Blandon and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Blandon and Comcare (Compensation) [2018] AATA 4614 (18 September 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2001; and 2017/2388

Re:Allan Blandon

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries

Date:18 September 2018

Date of written reasons:        17 December 2018

Place:Canberra

This hearing of this matter will be reopened. The hearing will resume on 18 December 2018.

........................................................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to reopen the hearing – inquisitorial function of the Tribunal – mistaken apprehension of the facts – hearing reopened.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 2A, 33

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 14

Cases

Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165

BQRW and Commissioner of Taxation [2014] AATA 410

Confidential and Commissioner of Taxation [2013] AATA 382

Kowalski and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2007] AATA 1988

Inspector-General in Bankruptcy v Bradshaw [2006] FCA 22

WRITTEN REASONS FOR ORAL DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries

17 December 2018

  1. On 27 August 2018 the Tribunal conducted a hearing in this matter. The hearing was completed that day and closing submissions were made. The following day, the Applicant, Mr Allan Blandon, sought permission to reopen his case. After hearing the parties, the Tribunal decided on 18 September 2018 to accede to this request. What follows are the reasons for that decision.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Blandon suffered an injury at work on 14 May 2010 in which he fractured his left wrist. Comcare subsequently accepted liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) for two conditions arising from that incident: fracture of carpal bones (left) and chronic pain syndrome.[1]

    [1] In this decision, italicised text is generally used to indicate direct quotations.

  3. Presently before the Tribunal are two applications for merits review, one relating to each accepted condition. In the first (2016/2001) Mr Blandon seeks review of Comcare’s determination that he is entitled to compensation under s 24 for whole person impairment of 18% in relation to the fracture of carpal bones (left) condition (he believes he is entitled to more than 18%). In the second (2017/2388) he challenges a decision denying compensation under ss 24 and 27 in relation to the condition of chronic pain syndrome. Specifically, he claims to be entitled to compensation for whole person impairment of 36% arising from the loss of grip strength in his left hand.

  4. At the hearing on 27 August 2018, the Tribunal considered an application by Comcare to dismiss Mr Blandon’s application under s 42B(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) on the basis that it had no reasonable prospect of success. The Tribunal decided to dismiss that application, and the hearing proceeded.

  5. As it did so, medical reports were tendered from Prof David Champion, Dr Garth Eaton, Dr David McNicol and Dr Graeme Griffith, among others. However, neither party called medical experts to give viva voce evidence.[2] The intention of the parties evinced by this approach was that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blandon and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4614
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerned applications for merits review by Mr Allan Blandon against decisions made by Comcare. Mr Blandon sought compensation for a fractured wrist sustained in 2010, which resulted in accepted conditions of carpal bone fracture and chronic pain syndrome. The dispute centred on the extent of whole person impairment arising from these conditions, with Mr Blandon believing he was entitled to greater compensation than determined by Comcare.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Blandon's accepted conditions resulted in permanent impairments for which compensation was payable under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, and how to interpret the medical evidence presented in written reports to determine the extent of any such impairment. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the medical reports clearly established the existence, permanence, and cause of any impairment, and whether pain experienced by Mr Blandon related to his accepted conditions.

Deputy President Gary Humphries P reasoned that while the hearing had concluded and closing submissions made, the medical evidence presented was sufficiently ambiguous to create doubt regarding the correct interpretation of the doctors' opinions. The Tribunal acknowledged that reopening a concluded hearing is an exceptional step, but found that the circumstances warranted it. This decision was influenced by the fact that the ambiguity in the medical evidence meant the Tribunal could not confidently determine Mr Blandon's entitlement to compensation based on the initial hearing. The Tribunal also considered that reopening the hearing would not significantly affront the public interest in finality or expedition, given the relatively short delay until the resumed hearing.

