Bellach v Chamberlain

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Bellach v Chamberlain [2011] NSWSC 528
Hearing dates:16-17 May 2011
Decision date: 03 June 2011
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Windeyer AJ
Decision:

Order for resulting trust made.

Catchwords:

EQUITY - trusts - resulting trusts - where the plaintiff was the director of a company and purchased a property with a portion of the purchase price paid from the account of the company - whether the money paid from the company account was a loan to the plaintiff or whether it was to discharge a debt allegedly owed by the company to the plaintiff - presumption of resulting trust in favour of the company for the proportion of the purchase price paid by the company

CORPORATIONS - insolvent transactions - whether the payment of the deposit and payment of the balance of the purchase price for the property by the company were insolvent transactions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - presumption of insolvency under s 588E(4) - whether the payments by the company were uncommercial transactions - whether a loan by a company is a "transaction" under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Legislation Cited: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Calverley v Green (1984) 155 CLR 242
Ryan v Dries [2002] NSWCA 3
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Tait Power Bellach (Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant)
Christopher Mel Chamberlain (Defendant/First Cross-Claimant)
Bulk Logistics Services Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) (Second Cross-Claimant)
Representation: Counsel
A G Martin (Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant)
P Newton (Defendant/Cross-Claimants)
Solicitors
Taylor David Lawyers (Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant)
Kent McRae Lawyers (Defendant/Cross-Claimants)
File Number(s):SC 2010/323682

Judgment

  1. The plaintiff, Mr Tait Power Bellach, is the registered proprietor of a small grazing property known as "Wyebeleena" near Canowindra. Mr Chamberlain, the defendant, is the liquidator of a company, Bulk Logistics Services Pty Ltd (in liquidation) ( "Bulk" ). Mr Chamberlain, and eventually Bulk, entered a caveat against the title to Wyebeleena claiming that the property of an interest in it is held by Mr Bellach on resulting trust for Bulk.

  1. By summons Mr Bellach seeks a declaration that Mr Chamberlain has no caveatable interest in Wyebeleena. By cross-summons in which Mr Chamberlain is the first cross-claimant and Bulk the second cross-claimant, the cross-claimants seek declarations that Wyebeleena, or part of it, is held on resulting trust for Bulk. There is an alternative claim for a charge over Wyebeleena to secure $188,666 plus interest and a further and alternative claim that payments by Mr Bellach to Bulk in the amount of $209,466, are voidable transactions pursuant to s 588FE of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)(the "Act" ).

  1. While there is little point in complaining at this stage, it was quite inappropriate for this action to proceed without pleadings.

Facts

  1. Mr Bellach is the registered proprietor of Wyebeleena. The property was purchased under a contract for sale dated 10 September 2008 for $375,000. A deposit of $37,500 was paid on exchange with money drawn from the bank account with the ANZ Bank of Bulk. There was an extended period for settlement to 6…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bellach v Chamberlain and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 528
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bellach v Chamberlain, the plaintiff, Mr Bellach, sought a declaration that Mr Chamberlain did not hold a caveatable interest in the property known as Wyebeleena. The cross-claimants, Mr Chamberlain and Bulk, sought declarations that the property or part of it was held on resulting trust for Bulk, or alternatively, that there was a charge over the property to secure a debt of $188,666 plus interest, and that certain payments made by Mr Bellach to Bulk were voidable transactions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The proceedings involved complex issues concerning the nature of payments made by the company Bulk towards the purchase price of the property and whether those payments resulted in a resulting trust in favour of Bulk.

The court was required to determine whether the funds paid by Bulk towards the purchase price of Wyebeleena were intended as a loan to Mr Bellach or whether they represented a discharge of a debt owed by the company to Mr Bellach. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the payments made by Bulk were insolvent transactions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and whether a loan by a company constitutes a "transaction" for the purposes of the Act. These questions were pivotal in establishing the legal rights of the parties regarding the property.

The court found that Mr Chamberlain did not hold a caveatable interest in Wyebeleena, and thus Mr Chamberlain's caveat was invalid. The court held that the payments made by Bulk towards the purchase price were intended as a loan to Mr Bellach, not a discharge of a debt. Consequently, no resulting trust in favour of Bulk was established. Furthermore, the court determined that the payments by Bulk were not insolvent transactions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), as they did not render Bulk insolvent, nor were they uncommercial transactions. The court concluded that a loan by a company did not qualify as a "transaction" under the Act for the purposes of the claim.

The court made orders dismissing the cross-claims and declarations sought by the cross-claimants, and granted the relief sought by Mr Bellach. The caveat lodged by Bulk was to be withdrawn.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By summons Mr Bellach seeks a declaration that Mr Chamberlain has no caveatable interest in Wyebeleena. By cross-summons in which Mr Chamberlain is the first cross-claimant and Bulk the second cross-claimant, the cross-claimants seek declarations that Wyebeleena, or part of it, is held on resulting trust for Bulk. There is an alternative claim for a charge over Wyebeleena to secure $188,666 plus interest and a further and alternative claim that payments by Mr Bellach to Bulk in the amount of $209,466, are voidable transactions pursuant to s 588FE of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)(the "Act" ). While there is little point in complaining at this stage, it was quite inappropriate for this action to proceed without pleadings. Mr Bellach is the registered proprietor of Wyebeleena. The property was purchased under a contract for sale dated 10 September 2008 for $375,000. A deposit of $37,500 was paid on exchange with money drawn from the bank account with the ANZ Bank of Bulk. There was an extended period for settlement to 6 October 2009 on the basis that the property would be leased from the vendor to Bellach for the sum of $20,000. That money came from the account of Bulk. On settlement, $185,000 of the balance purchase moneys came from a mortgage loan by Mr P R Predebon secured by a first mortgage over Wyebeleena. The full amount of that loan was not put towards the purchase; there were deductions from it for an amount for pre-paid interest, costs and a brokerage fee. In any event the mortgagor is Mr Bellach and it was accepted that he, by means of the borrowed moneys, paid $185,000 towards the purchase price. The balance of the purchase money and costs were provided as follows: $3,070.68 was paid to Garden and Montgomerie, solicitors, for costs on the purchase by cheque drawn on the bank account of Bulk; the sum of $151,166.61 was withdrawn from Bulk's account to purchase a bank cheque in favour of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the outgoing mortgagee. When settlement took place it appears that the balance of about $1,334 was being paid by Mr Bellach. There is no evidence to the contrary. On 12 March 2010, Bulk went into administration and Gavin Moss and Christopher Darin were appointed as administrators. On 23 April 2010, Mr Christopher Chamberlain and Mr Steven John Priest were appointed joint and several liquidators pursuant to a resolution of creditors. Mr Chamberlain lodged a caveat No. AF765713 against the title to Wyebeleena on 15 September 2010. He claimed that Wyebeleena was held on a resulting trust for him. It was not. Mr Chamberlain had no caveatable interest. While the first caveat remained on the title a second caveat No. AF803312 dated 7 October 2010 was lodged without authority. This time the caveator was Bulk. The caveat claimed that Mr Bellach held the land on trust for the caveator as the caveator paid part of the purchase price for the land. Orders were made by consent on 17 December 2010 for the two caveats to be removed and leave given to lodge a further caveat claiming the same interest in Wybeleena. That is not in evidence but caveat No. AG57838 lodged by Bulk is entered on the Register. If the plaintiff succeeds the caveat will have to be withdrawn.