BGV15 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BGV15 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1753

Appeal from: BGV15 & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018] FCCA 1787
File number(s): NSD 1337 of 2018
Judge(s): DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 15 November 2018
Catchwords:

MIGRATION  – application for protection visa – review of Refugee Review Tribunal decision – refusal to grant visa – no error in Tribunal’s decision

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – allegation that the Tribunal’s decision affected by jurisdictional error by reason that it was unreasonable or illogical and was based on a failure to consider all claims made by the applicants – no error shown – appeal dismissed

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 36(2)(aa)

Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees 1967

United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees 1951

Cases cited:

CQG v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 253 FCR 496

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZUXN (2016) 69 AAR 210

SZRHL v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (now Minister for Immigration and Border Protection) (2013) 136 ALD 641

SZTQD v Minister for Immigration (2016) 240 FCR 181

Date of hearing: 14 November 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 30
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr P Bodisco
Solicitor for the Appellants: ABU Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

NSD 1337 of 2018
BETWEEN:

BGV15

First Appellant

BGW15

Second Appellant

BGX15

Third Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 NOVEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is dismissed.

2.The appellants are to pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DERRINGTON J:

Introduction

  1. The appellants appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC) delivered on 12 July 2018.  In that decision the FCC dismissed an application for judicial review of the determination of the Refugee Review Tribunal, now the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) which on, 23 June 2015, affirmed a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection not to grant protection visas to the appellants.  The Minister’s decision had been made on 28 May 2014.

  2. The first and second appellants, who are wife and husband respectively, each submitted their own claims for a protection visa.  The third appellant is their son and he was included in the application as a member of a family unit.  Although the husband advanced his own claim for a protection visa, it was dependent upon the acceptance of the factual substratum of his wife’s claims.  In order to distinguish between the various appellants the nomenclatures “wife appellant”, “husband appellant” and “child appellant” will be used.

    Background facts

  3. Each of the appellants are citizens of Bangladesh who arrived in Australia on 24…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BGV15 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1753
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of BGV15 v Minister for Home Affairs, the applicants, citizens of Bangladesh, sought judicial review of a decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) to refuse their applications for protection visas. The wife appellant’s claims for a protection visa were based on allegations that she was raped on several occasions by a business associate of her husband. The husband’s claim was dependent on the acceptance of the wife’s allegations. The Tribunal found that the wife appellant’s claims were not credible due to numerous inconsistencies and improbabilities in her evidence. As a result, the Tribunal concluded that the applicants were not owed protection obligations by Australia under the relevant international conventions and legislation.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal's decision was affected by jurisdictional error, specifically if it was unreasonable or illogical and based on a failure to consider all claims made by the applicants. The court needed to determine whether the Tribunal erred in finding the wife appellant's claims of rape to be fabricated and if this conclusion was supported by the evidence. The court also needed to assess whether the Tribunal appropriately considered the husband appellant’s fear of harm and the child appellant’s potential psychological harm upon return to Bangladesh.

The court examined the evidence presented to the Tribunal and found no basis to interfere with the Tribunal's findings. The wife appellant’s claims were riddled with inconsistencies, and her explanations for remaining in Bangladesh despite having visas to visit Canada were unconvincing. The court held that the Tribunal had carefully considered the evidence and provided detailed reasons for its conclusions. The inconsistencies in the wife appellant’s evidence, particularly regarding her interactions with Mr R and her allegations of sexual harassment and rape, were significant and undermined the credibility of her claims. The court found that the Tribunal's decision was not unreasonable or illogical, and it had appropriately considered all relevant evidence.

