FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| BEACH & BEACH (NO. 2) | [2007] FamCA 1006 |
| FAMILY LAW – property – dispute about valuations |
| Family Law Act 1975 (C’th) |
| HUSBAND: | MR BEACH |
| WIFE: | MRS BEACH |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLF | 2761 | of | 2003 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 15 August 2007 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Melbourne |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Brown J |
| HEARING DATE: | 15 August, 2007 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE HUSBAND: | Ms. Molyneux SC |
| THE HUSBAND: | Mr. Beach |
| COUNSEL FOR THE WIFE: | Ms. Watts |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE WIFE: | Gillian Coote |
Orders
That by 17 August, 2007 the solicitors for the wife advise the husband (by ordinary post addressed to his address for service and posted on or before 17 August, 2007) of :
(a)the estimated sum to be charged by E Estate Agents, A (or such other office or E Estate Agents nominated by the A office) to value the plant, equipment and stock in the husband’s possession or control, including any fee charged by E Estate Agents or the report dated 14 August, 2007, marked as exhibit W-1 this day; and
(b)the estimated sum to be charged by C Auctions to value the furniture and chattels in the property at D.
That B Pty. Ltd. be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare an updated valuation of the property at D.
That S Property Advisors be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare an updated valuation of the farming property known as F.
That E Estate Agents be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare a valuation of the plant and equipment (including motor vehicles) and stock in the husband’s possession or control.
That C Auctions be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare a valuation of the furniture and chattels in the property at D.
That at or before 4:00 pm. on 23 August, 2007 the husband pay to the wife’s solicitor the following sums, to be held on trust pursuant to these orders, and disbursed to pay the respective valuers referred to in these orders :
(a)the sum of $1,100, to be disbursed forthwith to S Property Advisors, being a sum outstanding in respect of a valuation of the F property obtained by the husband in 2006;
(b)the sum of $1,650, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the F property;
(c)the sum of $247.50, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the property at D;
(d)one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(a) hereof;
(e)one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(b) hereof.
That at or before 4:00 pm. on 23 August, 2007 the wife pay to her solicitors the following sums, to be held on trust pursuant to these orders, and disbursed to pay the respective valuations :
(a)the sum of $1,650, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the F property;
(c)the sum of $247.50, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Beach and Beach (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] FamCA 1006
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the process for obtaining updated valuations of the parties' assets, including the specific entities to be instructed for each valuation. The court also needed to address the immediate payment of certain outstanding and prospective valuation costs, with a view to determining ultimate responsibility at a later stage. Further issues included the vacating of a trial date and the adjournment of competing applications for final property orders.
Brown J ordered that specific valuers, including E Estate Agents, C Auctions, B Pty. Ltd., and S Property Advisors, be jointly instructed by the parties to conduct valuations of the husband's plant, equipment, and stock, as well as furniture and chattels, and the respective properties. The husband and wife were each ordered to pay specified sums to the wife's solicitor to cover the costs of these valuations, with the husband also being required to pay an outstanding sum for a previous valuation. The court reserved the question of ultimate responsibility for these costs to the trial judge and vacated the previously scheduled trial date, adjourning the property applications to a later date.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
That by 17 August, 2007 the solicitors for the wife advise the husband (by ordinary post addressed to his address for service and posted on or before 17 August, 2007) of :
(a) the estimated sum to be charged by E Estate Agents, A (or such other office or E Estate Agents nominated by the A office) to value the plant, equipment and stock in the husband’s possession or control, including any fee charged by E Estate Agents or the report dated 14 August, 2007, marked as exhibit W-1 this day; and
(b) the estimated sum to be charged by C Auctions to value the furniture and chattels in the property at D.
2.
That B Pty. Ltd. be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare an updated valuation of the property at D.
3.
That S Property Advisors be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare an updated valuation of the farming property known as F.
4.
That E Estate Agents be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare a valuation of the plant and equipment (including motor vehicles) and stock in the husband’s possession or control.
5.
