was accepted into evidence.[19] She is 65 years of age and lives with her husband and 22 year-old son. Ms Song states she has a very close association with the Bou family, is best friends with the Applicant’s mother, and considers the Applicant to be her ‘second son.’ She is aware of Mr Bou’s struggle with ‘drug addiction…[and] the effect of his substance abuse on his behaviour.’ Ms Song submits that her family rents a three-bedroom house and that Mr Bou resided for some weeks in their spare bedroom after being released on bail in September 2017. She contends he was pleasant to live with and confided in her family about his offending, allowing him to develop some insight into his behaviour.(ii)Ms Song states that she and her family are committed to providing Mr Bou with accommodation and social support for as long as required. She believes this will help prevent him from re-offending and ‘help keep his life on track,’ because he will be ‘physically separate from his three step-brothers, thus avoiding the occurrence of confrontation.’ (e)Evidence of Ms Sonny Kim. A Statutory Declaration from Ms Sonny Kim, the biological aunt of Mr Bou’s step-brothers was accepted into evidence.[20] Ms Kim says she has enjoyed a close relationship with Mr Bou since 2006 and visits his mother daily. Prior to Mr Bou’s detention, she claims to have seen him ‘every day as he used to help Mary with house work.’ Ms Kim submits she is aware of Mr Bou’s epilepsy and struggle with substance abuse, and that her family has provided him with social support in the past. She claims to have visited Mr Bou in detention a few times, finds his situation ‘heart breaking’ and believes he should be with his family and two children. Ms Kim contends that if Mr Bou received ‘continuous medical assistance,’ she would do her best to help. She contended that Mr Bou had learned a lot from being imprisoned, but that it was important he lived separately from his step-brothers, who he was jealous of. [17] Exhibit A7.[18] Exhibit A8.[19] Exhibit A3.[20] Exhibit A4.Expert Medical Evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find that there is an unacceptable risk of Mr Bou engaging in further violent conduct, which the Australian community should not have to accept. Notwithstanding the higher tolerance extended to him as a visa holder since the age of 14, the violent and repeat nature of his offences is such that he has been given a number of chances to change his ways. The Australian community would therefore expect his visa to be cancelled, despite the significant challenges Mr Bou would experience in re-establishing himself in Cambodia and the emotional impact on his mother, his two children and others in Australia who will miss him. I acknowledge in particular that it is in the best interests of Mr Bou’s children that his visa is not cancelled, which I have treated as a primary consideration. I also acknowledge that his ties to the Australian community and extent of impediments if removed are countervailing considerations weighing against cancellation of his visa. But having applied the considerations in Part A of the Direction, to the specific circumstances of Mr Bou’s case, the primary considerations of protecting the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community outweigh any other considerations in this matter. DECISION It therefore follows that the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent contends that Mr Bou does not pass the character test and that the discretion under section 501(2) of the Act should be exercised to cancel his visa.CONSIDERATION – DOES MR BOU FAIL THE CHARACTER TEST? Lander J (Carr and Sundberg JJ concurring) of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia explained the nexus between the character test and Parliament’s intent in Akpata:[8] The definition of a person passing the character test in s 501(6) shows that Parliament intended that persons who have been convicted of relatively serious crime; associate with criminals; have a history including an immediate history of criminal conduct or general conduct indicating bad character; are a significant risk of engaging in criminal conduct or undesirable conduct (s 501(6)(d)), should not be permitted to travel to or remain in Australia. Shortly put, persons who have committed or are likely to commit criminal or other like conduct should not be permitted to travel to or remain in Australia. Because the purpose is to exclude those persons, the matters that are relevant to the exercise of the Minister’s discretion will include any fact or circumstance which would suggest that a person of otherwise bad character (as it is defined in the Act) should be allowed to travel to or remain in Australia. [8] Akpata v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 65 at [105]. Having regard to Mr Bou’s criminal history, which includes sentences of two or more terms of imprisonment, where the total of those terms is 12 months or more, I am satisfied that he has a substantial criminal record within the meaning of section 501(7)(d) of the Act. I find that Mr Bou does not pass the character test. Having made that finding, I must make a supervening determination regarding the discretion granted under section 501(2) of the Act, which requires application of the considerations in Part A of the Direction, to the specific circumstances of his case.WITNESS EVIDENCEEvidence of Mr Bou and His Family Mr Bou, his mother, his godmother, and the biological aunt of his step-brothers (a close family friend) submitted statements and gave oral evidence at the hearing as follows: (a)Evidence of Mr Chanphanna Bou. (i)I have had regard for Mr Bou’s Statutory Declaration, which was taken into evidence.