Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Bott v NSW Land and Housing Corporation [2017] NSWCATCD 88 Hearing dates: 11 September, 9 November, 13 November 2017(submissions) Date of orders: 24 November 2017 Decision date: 24 November 2017 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: The Hon F Marks ADCJ Decision: The following matters are referred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for its consideration, namely whether the respondent, NSW Land and Housing Corporation has committed contempt of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal by reason of its failures, or any one or more of those failures with reference to premises occupied by the applicant under tenancy from the respondent;
(1) to comply with order made on 20 October,2016 in matter SH 16/16880 to carry out replacement of a door and door frame
(2) to comply with order made on the same day and in the same matter as referred to in (1) to conduct an inspection of the premises to ascertain whether there was a water leak and conduct any necessary maintenance work for the leak on or before 18 November, 2016
(3) to comply with orders made on 24 March, 2017 in matter SH 17/11245;
(a) to complete the work described in (1) above
(b) to complete the work described in (2) above
(c) to replace a pre-existing security door in a proper and workmanlike manner by 20 April, 2017
(d) to refund by 6 April, 2017 all rent paid in excess of $108.80 per week from 18 November, 2016 to 15 February, 2017
(e) to refund by 6 April, 2017 all rent paid in excess of $80 per week from 16 February, 2017 to 6 April, 2017
(f) to reduce all rent payable to the sum of $80 per week from 7 April, 2017 to the earlier of 17 November, 2017 or the date upon which all of the work referred to in (3) and (4) is completedCatchwords: Application to refer proceedings to Supreme Court under section 73 (5) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act – principles relevant to referral – whether Crown immunity from suit applies to contempt proceedings-proceedings referred Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act
Housing Act 2001
Interpretation Act (NSW) 1987
Crown Proceedings Act 1988Cases Cited: Mohareb v Palmer [2017] NSWCA 281
AMIEU v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd [1986] HCA 46
Witham v Holloway [1995] HCA 3
State Authorities Superannuation Board v Commissioner of State Taxation (WA) [1996] HCA 32.
Crowther v State of Qld [2006] QCA 308
Hoxton Park Resident’s Action Group Inc v Liverpool City Council [2014] NSWSC 704
O’ Shane v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 1358Category: Principal judgment Parties: David Charles Bott (applicant)
NSW Land and Housing Corporation (respondent)Representation: Applicant (self represented)
Solicitors:
Counsel:
H White (respondent)
File Number(s): SH 17/11245
Reasons for decision
Introduction
-
In these proceedings, the applicant David Charles Bott seeks a referral of certain matters alleging contempt by the respondent New South Wales…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bott v NSW Land and Housing Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWCATCD 88
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the CAT was whether the application for referral under section 73(5) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act was appropriate given the respondent's alleged failures to comply with the tribunal’s orders. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the doctrine of Crown immunity from suit applied to the contempt proceedings. Crown immunity could potentially bar the CAT from having jurisdiction over the contempt proceedings, thereby necessitating a referral to the Supreme Court.
In its decision, the CAT considered the principles relevant to the referral of proceedings, including the importance of ensuring that the appropriate forum for the resolution of the dispute is identified. The court held that the respondent's alleged failures to comply with the orders warranted a referral to the Supreme Court to address the contempt proceedings. The CAT found that Crown immunity did not apply to the contempt proceedings, thereby allowing the referral to proceed. Consequently, the CAT referred the matter to the Supreme Court for further consideration and determination.
The final orders of the CAT were that the Supreme Court of New South Wales be requested to consider whether the respondent had committed contempt of the CAT by failing to comply with specified orders related to maintenance and repair works on the premises. The referral included specific details of the orders and the respondent's alleged non-compliance, thereby setting the stage for the Supreme Court to make a determination on the contempt proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
The following matters are referred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for its consideration, namely whether the respondent, NSW Land and Housing Corporation has committed contempt of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal by reason of its failures, or any one or more of those failures with reference to premises occupied by the applicant under tenancy from the respondent;
(1) to comply with order made on 20 October,2016 in matter SH 16/16880 to carry out replacement of a door and door frame
(2) to comply with order made on the same day and in the same matter as referred to in (1) to conduct an inspection of the premises to ascertain whether there was a water leak and conduct any necessary maintenance work for the leak on or before 18 November, 2016
(3) to comply with orders made on 24 March, 2017 in matter SH 17/11245;
(a) to complete the work described in (1) above
(b) to complete the work described in (2) above
(c) to replace a pre-existing security door in a proper and workmanlike manner by 20 April, 2017
(d) to refund by 6 April, 2017 all rent paid in excess of $108.80 per week from 18 November, 2016 to 15 February, 2017
(e) to refund by 6 April, 2017 all rent paid in excess of $80 per week from 16 February, 2017 to 6 April, 2017
(f) to reduce all rent payable to the sum of $80 per week from 7 April, 2017 to the earlier of 17 November, 2017 or the date upon which all of the work referred to in (3) and (4) is completed
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi