Beesley and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 476

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/196

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      TERENCE FRANCIS BEESLEY
  Applicant
           And    COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       M J Sassella, Senior Member      

Date4 June 2001

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the deemed internal review decision under review and decides as follows: 1) The searches undertaken in response to the Applicant's request were appropriate and reasonable. 2) In order that s 24A(a) of the FOI Act may be satisfied and it can be said that "all reasonable steps have been taken to find the [relevant] document[s]", two additional searches need to be attempted and the Tribunal now orders that these searches be undertaken. The first of these is a search for any correspondence tracking records maintained on behalf of the Commissioner of Taxation in the period between 1978 and 1984. The second is a search of a similar kind in respect of the NSW Deputy Commissioner of Taxation for the same period. If those records exist, there is to be a reasonable search of the records for references to any correspondence from or to Mr Beesley, with a view to identifying any ATO file numbers connected to files which may contain copies of that correspondence.
   [Sgd] M J Sassella
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – Australian Taxation Office - access to personnel records – delay in providing information – search of computer records - existence of computer databases of copies of correspondence – incomplete documentation provided
Freedom of Information Act 1982, ss 11, 14, 15(1), (2), (3), (5), 15A, 18, 24A, 26, 54(1)(a), (1A)(a), (2), 55(1)(a), (ab), (2), (3), (4)(a), (b), (5A), 58(1), 61(1)
Re Cristovao and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1998) 53 ALD 138
Re Luton and Child Support Registrar [1999] AATA 808

REASONS FOR DECISION

4 June 2001  M J Sassella, Senior Member                  

History of application

  1. On 30 July 1999 the Applicant, Mr Terence Francis Beesley, wrote to the Respondent seeking access to his file and personal documents held by the personnel section in the Australian Taxation Office ("ATO") relating to his employment with the ATO between 1978 and 1984 (T3).  The terms of the request referred to, but were not limited to a desire for access to:

  • performance appraisals and other assessments, including miscellaneous expressed opinions;

  • files relating to promotions appeals and associated correspondence;

  • files relating to any dealing between the ATO and any other department or authority, State or Federal, for example, the NSW Police Department, the Commonwealth Police, the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation ("ASIO") and the Federal Public Service Board;

  • files relating to any dealings between the ATO and private enterprise organisations such as Mayne Nickless's Cash Carrying and Security Service Divisions. 

  1. He mentioned that he had been employed in the Sydney, NSW office. 

  2. In oral evidence before the Tribunal it was explained that this was taken by the Respondent to be a request of the type described in s 15A of the Freedom of Information Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beesley and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 476
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Beesley and Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant sought access to personnel records under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) had delayed in providing the information, leading to a dispute about the extent of their search for relevant documents. The case was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary legal issues were whether the ATO had conducted reasonable searches for the requested documents and if they had met the statutory requirements under the FOI Act for a deemed internal review.

The AAT found that, with the exception of the searches relating to the correspondence records of two tax commissioners, the ATO had met the standard of proof under section 61 of the FOI Act. The searches were considered reasonable given the circumstances and the age of the documents in question. However, the Tribunal identified that two additional searches should be conducted to ensure compliance with section 24A(a) of the FOI Act. These searches involve looking for correspondence tracking records for the Commissioner of Taxation and the NSW Deputy Commissioner of Taxation from 1978 to 1984. If these records exist, a subsequent search would be required to identify any ATO file numbers related to correspondence with Mr Beesley.

The Tribunal set aside the deemed internal review decision and ordered the ATO to undertake the additional searches as outlined above. This decision ensures that all reasonable steps are taken to find the requested documents and comply with the FOI Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There was much discussion about the possible continued existence on computer databases of copies of correspondence from as far back as 1985. Mr Ebert's recollection was that word processing had not been adopted in the ATO by 1985. There was a typing pool and all retained copies of correspondence were in paper form on paper files. In the early 1980s there were some standard letters and questionnaires on computers in the ATO but that would be all there was.Respondent's evidence The Respondent's documentary evidence elicited the following new information. In Exhibit R2 the Respondent stated that all copies of performance appraisals should have been contained on the Applicant's personnel file which had been given to him. As regards correspondence, a search of administrative file indexes for the Sydney office had not revealed any files relating to personal correspondence with the Deputy Commissioner. Correspondence from the Deputy Commissioner to the Applicant should have been copied onto the Applicant's personnel file which is the only place where it would be retained. This appears not to have been done. As regards communiques with external organisations, staff working for the manager of security services in the ATO undertook a further search and could find no records relating to the Applicant. Pre-employment police checks would be attached to the personnel file. Promotion appeals documents were retained at the relevant time for only one year. The Respondent had searched for the Applicant's taxation records for 1978-1986 but the files had been destroyed. The Respondent wrote that there was no other avenue to be pursued that would reveal any files about the Applicant. "Given the time period in question, it is likely that this is due to the age of the documents in question, and the probability that all files which may have existed (except for [the Applicant's] personnel file) have been destroyed." In the affidavit (Exhibit R3) dated 15 December 2000 Ms Thompson says, relevantly, that: She had been responsible for conducting searches for documents relating to the Applicant's request. She had asked for a variety of searches to be done. The ATO storage facility at Pyrmont was searched and no additional personnel file was found. There was no personal security file held about the Applicant. The Moonee Ponds site in Victoria had been searched. It handles national and Canberra staff. It had nothing relating to the Applicant. The Parramatta, Penrith and National Offices had no record of any file relating to the Applicant being sent to Australian Archives. Any promotion files about the Applicant would have been destroyed after a year in accordance with the current General Disposal Authority. Normal practice in the ATO is for an employee to have only one personnel file. The Applicant has had access to the file the ATO had found about him. A document in the personnel file makes reference to file AF 2731 Pt 4, "Appeals Against Promotion of Officers, Transfers of Officers, Regulation 33 Appeals". A search of the stored AF 2731 files at Pyrmont did not result in the finding of Pt 4.

Decision

Reasons for decision

With the exception of the searches relating to the correspondence records of the two tax commissioners, the Tribunal finds that the Respondent has met the standard of proof in s 61 of the FOI Act in that the searches conducted were reasonable in the circumstances of this case.Decision The Tribunal sets aside the deemed internal review decision under review and decides as follows: The searches undertaken in response to the Applicant's request were appropriate and reasonable. In order that s 24A(a) of the FOI Act may be satisfied and it can be said that "all reasonable steps have been taken to find the [relevant] document[s]", two additional searches need to be attempted and the Tribunal now orders that these searches be undertaken. The first of these is a search for any correspondence tracking records maintained on behalf of the Commissioner of Taxation in the period between 1978 and 1984. The second is a search of a similar kind in respect of the NSW Deputy Commissioner of Taxation for the same period. If those records exist, there is to be a reasonable search of the records for references to any correspondence from or to Mr Beesley, with a view to identifying any ATO file numbers connected to files which may contain copies of that correspondence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established