FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| MASSEY & MASSEY AND ANOR (NO. 3) | [2007] FamCA 1502 |
| FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY SETTLEMENT – Section 79 Property Orders – Child Support – Intervention by Australian Taxation Office – Identification of pool of assets – Valuation of wheat and barley crop – Whether a crop is property or its proceeds upon harvest are income – Legal fees and if they are to be repaid to the pool of assets – Standard of Proof – Observation of witnesses – Assessment of contribution factors – Assessment of s75(2) factors – Substantial other debts and liabilities – Sale of farming lands to satisfy orders and liability to intervenor – Just and equitable division of property |
| Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 at 361-2 Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 4; s 75(2); s 79(2); s 79(4); s 106A |
| APPLICANT: | MRS MASSEY |
| RESPONDENT: | MR MASSEY |
| INTERVENOR: | THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLF | 2141 | of | 2005 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 30 November 2007 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | MELBOURNE |
| PLACE HEARD: | MELBOURNE |
| JUDGMENT OF: | YOUNG J |
| HEARING DATE: | 24, 25 AND 26 October 2007 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | MR WOOD |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | PEARSONS SCHETZER & ASSOCIATES |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | MS SMALLWOOD |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | GARDEN & GREEN |
| COUNSEL FOR THE INTERVENOR: | MR THOMSON |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE INTERVENOR: | ATO LEGAL SERVICE BRANCH |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ORDERS
ISSUE
APPLICATIONS
AFFIDAVITS
BACKGROUND FACTS
PREVIOUS ORDERS (A Summary)
STANDARD OF PROOF
OBSERVATION OF WITNESSES
FAMILY LAW ACT 1975 (CTH), S.79 AND RELEVANT CASE LAW
SECTION 75(2) FACTORS
INITIAL PROPERTY CONTRIBUTIONS
INHERITANCES AND PRE-COHABITATION CONTRIBUTIONS
INTERVENOR – HUSBAND’S TAXATION LIABILITY
POOL OF ASSETS, RESOURCES AND LIABILITIES
THE WIFE
MR L
HUSBAND
FARMING LANDS AT W
ACREAGE
SALE OF FARMING LANDS
M PROPERTY
S PROPERTY
COMMONWEALTH BANK OVERDRAFT - WIFE
COMMONWEALTH BANK OVERDRAFT – HUSBAND
PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
LIVESTOCK
CROP VALUATION
VALUE…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Massey and Massey and Anor (No. 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] FamCA 1502
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the division of the parties' property under section 79 of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth), the application of section 75(2) factors, the resolution of the intervenor's claim, the allocation of tax liabilities, and the determination of child support obligations. The court also had to consider the sale of various properties and assets, the application of sale proceeds, and the ultimate responsibility for outstanding debts and liabilities.
Young J applied established principles of family law to determine the property settlement. The court meticulously detailed the orders for the sale of specific properties, including the "C Property" and "T Property," and the application of sale proceeds to satisfy various debts, including those owed to the intervenor and the wife, as well as mortgage obligations. Orders were made for the clearance sale of plant and equipment, with proceeds to be applied towards specific debts and payments to the intervenor and wife. The court also directed the sale of the husband's wheat and barley crops, with specific allocations of the proceeds to cover crop liens, payments to the intervenor and wife, and child support arrears. Further lump sum payments were ordered to the wife, with default provisions involving the sale of "T Property." The court clarified the retention of remaining assets by each party and their respective liabilities, including significant debts to Rural Finance Corporation and bank overdrafts. Finally, the court made detailed orders regarding child support assessments for the period of 1 July 2005 to 30 June 2009, specifying lump sum non-periodic payments.
