BGW17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILYCOURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
BGW17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] FedCFamC2G 306
File number(s):
MLG 605 of 2017
Judgment of:
JUDGE RILEY
Date of judgment:
1 December 2021
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Administrative Appeal Tribunal – protection visa – whether the Tribunal’s failure to disclose a s.438 certificate was a material jurisdictional error – whether the Tribunal improperly rejected or did not consider the applicant’s documents – whether the Tribunal being unable to find the applicant’s home village on a map was a jurisdictional error – whether the Tribunal, having said that the applicant faced a real risk of harm in his home region, was bound to not affirm the delegate’s decision – the Tribunal finding that the applicant could reasonably relocate within Pakistan.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILYCOURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
BGW17 Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE RILEY
DATE OF ORDER:
1 DECEMBER 2021
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application filed on 27 March 2017 be dismissed.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the court’s records.
Note:This copy of the court’s reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
JUDGE RILEY:
INTRODUCTION
This is an application for review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. In that decision, the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a protection visa. The applicant is a citizen of Pakistan. He is not legally represented.
The Tribunal summarised the applicant’s claims in paragraph 20 of its reasons for decision as follows:
The applicant claims to fear returning to Pakistan because he will be harmed or killed by the Pakistani Taliban because of volunteer work in the local school and the Polio Vaccination Program in and around his home village, and because he is perceived as having westernised views. He also claims to fear returning to Pakistan because he will be harmed or killed by the Uncle of his…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BGW17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
In BGW17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) to affirm a delegate's decision to refuse his application for a protection visa. The Tribunal's reasons for decision summarised the applicant's claims as being that he feared returning to Pakistan due to harm or death by the Pakistani Taliban or the uncle of his former fiancée. The legal issues for the Court were whether the Tribunal's failure to disclose a section 438 certificate was a material jurisdictional error, whether the Tribunal improperly rejected or did not consider the applicant's documents, whether the Tribunal being unable to find the applicant's home village on a map was a jurisdictional error, and whether the Tribunal, having said that the applicant faced a real risk of harm in his home region, was bound to not affirm the delegate's decision.
The Court found that the Tribunal's failure to disclose the section 438 certificate was not a material error, as the documents in question were of no evidentiary value, unsubstantiated opinions, and the subject of a certificate under section 438(1)(b) of the Act. The Court also found that the Tribunal did not improperly reject or fail to consider the applicant's documents, and that the inability to locate the applicant's home village on a map was not a jurisdictional error. Furthermore, the Court held that the Tribunal was not bound to not affirm the delegate's decision, as it found that the applicant could reasonably relocate within Pakistan. The Court concluded that the application for judicial review must be dismissed with costs.
The Court ordered that the parties be heard on the question of costs due to the unusual course the matter had taken. This decision highlights the importance of procedural fairness in judicial review proceedings and the need for the proper handling of confidential information.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal summarised the applicant’s claims in paragraph 20 of its reasons for decision as follows:The applicant claims to fear returning to Pakistan because he will be harmed or killed by the Pakistani Taliban because of volunteer work in the local school and the Polio Vaccination Program in and around his home village, and because he is perceived as having westernised views. He also claims to fear returning to Pakistan because he will be harmed or killed by the Uncle of his former fiancée because he is perceived to have injured the honour of the uncle’s family.BACKGROUND In his written submissions filed on 11 May 2018, the Minister provided the following background to this matter: 9.The Applicant is a citizen of Pakistan. He first arrived in Australia on 28 March 2013 as the holder of a Prospective Marriage Visa. On 6 December 2013, the Applicant applied for a Protection Visa. In support of his application, the Applicant made a Statutory Declaration.10.On 27 November 2015, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the Applicant a Protection Visa for the reasons he gave at CB 85 to 106. The delegate also notified the Tribunal that the confidential information was subject to s 438(1)(b) of the Act as the information had been given to the Minister’s Department ‘in confidence’. The Delegate stated that the confidential information should not be disclosed to the Applicant because it was provided in confidence by another person or organisation; was from a third party whose identity could not be disclosed to the Applicant, and if released, would otherwise affect the privacy of another person. 