2 ,93
JUDGMENT NO. ........ ..... .a.. . H........ ..
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
1 1
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
1 No.VG 341 of 1993 1 GENERAL DIVISION 1 B E T W E E N :
BHP PETROLEUM (TIMOR SEA) PTY LIMITED and OTHERS
Appellant
MINISTER FOR RESOURCES
Respondent
Judge : Heerey J Date: 18 November 1993
Place: Melbourne
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
I have been asked to exercise the jurisdiction conferred by
0.10, r.l(lA) to give certain directions as to the hearing of this appeal to the Full Court from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. That rule provides:
"In any proceeding which is to be heard by a Full Court, whether in the original or appellate jurisdiction, such directions as is thought proper with respect to the conduct of the proceeding may be given by the Court constituted by a single Judge."
AUSTRA' '4
The appeal must be heard by a Full Court because one of the members of the tribunal was a judge: see Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s.44(3)(c).
The case before the Tribunal concerned a decision that the appellant could not combine a number of petroleum projects for the purposes of s.20 of the Petroleum Resources Rent Assessment Act 1987.
- 5 DEC 1993
FEDERAL COURT OF
The respondent succeeded before the Tribunal on a jurisdictional point. It was argued that the appeal to the Tribunal was brought out of time. The initial appeal to the Tribunal was lodged in March 1991, and the jurisdictional point was only raised very shortly before the Tribunal commenced its hearing in February 1993.
The Tribunal proceeded to deal with the whole of the case and in the event upheld the jurisdictional point, although it found in favour of the appellant on the merits.
I have been asked by the respondent to give a direction that the jurisdictional point be decided by the Full Court as a preliminary question. I have been told that the estimate of time for a Full Court hearing, if the matter proceeds on the merits as well as the jurisdictional point, is four days. Argument on the latter point alone would, I am told, take half a day.
somewhat large, bearing in mind that the hearing before the I must say the estimate of four days for a full hearing seems Tribunal itself only took seven days, and of course the appeal to the Full Court will be confined to questions of law. There will be, as Practice Note No 1 requires, written summaries of arguments required to be submitted beforehand.
There is some significance in the fact that the Tribunal itself considered that the appropriate and convenient course was to deal with both jurisdictional point and merits at the one time.
However the major fact which influences me against granting the direction sought is the potential for delay which would, or might, ensue if the course suggested were adopted. The next callover for Full Court hearings in Melbourne is December for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BHP Petroleum (Timor Sea) P/L v Minister for Resources and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1993] FCA 882
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the jurisdictional point should be decided by the Full Court as a preliminary question, as sought by the Minister for Resources, or whether the case should proceed with both the jurisdictional point and the merits being decided together. This issue arose because the Tribunal had previously decided to address both aspects concurrently. The court had to balance the potential delay and burden on the appellant against the efficiency of addressing the jurisdictional issue separately.
Justice Heerey concluded that splitting the case into two parts for the Full Court hearing would likely result in significant delay for the appellant, as the jurisdictional point might not be decided until well into the next year. He also noted that this could result in the inconvenience of reconvening the same members of the Full Court or starting afresh with a new court. While the potential for obtaining special leave to appeal to the High Court was mentioned, the court did not consider it a decisive factor. The court ultimately decided to dismiss the application and proceed with both the jurisdictional point and the merits together.
The court ordered that the Minister for Resources pay the appellant's costs of the motion.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi