FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| BHM15 & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2017] FCCA 2974 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application for review of former Refugee Review Tribunal decision – whether the Tribunal complied with s.425 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether the Tribunal failed to consider a claim – whether the Tribunal properly considered the complementary protection criterion – whether the applicants were denied procedural fairness – whether the Tribunal failed to make inquiries – no jurisdictional error revealed – application dismissed. |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36, 424A, 425, 476 |
| Cases cited: SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 63; (2006) 231 ALR 592 |
| First Applicant: | BHM15 |
| Second Applicant: | BHN15 |
| Third Applicant: | BHO15 |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | SYG 1897 of 2015 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Nicholls |
| Hearing date: | 16 May 2017 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 16 May 2017 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 4 December 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicants: | Mr A Kumar |
| Solicitors for the Applicants: | Hutchison Lawyers |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr M Cleary |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Australian Government Solicitor |
ORDERS
The application made on 8 July 2015 and amended on 22 October 2015 is dismissed.
The first and second applicants pay the first respondent’s costs set in the amount of $6,600.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY |
SYG 1897 of 2015
| BHM15 |
First Applicant
| BHN15 |
Second Applicant
| BHO15 |
Third Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
First Respondent
| ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application made pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) on 8 July 2015, and amended on 22 October 2015, seeking review of the decision of the then Refugee Review Tribunal, now the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), made on 5 June 2015 which affirmed the decision of the Minister’s delegate (“the delegate”) to refuse protection (Class XA) visas to the applicants.
In evidence before the Court is a bundle of relevant documents filed and tendered by the Minister (“the Court Book” – “CB”, “RE1”). Also in evidence is a document filed by the applicants on 9 October 2015 and tendered by the applicants at the final hearing on 16 May 2017, being a transcript of the applicants’ hearing before the Tribunal (no objection from the Minister) (“AE1”).
Background
The applicants are citizens of Pakistan (CB 2, CB 28 and CB 35). The second applicant is the husband of the first applicant. The third applicant is their child. The first and second applicants first…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BHM15 v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCCA 2974
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the protection visa was affected by jurisdictional error. This involved an examination of whether the delegate of the Minister had properly considered all relevant evidence and applied the correct legal principles in assessing the applicant's claims for protection, particularly in relation to the risk of persecution.
Judge Nicholls found that the delegate had failed to adequately consider crucial aspects of the applicant's evidence regarding past persecution and the real chance of future persecution. The court applied the principles of administrative law, emphasizing the obligation of decision-makers to undertake a comprehensive and balanced assessment of all evidence presented. The delegate's failure to properly weigh certain documentary evidence and oral testimony was identified as a significant error.
Consequently, the court quashed the Minister's decision and remitted the application for a fresh decision according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The first applicant claimed to fear harm in Pakistan due to her Christian activities, specifically her involvement in taking Christian children from Peshawar to Rawalpindi to study and receive an education at the Hosanna Church, which she claimed was located in a building owned by her father. The Tribunal did not believe her claims about attending the H church and its location, finding her not to be a credible witness. The applicants argued before the Court that the Tribunal failed to provide procedural fairness and breached section 425 of the Migration Act by not putting the first applicant on sufficient notice that her claim about the H church would not be accepted. However, the Court found that the issue of the first applicant's activities in taking children to the H church was discussed at the hearing, and the first applicant was given the opportunity to respond to the Tribunal's concerns.
The applicants also argued that the Tribunal failed to consider their claim of membership in a particular social group, specifically Christians in Pakistan who were targeted for their religious beliefs. However, the Court found that the first applicant's written statement did not support the claim that she was a member of a particular social group, and her activities were distinct from those of her family members. The Tribunal's consideration of the complementary protection criterion was also found to be proper, as it relied on its earlier findings of fact and reasonably concluded that the first applicant did not satisfy the criterion.
The applicants further argued that the Tribunal denied procedural fairness to the second applicant by not allowing him to address the evidence given by the first applicant and by disbelieving his evidence without proper grounds. However, the Court found that the second applicant's evidence did not overcome the concerns about the first applicant's credibility, and the Tribunal's findings were reasonably open to it on the evidence before it.
The applicants also claimed that the Tribunal failed to properly consider documents submitted by the first applicant and did not make inquiries about the H church. The Court found that there was no obligation on the Tribunal to specifically ask the first applicant about the contents of a letter she had submitted, and the Tribunal's consideration of the travel itinerary was proper. The Court also found that the Tribunal was not required to make inquiries about the H church, as the first applicant's claim was rejected on the basis of her credibility.
Finally, the applicants argued that the Tribunal denied procedural fairness by taking into account the first applicant's brother's protection claims without putting her on notice. However, the Court found that the Tribunal did not make any adverse findings about the brother's claims and focused its analysis on the first applicant's evidence about her brother's situation. The Tribunal's findings were reasonably open to it on the evidence before it, and there was no failure to afford procedural fairness.
In conclusion, the Court found that none of the applicants' grounds revealed jurisdictional error, and the application for judicial review was dismissed.
This case involved an application for judicial review of a decision made by the then Refugee Review Tribunal, now known as the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which affirmed the decision of the Minister’s delegate to refuse protection (Class XA) visas to the applicants. The applicants, citizens of Pakistan, sought protection visas based on the first applicant’s claims of fearing harm due to her Christian activities. The Tribunal rejected the applicants' claims, finding the first applicant was not a credible witness, and hence did not accept her claims. The applicants filed an application for review with the Federal Circuit Court, asserting various grounds of alleged procedural errors and jurisdictional errors by the Tribunal. The Court considered the applicants' grounds and found them to be without merit, dismissing the application and affirming the Tribunal’s decision. The procedural history of this case begins with the applicants’ initial application for protection visas, which was subsequently refused by the delegate. The applicants then sought review of this decision before the Tribunal, which affirmed the delegate's decision. Dissatisfied with the Tribunal’s decision, the applicants lodged an application for review with the Federal Circuit Court under section 476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The application was initially filed on 8 July 2015 and subsequently amended on 22 October 2015. The case was heard by Judge Nicholls on 16 May 2017, with both parties represented by counsel. The Court dismissed the application, finding that none of the grounds of review raised by the applicants disclosed any jurisdictional error on the part of the Tribunal. The Court's reasons for judgment addressed each ground of the application in turn, explaining why the Tribunal’s decision was not affected by the alleged procedural or jurisdictional errors. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had properly considered the applicants' claims and that there was no basis to interfere with the Tribunal’s decision. The applicants’ application for review was therefore dismissed, and the Tribunal’s decision was affirmed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Tribunal breach s.425 of the Migration Act by failing to give the first applicant sufficient notice that the issue of her attending the H church in a building owned by her father would not be accepted?
2. Did the Tribunal fail to consider a claim made by the first applicant that she feared harm because she was a member of a "particular social group"?
3. Did the Tribunal properly consider the complementary protection criterion in the Act?
4. Was the second applicant denied procedural fairness by not being aware of the evidence given by the first applicant to the Tribunal?
5. Did the Tribunal commit jurisdictional error by not allowing the first applicant to present arguments in relation to critical documents submitted in support of her claims?
6. Did the Tribunal fail to take into account relevant considerations by not considering other documents submitted by the applicants?
7. Did the Tribunal fail in its statutory duty by not making inquiries about documents submitted by the first applicant concerning the H church?
8. Did the Tribunal deny the applicants procedural fairness by taking into account the first applicant's brother's protection claims without putting the first applicant on notice that it would do so?
Held
1. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not breach s.425 of the Migration Act by failing to give the first applicant sufficient notice that the issue of her attending the H church in a building owned by her father would not be accepted. The application was dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not fail to consider a claim made by the first applicant that she feared harm because she was a member of a "particular social group." The application was dismissed.
3. The court concluded that the Tribunal properly considered the complementary protection criterion in the Act. The application was dismissed.
4. The court concluded that the second applicant was not denied procedural fairness by not being aware of the evidence given by the first applicant to the Tribunal. The application was dismissed.
5. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error by not allowing the first applicant to present arguments in relation to critical documents submitted in support of her claims. The application was dismissed.
6. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not fail to take into account relevant considerations by not considering other documents submitted by the applicants. The application was dismissed.
7. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not fail in its statutory duty by not making inquiries about documents submitted by the first applicant concerning the H church. The application was dismissed.
8. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not deny the applicants procedural fairness by taking into account the first applicant's brother's protection claims without putting the first applicant on notice that it would do so. The application was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the applicants' grounds for review, which included claims of jurisdictional error and breaches of procedural fairness. The Court found that none of the grounds were made out.
First, the Court found that the Tribunal did not breach s.425 of the Migration Act by failing to give the first applicant sufficient notice that the issue of her attending the H church in a building owned by her father would not be accepted. The Court found that the issue was discussed at the hearing, and the first applicant was given the opportunity to comment and respond to the Tribunal's concerns.
Second, the Court found that the Tribunal did not fail to consider a claim made by the first applicant that she feared harm because she was a member of a "particular social group". The Court found that the first applicant's written statement did not support the proposition that a particular social group was apparent, and that the first applicant was a member of such a group.
Third, the Court found that the Tribunal properly considered the complementary protection criterion in the Act. The Court found that the Tribunal was entitled to rely on earlier expressed findings of fact in its decision record, which were reasonably open to it.
Fourth, the Court found that the second applicant was not denied procedural fairness by not being aware of the evidence given by the first applicant to the Tribunal. The Court found that the second applicant did not make any claims on his own behalf, and it was reasonably open to the Tribunal to find that he purported to corroborate the first applicant's claims.
Fifth, the Court found that the Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error by not allowing the first applicant to present arguments in relation to critical documents submitted in support of her claims. The Court found that there was no obligation on the Tribunal to specifically ask the first applicant about the contents of a letter she herself had provided to the Tribunal, which did no more than seek to corroborate her claims.
Sixth, the Court found that the Tribunal did not fail to take into account relevant considerations by not considering other documents submitted by the applicants. The Court found that the Tribunal made specific reference to the travel itinerary, and that the Tribunal's view that the first applicant was willing to return to Pakistan in 2013 when she claimed to have left in 2011 because she feared harm, and that this raised concerns about the credibility of her claims to fear harm, was entirely reasonable and open to the Tribunal on what was before it.
Seventh, the Court found that the Tribunal did not fail in its statutory duty by not making inquiries about documents submitted by the first applicant concerning the H church. The Court found that the Tribunal rejected the first applicant's claim on the basis that she was not a credible witness, and that there was nothing put forward by the applicants now to say that a telephone call could have changed that conclusion.
Eighth, the Court found that the Tribunal did not deny the applicants procedural fairness by taking into account the first applicant's brother's protection claims without putting the first applicant on notice that it would do so. The Court found that the Tribunal did not make any adverse finding about the first applicant's brother's claims, and that it was reasonably open to the Tribunal to find that the first applicant's brother's claims were put by the first applicant to it, in purported corroboration of her own claims.
In conclusion, the Court found that none of the applicants' grounds revealed jurisdictional error, and therefore dismissed the application. The Court certified that the preceding 109 paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for judgment of Judge Nicholls.