BDA v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

CHILDRENS COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

BDA v Director of Public Prosecutions [2023] QChC 34

PARTIES:

BDA
(applicant)

v

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

CCJ 27/23

DIVISION:

Childrens Court of Queensland

PROCEEDING:

Sentence Review Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Pine Rivers Childrens Court

DELIVERED ON:

8 March 2023 (delivered ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

8 March 2023

JUDGE:

Dearden DCJ

ORDER:

(1)      Application for sentence review granted;

(2)      Order the 12-month probation order imposed at the Childrens Court at Pine Rivers on 12 December 2022 be discharged; and

(3) Substitute a good behaviour order of three months pursuant to YJA s 175(1)(b) in respect of all offences the subject of this application for sentence review.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE –SENTENCING JUVENILES – APPLICANT OUT OF TIME TO MAKE APPLICATION – where the applicant child was sentenced to 12 months probation in respect of 35 charges – whether the sentence was manifestly excessive – whether insufficient weight was given to the applicant’s young age, lack of criminal history and personal circumstances - where the applicant child was 11 at the time of offending – where the applicant child had spent 15 days in detention

Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld) ss 118, 119, 122, 123, 150, 175

COUNSEL:

A Acreman for the applicant

AR Hall for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the applicant

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Introduction

  1. This is an application to extend time for a sentence review arising out of sentences imposed at the Pine Rivers Childrens Court on 12 December 2022 in respect of charges which will be set out shortly, and if that application is successful (I note that it is not opposed by the respondent), then an application for sentence review in respect of those same charges. 

  2. The sentence imposed at the Pine Rivers Childrens Court was a sentence of 12 months’ probation in respect of 35 charges, with no conviction recorded.  Those charges are as follows: 

Date of Offence Place of Offence Offence
06/03/2022 Rothwell

Enter premises and commit indictable offence by break

06/03/2022 Rothwell Enter premises and commit indictable offence by break
09/03/2022 North Lakes

Unlawful use of motor vehicle, aircraft, or vessel – use 

06/03/2022 Rothwell Stealing
13/03/2022 Deception Bay Stealing
15/03/2022 North Lakes Enter premises and commit indictable offence
15/03/2022 North Lakes Enter premises and commit indictable offence
15/03/2022 North Lakes Enter premises and commit indictable offence
8/03/2022 Brisbane City Wilful damage
25/04/2022 Caboolture Stealing
28/04/2022 Brisbane City Stealing
01/05/2022 Caboolture Common Assault
28/07/2022 Caboolture South Stealing
16/05/2022 Caboolture South Stealing
01/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
02/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
08/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
24/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
23/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
25/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
27/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
29/08/2022 Morayfield Stealing
11/08/2022 Caboolture South Stealing
06/06/2022 Mount Ommaney Common Assault
Between 22/09/2022 and 25/09/2022 Caboolture South Unlawful use of motor vehicles, aircraft, or vessel – use
05/10/2022 Caboolture South Enter premises with intent
29/08/2022 Morayfield Enter premises and commit indictable offence by break
28/10/2022 Bray Park
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BDA v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QChC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of BDA v Director of Public Prosecutions, the applicant, an 11-year-old child at the time of the offending, was sentenced to 12 months of probation by the Pine Rivers Children’s Court for 35 charges. The case came before the court for a review of the sentence, with the applicant arguing that the sentence was manifestly excessive and that insufficient weight was given to his young age, lack of criminal history, and personal circumstances. The applicant, who had spent 15 days in detention, was represented by legal counsel who submitted that the sentence imposed was disproportionate and did not adequately account for the mitigating factors presented.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the sentence was manifestly excessive and whether there was an inadequate consideration of the applicant’s age, criminal history, and personal circumstances. The court had to determine if the sentence was proportionate to the offending and whether the sentence review process was correctly applied. The court examined the principles of sentencing for juveniles, which emphasise rehabilitation and the circumstances of the offender, and assessed whether the sentence met these objectives.