The appeal was dismissed, and the applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the appeal. The court confirmed that the Tribunal's decision was well-reasoned and based on a thorough assessment of the evidence, and there was no basis for finding that it was affected by jurisdictional error.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The appellants are to pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first and second appellants, who are wife and husband respectively, each submitted their own claims for a protection visa. The third appellant is their son and he was included in the application as a member of a family unit. Although the husband advanced his own claim for a protection visa, it was dependent upon the acceptance of the factual substratum of his wife’s claims. In order to distinguish between the various appellants the nomenclatures “wife appellant”, “husband appellant” and “child appellant” will be used.Background facts Each of the appellants are citizens of Bangladesh who arrived in Australia on 24 July 2013. They each lodged applications for protection visas with what is now referred to as the Department of Home Affairs. The essence of the wife appellant’s claim for a protection visa is founded upon her assertion that she was raped on a number of occasions by a business associate of her husband. She claimed that she and her husband had been in business together and, subsequently, they entered into another business with a number of other persons including a Mr R. Mr R was the Chairman of the corporate vehicle through which the new business was pursued. The wife appellant claimed that she was sexually harassed by Mr R during the course of their business relationship and, in July 2009, he raped her. She said that she reported the commission of this offence to the police. She further claimed that her cousin confronted Mr R about the rape and that Mr R shot and killed him on 20 July 2009. She also said that although Mr R was arrested he was subsequently released because he was rich and powerful. For reasons which were identified by the wife appellant, she and her husband remained in business with Mr R despite the occurrence of the alleged rape. The wife appellant asserts that she was raped by Mr R on two more occasions in April 2013. She says that it was this which precipitated their departure from Bangladesh and travel to Australia. The Tribunal’s decision The crux of the Tribunal’s decision is that it did not believe the appellants’ claim that the wife appellant had been raped on a number of occasions and, as that was the foundation of the appellants’ claimed fear of harm, it determined that they were not persons to whom Australia had protection obligations under the United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees 1951, as amended by the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees 1967, or s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). The reasons of the Tribunal included a detailed consideration of the evidence before it in relation to the allegations of rape. It assayed that evidence and identified numerous inconsistencies across the various integers of the wife appellant’s claim. It reached the conclusion that the wife and husband appellants had fabricated this core element. Although it does not do justice to the careful analysis undertaken by the Tribunal it suffices to summarise its findings as to why it concluded the appellants were not truthful as follows:(a)The appellants were insufficiently able to explain why it was that given the alleged rapes they remained in Bangladesh despite having visas to visit Canada which were granted to them on 29 October 2012. Although that date was prior to the alleged second and third rapes, the visa apparently remained valid until 2017. Nevertheless, they did not seek to utilise it to travel to Canada where they could have claimed asylum. Instead, they remained in Bangladesh after the alleged second and third rapes in April until they left in July 2013. Their explanations for that were, as the Tribunal found, unconvincing.(b)The wife appellant’s account of the first rape was “unpersuasive”. In particular, it was found that given her alleged knowledge of Mr R’s dangerous character and long history of alleged sexual harassment, it was most unlikely she would have voluntarily attended a business office where she would be alone with him. Her attempted explanations for doing that were found to be unconvincing.(c)The wife appellant gave inconsistent and changing evidence as to her discussions with other persons about the conduct of Mr R.(d)The wife appellant also gave inconsistent and varying evidence about the occasions on which she reported the harassment and rape to the police. The evidence between herself and her husband had significant and important differences. It was also found that the wife appellant gave inconsistent evidence about Mr R and what she had been told about him. (e)The evidence from the appellants as to the interactions between the husband appellant and Mr R were also inconsistent. These were important aspects of the allegation which were unlikely to have been forgotten or confused. (f)The evidence of the appellants as to their contact with police about the allegations was also inconsistent and unconvincing.(g)Similarly, the evidence of the wife appellant alleging that her cousin had been shot by Mr R in relation to the rape allegations was not credible and was inconsistent with her allegations of rape.(h)The wife appellant’s claims as to assault by Mr R on her brother and other members of her family were also inconsistent.(i)The appellants’ travel histories in Bangladesh and internationally, including the husband’s solo travel to the United Kingdom for a holiday in 2010, were not consistent with the rape allegations. The claims that the appellants were fearful of Mr R after the rape in 2009 were not consistent with the husband appellant taking a holiday in the United Kingdom by himself.(j)The alleged documentary medical evidence which was adduced was identified as probably being fraudulent and forgeries. That was particularly so because the dates shown on the documents were inconsistent with the events recorded. (k)The Tribunal concluded that the concerns which it had as to the many inconsistencies and improbabilities in the evidence were so numerous and significant that it could not be satisfied of the truthfulness of the claims that the wife appellant had been raped as alleged. The husband appellant’s claim that he feared harm as a result of the rapes having occurred, necessarily fell with the rejection of those allegations. His claim that the third appellant would suffer psychological harm on return to Bangladesh were also unsupported because it had been determined that the rapes which had been alleged did not in fact occur.Grounds of appeal

