Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Bird In The Hand 2 Pty Ltd v S&K Johnson Construction Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 560 Hearing dates: 29 April, 3 May 2024 Date of orders: 3 May 2024 Decision date: 03 May 2024 Jurisdiction: Equity - Real Property List Before: Parker J Decision: See [64]
Catchwords: COSTS — security for costs — corporate plaintiff — off the plan development — application by plaintiff for statutory leave to rescind — plaintiff a special purpose vehicle — overall loss projected for development but loan facility funds available to pay legal costs — inability to pay not established — proceedings defensive in nature — application for security refused
Legislation Cited: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Aquatown Pty Ltd v Holder Stroud Pty Ltd [1995] FCA 1667
Aurora Networks v Helbedl [2013] FCA 632
Classic Ceramic Importers v Ceramica Antiga SA (1994) 13 ACSR 263
Heller Factors v John Arnold's Surf Shop (1979) 4 ACLR 492
Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd v Sanrus Pty Ltd [2019] 3 Qd R 143
Texts Cited: Nil.
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Notice of Motion filed 15 April 2023
S&K Johnson Constructions Pty Limited (First Applicant/First Defendant)
Maggie-Rose Melanie Sciascia (Second Applicant/Second Defendant)
Dean John Glen-Holmes (Third Applicant/Fourth Defendant)
Rebecca Ann Benney (Fourth Applicant/Fifth Defendant)
Gregory John Chapman (Fifth Applicant/Sixth Defendant)
Daniel Gregory Chapman (Sixth Applicant/Seventh Defendant)
Brock Anthony King (Seventh Applicant/Eighth Defendant)
Stephen Schulter Schulter (Eighth Applicant/Ninth Defendant)
Lynn-Holly Casolocan Ting (Ninth Applicant/Tenth Defendant)
Pervin Rajah (Tenth Applicant/Eleventh Defendant)
Timothy Malcolm Cole (Eleventh Applicant/Twelfth Defendant)
Alison Morag Russell (Twelfth Applicant/Thirteenth Defendant)
Clint Mathew (Thirteenth Applicant/Fifteenth Defendant)
Shoby Alias (Fourteenth Applicant/Sixteenth Defendant)
Bird In The Hand 2 Pty Limited (Respondent/Plaintiff)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
A Avery-Williams (Applicants)
D R Pritchard SC/J J Young (Respondent)
Moin & Associates Pty Ltd (Applicants)
OMB Solicitors (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2023/164680 Publication restriction: Nil
JUDGMENT- Ex Tempore
Revised from transcript and annotated; issued 14 May 2024
-
This is an application for security for costs in property litigation pending before the Court. The application is made by 14 of the 15 active defendants, who are commonly represented in the proceedings. They seek security from the plaintiff in the sum of $300,000. I will refer to them collectively as the "defendants" in this judgment.
-
The proceedings concern land which is being subdivided into development lots. The plaintiff, Bird In The Hand 2 Pty Limited ("BIH"), owns the land and is undertaking the subdivision. The defendants are off the plan purchasers of lots in the subdivision. Their contracts provide, as is commonly the case, for BIH, as vendor, to be able to rescind if the plan of subdivision is not registered by a sunset date.
-
The development is subject to the statutory regime for off the plan contracts in the Conveyancing Act 1919 (“CA”) (Part 4, Div…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bird in the Hand 2 Pty Ltd v S&K Johnson Construction Pty Lt... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 560
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether Bird in the Hand 2 Pty Ltd could demonstrate that it was unable to pay the costs of the proceedings. The plaintiff argued that its inability to pay was evidenced by the projected overall loss for the development. However, the court noted that the plaintiff had access to a loan facility that could be used to cover the legal costs. This facility demonstrated that the plaintiff had the means to fund its legal expenses, thus negating the argument that it was unable to pay. Furthermore, the court considered the nature of the proceedings and found that they were defensive in character, as the plaintiff sought to rescind the contract due to alleged breaches by the defendant. Consequently, the plaintiff was not entitled to statutory leave to rescind without providing security for the defendant's costs.
The court ultimately refused the plaintiff's application for security for costs. The reasoning was based on the plaintiff's access to a loan facility that could be used to cover the legal costs and the defensive nature of the proceedings. The court found that the plaintiff had not established its inability to pay the costs and that the proceedings were defensive in nature, which were factors that weighed against granting security for costs. As a result, Bird in the Hand 2 Pty Ltd was required to provide security for the costs of the defendant's legal proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was brought before the court on an application by the plaintiff for statutory leave to rescind the requirement for security for costs. The plaintiff had previously unsuccessfully applied for security for costs in another court. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff had established its inability to pay the legal costs of the defendant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff has established its inability to pay the legal costs of the defendant?
2. Whether the plaintiff's projected overall loss for the development constitutes a sufficient basis for the court to rescind the requirement for security for costs?
3. Whether the plaintiff's access to a loan facility to potentially cover the legal costs affects its ability to pay the defendant's costs?
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff has not established its inability to pay the legal costs of the defendant. The application for statutory leave to rescind the requirement for security for costs was dismissed.
2. The court found that the plaintiff's projected overall loss for the development does not constitute a sufficient basis for the court to rescind the requirement for security for costs.
3. The court determined that the plaintiff's access to a loan facility to potentially cover the legal costs does not affect its ability to pay the defendant's costs. This factor was not deemed sufficient to establish an inability to pay.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Bird in the Hand 2 Pty Ltd v S&K Johnson Construction Pty Ltd examined the plaintiff's application for statutory leave to rescind the requirement for security for costs, focusing on the plaintiff's ability to pay and the overall financial viability of the project. The court noted that the plaintiff, being a special purpose vehicle for an off the plan development, had projected an overall loss for the development. However, this did not lead the court to conclude that the plaintiff was unable to pay the defendant's costs.
In considering the plaintiff's inability to pay, the court emphasised that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate its current inability to meet its financial obligations. The court relied on established principles that a plaintiff must establish an inability to pay costs on the balance of probabilities. The availability of a loan facility to potentially cover the legal costs was noted but did not sway the court, as it was not convinced that this access to funds equated to an inability to pay.
Further, the court found that the plaintiff's projected overall loss for the development was not a sufficient basis for rescinding the security for costs. This decision was made considering the overall nature of the proceedings, which the court viewed as defensive rather than offensive. The court held that the plaintiff's financial projections did not outweigh the defendant's right to be protected against potential unpaid costs.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a plaintiff must establish an inability to pay costs on the balance of probabilities, and projections of overall loss or availability of future funding do not suffice in the absence of concrete evidence of current inability. The court's refusal to rescind the requirement for security for costs was grounded in its assessment that the plaintiff had not met the requisite standard of proof regarding its financial position.