Beat the Q Pty Ltd v Ian Charles Ogilvy

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Beat the Q Pty Ltd v Ian Charles Ogilvy [2015] APO 47

Patent Application:                2011253607

Title:A transaction processing method, apparatus and system

Patent Applicant:                   Ian Charles Ogilvy

Opponent:  Beat the Q Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Greg Powell

Decision Date:  7 August 2015

Hearing Date:  26 May 2015, in Canberra

Catchwords:  PATENTS - section 59 – opposition to the grant of a patent –whether the claimed invention is novel – lack of novelty not established – whether the claimed invention involves an inventive step – lack of inventive step not established on evidence filed – whether the claims are clear and fairly based – claims clear and fairly based – whether claims define a manner of manufacture – claims define a manner of manufacture – opposition unsuccessful – costs awarded against the opponent.

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Tim Staley, Patent attorney of Griffith Hack, Sydney

Opponent:Lorne Wood-Roe, Patent attorney of Adams Pluck, Hornsby

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2011253607

Title:A transaction processing method, apparatus and system

Patent Applicant:                   Ian Charles Ogilvy

Date of Decision:                   7 August 2015

DECISION

The opposition is unsuccessful.  I direct that the application proceed to grant, subject to any appeal of this decision.

Costs are awarded according to Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations against Beat the Q Pty Ltd.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Application 2011253607 in the name of Ian Charles Ogilvy (“ICG”) was filed on 23 November 2011 as a divisional application of parent application 2005256142 and accepted on 3 December 2012.  The parent application had lapsed due to failure to gain acceptance following examination.  Beat the Q Pty Ltd (“BTQ”) filed a Notice of Opposition on 10 April 2013.  The evidence in support of the opposition was completed on 22 October 2013, the evidence in answer was complete by 22 January 2014 and, despite indicating that evidence in reply was going to be filed, BTQ filed no evidence in reply.

    The hearing was held on 26 May 2015.  ICG’s representative appeared in person along with Ian Ogilvy as an observer.  BTQ’s representative appeared by phone.

    The Opposition

  2. While more grounds appear in the Statement of Grounds and Particulars, at the hearing BTQ opposed the grant of a patent on the basis of:

    (i)non-compliance with sections 40(2) and (3)

    (ii)lack of novelty

    (iii)lack of inventive step

    (iv)lack of manner of manufacture.

  3. Evidence in support consists of two declarations as follows:

    (i)Dr Ka Ching Chan with Annexures A–E; and

    (ii)Stefan Mozar with Annexures A–F.

    Evidence in answer consists of a single declaration by Dr Seppo Keronen with Annexures A–E.

    I will refer to the relevant parts of the evidence where appropriate.

    The Specification

  4. The present invention relates to a transaction processing system for facilitating payments in various circumstances.  The specification notes that payments often occur in an electronic manner in which a credit or charge card is used and, following appropriate authorisation such as the payer’s signature on an invoice, the amount owing for the purchase is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beat the Q Pty Ltd v Ian Charles Ogilvy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] APO 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Patent Office considered an opposition to the grant of a patent for a transaction processing method, apparatus and system, which involved a payer electronic device associated with the payer, in the case of Beat the Q Pty Ltd v Ian Charles Ogilvy [2015] APO 47. The opposition was based on several grounds including lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, lack of manner of manufacture and unclear and unfair basis of the claims. The primary focus of the case was on the interpretation of the claims, specifically the meaning of the term "payer electronic device associated with a payer". The court found that the claims were clear and fairly based, novel, involved an inventive step and defined a manner of manufacture. The opposition was therefore unsuccessful and the application was directed to proceed to grant, subject to any appeal. The court also awarded costs according to Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations against Beat the Q Pty Ltd.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a patent application for a transaction processing method, apparatus, and system filed by Ian Charles Ogilvy. The application, number 2011253607, is a divisional application of a previously lapsed application, 2005256142. The invention pertains to a transaction processing system designed to improve security and convenience in electronic payments. It involves a payer using a personal electronic device, such as a mobile phone, to select products and transmit payment information directly to a transaction processing system, thereby reducing the security risks associated with conventional payment methods where credit card details are shared with merchants.

Beat the Q Pty Ltd opposed the grant of the patent, arguing that the claims lacked novelty, did not involve an inventive step, were not clear or fairly based, and did not define a manner of manufacture. The opposition was based on several grounds, including prior art references that allegedly anticipated the invention or made it obvious.

The patent application was opposed by Beat the Q Pty Ltd, which filed a Notice of Opposition on 10 April 2013. The evidence in support of the opposition was completed on 22 October 2013, and the evidence in answer was complete by 22 January 2014. Despite indicating that evidence in reply would be filed, Beat the Q Pty Ltd did not submit any evidence in reply. The hearing took place on 26 May 2015. The decision was rendered on 7 August 2015, dismissing the opposition and directing that the application proceed to grant, subject to any appeal. Costs were awarded against Beat the Q Pty Ltd.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claimed invention is novel in light of the prior art.
2. Whether the claimed invention involves an inventive step in light of the prior art and common general knowledge.
3. Whether the claims are clear and fairly based on the specification.
4. Whether the claims define a manner of manufacture.

Held
1. The court held that the claimed invention is novel in light of the prior art.
2. The court held that the claimed invention involves an inventive step in light of the prior art and common general knowledge.
3. The court held that the claims are clear and fairly based on the specification.
4. The court held that the claims define a manner of manufacture.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the construction of the claims based on the specification as a whole. It held that the term "payer electronic device associated with the payer" meant a personal, consumer electronic device operated by a payer, who could be a company. The court held that the term "associated" imparted some notion of possession between the payer and the payer electronic device. The court held that the claims were novel because the prior art document did not disclose a payer electronic device associated with the payer as construed by the court. Regarding inventive step, the court found that the prior art documents did not disclose a payer electronic device as defined in the claims. The court found that the specification was fully descriptive and disclosed the best method of performance of the invention. The court found that the claims were clear and fairly based on the specification. Finally, the court held that the claims defined a manner of manufacture as the invention lay in a method and apparatus which used a payer electronic device that did not operate in the same way as other electronic devices associated with payers in general. The court awarded costs to the opponent as the opposition was unsuccessful.