Belan v National Union of Workers

Link copied
Case Copied 93 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Belan v National Union of Workers [2000] FCA 1828

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Agreement under s 202 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the Act”) between an organisation and the counterpart state union in New South Wales – whether the agreement prevented alterations to the rules of the organisation concerning the branch of the organisation in New South Wales – whether rules creating a Central Branch and providing for allocation of members to that branch are in breach of s 196 of the Act and/or the agreement – whether the agreement contained an implied limitation on power of organisation to amend its rules.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether resolutions passed by organisation authorised by its rules – resolutions passed in respect of litigation arising out of industrial dispute in New South Wales – resolution that New South Wales Branch pay the legal expenses of the organisation relating to the industrial dispute litigation – resolution that officers of the New South Wales Branch be prohibited from commenting on the litigation – resolutions limiting the ability of a state branch to take advantage of provisions of the Act relating to industrial action and enterprise bargaining.

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 170MO, 170MR, 196, 202

McVeigh, in the matter of Piccolo v National Australia Bank Ltd [2000] FCA 187, applied
Darin Nominees Pty Ltd v Franklin’s Selfserve Ltd [2000] NSWCA 209, referred to
Re McJannet; Ex parte the Australian Workers’ Union of Employees, Queensland (1995) 184 CLR 620, referred to
Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41, referred to

FRANK BELAN and ANOR v NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS AND ORS

MOORE J

SYDNEY
15 DECEMBER 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 232 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

FRANK BELAN
FIRST APPLICANT

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS’ NEW SOUTH WALES BRANCH
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS
FIRST RESPONDENT

GREGORY SWORD
SECOND RESPONDENT

JOHN BARLOW & ORS
THIRD RESPONDENT TO FORTY-THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 DECEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS AND DECLARES THAT:

1.Under the rules of the National Union of Workers certified on 17 April 1998, the secretary of a branch or a person authorized by the Branch Committee of Management has power, in relation to industrial action to be taken by members belonging to the branch, to give notice of an intention to take industrial action pursuant to s 170MO(2) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the Act”) and give written notice of the giving of authorization pursuant to s 170MR(1)(c) of the Act.

2.The second to forty-third respondents comply with the rules of the National Union of Workers by treating as null and void and of no effect the resolution passed by the National Committee of Management on 30 November 1998 and endorsed and adopted by the National Council between 15 and 18 August 1999 directing steps to be taken to pay all legal expenses…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belan v National Union of Workers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1828
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Belan v National Union of Workers involved enforcement and restitution proceedings brought by the applicants against the National Union of Workers (NUW) and its members. The dispute centred on the validity of certain resolutions and the interpretation of the union’s rules, particularly those concerning enterprise bargaining, legal expenses, and the governance structure of the union. The proceedings were complex, involving detailed examination of the union’s internal governance and the impact of specific resolutions on its members.

The primary legal issues before the court included the interpretation of the union's rules, the validity of specific resolutions passed by the union’s governing bodies, and the implications of these resolutions on the union’s members. The court was required to determine whether certain resolutions, including those related to enterprise bargaining and legal expenses, were valid under the union’s rules and whether they had the effect of restricting members' rights. Additionally, the court had to consider the proper interpretation of the union's rules concerning the disbursement of branch funds and the governance structure of the union.

In its reasoning, the court examined the union's rules and the resolutions in question, focusing on their language, context, and intended effect. The court found that certain resolutions, such as those restricting the initiation of bargaining periods and the certification of agreements, were not supported by the union’s rules. It held that these resolutions were invalid as they exceeded the powers conferred by the rules. Regarding the legal expenses resolution, the court determined that while the National Committee of Management had the authority to direct the disbursement of branch funds for specified purposes, any such resolution must be reasonable and in line with the union’s objects. The court concluded that the resolution in question was valid, as it was within the powers of the National Committee of Management and was reasonable.