Decision

Reasons for decision

The wife appellant asserts that she was raped by Mr R on two more occasions in April 2013. She says that it was this which precipitated their departure from Bangladesh and travel to Australia. The Tribunal’s decision The crux of the Tribunal’s decision is that it did not believe the appellants’ claim that the wife appellant had been raped on a number of occasions and, as that was the foundation of the appellants’ claimed fear of harm, it determined that they were not persons to whom Australia had protection obligations under the United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees 1951, as amended by the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees 1967, or s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). The reasons of the Tribunal included a detailed consideration of the evidence before it in relation to the allegations of rape. It assayed that evidence and identified numerous inconsistencies across the various integers of the wife appellant’s claim. It reached the conclusion that the wife and husband appellants had fabricated this core element. Although it does not do justice to the careful analysis undertaken by the Tribunal it suffices to summarise its findings as to why it concluded the appellants were not truthful as follows:(a)The appellants were insufficiently able to explain why it was that given the alleged rapes they remained in Bangladesh despite having visas to visit Canada which were granted to them on 29 October 2012. Although that date was prior to the alleged second and third rapes, the visa apparently remained valid until 2017. Nevertheless, they did not seek to utilise it to travel to Canada where they could have claimed asylum. Instead, they remained in Bangladesh after the alleged second and third rapes in April until they left in July 2013. Their explanations for that were, as the Tribunal found, unconvincing.(b)The wife appellant’s account of the first rape was “unpersuasive”. In particular, it was found that given her alleged knowledge of Mr R’s dangerous character and long history of alleged sexual harassment, it was most unlikely she would have voluntarily attended a business office where she would be alone with him. Her attempted explanations for doing that were found to be unconvincing.(c)The wife appellant gave inconsistent and changing evidence as to her discussions with other persons about the conduct of Mr R.(d)The wife appellant also gave inconsistent and varying evidence about the occasions on which she reported the harassment and rape to the police. The evidence between herself and her husband had significant and important differences. It was also found that the wife appellant gave inconsistent evidence about Mr R and what she had been told about him. (e)The evidence from the appellants as to the interactions between the husband appellant and Mr R were also inconsistent. These were important aspects of the allegation which were unlikely to have been forgotten or confused. (f)The evidence of the appellants as to their contact with police about the allegations was also inconsistent and unconvincing.(g)Similarly, the evidence of the wife appellant alleging that her cousin had been shot by Mr R in relation to the rape allegations was not credible and was inconsistent with her allegations of rape.(h)The wife appellant’s claims as to assault by Mr R on her brother and other members of her family were also inconsistent.(i)The appellants’ travel histories in Bangladesh and internationally, including the husband’s solo travel to the United Kingdom for a holiday in 2010, were not consistent with the rape allegations. The claims that the appellants were fearful of Mr R after the rape in 2009 were not consistent with the husband appellant taking a holiday in the United Kingdom by himself.(j)The alleged documentary medical evidence which was adduced was identified as probably being fraudulent and forgeries. That was particularly so because the dates shown on the documents were inconsistent with the events recorded. (k)The Tribunal concluded that the concerns which it had as to the many inconsistencies and improbabilities in the evidence were so numerous and significant that it could not be satisfied of the truthfulness of the claims that the wife appellant had been raped as alleged. The husband appellant’s claim that he feared harm as a result of the rapes having occurred, necessarily fell with the rejection of those allegations. His claim that the third appellant would suffer psychological harm on return to Bangladesh were also unsupported because it had been determined that the rapes which had been alleged did not in fact occur.Grounds of appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the Tribunal's decision was affected by jurisdictional error by reason that it was unreasonable or illogical and was based on a failure to consider all claims made by the applicants. The court found that the Tribunal's detailed consideration of the evidence, including numerous inconsistencies in the wife appellant's claims, demonstrated that the decision was neither unreasonable nor illogical. The Tribunal had considered all claims made by the applicants and had provided sufficient reasons for its findings. Therefore, the court concluded that there was no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision.

The court also assessed whether the Tribunal erred in concluding that the wife appellant's claims of rape were not credible due to inconsistencies and improbabilities in her evidence. The court noted that the Tribunal had meticulously analysed the wife appellant's testimony and identified multiple inconsistencies and improbabilities. These included the wife appellant's failure to explain why she and her husband remained in Bangladesh despite having visas to visit Canada, her implausible account of the first rape, inconsistent evidence about her discussions with others regarding Mr R, and discrepancies in her reports to the police. The court found that the Tribunal's conclusion that the wife appellant's claims were not credible was supported by the evidence and that the Tribunal had correctly applied the principles of assessing credibility in refugee cases. Therefore, the court held that the Tribunal did not err in its assessment of the wife appellant's credibility.