Bhara & Anor v De Costa & Anor (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BHARA & ANOR v DE COSTA & ANOR (Residential Tenancies) [2024] ACAT 62

RT 175/2024

Catchwords:               RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – breach of standard terms of Residential Tenancies Act 1997 – interference with peace, comfort and privacy – whether the premises fit for habitation, reasonably clean, in a reasonable state of repair and secure – compensation – rent reduction – mould – whether lessor to make repairs – whether damage is caused by tenant – duty to mitigate – inspection notice

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 48

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 38, 71, 83(1)(d), sch 1 standard terms 52, 54, 55, 56, 57, 59, 60, 72, 75, 77, 79, 82

Cases cited:Banco de Portugal v Waterlow and Sons [1932] AC 452 at 506

Brogan Prestige Properties v Strand & Black [2010] ACAT 60

Faulder v Tran [2018] ACAT 80
Halcombe v Hitchman [2018] ACAT 5
Hasell v Bagot, Shakes & Lewis Ltd [1911] HCA 62
Karacominakis v Big Country Developments Pty Ltd [2000] NSWCA 313
Lee v Guo [2017] ACAT 60
Nichols v Amers Pty Limited ACN 112 055 366 (No. 2) [2020] ACAT 79

Salem & Gizgeez v Abeeygunasekara & Jeevanthan [2011] ACAT 9

TC Industrial Plant Pty Ltd v Robert’s Queensland Pty Ltd [1963] HCA 57

Withers-Norris v Pastrello [2016] ACAT 95

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Chi-Ching Tsang et al, Taxonomy and evolution of Aspergillus, Penicillium and Talaromyces in the omics era - Past, present and future (Computational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2018)

Collins English Dictionary (online at 24 July 2024) ‘permit’ (def 1)
Christopher Adkins, Peter Christensen, and Allan Anforth, Residential Tenancies Law and Practice (Federation Press, 8th ed, 2022)

Tribunal:Member P Hatami

Date of Orders:  15 July 2024

Date of Reasons for Decision:      20 August 2024

Date of Publication:  28 August 2024

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          RT 175/2024

BETWEEN:

GURDHAIN BHARA
First Applicant/Tenant

NICOLE ARCHER
Second Applicant/Tenant

AND:

LAWRENCE DE COSTA
First Respondent/Lessor

GABRIELLE SULLIVAN
Second Respondent/Lessor

TRIBUNAL:Member P Hatami

DATE:15 July 2024

IN CHAMBERS ORDER

  1. The lessors are to pay to the tenants the sum of $2,076.50 by 12 August 2024, being comprised of:

    (a)Compensation for loss of amenities –$1,207.50;

    (b)Compensation for faulty toilet – $495.00;

    (c)Compensation for purchase of surveillance camera – $198.00; and

    (d)ACAT Application fee – $176.00.

  2. ACT Rental Bonds on behalf of the Territory is directed to release the whole bond of $2,300.00 to the tenants.

  3. The tenant’s claim for $1,725.00 for 50% rent reduction for 6 weeks loss of use and enjoyment of the property is dismissed.

  4. The tenant’s claim for $76.70 for medical expenses is dismissed.

  5. The tenant’s claim for $2012.50 for the loss of amenities and loss of use of bedroom 3 is partly successful for $1,207.50 as ordered at 1(a).

  6. The tenant’s claim for $1,610.00 for rent reduction for mould in bedroom 1, 2 and 3 is dismissed.

  7. The tenant’s claim for $262.89 for printing costs is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bhara & Anor v De Costa & Anor (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACAT 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Bhara & Anor v De Costa & Anor, the dispute involved claims for compensation by tenants regarding mould in the residential property they leased. The matter was heard by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The tenants argued that the mould in the property caused health issues for one of the tenants, and they sought compensation for health impacts, loss of income, and the cost of moving out. The lessors denied the claims, stating that the mould was not as extensive as alleged and that the tenants' health issues were not directly linked to the mould.

The court was required to determine the extent of the mould in the property and whether it was responsible for the tenants' health issues. The tribunal assessed the medical evidence provided by the tenants and considered whether it sufficiently linked the mould to the tenants' health problems. The court also needed to decide whether the tenants were entitled to compensation for the cost of moving and any other claimed damages.

The tribunal dismissed all claims for compensation related to the mould, finding that the evidence did not support the tenants' assertions about the extent of the mould and its impact on their health. The tribunal concluded that the mould report did not substantiate the tenants' claims and thus the tenants were required to bear the cost of the report. The tribunal accepted that the tenants had experienced health issues but found that the medical evidence provided did not sufficiently link these issues to the mould in the property. Consequently, the claim for medical expenses was dismissed. The tribunal also found that while the tenants had moved out, the lessors were not responsible for this decision as the property was not deemed uninhabitable.

The tribunal awarded the tenants some compensation, as the application was partially successful, and ordered the lessors to pay the cost of the application fee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons all of the tenants claims for compensation as they relate to mould are dismissed. These claims include impact on Ms Archer’s income, capacity to move into the property, impact on their relationship and loss of enjoyment as well as the need to move out of the property. As the mould report does not support the tenants’ claims in relation to the extent of mould and the conditions of the property, the cost of the mould report must be borne by the tenants.Medical evidence The medical evidence submitted by Ms Archer suggests that her asthma has worsened. I accept her evidence that she suffered health issues during the tenancy. However, the medical evidence she has submitted does not on its own support a link between the mould and her health. For example, in her letter of 27 January 2024, Dr Priyank Jani Belconnen Mall Medical Centre states:Nicole has recently relocated to the ACT and her current property has an extensive mould issue. This is worsening her asthma to the extent that she has needed to restart a regular preventer and reliever inhaler, something which she has not needed for the last 7-8 months. There is no evidence that Dr Jani attended the premises to assess the presence of mould. She has relied on her patient’s instructions on this. This letter cannot be accepted as evidence of the presence of mould at the property or evidence that Ms Archer’s health was impacted by the mould at the property. Similarly, the Emergency Department Discharge Summary dated 2 February 2024 provides self-reported information about the presence of mould and cannot be relied upon as evidence of the impact of the mould on Ms Archer’s health:Diagnosis – shortness of breath.Worsening SOB [shortness of breath] and irritated and sore chest dry cough very teary. Ongoing 1/52 weeks seen GP commenced on preventer. 2 x 4 puff ventolin tonight with nil relief. Speaking full sentences (blacked out....) Appears highly anxious, H x asthma mold in rental house. Much of the Emergency Department Discharge summary is blacked out so it is difficult to determine what weight to give any of the information that is legible. The medical evidence will be accepted as evidence that Ms Archer has suffered from asthma and shortness of breath since relocating to Canberra. But the evidence does not support the submission that the mould at the property is responsible for Ms Archer’s health issues. Therefore, the claim for medical expenses is dismissed. While the Tribunal acknowledges the inconvenience and cost to the tenants in relocating, the decision to move out of the property was taken by the tenants and the lessor is not responsible for this decision. Moreover, the Tribunal has not found that the failures of the lessor rendered the property uninhabitable causing the tenants to move out. The Tribunal has found that the lessor owes the tenant some compensation, as the application is partly successful the tenant is entitled to the cost of the application fee.[16][16] ACT Civil and Administrative Act 2008 s 48

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established