Bond v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Bond  v State of Queensland & Anor [2019] QCATA 60

PARTIES:

ROBYN BOND
(appellant/respondent)

v

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(first respondent/first appellant)

and

CHRISTINE THOMAS

(second respondent/second appellant)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL170-17; APL191-17

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL089-15

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-Discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

10 May 2019

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judge Allen QC, Deputy President

Member Ann Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

1.   The application for leave to appeal in APL170-17 is granted.

2.   The appeal in APL170-17 is dismissed.

3.   The application for leave to appeal in APL191-17 is granted.

4.   The decision in ADL089-17 is set aside.

5.   The Appeal Tribunal substitutes its own decision, namely, that leave is granted to the applicant Robyn Bond to amend her complaint to include allegations of victimisation by Sean Harvey as decision-maker in her public interest disclosure complaint to the Department of Justice and Attorney-General, limited to allegations of breach of natural justice through bias.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – where the applicant made a number of complaints to the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – where some of the matters complained about were out of time – where the out of time allegations were not accepted by the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – whether the out of time allegations were rejected by the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – whether the allegations lapsed and could not be the subject of complaint in Tribunal proceedings  – whether the Tribunal has the power to permit the inclusion of the out of time allegations in amended contentions before the Tribunal   –  whether the Tribunal should permit the inclusion of the out of time allegations in amended contentions before the Tribunal

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – where the applicant made a number of complaints to the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – whether an allegation of victimisation was not dealt with by the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – whether the allegation of victimisation was rejected by the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner – whether the allegation lapsed and could not be the subject of complaint in Tribunal proceedings – whether the Tribunal has the power to permit the inclusion of the allegation of victimisation in amended contentions before the Tribunal   –  whether the Tribunal should permit the inclusion of the allegation of victimisation in amended contentions before the Tribunal

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 136, s 138, s 139,
s 141, s 142, s 175, s 178
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 142

Aleksic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2011] QCAT 342
Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32
Bond v State of Queensland & Anor (No 2) [2017] QCAT 185
Brown & Ors v McArthur & Walters [2002] QSC 236
Buderim Ginger Ltd v Booth [2003] 1 Qd R 147
Cachia v Grech [2009] NSWCA 232
Glenwood Properties Pty Ltd v Delmoss Pty Ltd [1986] 2 Qd R 388
McKenzie v Mackay and State of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bond v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCATA 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bond v State of Queensland, the applicant, Robyn Bond, sought to appeal the decisions of the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner and the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). Robyn Bond alleged that she had been discriminated against in her employment due to her marital status and sought to include certain allegations in her complaint that had been previously rejected by the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner as being out of time. The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal had the power and whether it should permit the inclusion of the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation in amended contentions before the Tribunal.

The court found that the Tribunal did have the power to permit the inclusion of the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation in amended contentions before the Tribunal. The court held that the Tribunal should permit the inclusion of the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation in amended contentions before the Tribunal, as it was in the interest of justice to do so. The court found that the applicant had shown good cause for the delay in making the complaints and that the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation were relevant to the issues before the Tribunal.

In conclusion, the court granted leave to the applicant to amend her complaint to include the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation. The court set aside the decision of the Tribunal and substituted its own decision, which was that leave was granted to the applicant to amend her complaint to include the out of time allegations and the allegation of victimisation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal in APL170-17 is granted.

