Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ausipile Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2021] QCA 226

COURT OF APPEAL

FRASER JA

Appeal No 3642 of 2021
SC No 8953 of 2019

BOTHAR BORING AND TUNNELLING
(AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD  Respondent/Applicant
ACN 622 309 264

v

AUSIPILE PTY LTD  Appellant/Respondent
ACN 101 402 322

BRISBANE

THURSDAY, 21 OCTOBER 2021

JUDGMENT

FRASER JA: On 15 October 2021 the Court allowed the appellant’s appeal from a decision made in the trial division and it made an order under s 78(2)(a) of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) (“the Act”), that judgment be entered for the appellant Ausipile Pty Ltd against the respondent, Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd, in the amount of $761,296.75. (See Ausipile Pty Ltd v Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd [2021] QCA 223.)

The unsuccessful respondent to that appeal has applied for an order pursuant to r 800 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) that the enforcement of the Court’s orders made in that appeal be stayed until delivery of the arbitral award in an arbitration between it and the appellant.

The background is that the parties to the appeal were parties to a construction contract.  They fell into dispute.  On 5 July 2019 the respondent served a defects notice upon the appellant complaining that work improperly done by the appellant required the respondent to do a great deal of work at great expense.  Four days later, on 9 July 2019, a company called Ausipile Foundation & Engineering Services Pty Ltd (“Ausipile No 2”) was incorporated.  Ausipile No 2 has the same director as the appellant.  It has a paid-up share capital of $6,001, whereas the appellant has a paid-up share capital of $1 and is subject to the registration of personal property securities by a bank for all present and after-acquired properties.  Ausipile No 2 owns no real property.  It holds a building licence issued by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission in the same class as the licence held by the appellant.  From a date in September 2019 until 2 June 2021, Ausipile No 2 had Mr Cawse as its current nominee for the purpose of its building licence.  Mr Cawse is the sole director of the appellant and of Ausipile No 2.  On 18 June 2021, so relatively very recently, the appellant changed its name; its name now is simply its ACN.  Ausipile No 2 will now be able to operate under the descriptive part of its name, “Ausipile”, which had previously been used by the appellant.

Notwithstanding the persuasive submissions of Ms Hindman for the appellant, it seems to me quite clear that the circumstances involving these corporate rearrangements provide ample justification for what the respondent submits are its genuine concerns about the prospect that the appellant will actually pay any substantial amount of any large arbitral award in favour of the respondent, if there is any such award.

Before the litigation commenced, there was a major arbitration under way, in which the respondent claims a sum of money which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ausipile... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCA 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ausipile Pty Ltd, the respondent applied for a stay of enforcement of the Court of Appeal’s orders in an earlier appeal. The appeal involved a dispute between the parties, who were involved in a construction contract. The respondent sought to stay the enforcement of the Court’s orders until the delivery of the arbitral award in an arbitration between the parties. The Court was required to decide whether to grant the stay of enforcement and, if so, what conditions should be attached to the stay. The Court considered the policy of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) and the discretion to grant a stay under r 800 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The Court held that the circumstances involving the corporate rearrangements provided ample justification for the respondent's concerns about the prospect that the appellant would actually pay any substantial amount of any large arbitral award in favour of the respondent. The Court granted the stay upon the respondent giving the usual undertaking as to damages and either paying into court or supplying a bank guarantee in a form satisfactory to the registrar securing payment of the amount of the judgment debt payable by the respondent to the appellant, together with interest up to and including 1 December 2021. The Court ordered that the enforcement of the Court of Appeal’s orders be stayed until delivery of the arbitral award in the matter of an arbitration between Bothar Boring and Tunnelling (Australia) Pty Ltd and Ausipile Pty Ltd or earlier order. The respondent was also ordered to pay into court or deposit a bank guarantee in a form satisfactory to the registrar for the sum of $953,364.63 by 6 pm on 25 October 2021. The Court also ordered that if the respondent failed to comply with this order by the date therein, the stay in order 1 is lifted. The Court further ordered that the security amount of $30,000 paid into court by the appellant by order of Justice Bond made on 20 July 2021 be paid to the appellant together with accretions thereto. The Court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the respondent’s application.
The Court held that the policy of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) was not a full statement of the relevant policy of the Act. The Court held that the Act is concerned with establishing a scheme for the interim payment of progress claims in defined circumstances, including where a respondent to a progress claim does not lodge a schedule in response to a claim under the Act. The Court held that the policy of the Act favours the appellant was sufficiently catered for by imposing a condition of any stay that the respondent provide security for the payment of the judgment debt, which it unconditionally owes the appellant. The Court also held that the respondent should be obliged to give the usual undertaking as to damages. The Court held that the circumstances gave rise to a legitimate concern by the respondent that it may not be paid if it succeeds in obtaining a substantial award in the arbitration. The Court held that the respondent sought an indulgence and it did not offer to pay the amount of the judgment together with interest into Court or, alternatively, to provide security for the payment of the judgment together with interest, as a condition of it being granted a stay. The Court held that it was appropriate that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the respondent’s application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established