The Tribunal acceded to Mr Blandon's request to reopen the hearing, finding that exceptional circumstances existed. This decision was made despite Comcare's arguments regarding the adequacy of the opportunity to present the case, the public interest in finality, and potential cost consequences. The Tribunal noted that Comcare had indicated an intention to adduce new evidence relating to Mr Blandon's credit as a witness.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 27 August 2018 the Tribunal conducted a hearing in this matter. The hearing was completed that day and closing submissions were made. The following day, the Applicant, Mr Allan Blandon, sought permission to reopen his case. After hearing the parties, the Tribunal decided on 18 September 2018 to accede to this request. What follows are the reasons for that decision. BACKGROUND Mr Blandon suffered an injury at work on 14 May 2010 in which he fractured his left wrist. Comcare subsequently accepted liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) for two conditions arising from that incident: fracture of carpal bones (left) and chronic pain syndrome.[1] [1] In this decision, italicised text is generally used to indicate direct quotations. Presently before the Tribunal are two applications for merits review, one relating to each accepted condition. In the first (2016/2001) Mr Blandon seeks review of Comcare’s determination that he is entitled to compensation under s 24 for whole person impairment of 18% in relation to the fracture of carpal bones (left) condition (he believes he is entitled to more than 18%). In the second (2017/2388) he challenges a decision denying compensation under ss 24 and 27 in relation to the condition of chronic pain syndrome. Specifically, he claims to be entitled to compensation for whole person impairment of 36% arising from the loss of grip strength in his left hand. At the hearing on 27 August 2018, the Tribunal considered an application by Comcare to dismiss Mr Blandon’s application under s 42B(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) on the basis that it had no reasonable prospect of success. The Tribunal decided to dismiss that application, and the hearing proceeded. As it did so, medical reports were tendered from Prof David Champion, Dr Garth Eaton, Dr David McNicol and Dr Graeme Griffith, among others. However, neither party called medical experts to give viva voce evidence.[2] The intention of the parties evinced by this approach was that the correct or preferable decision in these applications would be clear to the Tribunal from a perusal of the doctors’ reports. This however proved to be far from the case.[2] In the case of Dr Griffith, this omission was accounted for by the doctor having died before the hearing. The primary issue faced by the Tribunal at the hearing – as articulated by Comcare in its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions – was whether Mr Blandon’s accepted conditions resulted in one or more permanent impairments, for which compensation could be calculated pursuant to s 24. As the hearing proceeded, however, the focus of submissions turned to the question of what precisely particular doctors had meant by the words they used in their reports where they addressed aspects of the issue before the Tribunal. Areas of disagreement included whether pain experienced by Mr Blandon related to either or both of his accepted conditions, whether he suffered any impairment and whether any impairment, if suffered, was permanent. Counsel for the parties took diametrically opposed positions on how the Tribunal should interpret the opinions expressed by the doctors on those topics, and each was able to point to passages in the opinions lending their respective position some weight.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the case of hearings conducted pursuant to claims made under the Act, a constraint on the Tribunal is the requirement in s 66(1):Evidence in proceedings before Administrative Appeals Tribunal(1)Where: (a)a claimant who has instituted proceedings under this Part seeks to adduce any matter in evidence before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in those proceedings; and (b)the claimant had not disclosed that matter to the Tribunal at least 28 days before the day fixed for the hearing of those proceedings; that matter is not admissible in evidence in those proceedings without the leave of the Tribunal. CONSIDERATION In resisting the application to reopen the hearing, Comcare argued that Mr Blandon had been given an adequate opportunity to present his case at the hearing, and that the reopening of that case was unwarranted. It reminded the Tribunal that there were costs consequences in doing so, and that there was a public interest in the finality of litigation, noting that these proceedings have been on foot since 2016. It was observed that any new evidence adduced by Mr Blandon would fall foul of s 66, and may trigger the need for further evidence to be obtained by Comcare. Reference was made to BQRW and Commissioner of Taxation [2014] AATA 410, where, at [96], the Tribunal declined to allow the reopening of the applicants’ case to remedy any failure by them to take best advantage of the hearing. In that respect, Comcare noted that it had not sought to introduce any new evidence or call its own doctors, nor to cross-examine Mr Blandon’s doctors. The inference I take from the reference in this context to BQRW is that Comcare considered that Mr Blandon had made a tactical error in failing to call the doctors, in that the propositions he relied upon to demonstrate his eligibility for compensation were not as clearly demonstrated by the doctors’ written reports as Mr Blandon’s legal advisers might have assumed. Counsel for Comcare said that the applicant’s case was mosaicked, by which I understand her to mean that key elements of the claim were based on extrapolations from the doctors’ reports rather than clear statements establishing those elements. An applicant seeking merits review must satisfy the Tribunal that the statutory power to set aside or vary a decision maker’s adverse decision should be exercised in his or her favour. This does not impose an onus of proof, but recognises that the conditions of a legislative scheme offering benefits must be met: Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165 at [68]. Where an applicant’s evidence that they meet the conditions of a scheme falls short of the required satisfaction, an application must fail. In the present case, Comcare argues that Mr Blandon’s medical evidence is inadequate to satisfy the Tribunal that he is entitled to compensation, and his application must, therefore, fail. I am not unfamiliar with the experience of an applicant presenting medical evidence which fails to motivate the Tribunal to accept the case for entitlement which the evidence is alleged to support. Such cases are all too common. But this is not such a case. This is a case where the totality of the medical evidence, if interpreted in a certain way, is quite capable of supporting a claim for entitlement to compensation. If interpreted in another way, it is not. The dilemma facing the Tribunal is that, at the conclusion of the hearing, the evidence was sufficiently ambiguous as to create doubt as to which interpretation is to be preferred.

Decision

Reasons for decision

With respect to the other factors mentioned in Confidential and Commissioner of Taxation, I do not consider that reopening the hearing significantly affronts the public interest in finality of litigation, or the requirement for expedition, given that the resumed hearing will occur three months from the date of my decision to reopen. I also consider that this is not a case of the applicant tactically choosing not to adduce evidence to obtain some forensic advantage or of the boundaries of the reopened case being hard to define and difficult to protect. I note, in addition, since making the decision to allow the hearing to be reopened, Comcare has indicated its intention to adduce new evidence of its own, relating to Mr Blandon’s credit as a witness.CONCLUSION The reopening of a concluded hearing is a step we should be taken only in exceptional circumstances. I am satisfied that those circumstances exist here.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.