Blandon and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Blandon and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 3277 (5 September 2019)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2001 and 2017/2388

Re:Allan Blandon

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Date:5 September 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal:

(a)affirms the reviewable decision of 21 March 2016 assessing permanent impairment for the accepted carpal fracture condition under s 24 of the Act at 18%;

(b)sets aside the reviewable decision of 3 March 2017 and instead decides that the Australian Capital Territory is liable to pay compensation to Mr Blandon for permanent impairment and non-economic loss under ss 24 and 27 in respect of the accepted chronic pain syndrome condition, with the degree of permanent impairment pursuant to s 24(5) being 10%.

.......................................................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – chronic pain syndrome – whether Mr Blandon suffers from claimed condition – whether Mr Blandon’s chronic pain syndrome condition results in permanent impairment – nature of assessment of whole person impairment considered – manner of assessment of impairments pursuant to s 24 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – one decision under review affirmed, second decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47

Comcare v Broadhurst [2011] FCAFC 39

Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197

Comcare v Wuth[2018] FCAFC 13

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

Portors v Comcare [2018] FCA 914

Secondary Materials

American Medical Association, Guide to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition)

Comcare, Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment (Edition 2.1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

5 September 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Allan Blandon was at work as a warehouse manager for ACT Health on 14 May 2010 when he fell and broke his left wrist. Comcare subsequently accepted liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) for three conditions arising from that incident, including one for fracture of carpal bones (left) and another for chronic pain syndrome.[1]

    [1] In this decision, italicised text is generally used to indicate direct quotations.

  2. Presently before the Tribunal are two applications for merits review, one relating to each of those accepted conditions. The first of these (2016/2001) seeks review of Comcare’s determination that Mr Blandon is entitled to compensation under s 24 for whole person impairment (WPI) of 18% in relation to the fracture of carpal bones (left) condition. In the second (2017/2388) he challenges a decision denying compensation under ss 24 and 27 in relation to the condition of chronic pain syndrome.

  3. These proceedings have taken, at times, an eventful course. At the initial hearing on 27 August 2018 before me and Member Dr Wilkins, the Tribunal considered an application by Comcare to dismiss Mr Blandon’s application under s 42B(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 on the basis that it had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blandon and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 3277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Blandon against decisions made by Comcare regarding compensation for permanent impairment. The dispute centred on whether Mr Blandon suffered from chronic pain syndrome as a secondary injury, and if so, whether this condition resulted in permanent impairment warranting further compensation beyond that already assessed for his original carpal fracture. The case was heard by Deputy President Gary Humphries Ao of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Blandon suffered from a condition of chronic pain syndrome in addition to his accepted carpal fracture, and if such a condition existed, whether it resulted in a permanent impairment that was compensable under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The Tribunal was required to assess the nature and extent of any permanent impairment, considering the medical evidence presented by both parties and the relevant assessment guides.

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence from several specialists. While Comcare contended that Mr Blandon suffered only one condition, the Tribunal found that the medical opinions, particularly those of Dr Eaton, supported the existence of a secondary condition of chronic pain syndrome, likely arising from the chronic pain and dysfunction following the initial injury. The Tribunal noted that even if Mr Blandon had exaggerated the severity of his symptoms, this did not negate the existence of the condition or the resulting impairments. The Tribunal applied the principles of assessing whole person impairment under section 24 of the Act, cautioning against double compensation for pain.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the initial assessment of 18% permanent impairment for the accepted carpal fracture. However, it set aside the previous decision regarding the secondary injury and substituted a new decision, finding that Mr Blandon was entitled to compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss in respect of the accepted chronic pain syndrome, assessing this impairment at 10%. Comcare was also directed to pay Mr Blandon's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Blandon was examined again when the hearing was reopened on 18 December 2018. He told the Tribunal he was aware he was under surveillance because of the presence of a strange car in his street. He denied that he had exaggerated the extent of his disability to either Prof Champion or Dr Eaton.MEDICAL EVIDENCE A number of medical reports were tendered. Three doctors were called to give live evidence before the Tribunal: ·For Mr Blandon: Dr Garth Eaton, Occupational Physician, and Prof David Champion, Consultant Physician in Rheumatology, Musculoskeletal Medicine and Pain Medicine; and·For Comcare: Dr David Gorman, Consultant General Physician, Pain Management Specialist and Medical Oncologist. The medical evidence is summarised below.Doctors who did not appearDr W Bruce Conolly, Associate Professor of Hand Surgery Three reports of Dr Conolly were tendered. The first, dated 15 July 2013, noted Mr Blandon’s complaint of residual arm pain. In addition to reporting on his accepted wrist condition, Dr Conolly noted that the remainder of his upper limb functioned well. In his third report, dated 4 September 2013, Dr Conolly discussed the inadequate initial diagnosis of Mr Blandon’s condition and the delay of treatment. Dr G G Griffith, Consultant Surgeon Dr Griffith provided a report dated 30 November 2013 in which he noted that Mr Blandon described throbbing myalgia in his arm as far as the shoulder and cervical region. He assessed him as suffering from a permanent impairment of 14% utilising the Comcare Guide. When utilising the American Medical Association’s Guide to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th Edition (the AMA Guide), Dr Griffith assessed a 20% permanent impairment when using conversion Table 16-3. However, in a further report dated 24 March 2014, he corrected the impairment rating under the Comcare Guide to 23%.Dr A Cairns, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon In his report dated 16 July 2014, Dr Cairns observed in Mr Blandon an apparent chronic, non-specific regional pain dysfunction syndrome and manifestations of biopsychosocial potentiation in his presentation. Dr Cairns noted the following:He is able to drive a motor vehicle, indicating that he employs the 4th and 5th fingers on the left hand…He was seen to consistently lean on the arm of the chair on his left elbow throughout provision of his history, and there was no apparent restriction of movement of his left upper limb when removing his upper garments to allow physical examination….Apart from the subjective report of an area of numbness involving the left index, thumb and forearm, there were no other neurologic abnormalities apparent in either upper limb….he consistently leaned to the left, demonstrating a full range of pain-free movement at the right shoulder…Active movements of the left shoulder undertaken with grimacing and contortion of abnormal pain behaviour were estimated as flexion 160◦ extension 50◦…Movements of flexion and extension of the left elbow were comparable to the right…Serial grip strength measurements averaged 47kg on the right as compared to 13.5kg on the left…there was minimal reduction in power of pincer pinch strength of the thumb and index fingers…he writes and plays tennis with his “ambidextrous” right upper limb.Dr David McNicol, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon

Decision

Reasons for decision

Even assuming, as one could here, that there has been a patina of exaggeration by Mr Blandon on the severity of his symptoms, this does not establish either that the condition is a fiction or that the impairments are imaginative embellishments. Mr Blandon struck me as a witness of truth, notwithstanding my perception that it is possible he has overstated the effects of his condition.CONCLUSION I am satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Blandon’s accepted condition of chronic pain syndrome persists, and produces impairments which entitle him to compensation pursuant to ss 24 and 27. Accordingly, the Tribunal:(c)affirms the reviewable decision of 21 March 2016 assessing person impairment for the accepted carpal fracture under s 24 of the Act at 18%;(d)sets aside the reviewable decision of 3 March 2017 and instead decides that Comcare is liable to pay compensation to Mr Blandon for permanent impairment and non-economic loss under ss 24 and 27 in respect of the accepted chronic pain syndrome, with the degree of permanent impairment pursuant to s 24(5) being 10%; and(e)directs that Comcare pay Mr Blandon’s costs, as agreed or taxed, pursuant to s 67(8) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Therefore, to assess pain separately would result in double compensation. Double compensation must be guarded against. She cited Principle 7 of the Guide is authority for that proposition.CONSIDERATION As Mr Anforth aptly observed, the parties in these proceedings disagree on just about every point of law raised in the submissions and on many of the facts. That fact has made reaching a decision here an arduous exercise.Does Mr Blandon suffer the injury of chronic pain syndrome? It may be observed that the central issue in these proceedings is whether Mr Blandon suffers from a condition other than his original carpal fracture. The parties now accept that an 18% WPI was correctly assessed with respect to that original injury, and so the question of a secondary injury assumes some significance.[3] [3] Mr Blandon argued that an alternative characterisation of his case is that the various impairments he suffers in his left upper limb (including loss of grip strength, loss of elbow joint rotation and loss of shoulder joint rotation) are attributable to the original injury and not to the secondary injury. Under this contention, the impairments, however arising, must still be assessed and they have not been assessed using the method chosen by Comcare. However, this contention appears to be at odds with his submission that The assessment from the structural injury is agreed at 18% and is not in issue, and I have set it aside. The task facing the Tribunal is to determine whether there is in fact a secondary injury, or whether Comcare should succeed with its contention that liability for the accepted secondary injury be withdrawn pursuant to the principles in Hannaford. In this respect, Comcare contended that all three experts appearing before the Tribunal agreed that Mr Blandon suffered only one condition, not two. However, I cannot concur with this characterisation of the evidence. Dr Gorman’s opinion is quite clear; he considers that there is only one condition. In his report of 23 November 2018 he answered the question as to whether Mr Blandon suffers any condition besides that which arose on 14 May 2010:No, he did not suffer from any condition besides that which arose on 14 May 2010. In his report of 24 August 2016, Dr Eaton referred to the possibility that Mr Blandon had developed Secondary musculolligamentous strain of the neck, left shoulder and left elbow … due to the adoption of an antalgic posture of the left upper limb due to chronic pain and dysfunction over an extended period. In his subsequent report of 25 September 2016 he again referred to this condition, saying this does not refer to definite additional underlying structural injury but probable secondary effects of the chronic left wrist injury and subsequent chronic regional pain condition. Again, in his report of 7 December 2018 Dr Eaton made reference to severe chronic pain and dysfunction in the left upper limb which he said was likely to be permanent. And in his report of 10 December 2018 he referred to the left upper limb pain condition.