The court made declaratory orders concerning the powers of branch officers and the validity of the resolutions, providing clarity on the union's governance and the rights of its members. The outcome ensured that the union’s operations adhered to its constitutional rules and protected the rights of its members as per the interpreted provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The enforcement proceedings were commenced over 18 months ago and the substantive hearings took place in February 2000. While it is unnecessary to detail the course the proceedings took, I should note that in February 2000 an order was made that the enforcement proceedings and the restitution proceedings should be joined and heard one after the other as soon as practicable. That order was made because both sets of applicants (who, as between each set, plainly had diverging interests) relied in both matters on the 202 Agreement. It was desirable that judgment not be given in the enforcement proceedings, which may have involved the construction of some parts of the 202 Agreement, if it might become necessary to construe other parts of the 202 Agreement in determining the restitution proceedings. The hearing of the restitution proceedings commenced in April 2000 and there were a number of days of hearing on several occasions in the following months. The issues in the restitution proceedings ebbed and flowed as several tranches of documents were sought and produced, principally by the respondents. The matter was ultimately settled on 25 July 2000 by undertakings being given by the respondents to the Court. At that time the Court had not received all the material the parties had undertaken to provide during the earlier hearing of the enforcement proceedings. The last of this material was provided on 10 October 2000.Background Because the restitution proceedings have been settled, it is necessary to focus only on the background and evidence which is relevant to the enforcement proceedings. From this point, I will refer to the applicants and respondents in those proceedings only. The enforcement proceedings are brought against a background which involves two events of significance. The first was the execution of the 202 Agreement and the other was a dispute between members of the NUW in NSW and a large grocery wholesaler, Davids Distribution Pty Ltd (“Davids Distribution”) which resulted in litigation in the Supreme Court of NSW and this Court.The execution of the 202 Agreement The following is a summary of events leading to the execution of the 202 Agreement drawn from a chronology provided by the parties (which I understand is agreed to by the parties) and documents tendered during the hearing. I should note that counsel for the applicants objected to much of this material being used to construe the 202 Agreement. The NSW Union was first registered in NSW under state law in 1908. The NUW was first registered under federal law in 1912. On 22 March 1991 what was then called the National Conference of the NUW discussed amalgamations in NSW. On 28 March 1991 a firm of solicitors wrote to Mr Belan giving advice concerning a letter of 13 March 1991 he had received from Mr Sword. In very general terms the advice concerned the registration under state law of a branch of an organisation registered under federal law and whether there was any requirement under federal law that state branches have autonomy. The firm took issue with certain legal propositions on these matters advanced by Mr Sword in the earlier letter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The two contentious resolutions also remove the power to initiate bargaining periods or to apply for the certification of agreements. In my opinion, the powers conferred (either expressly or impliedly) by rule 53A do not extend to these matters. However rule 71(9) is also relied on by the applicants as is rule 37A. The terms of sub-rule (9) are set out in par 29 above. While that sub-rule (in the form it was in as at 30 November 1998) was repealed in June 1999, it was effective when the enterprise bargaining and bargaining period resolutions were passed. But neither rule 71, and sub-rule (9) in particular, nor rule 37A (which vested in a branch committee of management the government, management and control of the affairs of a branch but subject to any decision of National Council) conferred, in my opinion, a power on either the branch committee of management or an officer of the branch to certify agreements or initiate bargaining periods which the impugned resolutions sought to fetter. Indeed the rules expressly dealt with the power to sign documents on behalf of the NUW (rule 27) and the authority of a branch secretary to sign a document on behalf of the NUW depended on authorisation by the National Council or the National Committee of Management (rule 27(c)). Any authority to sign certified agreements or initiate bargaining periods deriving from a policy of the National Council could be removed by that body. In my opinion the enterprise bargaining and bargaining period resolutions were, in this respect, valid resolutions. No submissions were made as to whether the invalid elements of the resolutions could be severed (if that be an appropriate approach). The matter is best addressed, in my opinion, by simply making declaratory orders concerning the powers of branch officers to give notices under ss 170MO(2) and 170MR(1)(c).The validity of the legal expenses resolution It is to be recalled that the National Committee of Management passed a resolution on 30 November 1998 directing the NSW Branch to pay the legal expenses of proceedings related to the Davids Distribution dispute. It is also to be recalled