11.On 4 January 2016, the Applicant applied for review of the Minister’s delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. 12.On 24 November 2016, the Applicant appeared at a hearing before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments. The Applicant was not represented at the hearing before the Tribunal. The Tribunal received certain documents in support of the Applicant’s case.13.On 6 March 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the Minister’s delegate’s decision for the reasons it gave at CB 139 to 160. (footnotes omitted) …2.On 27 March 2017, the Applicant applied to this Court for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision (the original application).3.On 14 December 2017, Judge Riethmuller dismissed the original application pursuant to r 13.03C(1)(c) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) as there was no appearance by or on behalf of the Applicant at the hearing scheduled that day.4.On 24 January 2018, by consent, Judge Riethmuller ordered that the orders of 14 December 2017 be set aside and the original application be listed for final hearing on 21 May 2018 (later scheduled to 24 May 2018). The Applicant was to file and serve any amended application, affidavits and written submissions 28 days before the final hearing. As at the date of these submissions, the Applicant has filed no further materials in support of the original application. In his written submissions filed on 15 July 2021, the Minister provided the following procedural background to this matter:2.On 6 March 2017, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) decided to affirm a decision of a delegate of the First Respondent (the Minister) not to grant the Applicant a protection visa.3.The Tribunal had before it material that was subject to a valid notification issued by the Secretary under s 438(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) that certain information should not be disclosed to the Applicant on the basis that it had been provided to the Department “in confidence”. (That material is Confidential Annexure B.)4.On 22 March 2017, the Applicant sought judicial review in respect of the of the Tribunal’s decision. The judicial review proceeding was heard by Judge Riethmuller on 24 May 2018. At the hearing, the Minister sought a direction under s 130(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) that Confidential Annexure B not be adduced on public interest immunity grounds – namely, that adducing the document would result in the disclosure, or potential ascertainment, of the existence or identity of a confidential source of information relating to the enforcement or administration of a law of the Commonwealth.5.Confidential Annexure B was not disclosed to the Applicant while that application under the Evidence Act remained outstanding. 6.The learned primary judge made orders dismissing the judicial review proceeding on 6 September 2018, and gave reasons for doing so. However, it was apparent that the Court had regard to the material in Confidential Annexure B while considering the substance of the judicial review proceeding. This was done without expressly ruling on the Minister’s Evidence Act application as a preliminary matter, and importantly, without Confidential Annexure B ever being disclosed to the Applicant.17.The Applicant subsequently appealed to the Federal Court. On 1 August 2019, Justice Anderson of the Federal Court made orders, by consent, remitting the matter to the Federal Circuit Court. The Federal Court noted, again by consent, that the course adopted below resulted in a denial of procedural fairness to the Applicant.8.On 11 May 2021, the matter was listed before her Honour Judge Riley. On that occasion, the Minister’s representatives gave the Applicant copies of the Allan affidavit (with no Confidential Annexure B), and the Thomas affidavit. The matter was otherwise adjourned to 9 August 2021 for the hearing of an interlocutory application for public interest immunity over Confidential Annexure B (with consequential timetabling orders).:BGW17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCCA 2488, at [39]-[41]. CONFIDENTIALITY OF ANNEXURE B
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
I gave ex tempore reasons for that order, which were as follows, with minor amendments:1.This is an application by the Minister for Immigration for an order that there be public interest immunity in respect of annexure B to the affidavit affirmed by Ashley Allen on 11 May 2018. This application has arisen in the context of a refugee application. The matter was originally determined by Judge Riethmuller, who unfortunately did not directly address the Minister’s application for an order for public interest immunity under s.130(1) of the Evidence Act 1995. The matter went on appeal to the Federal Court where orders were made by consent referring the matter back to this court for that particular issue to be dealt with, along with the application generally.2.The matter has been listed today for hearing and determination of the public interest immunity question. I have looked at annexure B. The applicant has been given a copy of the affidavit of Ashley Allen without annexure B and has also been given a copy of the affidavit of Michael Anthony Thomas affirmed on 14 May 2018.3.The Minister filed written submissions dated 15 July 2021.The applicant was given an opportunity to file written submissions, but he did not do so. He is unrepresented.4. Section 130 of the Evidence Act 1995 provides as follows:Exclusion of evidence of matters of state (1)If the public interest in admitting into evidence information or a document that relates to matters of state is outweighed by the public interest in preserving secrecy or confidentiality in relation to the information or document, the court may direct that the information or document not be adduced as evidence.(2)The court may give such a direction either on its own initiative or on the application of any person (whether or not the person is a party).(3)In deciding whether to give such a direction, the court may inform itself in any way it thinks fit.(4)Without limiting the circumstances in which information or a document may be taken for the purposes of subsection (1) to relate to matters of state, the information or document is taken for the purposes of that subsection to relate to matters of state if adducing it as evidence would:(a)prejudice the security, defence or international relations of Australia; or(b)damage relations between the Commonwealth and a State or between 2 or more States; or(c)prejudice the prevention, investigation or prosecution of an offence; or(d)prejudice the prevention or investigation of, or the conduct of proceedings for recovery of civil penalties brought with respect to, other contraventions of the law; or(e)disclose, or enable a person to ascertain, the existence or identity of a confidential source of information relating to the enforcement or administration of a law of the Commonwealth or a State; or(f)prejudice the proper functioning of the government of the Commonwealth or a State.(5)Without limiting the matters that the court may take into account for the purposes of subsection (1), it is to take into account the following matters:(a)the importance of the information or the document in the proceeding;(b)if the proceeding is a criminal proceeding--whether the party seeking to adduce evidence of the information or document is a defendant or the prosecutor;(c)the nature of the offence, cause of action or defence to which the information or document relates, and the nature of the subject matter of the proceeding;(d)the likely effect of adducing evidence of the information or document, and the means available to limit its publication;(e)whether the substance of the information or document has already been published;(f)if the proceeding is a criminal proceeding and the party seeking to adduce evidence of the information or document is a defendant--whether the direction is to be made subject to the condition that the prosecution be stayed.(6)...5.It can be seen from that section that the court must first ascertain whether the document relates to matters of State. The Minister said that annexure B falls within s.130(4)(e) because it would:disclose, or enable a person to ascertain, the existence or identity of a confidential source of information relating to the enforcement or administration of a law of the Commonwealth or a State[.]6.That test is satisfied in respect of annexure B because disclosure of the document would disclose the identity of a confidential source of information and that information relates to the administration of a law of the Commonwealth, being the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”).7.That being so, the court is then required to consider the matters set out in s.130(5) of the Evidence Act 1995 to consider the balance between the interest in the confidentiality of the document against the public interest in admitting all relevant evidence in the hearing of this proceeding. 8.The first matter that the court must consider, under s.130(5)(a), is the importance of the information or the document in the proceeding. There is nothing in annexure B that would be of importance in the proceeding. Judge Riethmuller said in his reasons for decision at paragraph 39: The factual claims made in the documents, even if accepted, largely are of no relevance to the issues that the Tribunal had to determine. However the document does make a bare allegation that the applicant may be seeking a protection visa for his own personal and economic benefits, rather than for protection from a genuine fear or harm. 9.The statement in annexure B, that the applicant is seeking a protection visa for personal benefit rather than for protection from harm, is simply a bare assertion. The statement was not substantiated or particularised. It is completely unhelpful, one way or the other. It could not be regarded as assisting in the determination of the applicant’s application in any way. 10.There is another statement in annexure B, which Judge Riethmuller did not disclose in his reasons for judgment. That statement was of even less relevance to the matters the Tribunal was required to determine than the bare assertion mentioned above.11.The Tribunal said at paragraph 24 of its reasons for decision that the documents in annexure B:a. were of no evidentiary value;b. were the untested