Orders
Orders of the court
ISSUE
APPLICATIONS
AFFIDAVITS
BACKGROUND FACTS
PREVIOUS ORDERS (A Summary)
STANDARD OF PROOF
OBSERVATION OF WITNESSES
FAMILY LAW ACT 1975 (CTH), S.79 AND RELEVANT CASE LAW
SECTION 75(2) FACTORS
INITIAL PROPERTY CONTRIBUTIONS
INHERITANCES AND PRE-COHABITATION CONTRIBUTIONS
INTERVENOR – HUSBAND’S TAXATION LIABILITY
POOL OF ASSETS, RESOURCES AND LIABILITIES
THE WIFE
MR L
HUSBAND
FARMING LANDS AT W
ACREAGE
SALE OF FARMING LANDS
M PROPERTY
S PROPERTY
COMMONWEALTH BANK OVERDRAFT - WIFE
COMMONWEALTH BANK OVERDRAFT – HUSBAND
PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
LIVESTOCK
CROP VALUATION
VALUE OF CROPS
LEGAL COSTS
CAPITAL GAINS TAX AND TAX LOSSES
B FINANCE
FINAL NET ASSET POOL
MONIES RECEIVED BY WIFE
SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE AND OTHER PAYMENTS
CHILD SUPPORT
SECTION 75(2) FACTORS
OUTCOME
MONIES AVAILABLE TO HUSBAND TO SATISFY ORDERS
MONIES TO BE PAID TO INTERVENOR
OTHER LIABILITIES TO BE PAID BY HUSBAND
MONETARY EFFECT OF ORDER
FOURTH STEP
MONIES TO BE PAID TO WIFE
SECTION 106A
ORDERS
1.
THAT all prior partial property, maintenance and financial orders be discharged.
2.
THAT the husband forthwith sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary to sell the properties of 1,100 acres known as “[C Property]” and being the whole of the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume … Folio … and Folio … (Crown Allotments [1] and [2]) subject to the following terms and conditions:
(a) the properties be offered for sale (jointly or individually) prior to 22 December 2007 with a settlement date scheduled no later than 28 March 2008;
(b) the sale(s) be on an unconditional contract basis and for the best available price;
(c) the husband have the conduct of sale(s) but the selling agent is to be Mr S of L Real Estate and the solicitors for the husband, wife and Intervenor are to be kept fully informed of all offers, discussions and issues concerning each of the properties and the proposed sale(s) price thereof;
(d) the reserve price is to be $385,000 or individually $192,500 each;
(e) the wife is to ensure that, at her expense, the caveats lodged by her and encumbering each of the titles are withdrawn prior to settlement.
3.
THAT upon settlement the proceeds of sale of C property be applied as follows:
(a) in payment of all reasonable and proper costs, commissions and expenses of sale(s);
(b) in payment of any arrears of rates, taxes and outgoings;
(c) in payment to the Intervenor of a sum of $280,000;
(d) in payment of a sum of $40,000 to the wife;
(e) in payment of the balance or such lesser sum as the husband may then negotiate to the Rural Finance Corporation in partial reduction of its mortgage security held over all of the farming properties owned by the husband.
4.
THAT by early February 2008 a clearance sale be held to realise all of the plant and equipment identified in the Certificate of Valuation prepared by Mr BL and which is annexure “IBL2” to his affidavit filed 20 August 2007.
5.
THAT the husband, by himself, his servants or agents be and is hereby restrained from removing from any of his properties any item of plant or equipment identified in that valuation and, if any such item is now located elsewhere, it is to be returned forthwith by or on behalf of the husband to the properties or to the location of the clearance sale.
6.
THAT the husband co-operate in all ways and do all acts and things and give all necessary and proper instructions to achieve the best available price on each of the items.
7.
THAT the selling agent for the purposes of the plant and equipment clearance sale be the firm B Company, but not Mr X of that firm.
8.
THAT the reserve price for all such items shall be the valuation sum of Mr BL unless it be otherwise varied by agreement between the husband and wife or as recommended in writing by B Company.
9.
THAT the proceeds of sale of the plant and equipment clearance sale are to be applied as follows:
(a) first to pay all actual costs, commissions and expenses of such sale;
(b) in discharge of the chattel mortgage liabilities owing to D Finance and the Bank of Queensland;
(c) in payment to the Intervenor of the sum of $138,308.17;
(d) in payment to the wife of the sum of $150,000;
(e) in payment of the balance, if any, to the husband.
