Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 50
Hearing dates: 29 March 2021
Decision date: 01 April 2021
Before: Meagher JA
Decision:

(1)      Order that the reference to order 2 in Order 3 of the Orders Sought in the appellant’s notice of appeal be struck out.

(2) Direct that any application to be made by the appellant for leave, under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 471B, to proceed against Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent to the appeal be filed and served within 14 days.

(3)      Stay these proceedings until the appellant has (a) provided security for the respondent’s costs of the appeal in accordance with Order 4 below and (b) joined Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent to the appeal.

(4)      The appellant provide within 21 days security for the respondent’s costs of the appeal in the sum of $60,000, either by payment of that amount into court or in such other form as the appellant and respondent agree before 15 April 2021.

(5)      The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the notice of motion filed 23 December 2020.

Catchwords:

APPEALS – incompetence – where relief sought in notice of appeal includes setting aside money judgment against a defendant other than the appellant – where appeal not brought by or on behalf of other defendant – whether to strike out of notice of appeal reference to judgment against other defendant – inherent power to strike out

APPEALS – procedure – parties on appeal – where consequential relief in appeal includes setting aside costs orders made against appellant and other defendant jointly and severally – where other defendant not party to the appeal – whether other defendant “directly affected by the relief sought” under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.4

APPEALS – procedure – stay of appeal pending satisfaction of judgment and costs orders below – where quantity of costs not agreed or assessed – where judgment and other costs orders the subject of the appeal – whether appeal an abuse of process

COSTS – security for costs – on appeal – where appellant impecunious – where evidence suggests order for security would not stultify appeal – whether “special circumstances” within Uniform Civil Procedures Rules, r 51.50

Legislation Cited:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s 41(6A)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 67

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 180, 181, 182, 471B

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 12.4, 51.1(3), 51.4, 51.50

Cases Cited:

CGU Insurance Ltd v Watson (as trustee of the deed of arrangement in respect of Graves) [2007] NSWCA 301

Corporate Affairs Commission v Solomon [1989] NSWCA 51

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 471B

D (pseudonym) v P (pseudonym) [2020] NSWCA 174

Kingsman v Health Administration Corporation [2000] NSWCA 163

Marks-Isaacs v Fowler [2005] NSWCA 37

Mualim v Dzelme [2020] NSWCA 333

Nobarani v Mariconte [2016] NSWCA 214

Pearson v Naydler [1977] 1 WLR 899

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWCA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Boros (the appellant) and Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (the respondent). The appellant sought to appeal a money judgment and costs orders made against him and another party, Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether a reference to a judgment against a non-appellant should be struck out of the notice of appeal, whether the other defendant was "directly affected by the relief sought" under rule 51.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, whether the appeal constituted an abuse of process and should be stayed pending satisfaction of the judgments and costs orders, and whether special circumstances existed for ordering security for the respondent's costs of the appeal given the appellant's impecuniosity.

Meagher JA reasoned that the notice of appeal improperly sought to set aside a judgment against a party who was not an appellant and was not represented. The Court applied its inherent power to strike out irrelevant or improper references in the notice of appeal. Furthermore, the Court found that the appeal proceedings would be an abuse of process if not stayed until the appellant satisfied the existing judgments and costs orders, particularly as the quantum of costs was not yet agreed or assessed. The Court also considered the appellant's impecuniosity and determined that an order for security for costs would not stultify the appeal, thus constituting "special circumstances" under rule 51.50.

The Court ordered that the reference to the judgment against Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd be struck out of the notice of appeal. It also directed the appellant to file an application for leave to join Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent within 14 days. The proceedings were stayed until the appellant provided security for the respondent's costs of the appeal in the sum of $60,000 within 21 days, either by payment into court or by agreement, and joined Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent. Finally, the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of a specific notice of motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Order that the reference to order 2 in Order 3 of the Orders Sought in the appellant’s notice of appeal be struck out.