That C Auctions be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare a valuation of the furniture and chattels in the property at D.
6.
That at or before 4:00 pm. on 23 August, 2007 the husband pay to the wife’s solicitor the following sums, to be held on trust pursuant to these orders, and disbursed to pay the respective valuers referred to in these orders :
(a) the sum of $1,100, to be disbursed forthwith to S Property Advisors, being a sum outstanding in respect of a valuation of the F property obtained by the husband in 2006;
(b) the sum of $1,650, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the F property;
(c) the sum of $247.50, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the property at D;
(d) one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(a) hereof;
(e) one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(b) hereof.
7.
That at or before 4:00 pm. on 23 August, 2007 the wife pay to her solicitors the following sums, to be held on trust pursuant to these orders, and disbursed to pay the respective valuations :
(a) the sum of $1,650, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the F property;
(c) the sum of $247.50, being one half of the cost of the updated valuation of the D property;
(d) one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(a) hereof;
(e) one half of the total sum advised by the solicitors for the wife pursuant to paragraph (1)(b) hereof.
8.
That the question of which party should be ultimately responsible for the cost of the valuations ordered this day be reserved to the trial judge.
9.
That each of the valuers referred to in this order be jointly instructed by the parties no later than 5:00 pm. on 24 August, 2007.
10.
That the parties have liberty to apply on short notice in writing in respect of the orders for valuations.
11.
That the trial date of 20 August, 2007 be vacated.
12.
That the competing applications for final property orders be adjourned to 10:00 am. on 17 September, 2007.
13.
That the wife have leave to file an affidavit relating to caveats registered over any property in dispute in this matter.
14.
That the reasons for judgment this day be transcribed and that copies be made available to the parties.
15.
That pursuant to Rule 19.50 of the Family Law Rules 2004 this matter reasonably required the attendance of senior counsel and a solicitor appearing as counsel.
AND THE COURT NOTES
1.
That unless and until a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service of the husband, and notwithstanding any communications received by the solicitors for the wife from Kempsons or any other legal practitioner who advises he or she has been requested to assist the husband :
(a) the obligation of the solicitors for the wife is to serve the husband at his current address for service herein; and
(b) the obligation of the Court is to address all correspondence to the husband at his current address for service herein.
Background
Background to the litigation
Additionally, the court ordered that E Estate Agents value the plant, equipment, and stock in the husband's possession or control, and C Auctions value the furniture and chattels in the property at D. The husband and wife were each required to contribute one half of the costs for these valuations. These payments were to be made by the husband and wife to their respective solicitors, who would then disburse the funds to the valuers by a specified deadline. The court also noted that the ultimate responsibility for the cost of the valuations would be reserved for the trial judge.
The case further required the joint instruction of the specified valuers by no later than a certain date. The wife was granted leave to file an affidavit relating to any caveats registered over any property in dispute, and the reasons for the judgment were to be transcribed and made available to the parties. The trial date was vacated, and the competing applications for final property orders were adjourned to a later date. The court also noted that the matter required the attendance of senior counsel and a solicitor appearing as counsel.
The matter of Beach and Beach (No. 2) came before the court following a series of procedural steps that began with applications filed by both parties in relation to the valuation and division of assets, particularly property, in their divorce proceedings. The case had previously been subject to multiple hearings and orders regarding the division of assets, with earlier disputes over the valuation of certain properties and the appointment of valuers. This hearing was an interlocutory application seeking further orders concerning the valuation of assets and the allocation of costs associated with those valuations. Prior to this hearing, the court had issued orders requiring the appointment of valuers to assess the worth of various assets, including farming property, residential property, and personal items. In light of these prior decisions and the ongoing disputes between the parties, the current hearing aimed to resolve the logistical and financial aspects of the valuation process and to set the stage for the final determination of property settlement. The orders made in this hearing reflect an attempt to balance the interests of both parties in obtaining accurate valuations while also managing the costs associated with these valuations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the solicitors for the wife are correctly obligated to serve the husband at his current address for service unless and until a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service.
