Blood v Kareela Aviation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Blood v Kareela Aviation Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 432

File number: SYG 1512 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE CAMERON
Date of judgment: 2 June 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Alleged breach of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and a modern award – consultation about major workplace change – redundancy.
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 23, 45

Cases cited:

Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation v Bupa Aged Care Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1246

Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2016) 248 FCR 18

Re Consultation clause in modern awards (2013) 238 IR 282

Division: Fair Work Division
Number of paragraphs: 52
Date of last submissions: 23 May 2022
Date of hearing: 4-5 May 2022
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Guy
Solicitor for the Applicants: Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers’ Association
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr G Fredericks
Solicitor for the Respondent: Norton White

ORDERS

SYG 1512 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

DAVID ROBERT BLOOD

First Applicant

AUSTRALIAN LICENCED AIRCRAFT ENGINEERS ASSOCIATION

Second Applicant

AND:

KAREELA AVIATION PTY LTD ACN 001 693 812

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE CAMERON

DATE OF ORDER:

2 JUNE 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE CAMERON

INTRODUCTION

  1. The first applicant, Mr Blood, was employed by the respondent, Kareela Aviation Pty Ltd (“Kareela Aviation”) as a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer (“LAME”) from February 2013 until 16 December 2020 when he was dismissed on the stated grounds of redundancy.  His employment was initially governed by the Airline Operations – Ground Staff Award 2010 and then, from 4 May 2020 until dismissal, by the Airline Operations – Ground Staff Award 2020 (“Award”). 

  2. At all relevant times, Mr Blood was a member of the second applicant, the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association (“Association”), which was not consulted in relation to his redundancy notwithstanding that Kareela Aviation knew that Mr Blood was an Association member.

  3. The applicants seek declarations of contraventions affecting each of them individually, financial compensation for Mr Blood and pecuniary penalties payable to each of them in respect of the particular contraventions allegedly relevant to them individually.

    PLEADINGS

    Statement of Claim

  4. The applicants alleged that on 15 December 2020, Trevor Breed, Kareela Aviation’s managing director, told Mr Blood that he was being made redundant because Kareela Aviation had no work and that on 16 December 2020 Kareela Aviation terminated Mr Blood’s employment.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blood v Kareela Aviation Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 432
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Commission heard an application by David Robert Blood against Kareela Aviation Pty Ltd. Mr Blood sought relief on the basis that Kareela Aviation failed to consult with him and the Association in relation to a decision to dismiss him, in contravention of cl.32 of the Engineering and Manufacturing Industries Award 2010. The Court was required to determine whether the decision to dismiss Mr Blood constituted a major change in production, program, organisation, structure or technology at Kareela Aviation, which was likely to have significant effects on employees.

The Court found that the termination of Mr Blood’s employment was a significant effect on him, pursuant to cl.32.5(a) of the Award. The question, therefore, was whether the decision to terminate Mr Blood’s employment constituted a major change in production, program, organisation, structure or technology at Kareela Aviation. The Court considered that the number of staff being directly affected by a decision to make positions redundant and the possible impact of the implementation of the decision “more broadly” were relevant to this question. The Court found that the termination of Mr Blood’s employment did not involve a major change in production, program, organisation, structure or technology at Kareela Aviation. The Court was not satisfied that the termination of Mr Blood’s employment was a major change.

Accordingly, the Court found that cl.32 of the Award did not require Kareela Aviation to give notice of its decision to dismiss Mr Blood to, and to hold discussions in relation to it with, him and the Association. The Court dismissed the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Kareela Aviation alleged that it is a small business employer within the meaning of s.23 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”) and the termination of Mr Blood’s employment complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. Statement of Agreed Facts The parties agreed that from 4 February 2013 to 16 December 2020, Mr Blood had been employed full-time by Kareela Aviation as a B1.3 licensed aircraft maintenance engineer, had been covered by the Award and had not received any written warnings. The parties agreed that Kareela Aviation had, since about May 2018, been aware of Mr Blood’s membership to the Association. The parties agreed that Kareela Aviation maintains aircraft on behalf of Trecked and that Trecked and Kareela Aviation are associated entities. From 2019 to 2021, Trecked was the registered operator of 7 helicopters and 2 aeroplanes. The parties agreed that at all relevant times Kareela Aviation employed fewer than 15 employees. LEGISLATION Clause 32 of the Award relevantly provides:32.Consultation about major workplace change32.1If an employer makes a definite decision to make major changes in production, program, organisation, structure or technology that are likely to have significant effects on employees, the employer must:(a)give notice of the changes to all employees who may be affected by them and their representatives (if any);and(b)discuss with affected employees and their representatives (if any):(i) the introduction of the changes; and(ii) their likely effect on employees; and(iii) measures to avoid or reduce the adverse effects of the changes on employees; and(c)commence discussions as soon as practicable after a definite decision has been made.32.2For the purposes of the discussion under clause 32.1(b),the employer must give in writing to the affected employees and their representatives (if any) all relevant information about the changes including:(a)their nature; and(b)their expected effect on employees; and(c)any other matters likely to affect employees.…32.4The employer must promptly consider any matters raised by the employees or their representatives about the changes in the course of the discussion under clause 32.1(b).32.5In clause 32 significant effects, on employees, includes any of the following:(a)termination of employment; …… The Award is a modern award. Section 45 of the FW Act relevantly provides that a person must not contravene a term of a modern award. APPLICANTS’ EVIDENCEDavid Robert Blood Mr Blood deposed that on 15 December 2020 when he was packing up for the day, Mr Breed approached him and they had the following conversation:Mr Breed:I’m going to make you redundant.Mr Blood:I don’t want to be made redundant. How is this fair when you’ve only just employed another engineer?Mr Breed:I can offer you a redundancy package at the moment.Mr Blood:I don’t want to be made redundant. Mr Breed:There is no work at the moment, and I don't need you anymore.Mr Blood:This is always going to happen. It's the nature of our work. ……Mr Breed:Well you are not getting along with the other engineers.Mr Blood:That's not true.…Mr Blood:You have not been treating me the same ever since I got the licence.Mr Breed: You're not worth it because you can't even diagnose a fault. I watched you and you had no clue.Mr Blood:Well we will have to disagree on that as I have the qualifications.Mr Breed: You're not worth it. You don’t even do the electrical inspections.Mr Blood:I was, and I wanted to, but you told me that I wasn't to do them as you wanted them done by Rotordyne so I stopped doing them. Anyway, it is not fair that you have just employed someone and now you want me to go after I have got all your machines ready for the season, and as usual there is nothing to do now but wait for fires to start as we do every year.Mr Breed: I don’t think there will be any fires this year.Mr Blood:Well at least let me find another job and then I will go at least give me that.Mr Breed: Go home and think about it and tomorrow we will have a meeting.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Award is a modern award. Section 45 of the FW Act relevantly provides that a person must not contravene a term of a modern award. APPLICANTS’ EVIDENCEDavid Robert Blood Mr Blood deposed that on 15 December 2020 when he was packing up for the day, Mr Breed approached him and they had the following conversation:Mr Breed:I’m going to make you redundant.Mr Blood:I don’t want to be made redundant. How is this fair when you’ve only just employed another engineer?Mr Breed:I can offer you a redundancy package at the moment.Mr Blood:I don’t want to be made redundant. Mr Breed:There is no work at the moment, and I don't need you anymore.Mr Blood:This is always going to happen. It's the nature of our work. ……Mr Breed:Well you are not getting along with the other engineers.Mr Blood:That's not true.…Mr Blood:You have not been treating me the same ever since I got the licence.Mr Breed: You're not worth it because you can't even diagnose a fault. I watched you and you had no clue.Mr Blood:Well we will have to disagree on that as I have the qualifications.Mr Breed: You're not worth it. You don’t even do the electrical inspections.Mr Blood:I was, and I wanted to, but you told me that I wasn't to do them as you wanted them done by Rotordyne so I stopped doing them. Anyway, it is not fair that you have just employed someone and now you want me to go after I have got all your machines ready for the season, and as usual there is nothing to do now but wait for fires to start as we do every year.Mr Breed: I don’t think there will be any fires this year.Mr Blood:Well at least let me find another job and then I will go at least give me that.Mr Breed: Go home and think about it and tomorrow we will have a meeting. Mr Blood deposed that on 16 December 2020 he went to Kareela Aviation’s workplace at 7:15am and that just after 7:30am he went to Mr Breed’s office where they then had the following conversation:Mr Blood:Do you want to have this meeting now?Mr Breed: Yes.Mr Blood: Well what are we going to do?Mr Breed: I want you gone.Mr Blood: How is that going to go then?Mr Breed: I will pay you your entitlements and a redundancy package and an extra $2000 dollars.Mr Blood: Are you going to give me a redundancy based on years worked? I think it's about 12 weeks for 7 years' service.Mr Breed: You will get what we have agreed on within 7 days.Mr Blood: Ok.Mr Breed: Ok, then Friday will be your last day, but you can go now.…Mr Breed: I will get Caroline to work out your payout and get you a letter of release within 7 days. You should be able to get work as I know Coulson are hiring and Careflight will need people when they get the 412. He deposed that about an hour later, whilst packing his tools and equipment, Mr Breed approached and gave him a signed document that recorded the redundancy agreement. They then had the following discussion:Mr Blood:Where is the redundancy payout? It's not on there as we agreed. You will need to put it on there.Mr Breed:This is not a legal document just a letter of intent.Mr Blood:It needs to have the redundancy payout added that we agreed to.Mr Breed:Ok, I will write it on there. How do you spell it? That will do.He watched Mr Breed write the words in pen and then initial them.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances I find that Mr Blood did not have a representative prior to his contact with Mr Re on 18 December 2020, after his employment had been terminated, and so cl.32 of the Award did not operate to require Kareela Aviation to give notice to such a person or organization, as the Association has contended. CONCLUSION The application will be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Williams reported various of those incidents to Mr Breed.CONSIDERATION I was impressed by Mr Breed and Mr Williams, who both gave their evidence in a straightforward way. Further, Mr Breed’s openness to conceding a mistake in his recollection when confronted with contradictory documentary evidence gave me confidence in the genuineness of his testimony, while Mr Williams’s patent frustration when recalling having been locked out of the hangar, or at least having the most convenient access denied to him for no apparent good reason, lent his evidence considerable credibility. I did not find Mr Blood’s demeanour equally persuasive, not least because of his unwillingness to admit that he did anything wrong notwithstanding that his own affidavit evidence indicated that he was not always a helpful or agreeable colleague or employee. The evidence also persuaded me that he was not hangar foreman as he claimed to be, and he conceded that he was not responsible for managing absences, which meant that he had no business recording staff absences on a calendar on display which, in such circumstances, should be recognised as simple harassment reflecting poorly on him. Further, to describe behaviour which tended to mock or belittle others, specifically the baby formula and “Dumb and Dumber” incidents, as jokes as Mr Blood did in his affidavit in reply, is either disingenuous or demonstrative of considerable insensitivity and lack of insight. Whatever the case, I have less confidence in the accuracy of Mr Blood’s recollection and understanding of events than I do in the accuracy of the recollection and understanding of Mr Breed and Mr Williams. Where the latters’ accounts differ from Mr Blood’s, I prefer their evidence. However, questions of credit have only limited relevance in this matter, which turns on whether Kareela Aviation had been obliged by cl.32 of the Award to give notice of its decision to dismiss Mr Blood to, and to hold discussions in relation to it with, him and the Association. That obligation is engaged if an employer:(a)makes a definite decision;(b)to make major changes in production, program, organisation, structure or technology; and(c)that are likely to have significant effects on employees. Mr Breed had decided, before speaking to Mr Blood on 15 December 2020, that Mr Blood was to be dismissed. Clause 32.5(a) of the Award states that termination of employment is a “significant effect”. The question therefore becomes whether the definite decision to terminate Mr Blood’s employment involved “major changes” in production, program, organisation, structure or technology at Kareela Aviation and it is only to that issue that questions of credit will be relevant. In Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation v Bupa Aged Care Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1246, O’Callaghan J had regard when considering the operation of an award provision similar to cl.32 of the Award not only to the number of staff being directly affected by a decision to make positions redundant, but also the possible impact of the implementation of the decision “more broadly”. In doing so, his Honour referred to the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2016) 248 FCR 18 where it was held that determination of whether a decision involved a “major change” involved consideration of:… facts which went beyond, although they may include, the facts of the redundancies. (per Jessup J at 72 [187]Examples of potentially relevant considerations were provided in the reasons for judgment of White J at 143 [499].