Belan v National Union of Workers

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Belan v National Union of Workers [2001] FCA 724

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Agreement between State-registered union and federal organisation – Interpretation of agreement – Whether a term should be implied limiting organisation’s power to amend its rules – Validity of rule amendments – Whether amendments to create a new branch are oppressive, unreasonable or unjust – Validity of resolutions of federal organisation’s National Committee of Management giving directions to a State branch and its officers.

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 196, 202, 208, 209

FRANK BELAN and NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS NEW SOUTH WALES BRANCH  -v-  NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS, GREGORY SWORD and JOHN BARLOW and ORS

N93 of 2001

WILCOX, RYAN and MARSHALL JJ

15 JUNE 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 93 of 2001

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

FRANK BELAN
First Appellant

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS NEW SOUTH WALES BRANCH
Second Appellant

AND:

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS
First Respondent

GREGORY SWORD
Second Respondent

JOHN BARLOW and ORS
Third Respondents

JUDGES:

WILCOX, RYAN and MARSHALL JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

15 JUNE 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be upheld in part.

2.The orders made by Moore J on 15 December 2000 be varied by omitting orders 3 and 4 and substituting the following new orders:

“3.The respondents perform and observe the rules of the National Union of Workers by treating as null and void and of no effect the resolution of the National Committee of Management of the said organisation, dated 30 November 1998, directing the New South Wales Branch of the organisation, its Branch Secretary and all of its officers, employees and members not to make any comment to anybody concerning certain specified legal proceedings.

4.The application be otherwise dismissed and the rule to show cause otherwise discharged.”

3.The appeal be otherwise dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 93 of 2001

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

FRANK BELAN
First Appellant

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS NEW SOUTH WALES BRANCH
Second Appellant

AND:

NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS
First Respondent

GREGORY SWORD
Second Respondent

JOHN BARLOW and ORS
Third Respondents

JUDGES:

WILCOX, RYAN and MARSHALL JJ

DATE:

15 JUNE 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. This is an appeal challenging parts of a judgment of Moore J, given on 15 December 2000. The proceeding before the primary judge was an amended rule to show cause which sought relief pursuant to ss 208 and 209 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the WR Act”) and, also, pursuant to the accrued jurisdiction of the Court.

  2. The amended rule called upon the respondents to show cause why “each of them should not be prohibited from proceeding or further proceeding in respect of [certain]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belan v National Union of Workers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 724
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Belan v National Union of Workers involved a dispute between the appellants, members of the New South Wales Branch of the National Union of Workers, and the respondents, the National Union of Workers and its National Committee of Management. The appellants challenged the validity of certain amendments to the rules of the National Union of Workers and resolutions made by the National Committee of Management, claiming that they were oppressive, unreasonable, and unjust. The primary legal issues before the court were the interpretation of an agreement between the State-registered union and the federal organisation, the validity of rule amendments, and the authority of resolutions issued by the National Committee of Management. The court had to determine whether a term should be implied limiting the organisation's power to amend its rules and whether the amendments and resolutions were oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust.

The court, in its decision, held that the agreement in question was intended to confer limited autonomy on the New South Wales Branch of the National Union of Workers in circumstances where it was agreeing to be bound by decisions of the National Conference of the NUW on matters of national significance. The court found that the appellants' submission about the construction of clause 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement was at odds with the language used in the clause. The court also rejected the appellants' contentions about the June 1999 amendments, stating that there was no incongruity or practical difficulty in construing clause 6 as referring only to the State Union. The court concluded that the 202 agreement was negotiated over a period of some 15 months, with both sides being represented by union officials who were seasoned negotiators. The court found that the National Committee of Management's resolutions and rule amendments were valid and did not infringe upon the autonomy of the New South Wales Branch.

The court varied the orders made by Moore J, omitting orders 3 and 4 and substituting new orders that required the respondents to treat as null and void and of no effect the resolution of the National Committee of Management of the said organisation, dated 30 November 1998, directing the New South Wales Branch of the organisation, its Branch Secretary, and all of its officers, employees, and members not to make any comment to anybody concerning certain specified legal proceedings. The appeal was upheld in part, and the application was otherwise dismissed and the rule to show cause otherwise discharged.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be upheld in part.

2. The orders made by Moore J on 15 December 2000 be varied by omitting orders 3 and 4 and substituting the following new orders:

“3. The respondents perform and observe the rules of the National Union of Workers by treating as null and void and of no effect the resolution of the National Committee of Management of the said organisation, dated 30 November 1998, directing the New South Wales Branch of the organisation, its Branch Secretary and all of its officers, employees and members not to make any comment to anybody concerning certain specified legal proceedings.