2. The appeal in APL170-17 is dismissed.

3. The application for leave to appeal in APL191-17 is granted.

4. The decision in ADL089-17 is set aside.

5. The Appeal Tribunal substitutes its own decision, namely, that leave is granted to the applicant Robyn Bond to amend her complaint to include allegations of victimisation by Sean Harvey as decision-maker in her public interest disclosure complaint to the Department of Justice and Attorney-General, limited to allegations of breach of natural justice through bias.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The following is a relevant chronology of uncontentious matters.(a)Mrs Bond worked with her husband, Kirk Bond, in the Department of Justice and Attorney-General (DJAG).(b)Both Mrs Bond and Kirk Bond were employed as Youth Justice Conferencing Convenors.(c)Mrs Bond asserts that from about November 2011 she was unlawfully discriminated against in her employment because of her marital status.(d)Mrs Bond developed a psychological disorder and in April 2014 ceased work and lodged a claim for Workers’ Compensation.(e)On 6 February 2015 Mr and Mrs Bond lodged a joint complaint with the ADCQ alleging discrimination against their employer and against their direct supervisor, Christine Thomas, the second respondent.(f)In the complaint, Mrs Bond relied on actions which allegedly occurred from November 2011 until Mrs Bond ceased work in April 2014.(g)By letter dated 3 March 2015, the ADCQ asked Mr and Mrs Bond to explain why alleged incidents occurring prior to 6 February 2014, described in the complaint, should be accepted. (h)In a letter dated 11 June 2015, the ADCQ advised Mr and Mrs Bond that the Commissioner had “decided not to accept the allegations under the Act made outside the statutory time limit”.The Commissioner considered the complaint form dated 6 February 2015, submissions of the parties, the respondents’ response, Mr and Mrs Bond’s reply together with statements of Mr and Mrs Bond, other submissions, attachments and the claimants’ natural justice response by Mr Bond.The Commissioner set out reasons for the decision including that:(i) no good cause had been shown to accept a complaint lodged after the expiration of time set out in s 138(1) of the Act;(ii) allegations outside the statutory time period are about two years and three months outside the limit;(iii) the background circumstances of the complainants were accepted;(iv) there were a number of reasons given by the complainants for the delay, however Mr Bond was a lawyer and should have been aware of statutory limitation periods. From at least May 2014 the complainants were aware of the right to complain and the limitation period but chose not to do so until February 2015;(v) the complainants said they feared reprisals if they were to make a formal complaint while still working, but nevertheless did make complaints about their alleged treatment;(vi) the complainants said they were both suffering psychological injuries, were pursuing a disputed WorkCover claim, were hoping to negotiate a return to work and were awaiting the WorkCover assessment to determine whether they were eligible to make a claim for damages. However, pursuit of other causes of action does not assist an applicant in establishing good cause for delay (GCE v Anti-Discrimination Commissioner [2006] QSC 58). The complainants have not shown that they were unable or reluctant to pursue a disputed claim against their employer and Mr Bond was well enough to seek admission as a solicitor in July 2014. They have not shown that making a formal claim of discrimination would diminish their ability to return to work under alternative arrangements any more than the disputed Workcover claim or that waiting for the resolution of their WorkCover assessment would preclude them from lodging a claim under the Act; (vii) Mr Bond had made an internal complaint of discrimination on behalf of himself and Mrs Bond that he described as formal, around the time of his leaving work on 12 May 2014, so it is difficult to understand why he did not or could not make a formal complaint to the Commission;(viii) it was noted that the respondents have not claimed witnesses are unavailable or that records have not been preserved so that there is no actual prejudice to the respondents.The Commissioner said that he formed his conclusion after weighing all the relevant factors. The decision set out relevant legislation and case law, not all of which is extracted here.(i)On 2 July 2015, the ADCQ notified Mr and Mrs Bond that the ADCQ had accepted their complaint but excluded those allegations that predated 6 February 2015.(j)The complaint was not able to be conciliated.(k)On 11 August 2015, Mrs Bond made a request to the ADCQ for referral of her complaint to QCAT pursuant to s 164A of the Act. (l)Mr Bond resolved his complaint with the respondents, leaving Mrs Bond to pursue her complaint referred to QCAT. (m)Mrs Bond made further complaints to the ADCQ.(n)On 26 August 2015, Mrs Bond lodged a complaint with the ADCQ. The Appeal Tribunal has not been provided with a copy of this complaint(o)On 20 November 2015, the ADCQ notified the applicant that it had not accepted the applicant’s 26 August 2015 complaint. The Appeal Tribunal has not been provided with a copy of this letter.(p)On 23 November 2015, Mrs Bond lodged a further complaint with the ADCQ, alleging relationship status discrimination. A number of matters were raised in that complaint. I have extracted those parts which are relevant to the decision of Senior Member Stilgoe, the subject of this Appeal.For ease of reference, parts of the complaint have been marked by me in bold.The Complaint sets out a heading on page 4: “Complaint of Victimisation in Contravention of Section 130 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 and Complaint of Public Interest Reprisal in Contravention of Section 40 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010”.Mrs Bond sets out at paragraph 25 of the complaint, the terms of an email from her husband to the Executive Director of the Ethical Standards Unit of DJAG dated 17 October 2015 which includes at its third paragraph the following:The fact that Sean Harvey was appointed as the decision-maker in relation to our public interest disclosures makes a mockery of the entire investigation. Sean Harvey is directing the department’s litigation position in relation to the Anti-Discrimination Act complaints that we lodged with QCAT. Moreover, his actions resulted in us filing reprisal complaints in the Anti-Discrimination Commission Queensland. Clearly, the decision-maker, in relation to our public interest