10.
THAT the husband, his servants or agents be and are hereby required to sell all of the current wheat crop through the Australian Wheat Board and to sell all of his current barley crop through the Australian Barley Board.
11.
THAT from the sale of the barley crop the husband sign all documents and do all acts and things to authorise and direct the following payment(s):
(a) the sum of $10,000 to his former accountants in discharge of the crop lien;
(b) the sum of $150,000 to the Intervenor;
(c) the sum of $60,000 to be paid to the wife;
(d) the balance to be paid to the husband.
12.
THAT from the sale of the wheat crop the husband sign all documents and do all acts and things to authorise and direct the following payment(s):
(a) in payment to the Child Support Agency on behalf of the wife of the sum of $10,000 as the proper sum of child support arrears for the period up to 30 June 2007.;
(b) the sum of $25,000 to be paid to the wife;
(c) the balance to be paid to the husband.
13.
THAT on or before 1 April 2008 (“the due date”) the husband pay to the wife the further lump sum of $105,092 (“the further lump sum”).
14.
THAT in default of payment by the husband to the wife all of that further lump sum by the due date the property known as T property and being the whole of the land described in Certificate of Title Volume … Folio … (Crown Allotment …) be forthwith sold and the husband sign all documents and do all acts and things required to complete the settlement of such sale subject to the following terms and conditions:
(a) the sale be on an unconditional contract basis for the best available price and be settled within a further sixty (60) day period;
(b) the husband have the conduct of sale but the selling agent is to be Mr S of L Real Estate and the solicitors for the wife are to be kept fully informed of all offers, discussions and issues concerning the sale of T property and its proposed sale price;
(c) the reserve price is to be no less than $195,000;
(d) the wife is to ensure that, at her expense, the caveat lodged by her and encumbering its title is withdrawn prior to settlement.
15.
THAT upon settlement the proceeds of sale of T property are to be applied as follows:
(a) in payment of all reasonable and proper costs, commissions and expenses of sale;
(b) in payment of any arrears of rates, taxes and proper outgoings;
(c) in payment to the wife of the balance of the lump sum inclusive of interest to be calculated as and from the due date and to be paid monthly in arrears at the interest rate prescribed from time to time pursuant to the Family Law Rules and to continue until the whole of the further lump sum and all accrued interest is paid in full;
(d) in payment of the balance, if any, to the husband and he to be responsible from that sum to pay any required amount to the Rural Finance Corporation in discharge or proper reduction of its mortgage security.
16.
THAT upon payment of all monies otherwise due and payable by the husband to the wife and the Intervenor pursuant to these Orders the husband then retain sole ownership of all remaining farming land and otherwise identified in these proceedings as properties known as T property (subject to orders 14 and 14 hereof), H property, LS property, LR property and B property.
17.
THAT upon payment to the wife of all monies required to be paid to her pursuant to these Orders the wife then, and at her expense, provide executed withdrawals in proper registerable form for all caveats lodged by her on the remaining farming lands.
18.
THAT the wife otherwise retain her furniture and chattels, her motor vehicle and monies received by her from the sale of the property at S and the $60,000 received by Court Order from the settlement of M property.
19.
THAT the husband otherwise remain solely responsible for all debt, liability and interest owing to the Rural Finance Corporation, his personal Commonwealth Bank overdraft and all arrears of rates and taxes and other liabilities encumbering the other real property to be now retained in his sole name.
20.
THAT the husband be solely responsible for the liability to B Finance Pty Ltd and for that purpose, and aside from any item of plant and equipment to be realised in the clearance sale, he is to retain sole ownership and possession of the four farming discs and the prime mover, subject to the existing repossession order in favour of B Finance Pty Ltd and specifically any balance of liability owing to B Finance Pty Ltd shall be and remain the sole responsibility of the husband.
21.