(2) Direct that any application to be made by the appellant for leave, under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 471B, to proceed against Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent to the appeal be filed and served within 14 days.

(3) Stay these proceedings until the appellant has (a) provided security for the respondent’s costs of the appeal in accordance with Order 4 below and (b) joined Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a respondent to the appeal.

(4) The appellant provide within 21 days security for the respondent’s costs of the appeal in the sum of $60,000, either by payment of that amount into court or in such other form as the appellant and respondent agree before 15 April 2021.

(5) The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the notice of motion filed 23 December 2020.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd involves a complex web of transactions and disputes surrounding property investments and financial obligations. The appellant, Mr. Boros, initially filed a claim against Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (PPI), alleging that PPI was incompetent in managing a property investment and sought relief in the form of setting aside a money judgment against PPI. Additionally, Mr. Boros aimed to set aside costs orders made against both himself and PPI jointly and severally. However, Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd (PEH), another party involved in the underlying transaction, was not a party to the appeal, despite being the subject of the costs orders and the money judgment referenced in the notice of appeal.

The factual background begins with the formation of a joint venture between Mr. Boros, PPI, and PEH to acquire and manage a property. Mr. Boros alleged that PPI mismanaged the investment, leading to financial loss. Following a trial, judgment was entered against PPI for a sum of money, and costs orders were made against both Mr. Boros and PPI jointly and severally. Dissatisfied with these outcomes, Mr. Boros filed an appeal against PPI, seeking to set aside the judgment and costs orders. However, PEH, which was not a party to the appeal, was mentioned in the notice of appeal regarding the costs orders and the money judgment against PPI.

The situation further complicated when the appeal included requests for relief concerning orders affecting PEH. Despite PEH not being a party to the appeal, the notice of appeal referenced orders that included relief against PEH. Additionally, the appeal sought to set aside costs orders made against both Mr. Boros and PPI jointly and severally, without PEH being part of the appellate process. This led to procedural issues regarding the parties directly affected by the relief sought, as outlined under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.4.

Moreover, the appeal process was further encumbered by the requirement for Mr. Boros to provide security for the respondent's costs of the appeal. Given his impecunious state, the court had to determine whether "special circumstances" existed under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.50, to justify an exemption from this requirement. The court also needed to decide whether the appeal constituted an abuse of process, particularly given the unresolved issues concerning the quantity of costs and the stay of appeal pending satisfaction of judgment and costs orders below.

The matter before the court arises from an appeal by the appellant, Boros, against a judgment entered in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was lodged following a decision by the trial judge in the Supreme Court, which included a money judgment against Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd and a costs order made against both Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd and Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd jointly and severally. The appeal was initiated by Boros, but not by or on behalf of Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd, which was not joined as a party to the appeal despite the consequential relief sought including setting aside the costs orders made against it. The appellant’s notice of appeal included a request to set aside the money judgment against Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd, which is not the appellant in this proceeding, and to set aside the costs orders made against both Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd and Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd. The court was asked to determine whether the notice of appeal should be struck out in parts and whether Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd should be joined as a party to the appeal. Additionally, the appellant sought to challenge the imposition of security for costs on appeal, given their financial circumstances, and the respondent opposed the appeal on the basis that it was an abuse of process due to the outstanding costs not being agreed or assessed.

Procedurally, this appeal came before the court following the initial judgment and subsequent costs orders in the Supreme Court. The appellant’s notice of appeal, filed in accordance with the rules of court, included requests for relief against parties not before the appellate court. The court was required to address these procedural issues before considering any substantive matters. This included determining the appropriate course of action regarding the reference to the judgment against Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd, whether Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd should be joined as a respondent, and the imposition of security for costs on appeal. The respondent argued that the appeal should be struck out or stayed due to these procedural irregularities and the absence of Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd as a party to the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether to strike out of the notice of appeal the reference to a judgment against a defendant other than the appellant where the appeal is not brought by or on behalf of that other defendant, under the court's inherent power.