that rule 34 dealt with the way Branch Funds were to be managed. It is comparatively clear that the funds of a branch are vested in the branch and are to be managed and controlled by the branch subject to any provision in the rules which might require that branch funds be disbursed other than at the direction of the branch (through its committee of management and officers) for the purposes of the branch. This was really common ground. The point in contention was whether rule 34(a)(ii) provided a mechanism by which the National Committee of Management could effectively direct the payment of moneys from the Branch Fund for a specified purpose. This raises the question of what is meant by “payable by the Branch to the National Council by way of sustentation or otherwise” in rule 34(a)(ii). Counsel for the respondents drew attention to rule 8 which declared that the supreme control of the NUW, which is vested in the members, may be exercised by the National Council. Reference was made, in particular, to para (c) of that rule which conferred a power on the National Council to disburse funds of the NUW to give effect to the objects of the organisation. It was noted that the National Committee of Management could exercise powers of the National Council: rule 29. Reference was made to rule 32 (dealing with the National Fund) which declared that the NUW could raise funds through each of its branches “by members payment of entrance fees, contributions and levies or other means” and that “disbursement of such funds shall be made only pursuant to the Rules”. In relation to rule 34, counsel for the respondents submitted that the National Council could require payment of moneys out of a Branch Fund because the word “payable” in rule 34 (a) (ii) meant “able to be required to be paid” and not merely “able to be paid”. By this route, it was submitted, the National Committee of Management had power to pass the legal expenses resolution creating an obligation on the NSW Branch to disburse funds from the Branch Fund of the branch. Counsel for the respondents accepted that it may be necessary for any such resolution to be reasonable having regard to the judgment of the Full Court in Ludwig v Harris (1991) 30 FCR 377.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Of this proposed rule, r 48A(2) is of some importance. It is a provision designed to entrench r 48A and make its amendment conditional upon consent being given by the National Council of the NUW.The rules of the NUW including the challenged alterations to them In order to explain the rules under challenge, is necessary to briefly summarise the structure of the NUW at the time some of the alterations were made. Reference should also be made to the rules relied on in the challenge to the legal expenses, no comment and enterprise bargaining and bargaining period resolutions. The description of the structure of the NUW is by reference to rules certified by a Deputy Industrial Registrar as at 17 April 1998. The eligibility rules were rule 4, description of industry, and rule 5, conditions of eligibility. They reflected the historical development of the NUW and amalgamations between organisations. It is sufficient to refer to rule 5. It contained fifteen sub rules ((A) to (N)). Some were exceptions or provisos and others represented the conditions of eligibility of the amalgam including storemen and packers (B), rubber workers (C), commercial travellers (D) and foremen and supervisors (E). Paragraph (E) is at the centre of the present controversy. It provided:The Union shall also consist of persons employed as:-Foremen, Forewomen, Store Supervisors and Transport Supervisors in the Department of Defence (Naval Establishments) Department of Administrative Services, Department of Productivity, Munitions Factories, Australian Department of Construction and Clothing Factories throughout Australia, where such Establishment and/or Factories are carried on by the Australian Government, and all foremen at all Government undertakings, including Australian National Airlines Commission and the Northern Territory Public Service.(There are two provisos to this paragraph which are not reproduced.) The NUW was (and is) constituted by a number of branches which are governed by committees of management. The NUW was (and is), as an organisation, governed by two bodies. The supreme governing body was the National Council though the management of the NUW on a more frequent basis was undertaken by the National Committee of Management. The powers of the National Council were set out in rule 8 which relevantly provided:8 – NATIONAL COUNCIL – POWERS(A) The supreme control of the Union is vested in the members of the Union. Subject thereto, the supreme control vested in the members shall be exercised on their behalf by the National Council which shall have the general control and conduct of the business of the Union and in addition to the powers conferred elsewhere upon National Council in the rules without limiting the foregoing the powers of the National Council shall include the following:-(a) To direct the policy of the Union in all matters affecting the interests of the members.(b) To repeal, alter, amend, revise, rescind or add to these rules and interpreting any Rule or Rules subject of disputation and administering the Rules for the general benefit of the members.(c) Disbursement of the funds of the Union to give effect to the objects of the Union.(d) …(e) To establish Branches and to arrange for Branches to amalgamate one with another and to allocate to Branches the territory within which they respectively shall operate and to transfer members from Branch to Branch and to close or disband any Branch or Branches.