THAT save for any proper purpose genuinely involved with the collection or delivery of the children of the marriage to and from the wife’s residential property the husband be and is otherwise restrained from entering upon or otherwise travelling in the immediate vicinity of or loitering within 200 metres of the wife’s residence at …, D or otherwise her residential address from time to time thereafter.
22.
THAT unless otherwise specified in these Orders and save for the purpose of enforcing any monies due and payable under these or any subsequent Orders:
(a) the husband and wife be entitled to the exclusion of the other to all other person or property, chattels or possessions as they now own or retain;
(b) each party retain any superannuation benefits or other work related benefits or entitlements owned by them;
(c) insurance policies remain the sole property of the owner thereof;
(d) the husband and wife otherwise be each solely liable for and indemnify the other against any other liability encumbering any item of property, real or personal, to which that party is entitled pursuant to these Orders.
23.
RESERVE liberty to the wife and the intervenor to apply to the Court on proper documentation filed and served upon the husband as to the enforcement of any of these orders.
24.
THAT all extant applications, interim and final, be otherwise dismissed and the proceedings be removed from the list of cases awaiting hearing.
25.
THAT after thirty (30) days all subpoenaed documents be returned by the Subpoenas Clerk, Family Court, Melbourne Registry to the person or organisation who produced same to the Court.
26.
THAT a sealed copy of these Orders be forthwith served upon the proper officer, Child Support Agency, by the solicitors for the wife.
27.
THAT the child support assessment for the period 1 July 2005 to 30 June 2007 be departed from by adjusting the annual rate to a sum sufficient to ensure that as at 30 June 2007 the total sum in child support then owing by the husband is $10,000 and that pursuant to Order 12(a) hereof that sum be paid from the proceeds of the wheat crop to the child support agency on behalf of the wife.
28.
THAT the child support assessment for the period 1 July 2007 to 30 June 2009 (inclusive) for the children M born … March 1994 and MA born … July 1998 be set in the sum of $15,600 per annum (payable as to $7,800 per annum per child) and that such sums be paid by the husband to the wife as follows:
§ in the 2007 – 2008 financial year the required sum being paid on or before 1 June 2008; and
§ in the 2008 – 2009 financial year the required sum being paid on or before 1 January 2009.
29.
THAT conditional upon the husband making each of these yearly payments as provided for in the preceding Order no penalty payments be charged or be applied to that yearly lump sum payment and I direct pursuant to s 124 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 the payments for each of these financial years be by lump sum non-periodic payment.
30.
RESERVE liberty to each of the husband and wife to apply if there is any difficulty or issue with the Child Support Agency as to the implementation or enforcement of these Orders for payment of child support.
IT IS CERTIFIED
31.
THAT pursuant to Rule 19.50 of the Family Law Rules this matter reasonably required the attendance of Counsel for all parties.
Background
Background to the litigation
The husband and wife's farming activities were extensive, involving multiple properties and substantial investments in plant and equipment. The husband had accumulated a significant debt with the Commonwealth Bank, which had placed a repossession order on some of the farming assets. The wife sought an equitable distribution of the assets, while the husband argued for retaining the majority of the farming properties.
The court was tasked with determining the fair distribution of the assets between the husband and wife, taking into account various factors such as property contributions, inheritances, and pre-cohabitation contributions. The sale of certain farming properties and equipment was ordered to realise funds for distribution. The court also addressed child support obligations and the husband's taxation liabilities. Various payments were ordered to be made to the wife, the Commonwealth Bank, and for child support, with specific timelines and conditions attached to these payments. Additionally, restrictions were imposed on the husband's access to the wife's residence to ensure the safety and well-being of the children of the marriage.