and unsubstantiated opinion of a third party; andc. were given in confidence.12. The Tribunal said that:a. it paid no regard to the documents in annexure B;b. it gave them no weight in the review; andc. they were the subject of a certificate under s.438(1)(b) of the Act.13.The Tribunal’s approach seems to have been the only sensible approach to the documents in annexure B as the assertions they contained were without any detail or substantiation. They cannot be regarded as helpful one way or the other. As the Minister has submitted, there would have been no practical injustice in the Tribunal not providing a copy of the documents in annexure B to the applicant, given that they were not material either way. 14.The documents in annexure B were not relevant to the Tribunal’s determination, and they are not relevant to the determination of the matter presently before the court.15.The matters for the court to consider in the balancing exercise under s.130(5)(b) and (f) of the Evidence Act only apply if the matter is a criminal proceeding. This is not such a proceeding. 16.The next matter for the court to consider in the balancing exercise under s.130(5) of the Evidence Act is set out in paragraph (c) of that subsection and is the nature of the cause of action to which the document or information relates and the nature of the subject matter of the proceeding. This is an application for a protection visa. It is inherently a very serious matter. In such matters, the court might be inclined to err on the side of anything that might assist an applicant. However, as I have already said, there is nothing in annexure B that could assist the applicant in this case, whether before the Tribunal or this court.17.The next factor for the court to consider in the balancing exercise under s.130(5) of the Evidence Act is set out in paragraph (d) of that subsection and is the likely effect that adducing evidence of the information document and the means available to limit its publication. It is most important that the documents in annexure B are not disclosed to the applicant. As the applicant is not represented, this is not a case where the court can release annexure B to the applicant’s legal representatives on the condition that they not release any or part of the information in it to the applicant. There seems to be no way of disclosing annexure B to the applicant while usefully limiting its publication. 18.The Thomas affidavit sets out various matters which are said to the likely effects of adducing the evidence. The first of those is that disclosure of annexure B, and placing it into evidence, would identify a confidential source of information, being an informant, in the course of the department’s administration of the Migration Act. That is patently correct. 19.Mr Thomas then said that release of annexure B would potentially found an action by the informant for breach of confidence. The Minister noted that, although the letter was not expressly stated to have been given in confidence:a. it has the quality of a confidential communication; andb.it was received in circumstances in which an obligation of confidence could be inferred.It seems to me that those points are sound. 20.Mr Thomas then said that release of annexure B would compromise the physical safety and wellbeing of the informant. Having read annexure B, I consider this claim by Mr Thomas is perhaps drawing a long bow, but it probably cannot be entirely discounted.21.Mr Thomas then said that, because of the previous factor, disclosure of annexure B could inhibit the future disclosure of information from third parties to the department and that could harm the department’s ability to administer the Migration Act. Whether or not the physical safety and wellbeing of the informant are at risk, it seems to me that any disclosure of annexure B could have the effect of diminishing the likelihood of future disclosures of information to the department.22.The next factor for the court to consider in the balancing exercise under s.130(5) of the Evidence Act is set out in paragraph (e) of that subsection and is whether the substance of the document has already been published. An aspect of the document was published in Judge Riethmuller’s, as he then was, reasons for judgment, as mentioned above. However, the critical points that the Minister wishes to remain confidential are not the part that has already been released. The critical points are the identity of the informant and one other assertion that the informant made. At this stage, those critical points have not already been published.23.Taking into account all those matters, it seems to me that the balance falls on the side of not disclosing annexure B. I cannot see any benefit to the applicant in the determination of this case, whether by the Tribunal or this court, in him knowing what is in annexure B. It is of no relevance to the case and would not be of any assistance to him. THE TRIBUNAL’S REASONS FOR DECISION
Decision
Reasons for decision
In the present case, I am not satisfied that the Tribunal’s error, in failing to disclose the certificate under s.438 of the Act, was a material error.CONCLUSION All in all, I am not persuaded that the Tribunal made any material jurisdictional error in this case. Consequently, the application must be dismissed with costs. As the matter has taken an unusual course, I will hear the parties on the question of costs.