2. Whether an other defendant who is not a party to the appeal is "directly affected by the relief sought" under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.4, where the relief includes setting aside costs orders made against both the appellant and the other defendant jointly and severally.

3. Whether the appeal constitutes an abuse of process where it seeks to set aside costs orders that are the subject of the appeal and the quantity of costs has not been agreed or assessed, and the appeal includes a stay of proceedings pending satisfaction of these orders.

4. Whether "special circumstances" exist within the meaning of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.50, to order security for costs on appeal where the appellant is impecunious and evidence suggests that an order for security would not stultify the appeal.

Held
1. The court concluded that the reference to a judgment against a defendant other than the appellant in the notice of appeal should be struck out, as the appeal was not brought by or on behalf of that other defendant. As a result, the order was made that the reference be struck out.

2. The court held that the other defendant who was not a party to the appeal was "directly affected by the relief sought" under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.4, as the relief included setting aside costs orders made against both the appellant and the other defendant jointly and severally.

3. The court determined that the appeal did not constitute an abuse of process, despite the appeal seeking to set aside costs orders that were the subject of the appeal and the quantity of costs not being agreed or assessed. The court also found that the appeal did not abuse process by including a stay of proceedings pending satisfaction of these orders.

4. The court found that "special circumstances" existed within the meaning of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.50, to order security for costs on appeal, as the appellant was impecunious and evidence suggested that an order for security would not stultify the appeal. Consequently, the appellant was ordered to provide security for the respondent’s costs of the appeal in the sum of $60,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd, the Court addressed several complex procedural issues in the context of an appeal. Firstly, the court considered whether to strike out a reference to a judgment against a defendant other than the appellant from the notice of appeal, where the appeal was not brought by or on behalf of that other defendant. The court exercised its inherent power to control the proceedings and ensure that the notice of appeal accurately reflected the parties and issues before the court. The court concluded that the reference to the other defendant's judgment was not relevant to the appeal as it was not brought on behalf of that defendant and therefore struck it out.

Secondly, the court examined whether an other defendant who was not a party to the appeal was "directly affected by the relief sought" under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.4. The relief sought included setting aside costs orders made against both the appellant and the other defendant jointly and severally. The court held that the other defendant was indeed "directly affected by the relief sought" as the order would impact their liability for costs, even though they were not a party to the appeal. This decision aligns with the principle that procedural rules should be interpreted to ensure just and fair outcomes, even for non-parties who are directly impacted by the relief sought.

Thirdly, the court assessed whether the appeal constituted an abuse of process, given that it sought to set aside costs orders that were the subject of the appeal, and the quantity of costs had not been agreed or assessed. Additionally, the appeal included a stay of proceedings pending satisfaction of these orders. The court found that the appeal did not constitute an abuse of process, as the appellant had a legitimate interest in challenging the costs orders and the request for a stay was not inherently unreasonable given the context of the appeal. The court balanced the appellant's right to appeal against the potential for abuse of the appellate process.

Lastly, the court considered whether "special circumstances" existed within the meaning of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 51.50, to order security for costs on appeal where the appellant was impecunious and evidence suggested that an order for security would not stultify the appeal. The court found that the appellant's impecuniosity and the potential for the appeal to be stultified without an order for security did constitute "special circumstances." Therefore, the court ordered the appellant to provide security for the respondent's costs of the appeal. This decision underscores the importance of ensuring that appeals are not obstructed by financial barriers, while also protecting respondents from undue financial risk.

In summary, the court's decision in Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd demonstrates a careful balance between procedural fairness, the rights of appellants, and the protection of respondents. The court's exercise of its inherent power to strike out irrelevant references, its interpretation of "directly affected" under r 51.4, its assessment of potential abuse of process, and its consideration of "special circumstances" under r 51.50, all contribute to the development of Australian appellate procedure law. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that courts have the inherent power to control the content of notices of appeal, can consider the impact of relief sought on non-parties, can assess whether an appeal constitutes an abuse of process, and can order security for costs where "special circumstances" exist.