The case Massey and Massey and Anor (No. 3) came before the Family Court of Australia as a continuation of property settlement proceedings between the parties. This case followed previous orders and appeals, including decisions made in Massey and Massey [2004] FamCA 1357, Massey and Massey and Anor [2006] FamCA 1398, and Massey and Massey and Anor (No. 2) [2007] FamCA 642. The procedural history involves multiple interlocutory applications and rulings, particularly concerning the sale of farming properties, equipment, and crops. The court has made several orders to facilitate the sale of specific properties and equipment, with strict timelines and conditions attached, ensuring that proceeds from these sales are applied to various debts and payments as stipulated. The court has also addressed child support payments, requiring the husband to make lump sum payments to the wife for the benefit of their children. The final orders in this case include the discharge of previous orders, the sale of specific properties and assets, and the allocation of proceeds to pay off debts, provide lump sum payments to the wife, and other specified recipients. The case underscores the complexity of property settlements post-divorce, particularly involving farming assets and the equitable distribution of proceeds.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether all prior partial property, maintenance, and financial orders should be discharged.
2. Whether the husband should be required to sell specified properties and, if so, under what terms and conditions.
3. How the proceeds from the sale of the specified properties should be distributed.
4. Whether the husband should be restrained from removing plant and equipment from his properties and, if so, under what conditions.
5. Whether the husband should be required to co-operate in the sale of plant and equipment and, if so, under what terms and conditions.
6. How the proceeds from the sale of plant and equipment should be distributed.
7. Whether the husband should be required to sell his current wheat and barley crops through specific boards and, if so, under what terms and conditions.
8. How the proceeds from the sale of the wheat and barley crops should be distributed.
9. Whether the husband should be required to pay a further lump sum to the wife by a specified due date.
10. If the husband fails to pay the further lump sum by the due date, whether the specified property should be sold and, if so, under what terms and conditions.
11. How the proceeds from the sale of the specified property should be distributed.
12. Whether the husband should retain sole ownership of specified farming lands and other properties and, if so, under what terms and conditions.
13. Whether the wife should provide executed withdrawals for caveats on the remaining farming lands upon payment of all monies due to her.
14. Whether the wife should retain her furniture, chattels, motor vehicle, and monies received from the sale of specified property.
15. Whether the husband should remain solely responsible for specified debts and liabilities.
16. Whether the husband should remain solely responsible for the liability to a specified finance company.
17. Whether the husband should be restrained from entering or loitering near the wife’s residence, and if so, under what terms and conditions.
18. Whether the husband and wife should be entitled to the exclusion of the other from their respective properties, superannuation benefits, work-related benefits, and insurance policies.
19. Whether the husband and wife should be solely liable for and indemnify the other against any liabilities encumbering any property to which that party is entitled.
20. Whether liberty should be reserved for the wife and intervenor to apply to the Court for the enforcement of any of these orders.
21. Whether all extant applications, interim and final, should be dismissed and the proceedings removed from the list of cases awaiting hearing.
22. Whether subpoenaed documents should be returned to their originating source after thirty days.
23. Whether a sealed copy of these Orders should be served upon the proper officer, Child Support Agency, by the solicitors for the wife.
24. Whether the child support assessment for a specified period should be departed from and, if so, how.
25. Whether the child support assessment for a subsequent period should be set and, if so, how.
26. Whether conditional upon the husband making specified payments, no penalty payments should be charged.
27. Whether liberty should be reserved for the husband and wife to apply if there is any difficulty or issue with the Child Support Agency regarding the implementation or enforcement of these Orders.
28. Whether this matter reasonably required the attendance of Counsel for all parties.
Held
1. All prior partial property, maintenance, and financial orders were discharged.
2. The husband was required to sell specified properties with set terms and conditions.
3. The proceeds from the sale of specified properties were to be distributed as outlined in the order.
4. The husband was restrained from removing plant and equipment from his properties under specified conditions.
5. The husband was required to co-operate in the sale of plant and equipment with set terms and conditions.
6. The proceeds from the sale of plant and equipment were to be distributed as specified.
7. The husband was required to sell his current wheat and barley crops through specific boards under set terms and conditions.
8. The proceeds from the sale of the wheat and barley crops were to be distributed as specified.
9. The husband was required to pay a further lump sum to the wife by a specified due date.
10. If the husband failed to pay the lump sum by the due date, the specified property was to be sold under set terms and conditions.
11. The proceeds from the sale of the specified property were to be distributed as specified.
12. The husband was to retain sole ownership of specified farming lands and other properties under set terms and conditions.
13. The wife was to provide executed withdrawals for caveats on the remaining farming lands upon payment of all monies due to her.
14. The wife was to retain her furniture, chattels, motor vehicle, and monies received from the sale of specified property.
15. The husband was to remain solely responsible for specified debts and liabilities.
16. The husband was to remain solely responsible for the liability to a specified finance company.
17. The husband was restrained from entering or loitering near the wife’s residence under set terms and conditions.
18. The husband and wife were entitled to the exclusion of the other from their respective properties, superannuation benefits, work-related benefits, and insurance policies.
19. The husband and wife were each solely liable for and indemnify the other against any liabilities encumbering any property to which that party was entitled.
20. Liberty was reserved for the wife and intervenor to apply to the Court for the enforcement of any of these orders.
21. All extant applications, interim and final, were dismissed and the proceedings were removed from the list of cases awaiting hearing.
22. Subpoened documents were to be returned to their originating source after thirty days.
23. A sealed copy of these Orders was to be served upon the proper officer, Child Support Agency, by the solicitors for the wife.
24. The child support assessment for a specified period was departed from and adjusted to ensure a specific total sum owing by the husband.
25. The child support assessment for a subsequent period was set and the payment schedule was specified.
26. Conditional upon the husband making specified payments, no penalty payments were to be charged.
27. Liberty was reserved for the husband and wife to apply if there was any difficulty or issue with the Child Support Agency regarding the implementation or enforcement of these Orders.
28. It was certified that this matter reasonably required the attendance of Counsel for all parties.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed several complex financial and property-related issues in this case, applying principles from the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and relevant case law. The decision involved the distribution of assets and liabilities between the husband and wife following the dissolution of their marriage. The court meticulously outlined the terms and conditions for the sale of specified properties, plant, and equipment, and crops, as well as the distribution of proceeds from these sales. It also directed the husband to pay a further lump sum to the wife by a specified due date, with terms for the sale of a property in the event of default.
The court began by discharging all prior partial property, maintenance, and financial orders, indicating a fresh start in the financial arrangements between the parties. It then mandated the husband to sell specified properties, setting clear terms and conditions for the sale, including the involvement of a specific real estate agent and solicitors. The court meticulously detailed how the proceeds from these sales should be distributed among the parties, the intervenor, and financial institutions. The court's approach to the sale of plant and equipment and crops followed a similar pattern, with detailed instructions on the sale process, restraint from removal, and distribution of proceeds.
In addressing the husband's financial obligations, the court set out a payment schedule for a further lump sum, with a clear consequence of property sale in the event of non-payment. It also detailed the husband's responsibility for specific debts and liabilities, including those to financial institutions and the Child Support Agency. The court's orders on the distribution of proceeds from the sale of properties and assets were grounded in a careful assessment of the pool of assets, resources, and liabilities, considering inheritances, pre-cohabitation contributions, and other relevant factors.
The court's decision on the husband's and wife's entitlement to exclude each other from their respective properties, superannuation benefits, work-related benefits, and insurance policies reflected a balanced approach to the division of assets and liabilities. It also reserved liberty for the wife and intervenor to apply for enforcement of the orders and for the husband and wife to apply for assistance with child support enforcement. The court's decision to dismiss all extant applications and remove the proceedings from the list of cases awaiting hearing indicated a finality to the financial arrangements and a closure to the financial aspects of the case.
The court's detailed and precise orders demonstrate its application of the principles of fairness and justice in dividing the assets and liabilities of the parties. The decision provides clear guidance on the terms and conditions for the sale of specified properties and assets, the distribution of proceeds, and the husband's financial obligations. The court's reliance on the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and relevant case law, as well as its consideration of the standard of proof and Section 75(2) factors, underscores the legal principles and authorities that guided its decision-making process. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the detailed and precise orders for the sale of specified properties and assets, the distribution of proceeds, and the husband's financial obligations, reflecting the application of the principles of fairness and justice in dividing the assets and liabilities of the parties.