Bornstein v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2012] AATA 424

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/5143

Re

Benjamin Bornstein

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Date 6 July 2012
Place Brisbane

The objection decision is set aside. In substitution, the Tribunal decides the contributions made by the taxpayer into his superannuation fund on 10 July 2007 should be attributed to the financial year ended 30 June 2007.

........................[Sgd]............................

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

CATCHWORDS

SUPERANNUATION – concessional contributions – excess contributions tax – discretion to move excess contribution to another financial year – discretion to be exercised only where there are special circumstances – objection decision set aside and substitute.

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth)

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth)

CASES

Chantrell and Commissioner of Taxation [2012] AATA 179

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

  1. The taxation law limits the amount of concessional contributions (ie, contributions which attract a lower rate of tax) that may be made into a superannuation fund in a financial year. If the concessional contribution limits are exceeded in a particular financial year, the taxpayer is required to pay a higher rate of tax on the amount of the excess. The taxpayer in this case has asked the Tribunal to reconsider an objection decision which says he is liable to pay excess contributions tax in the 2007-2008 financial year.

  2. This case raises the question of when a contribution is made for the purposes of the legislation. The question is important in cases like the present where the taxpayer made the contribution around the end of the 2006-2007 financial year: was the contribution actually made in the 2007-2008 financial year, as the Commissioner contends, or should it be treated as having been made in the previous financial year? To answer the question, I must consider the circumstances in which the Commissioner may exercise the discretion in s 292-465 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 to treat a contribution that is made in one year as if it were made in a different year.

    THE FACTS

  3. The taxpayer was employed by a company of which he was the sole director and shareholder. At the end of each financial year, his employer – which, as a practical matter, meant the taxpayer who managed the affairs of the company – would make a contribution into the taxpayer’s superannuation fund. That pattern of payments towards the end of each financial year was clear from the evidence given by the taxpayer and from a statement given by his accountant, Mr Alford.

  4. The taxpayer was traveling overseas between 21 June and 8 July 2007. He contacted Mr Alford by email (exhibit 6) to check whether he needed to make a super payment before the end of the financial year. There is no record of the response from Mr Alford but I understand the taxpayer was given the impression he had a period of grace in which to make the payments, which would then be backdated to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bornstein v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 424
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bornstein v Commissioner of Taxation concerns the issue of when a superannuation contribution is considered to be made for the purposes of the legislation. The dispute was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The taxpayer, who was the sole director and shareholder of his employer company, made a superannuation contribution on 10 July 2007. The Commissioner of Taxation assessed the contribution as being made in the 2007-2008 financial year, imposing excess contributions tax. The taxpayer objected, arguing that the contribution should be attributed to the previous financial year. The central legal issue was whether the Commissioner had the discretion to attribute the contribution to the previous financial year, and if so, whether the circumstances warranted exercising that discretion.

The Tribunal examined the circumstances under which the Commissioner could exercise the discretion provided in section 292-465 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The relevant provision allows for a contribution made in one year to be treated as if it were made in a different year where there are special circumstances. The Tribunal considered the taxpayer's actions and the information available to him at the time of the contribution. The taxpayer had been under the impression, based on a webpage from the Australian Taxation Office and advice from his accountant, that he had a grace period to make the contribution without penalty. The Tribunal determined that despite the taxpayer's misunderstanding of the law, the legislative intent to facilitate gradual contributions to superannuation was not frustrated in this case. The Tribunal was satisfied that special circumstances existed warranting the exercise of the Commissioner's discretion to attribute the contribution to the 2006-2007 financial year.

The Tribunal set aside the Commissioner's decision and substituted its own, ordering that the contributions made by the taxpayer on 10 July 2007 be attributed to the financial year ended 30 June 2007. This decision was based on the special circumstances and the taxpayer's mistaken but reasonable belief that he could make the contribution without penalty. The Tribunal's ruling ensures that the taxpayer is not unduly penalised for his misunderstanding of the legislative requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This case raises the question of when a contribution is made for the purposes of the legislation. The question is important in cases like the present where the taxpayer made the contribution around the end of the 2006-2007 financial year: was the contribution actually made in the 2007-2008 financial year, as the Commissioner contends, or should it be treated as having been made in the previous financial year? To answer the question, I must consider the circumstances in which the Commissioner may exercise the discretion in s 292-465 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 to treat a contribution that is made in one year as if it were made in a different year. THE FACTS The taxpayer was employed by a company of which he was the sole director and shareholder. At the end of each financial year, his employer – which, as a practical matter, meant the taxpayer who managed the affairs of the company – would make a contribution into the taxpayer’s superannuation fund. That pattern of payments towards the end of each financial year was clear from the evidence given by the taxpayer and from a statement given by his accountant, Mr Alford. The taxpayer was traveling overseas between 21 June and 8 July 2007. He contacted Mr Alford by email (exhibit 6) to check whether he needed to make a super payment before the end of the financial year. There is no record of the response from Mr Alford but I understand the taxpayer was given the impression he had a period of grace in which to make the payments, which would then be backdated to the 2006-2007 financial year. The taxpayer says he looked at the ATO website and visited the page dealing with the deadlines for making superannuation contributions. A copy of the page was tendered in evidence: exhibit 5. The page in question is titled “Superannuation guarantee – a guide for employers” with the sub-title “When to pay contributions”. It addresses an employer’s obligations under the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth) (“the SGA Act”) to make compulsory superannuation contributions for each employee in accordance with the law. The webpage pointed out an employer could make super contributions in respect of an employee up until 28 July and still have those amounts credited to the quarter ending the previous June. The webpage does not refer to the consequences for an employee when contributions are made after the end of the financial year under the excess contributions regime in the Income Tax Assessment Act. The page only refers to what an employer had to do to satisfy the employer’s obligations under the SGA Act. The taxpayer explained in his evidence that he assumed he was able to make the super contributions up until 28 July without any adverse consequences to anyone. He was not aware there was, in effect, a parallel regime in the Income Tax Assessment Act setting an absolute deadline for concessional contributions by 30 June so that he might become liable to an excess contributions tax even though his employer had made contributions within the time allowed to the employer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the matters referred to in sub-section (6) count against the taxpayer, I am nonetheless satisfied the discretion should be exercised in his favour. This is a case where it was clearly intended the taxpayer would make a gradual contribution towards his superannuation, as the legislative scheme intends. While he made mistakes in the way in which he sought to comply with the rules, the legislative purpose would be frustrated if the taxpayer were penalised. CONCLUSION The objection decision is set aside. The Tribunal decides in substitution that, pursuant to s 292-465 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, the contributions made by the taxpayer into his superannuation fund on 10 July 2007 should be attributed to the financial year ended 30 June 2007.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established