disclosures, was not unbiased. Thus, natural justice was absent from the decision-making process. Mr Harvey is well aware that if Christine Thomas was determined to have been guilty of corrupt conduct, maladministration and lying, those facts would be devastating to the department’s litigation position in relation to Robyn Bond’s Anti-Discrimination Act complaint that is pending before QCAT.Further in the email, Mr Bond requests that Sean Harvey’s decision – that their allegations could not be substantiated, be voided on the ground that it was made in the absence of natural justice.Mrs Bond sets out at paragraph [27] of the complaint the text of a complaint made by Mr and Mrs Bond to the Queensland Ombudsman on 29 October 2015, which relevantly includes the following:… I was informed by Lee Fairbank, the Manager for Youth, Justice, Workplace Health and Safety, that Sean Harvey was the person who would approve or reject any settlement offers. Moreover, Sean Harvey initiated a procedure against both of us that we allege was intended to medically terminate our employment. Because of Mr Harvey’s actions, we lodged reprisal allegations in the Anti-Discrimination Commission. We were stunned to learn that, of all people, Sean Harvey was the person who the department appointed as the decision-maker in relation to our public interest disclosure. Clearly, he is not an unbiased decision-maker. He is well aware that, if the complaints of misconduct and maladministration against our Service Leader are substantiated, her credibility would be destroyed and DJAG’s potential for being found liable by QCAT would grow exponentially.… Natural justice was absent from the decision-making process. We respectfully request that Sean Harvey’s decision be declared void and that any and all reports that he relied on in making his decision be referred to a non-DJAG decision-maker so our public interest disclosures can be decided with the principles of natural justice.In addition to the complaints about lack of natural justice affecting Mr Harvey’s decision in relation to the Bonds’ public interest disclosures, the 23 November 2015 complaint goes on to complain that Mr Harvey directed Mrs Bond to attend a medical examination which might result in her being medically retired from the public service. Mr Bond wrote to Mr Fairbank and others on 5 November 2015 objecting to the direction for Mrs Bond to attend a medical examination and threatening to lodge a further ADCQ complaint in relation to the matter.The 23 November 2015 complaint goes on at paragraph [35] to allege that Mr Harvey directed Mrs Bond to attend an independent medical examination, not for any legitimate reason, but rather as a reprisal for lodging a complaint with the Queensland Ombudsman in relation to Mr Harvey’s decision in response to her public interest disclosures and for continuing to pursue her QCAT complaints of discrimination against DJAG and Ms Thomas.(q)By letter dated 14 January 2016, the ADCQ responded to the 23 November 2015 complaint. The Commissioner articulated what the Commission understood to be the aspects of DJAG’s conduct said to be discriminatory:(i) failure to accept a psychiatrist’s opinion that Mrs Bond was medically unfit to attend an Independent Medical Examination (IME);(ii) making an offer to resolve Mr Bond’s complaint by including a term that Mrs Bond resign and drop her complaints;(iii) victimisation by directing Mrs Bond attend an IME as a reprisal for lodging a complaint with the Queensland Ombudsman in relation to Mr Harvey’s decision in response to the Bonds public interest disclosures;(iv) victimisation by directing Mrs Bond attend an IME as a reprisal for continuing to pursue Mrs Bond’s complaints of discrimination against DJAG and Ms Thomas.The Commissioner said that none of the allegations come under the Act or the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 (Qld). He said that there are insufficient details to indicate a breach of the Act. In relation to the victimisation complaints he says that there is no information to indicate the necessary causal nexus between Mr Harvey’s involvement in the direction to attend an IME and the ADCQ complaint and that there is no information to show that Mr Harvey’s direction to attend an IME three days after the complaint to the ombudsman was an act of reprisal.(r)On 1 December 2015, Mrs Bond filed Contentions in QCAT, setting out allegations of actions by the respondents from November 2011 to April 2014, that is the Pre-6 February 2014 Allegations.(s)On 11 January 2016, the respondents served Mrs Bond with Contentions asserting that a number of Mrs Bond’s Contentions should be struck out because they contained allegations that were out of time, scurrilous, vexatious and irrelevant and insufficiently particularised.(t)On 6 February 2016, Mrs Bond’s representative, Mr Bond, sent to QCAT and to the respondents’ solicitors a proposal to amend her Contentions to remove all out of time allegations in an effort to expedite the matter.(u)On 16 February 2016, Mrs Bond filed and served an Application seeking leave to amend her Contentions to remove the objectionable Contentions.(v)On 17 February 2016, the respondents filed a strike-out Application.(w)On 9 June 2016, a hearing of the Applications took place before Senior Member Endicott. The matter was resolved by the issue of Directions for the filing of new Contentions.(x)On 29 June 2016, Mrs Bond filed a new set of Contentions and filed an Application seeking leave to amend her complaint to include:(i) the Pre-6 February 2014 Allegations;(ii) an allegation of victimisation against the second respondent Christine Thomas. The allegation is that the second respondent victimised the applicant by subjecting her to the embarrassment and humiliation of being the subject of a tabloid news article, by submitting a lie to WorkCover, in response to a good faith allegation by Mrs Bond, that the second respondent had contravened the Act (the Victimisation by a lie to WorkCover Allegation); (iii) an allegation of victimisation raised in the 23 November 2015 complaint, related to a direction for Mrs Bond to attend an Independent Medical Examination (IME) (the Victimisation by IME Allegation);(iv) an allegation of victimisation by an employee of the first respondent, Mr Harvey, whose alleged bias and failure to provide natural justice when investigating Mrs Bond’s public interest disclosure, is said to have been a reprisal for Mrs Bond making complaints that the second respondent had contravened the Act (the Victimisation by breach of Natural Justice Allegation).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.