Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Borgese v Cater & Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater & Blumer (No 3) [2017] NSWSC 92 Hearing dates: 15 and 16 February 2017 Decision date: 17 February 2017 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: N Adams J Decision: (1) The plaintiff’s second application for leave to file a further amended statement of claim is refused.
(2) The defendant’s motion for summary dismissal is allowed.
(3) The plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of the motions.
(4) The plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis.
(5) The defendant has leave to approach my Associate within 14 days should it seek variation of Order 4.Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – second application for leave to file further amended statement of claim –breach of confidence alleged for the first time – lack of specificity in pleadings of nature of confidential information – prejudice to the parties - application refused
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application to dismiss proceedings because no reasonable cause of action disclosedLegislation Cited: Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 13.4(1)(b)Cases Cited: Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v The Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27
Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales (2006) 226 CLR 256; [2006] HCA 27
Belan v Casey [2002] NSWSC 58
Borgese v Cater & Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater & Blumer [2016] NSWSC 1252
Borgese v Cater & Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater & Blumer (No 2) [2017] NSWSC 79
Borgese v Papasidero [2006] NSWSC 407
Clarke v State of New South Wales (No.4) [2015] NSWSC 1054
Corrs Pavey Whiting and Byrne v Collector of Customs (Vic) (1987) 14 FCR 434; [1987] FCA 266
Duchess of Argyll v Duke of Argyll [1967] CH 302
General Steel Industries v Commission for Railways (1964) 112 CLR 125; [1964] HCA 69
Kallinicos v Hunt [2005] NSWSC 1181
LGS v Barbagallo (No 3) [2012] NSWSC 1099
Mancini v Mancini [1999] NSWSC 800
Marshall v Prescott [2015] NSWCA 110
Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG [1999] 2 A.C. 222
Spincode Pty Ltd v Look Software Pty Ltd [2001] VSCA 248Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Domenico Borgese (Plaintiff)
Cater & Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater & Blumer Solicitors (Incorporating Ian Denis Maguire t/as Maguire & Martin Solicitors) (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Ms J Merkel (Plaintiff)
Mr T Faulkner SC (Defendant)
Margiotta Solicitors & Attorneys (Plaintiff)
Meridian Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2012/138861
Judgment
-
These proceedings brought against a firm of solicitors have had a troubled procedural history. By statement of claim filed on 1 May 2012 proceedings were brought against the defendant for professional negligence. An amended statement of claim was filed on 25 March 2015 (“ASOC”). On 9 September 2016, Harrison J refused the defendant’s application to strike out the proceedings for want of due despatch. In so doing, his Honour observed that he was unable to identify any…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Borgese v Cater and Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater and Blumer (No... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWSC 92
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine two main legal issues. First, whether the plaintiff had adequately pleaded the nature of the confidential information that was allegedly breached. Second, whether granting leave to amend the statement of claim would cause prejudice to the defendant, Cater and Blumer. The court also considered whether the plaintiff had disclosed a reasonable cause of action warranting the continuation of the proceedings.
The court found that the plaintiff had not sufficiently specified the nature of the confidential information in the pleadings, which was a critical element in establishing the breach of confidence claim. The lack of detail in the pleadings made it difficult for the defendant to prepare a proper defence. Additionally, the court noted that allowing the amendment would cause significant prejudice to the defendant, as it would require them to investigate and respond to new allegations at a late stage in the proceedings. The court also concluded that the plaintiff had not disclosed a reasonable cause of action, as the amended claim lacked essential elements required to sustain a breach of confidence action. Consequently, the court refused the application for leave to amend the statement of claim and dismissed the proceedings.
The final orders of the court included the refusal of the plaintiff's application for leave to file a further amended statement of claim and the dismissal of the proceedings without any order as to costs. The court's decision highlighted the importance of adequately pleading the nature of confidential information and the potential consequences of introducing new claims at a late stage in litigation.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated when Mr Borgese filed a statement of claim in the Federal Circuit Court against Cater and Blumer Pty Ltd t/as Cater and Blumer. The defendant filed a notice of intention to defend and later applied to have the proceedings dismissed for want of prosecution due to Mr Borgese's failure to prosecute his claims with due diligence. Mr Borgese then sought leave to amend his statement of claim to include a new cause of action for breach of confidence. The defendant opposed this application, leading to the court refusing leave to amend the statement of claim. Mr Borgese subsequently made a second application for leave to amend his statement of claim, this time including a claim for damages for the defendant's alleged breach of confidence. The defendant opposed this second application on similar grounds, arguing that the proposed amendments were vague and would cause significant prejudice. The court was required to determine whether Mr Borgese should be granted leave to amend his statement of claim to include these new claims.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Mr Borgese should be granted leave to amend his statement of claim to include a new cause of action for breach of confidence.
2. Whether Mr Borgese should be granted leave to amend his statement of claim to include a claim for damages for the defendant's alleged breach of confidence.
3. Whether allowing the amendments would cause significant prejudice to the defendant.
Held
1. The court refused Mr Borgese leave to amend his statement of claim to include a new cause of action for breach of confidence.
2. The court refused Mr Borgese leave to amend his statement of claim to include a claim for damages for the defendant's alleged breach of confidence.
3. The court found that allowing the amendments would cause significant prejudice to the defendant.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by considering the first issue regarding Mr Borgese's application to amend his statement of claim to include a new cause of action for breach of confidence. The court noted that the application was brought late and the proposed amendment was not specific enough about the nature of the confidential information. The court emphasised the importance of specificity in pleadings, particularly when a new cause of action is introduced. The lack of detail made it difficult for the defendant to properly respond to the new claim. Furthermore, the court highlighted that allowing such late amendments could lead to significant prejudice to the defendant, potentially disrupting their defence preparations and causing unnecessary costs.
Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether Mr Borgese should be granted leave to amend his statement of claim to include a claim for damages for the defendant's alleged breach of confidence. The court found that the proposed claim for damages was similarly vague and lacked the necessary detail. The court reiterated that the amendments should be specific enough to enable the defendant to adequately respond. The court also noted the prejudice that allowing such amendments at this stage could cause, including the risk of disrupting the trial process and potentially leading to a mistrial.
In addressing the third issue, the court assessed whether allowing the amendments would cause significant prejudice to the defendant. The court concluded that granting leave to amend the statement of claim at this stage would indeed cause significant prejudice to the defendant. The late introduction of the breach of confidence claim, coupled with the lack of specificity, would disrupt the defendant's defence and potentially lead to a mistrial. The court found that the prejudice to the defendant outweighed any potential benefit to Mr Borgese of allowing the amendments. This consideration led the court to ultimately refuse both applications.
In summary, the court's refusal to grant leave for the amendments was based on the lateness of the applications, the lack of specificity in the proposed pleadings, and the significant prejudice that would result to the defendant. The binding principle established by this decision is that late and vague amendments to a statement of claim, particularly those that introduce new causes of action, may be refused if they cause significant prejudice to the opposing party.