The court found that the sentence was indeed manifestly excessive and that insufficient weight was given to the applicant’s age and personal circumstances. The court noted the applicant’s extensive history of placement instability, trauma, and mental health issues, as well as his limited educational experience and significant behavioural issues diagnosed as ADHD and reactive attachment disorder. The court held that the sentence did not appropriately reflect the need for rehabilitation and the circumstances of the young offender. As a result, the court granted the application for sentence review, discharged the 12-month probation order, and substituted a good behaviour order of three months.

The final orders of the court were to grant the application for sentence review, discharge the 12-month probation order imposed by the Pine Rivers Children’s Court, and substitute a good behaviour order of three months in respect of all offences the subject of this application for sentence review. The court’s decision underscored the importance of considering the unique circumstances of juvenile offenders and the need for sentences that align with the principles of rehabilitation and proportionality.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Application for sentence review granted;

(2) Order the 12-month probation order imposed at the Childrens Court at Pine Rivers on 12 December 2022 be discharged; and

(3) Substitute a good behaviour order of three months pursuant to YJA s 175(1)(b) in respect of all offences the subject of this application for sentence review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The sentence review process is a rehearing on the merits, and it is not necessary to demonstrate error (see, for example, R v JAM [2013] QChC 11, [9]; R v MKH [2014] QChC 3, p.2; KLP v R [2017] QChC 5, [3]; MOJ v R [2019] QChC 45, [7]; RSS v R [2022] QChC 29, [26]). Background The applicant has helpfully summarised the extensive detail of the offending and the appearance in the Pine Rivers Children’s Court as follows:[11]4.On 12 December 2022, the applicant was convicted and sentenced before the Pine Rivers Children’s Court to a probation order [of] 12 months for the offences in the table below. The facts of the charges were not read into the record, rather a schedule was admitted and marked exhibit 1. [11]Exhibit 5 – Outline of submissions on behalf of the applicant child, [4] – [9]. The reference in exhibit 5 – Outline of submissions on behalf of the applicant child [4] to “ABB” is drawn from the schedule of facts tendered at the sentence before the learned magistrate on 12 December 2022 at the Pine Rivers Childrens Court, but it is common ground between the applicant and the respondent that the reference is, in fact to the applicant BDA. The applicant’s antecedents The applicant’s outline helpfully summarises the applicant’s antecedents as follows:[12] [12]Exhibit 5 – Outline of submissions on behalf of the applicant child, [10]-[17]. 10.The applicant is a 12-year-old Aboriginal boy, born on 14 August 2010. He was 12 at the time of sentence and 11 at the time of a lot of the offending.11.The applicant came into the care of the Department of Children, Youth Justice and Multicultural Affairs (the Department) on interim orders in March 2011 when he was a baby due to concerns regarding neglect and exposure to parental domestic violence, drug use, criminal conduct and mental health concerns. He has been subject to a long-term guardianship child protection order since July 2014.12.The applicant has experienced at least 56 different placements, some with siblings, and at times he self-placed with his mother who was living rough and then later in a house at Morayfield.13.A comprehensive mental health, fitness and soundness assessment court liaison service report (CLS Report) was prepared for court and admitted and marked as exhibit 2. This report detailed the applicant’s antecedents and his presentation and diagnosis at the time of offending and sentence. 14.The report speaks to:a.the applicant’s involvement with Child Safety, including placement instability and trauma;b.the applicant’s limited educational experience;c.the applicant’s psychiatric history with Evolve Therapeutic Services in relation to significant behavioural issues, diagnosis of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and reactive attachment disorder of childhood (RAD); d.the applicant’s cultural connection and engagement with the Kabul Justice Program.15.The applicant and his brother currently reside together in a residential placement with care providers “One MOP” at the Sunshine Coast. This arrangement has a very heavy focus on culture and connecting the applicant with other young indigenous men.16.The applicant has not attended school since grade 5 and has remained completely disengaged from education, however, enrolment at Arethusa College on the Sunshine Coast is being pursued. 17.Monthly stakeholder meetings are held to discuss the applicant’s care. Representatives from the Department of Child Safety and Youth Justice (Caboolture and Caloundra), Education Queensland and One MOP participate (citations omitted).Grounds of review

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.