2. Whether the court is correctly obligated to address all correspondence to the husband at his current address for service unless a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service.
3. Whether the valuation instructions given by the court are appropriate and in line with the parties' requirements.
4. Whether the court's orders regarding the payment of valuation costs between the parties are just and equitable.
5. Whether the reservation of the ultimate responsibility for the cost of the valuations to the trial judge is appropriate.
6. Whether the time frames set for instructing valuers and making payments are reasonable.
7. Whether the adjournment of the trial date and the competing applications for final property orders is justified.
8. Whether the wife should be granted leave to file an affidavit relating to caveats registered over any property in dispute.
Held
1. The court held that unless and until a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service, the solicitors for the wife are obligated to serve the husband at his current address for service.
2. The court held that unless a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service, the court is obligated to address all correspondence to the husband at his current address for service.
3. The court found the valuation instructions given by the court to be appropriate and in line with the parties' requirements.
4. The court's orders regarding the payment of valuation costs between the parties were deemed just and equitable.
5. The court held that the reservation of the ultimate responsibility for the cost of the valuations to the trial judge is appropriate.
6. The court determined that the time frames set for instructing valuers and making payments were reasonable.
7. The court held that the adjournment of the trial date and the competing applications for final property orders was justified.
8. The court granted the wife leave to file an affidavit relating to caveats registered over any property in dispute.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in Beach and Beach (No. 2) provided clear directives on several procedural and substantive issues. Firstly, the Court addressed the obligation of solicitors and the Court itself in relation to the husband's address for service. The Court held that unless and until a legal practitioner files a notice of address for service, the solicitors for the wife must serve the husband at his current address for service. This decision aligns with the principle that unless otherwise notified, the current address remains the valid address for service. The Court further ruled that it must address all correspondence to the husband at his current address unless a change is formally notified, reinforcing the necessity for formal notification to alter the address for service. This reasoning ensures that the procedural integrity is maintained, and there is no ambiguity regarding where to direct communications.
Turning to the valuation instructions, the Court mandated that specific valuers be jointly instructed by the parties to prepare updated valuations of various properties and assets. The Court meticulously detailed the valuation scope and the division of costs between the parties, ensuring that each party bears half the cost of the updated valuations. This approach was deemed just and equitable, reflecting the principle that costs related to the property settlement should be shared fairly. The Court's decision to reserve the ultimate responsibility for the cost of the valuations to the trial judge ensures that this aspect of the property settlement can be revisited and resolved comprehensively at the trial.
The Court also addressed the timelines for instructing valuers and making payments. It set specific deadlines for instructing valuers and paying their fees, reflecting a reasonable balance between ensuring timely valuations and accommodating the parties' financial preparations. The Court's decision to vacate the trial date and adjourn the competing applications for final property orders was justified by the need for further evidence and the complexity of the issues at hand. This decision demonstrates the Court's commitment to ensuring that all relevant information is available to make informed orders.
Moreover, the Court granted the wife leave to file an affidavit relating to caveats registered over any property in dispute. This decision underscores the importance of transparency and the need to address all potential encumbrances on the properties in question. The Court's decision to require senior counsel and a solicitor to appear in the matter highlights the complexity of the case and the need for experienced legal representation.
In conclusion, the Court in Beach and Beach (No. 2) provided detailed and reasoned orders that balanced procedural fairness with the substantive needs of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision includes the principle that unless formally notified otherwise, the current address for service remains valid, and both solicitors and the Court must adhere to it. Additionally, the Court emphasized the equitable division of costs related to property valuations and the necessity for clear and timely instructions to valuers. The reservation of ultimate responsibility for valuation costs to the trial judge and the reasonable setting of time frames for instructing valuers and making payments were also key aspects of the Court's reasoning. The adjournment of the trial date and the granting of leave to file an affidavit regarding caveats further reflect the Court's approach to ensuring a comprehensive and fair resolution of the property settlement issues.