[9] He also gave oral evidence at the hearing with the assistance of a Cambodian interpreter and was cross-examined. [9] Statement of Mr Chanphanna Bou dated 24 November 2017 (Exhibit A1).(ii)Mr Bou said he had never worked since arriving in Australia and receives a Disability Support Pension. He submits that he has not returned to Cambodia since 2000 and apart from his grandmother and approximately 5-6 aunts and uncles, has no other relatives there. He submits that he has not been in contact with his Cambodian relatives or school friends, whose contact details he has lost. Mr Bou stated that his grandmother is almost 80 years of age and ‘couldn’t do much’ because of her health. When asked if he could live with her if returned to Cambodia, Mr Bou replied: ‘only her – I don’t have anybody else,’ but he expressed concern that if he ‘became sick, who can look after me?’ (iii)Mr Bou was taken through his criminal history, but often responded that he was unable to remember due to his epilepsy or the passage of time. When asked about a violent incident he was involved in requiring police attendance in January 2008, he stated: ‘I don’t know what I did – I went out with my friends – I forgot what I did.’ When asked if he could remember repeatedly punching his mother in the face and head during that incident, Mr Bou replied ‘I can’t remember that.’ When asked if he had taken up a knife during this incident, he responded: ‘it was a long time ago, I don’t remember.’ Mr Bou was also unable to recall many of the circumstances relating to his offending in 2011 and 2015, but was able to recall an incident in June 2015, when he chased his stepfather from the house with a meat cleaver. He stated: ‘Yes I remember that, but I didn’t chop him, I just chased him.’ Mr Bou was also taken through his breach of a Family Violence Safety Notice in late 2015, responding that he had breached it because ‘I missed my mum and I wanted to see her and see my daughter and son.’ When asked why he stopped attending court-ordered sessions linked to his Community Corrections Order (CCO) after only a few meetings, he replied ‘I can’t remember.’ In relation to an incident in September 2016 where he was heard yelling aggressively at his mother while holding a machete, Mr Bou responded: ‘I just wanted the whole family to be quiet.’(iv)Mr Bou was asked why he wasn’t released from prison when eligible for parole in December 2016, responding that he couldn’t read English and had not been told about bail applications. When it was pointed out to him that his parole application was in the Corrections Victoria file, Mr Bou agreed he had applied for parole with the assistance of ‘Legal Aid.’ Mr Bou also agreed that Corrections Victoria had recorded his involvement in verbal and physical aggression on a number of occasions while imprisoned, and that he had been assessed by prison authorities as being a high risk of re-offending. In response to questions about an incident on 6 June 2017 where he struck another prisoner in the head while holding pool balls, Mr Bou responded: ‘If I don’t do that he’ll hit me. I can’t just stand there – he’s the one who said something to make me angry – teasing me…they tease me all those Aussie people.’ (v)Mr Bou submitted that ‘living in prison is like living in the dark…if I don’t protect myself they will keep attacking me or bullying me.’ When asked if he had gotten angry and decided to hit the other prisoner, Mr Bou responded ‘yes,’ contending that ‘all those problems in prison making my anger getting worse…’. When asked why he had become angry in prison, Mr Bou said he wanted to come out and see his family, but in prison he couldn’t do anything. When asked if he felt angry often, Mr Bou responded: ‘yes, when someone comes to try and talk to me, but I try and close my mouth and not talk.’ Mr Bou submitted that he had not completed any rehabilitation courses relating to drugs, alcohol or anger management in the past.(vi)When asked about reports from his general practitioner about non-compliance with epilepsy medication, Mr Bou stated that he sometimes forgot to take it, but now took it daily.[10] In response to questions about his alcohol use, Mr Bou initially said he only drank occasionally and ‘not until drunk.’ In response to subsequent questions, however, he agreed that his consumption of alcohol in the past had resulted in a pattern of alcoholic blackouts. When asked why he had denied alcohol problems while in prison, he stated ‘they didn’t ask me about alcohol.’ When it was pointed out that Corrections Victoria had noted on 8 November 2016 that Mr Bou ‘denied any history of problematic alcohol use,’ Mr Bou responded: ‘I forget – it was a long time ago.’ [10] General Practitioner reports contained within Exhibit A11.(vii)Mr Bou was also referred to a St Vincent’s Hospital discharge summary, which states: ‘’…displays some anger when discussing his victims. Says that he has trouble managing his anger but will try to do so.’[11] Mr Bou acknowledged the report and his inability to control his anger while in prison, but stated: ‘now I don’t have any trouble controlling my anger anymore. I know how to control it.’ In relation to conflict with his three step-brothers, Mr Bou said he felt no anger towards them and even though plans were in place to keep him separated from his step-brothers, he claimed not to ‘have any problems’ with them.[11] Exhibit A11, p.31. St Vincent’s Hospital discharge summary dated 11 September 2017.(viii)Mr Bou said he had no contact with his former wife and that arrangements to see his children were coordinated by his mother. He said he had not seen his children for ‘over two weeks,’ since they had visited him in the detention centre. When given an opportunity to describe his relationship with his children, Mr Bou responded: ‘I like to ask them what they like to play and I play with them.’ In response to questions, Mr Bou was ‘not sure’ if his former wife had formed another relationship. He ‘forgot’ what grade his children were at in school or when he last took them to the movies, or what they saw. He was ‘not sure’ about the financial contribution he made to the living expenses of his children. If allowed to remain in Australia, Mr Bou said he would stop taking heroin, would only drink alcohol occasionally, avoid contact with his step-brothers, change ‘past mistakes to do good things,’ and see his children more frequently.(b)Evidence of Ms Mary Bou. (i)A Statutory Declaration from Ms Mary Bou, the Applicant’s mother, was taken into evidence.[12] She also gave oral evidence at the hearing with the assistance of a Cambodian interpreter. Ms Bou is a 59 year old woman who lives with her three male children aged 23, 25 and 27. They are all employed and assist their mother financially with rent, expenses and with requirements like attending medical appointments. She submits that her health has deteriorated in recent years, resulting in the payment of a Disability Support Pension since October 2014. Ms Bou currently suffers from a serious illness requiring chemotherapy.[13] Although Mr Bou does not live with his mother and step-brothers, Ms Bou contends he is ‘the only child that has constantly and unwaveringly provided…emotional and material support.’ As a consequence she has ‘become extensively reliant upon’ him and ‘cannot live without him.’[14] She states that Mr Bou visits her home frequently to complete daily household chores like cleaning and tidying the house, and gives her $150-200 fortnightly from his Disability Support Pension. She submits that since Mr Bou’s detention she has experienced great emotional distress with ‘suicidal thoughts every night’ at the prospect of his absence from her life, stating: ‘If he goes back I will be very stressed, depressed…I will kill myself.’[15] Ms Bou worries about her son’s physical and psychological health if returned to Cambodia due to the absence of medical, social and financial support, fearing his epilepsy will be left untreated and he will become homeless. Ms Bou states that her elderly mother lives alone in a commune a little outside of Phnom Penh, supported by a neighbour, nephews and nieces who visit occasionally. She sends money to her mother at times, describing her as ‘very frail and alone.’ She submits that the 5-6 aunts and uncles referred to by Mr Bou are her mother’s younger siblings. She considers that if her son is returned to Cambodia, contact will be difficult as it is unlikely he could regularly access a mobile phone or the internet. [12] Statutory Declaration of Ms Mary Bou dated 23 November 2017 and bundle of medical documents from Monash Health (Exhibit A2).[13] I note in this regard a bundle of medical documents from Monash health, including appointments with the Oncology Outpatient Clinic.[14] Ibid, paragraph 7.[15] At paragraph 11 of her Statutory Declaration, Ms Bou states: Without his constant presence and support in my life, I want to hang myself.(ii)If her son is allowed to remain in Australia, Ms Bou submits that she has made arrangements for him to live in the spare bedroom of her friend, Ms Hung Song, who is Mr Bou’s godmother, until other rental accommodation can be arranged. She submits that after being released on bail, Mr Bou previously lived with Ms Song, her husband and their son, who helped him ‘gain some insight into his behaviour.’ Ms Bou believes that if her son receives ‘continuous medical assistance’ and lives with Ms Song, he is less likely to re-offend. She submits that is partly because he will be ‘separated from his three step-brothers, thereby preventing any provocation...’[16] Ms Bou contends that her other three sons, who are currently employed, will assist with the bond for separate rental accommodation for herself and the Applicant. Ms Bou’s sons did not attend the hearing and when asked about their relationship with the Applicant, she replied: ‘I haven’t heard them talking.’ When asked if she was concerned that Mr Bou would become angry again with his step-brothers, Ms Bou responded: ‘Yes, that’s what I’m afraid of,’ contending it was best that she lived in separate accommodation with Mr Bou away from his three step-brothers. She said that their combined DSP payments were sufficient to pay the rent on a separate, small apartment and the two of them would look after each other.[16] Ibid, paragraph 21.(iii)Ms Bou attests to the close relationship between her son and his two children, stating he was ‘committed to seeing his children every weekend,’ taught them about Cambodia’s history and instilled values in them ‘such as being responsible, hardworking and honest.’ She submits the children have felt Mr Bou’s absence since his imprisonment and detention, contending they ‘need the constant presence of both their mother and father.’ She stated at the hearing that a member of her family collected Mr Bou’s children every Friday after to school to facilitate his access visits and that she coordinated those arrangements with Mr Bou’s former wife. Ms Bou said she had not taken the children to visit their father in jail, but had done so at the detention centre.(iv)Ms Bou said that she loves her son very much and expressed her commitment to look after him and ensure he receives all of the support needed to live a stable and peaceful life.(c)Evidence of Mr Mandy Ear and Mr Veng Hong Ear.(i)An undated statement from Mr Mandy Ear, the Applicant’s step-brother was accepted into evidence.[17] He submits in his statement that it makes him sad to see Mr Bou separated from his two children. He says his mother is so distressed by her son’s situation that she cries every day. He states ‘please don’t take away my brother he has not done anything bad to hurt anyone.’(ii)A statement from Mr Veng Hong Ear, another step-brother of the Applicant, was accepted into evidence.[18] He submits in his statement that the Department of Immigration should release Mr Bou from detention, because if he is returned to Cambodia, their ‘family life will not be normal.’ He contends that Mr Bou has never harmed anyone in the community, but that they sometimes argue, which Mr Ear attributed to Mr Bou’s epilepsy and stress.(iii)The Applicant’s step-brothers were not available for cross-examination. Their statements are of a very general nature and their assertion that Mr Bao has never hurt anyone in the community is clearly erroneous. I therefore place little weight on their evidence.(d)Evidence of Ms Hung Song. (i)A Statutory Declaration from Ms Hung Song, the Applicant’s godmother was accepted into evidence.[19] She is 65 years of age and lives with her husband and 22 year-old son. Ms Song states she has a very close association with the Bou family, is best friends with the Applicant’s mother, and considers the Applicant to be her ‘second son.’ She is aware of Mr Bou’s struggle with ‘drug addiction…[and] the effect of his substance abuse on his behaviour.’ Ms Song submits that her family rents a three-bedroom house and that Mr Bou resided for some weeks in their spare bedroom after being released on bail in September 2017. She contends he was pleasant to live with and confided in her family about his offending, allowing him to develop some insight into his behaviour.(ii)Ms Song states that she and her family are committed to providing Mr Bou with accommodation and social support for as long as required. She believes this will help prevent him from re-offending and ‘help keep his life on track,’ because he will be ‘physically separate from his three step-brothers, thus avoiding the occurrence of confrontation.’ (e)Evidence of Ms Sonny Kim. A Statutory Declaration from Ms Sonny Kim, the biological aunt of Mr Bou’s step-brothers was accepted into evidence.[20] Ms Kim says she has enjoyed a close relationship with Mr Bou since 2006 and visits his mother daily. Prior to Mr Bou’s detention, she claims to have seen him ‘every day as he used to help Mary with house work.’ Ms Kim submits she is aware of Mr Bou’s epilepsy and struggle with substance abuse, and that her family has provided him with social support in the past. She claims to have visited Mr Bou in detention a few times, finds his situation ‘heart breaking’ and believes he should be with his family and two children. Ms Kim contends that if Mr Bou received ‘continuous medical assistance,’ she would do her best to help. She contended that Mr Bou had learned a lot from being imprisoned, but that it was important he lived separately from his step-brothers, who he was jealous of. [17] Exhibit A7.[18] Exhibit A8.[19] Exhibit A3.[20] Exhibit A4.Expert Medical Evidence