4. The application be otherwise dismissed and the rule to show cause otherwise discharged.”

3.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the relationship between the National Union of Workers (NUW), a federal organisation, and the New South Wales (NSW) Union, a State-registered union. The dispute concerns the interpretation of an agreement between the NUW and the NSW Union, particularly Clause 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement. The NSW Union argued that Clause 6 limited the NUW's power to amend its rules, while the NUW claimed it did not. The case also involves the validity of certain rule amendments made by the NUW and whether those amendments, as well as resolutions of the NUW's National Committee of Management, were oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust.

The conflict began when the NUW made amendments to its rules without the consent of the NSW Union, leading to legal proceedings. The NSW Union sought to have these amendments and the resolutions of the NUW's National Committee of Management declared null and void. The dispute escalated when the NSW Union further argued that the resolutions of the NUW's National Committee of Management, which directed the NSW Branch and its officers not to comment on certain legal proceedings, were oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust. This case ultimately reached the court to determine the validity of the NUW's rule amendments and the resolutions of its National Committee of Management.

The matter was first heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Justice Moore delivered his judgment. The NSW Union appealed certain aspects of Justice Moore's decision to the Full Court, which included Justices Allsop, Sackville, and Hinkley. The appeal was primarily focused on the interpretation of Clause 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement and the validity of the NUW's rule amendments and resolutions of its National Committee of Management. The Full Court reviewed the arguments presented by both parties and examined the evidence and legal principles relevant to the case before delivering its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Hinkley also adopted the reasons of Moore J on this aspect of the case. Moore J said, at para 79 of his reasons, that the present appellants’ submission about the construction of cl 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement is at odds with the language used in the clause. He went on (at paras 79-80):“… there is no reason to believe that clause 6 was not intended to relate to the NSW Union only and, to the extent that the parties were agreeing to confer autonomy on the NSW Branch, that was achieved (and only achieved) by the inclusion of the proposed rule 71 in the rules of the NUW. In my opinion, clause 6 was directed only to the position of the NSW Union and the expression ‘the union’, was a reference to the NSW Union only.Understood this way, clause 6 was intended to confer limited autonomy on the NSW Union in circumstances in which it was agreeing to be bound by decisions of the National Conference of the NUW ‘on matters of National significance’. It was not intended to confer autonomy on the NSW Branch whose position (in terms of independence from the activities and powers of federal officials or federal governing bodies and other branches) was, at the time, established by the registered rules of the NUW and would be enhanced by the inclusion of proposed rule 71.”(ii) Conclusions We agree with Moore J in rejecting the appellants’ contentions about the June 1999 amendments. The 202 agreement was negotiated over a period of some 15 months, both sides being represented by union officials who were seasoned negotiators. The recital to Attachment A (quoted at para 9 above) defines the term used in cl 6, “the union”, as being “an industrial union of employees registered” under the New South Wales legislation. The definition clearly points to the State Union. We see no justification for attributing to the words “the union” a meaning different from that which the parties themselves agreed to attribute to them. Contrary to submissions put to us on behalf of the appellants, there is no incongruity or practical difficulty in construing cl 6 as referring only to the State Union. One of the purposes of the agreement was to enable persons who were members of the State Union, but who were otherwise ineligible to become members of the Organisation, to become so eligible; and, if they wished, to participate in its management and affairs. It would not be incongruous if, in return for this benefit to some of its members, the State Union had agreed to accept the direction of National Conference (and National Council) in respect of matters that had significance outside New South Wales. At the same time, it was no doubt important to the State Union to have the Organisation concede the autonomy of the State Union in respect of matters that were within the purview of a State-registered union and of merely local interest; for example, the making of an application by the State Union to the New South Wales Industrial Commission in respect of a State award.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the language used in Clause 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement and found that there was no reason to believe that the clause was not intended to relate to the NSW Union only. The court held that Clause 6 was directed only to the position of the NSW Union and the expression "the union" was a reference to the NSW Union only. The court concluded that Clause 6 was intended to confer limited autonomy on the NSW Union in circumstances in which it was agreeing to be bound by decisions of the National Conference of the NUW "on matters of National significance". The court further held that the recital to Attachment A (quoted at para 9 above) defines the term used in cl 6, "the union", as being "an industrial union of employees registered" under the New South Wales legislation. The definition clearly pointed to the State Union. The court found that there was no incongruity or practical difficulty in construing cl 6 as referring only to the State Union. The court held that the rule amendments made by the NUW were valid and rejected the appellants' contentions about the June 1999 amendments. The court concluded that the orders made by Moore J on 15 December 2000 should be varied by omitting orders 3 and 4 and substituting the following new orders. The court held that the resolutions of the NUW's National Committee of Management were not oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust and dismissed the application. The ratio decidendi of this case is that Clause 6 of Schedule A to the Memorandum of Agreement should not be interpreted as limiting the NUW's power to amend its rules. The court also held that the rule amendments made by the NUW were valid and that the resolutions of the NUW's National Committee of Management were not oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust.