Bbo16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BBO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 212

Appeal from: BBO16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016] FCCA 2541
File number: NSD 1856 of 2016
Judge: ROBERTSON  J
Date of judgment: 9 March 2017
Catchwords:

MIGRATION –  appeal from Federal Circuit Court of Australia dismissing an application for judicial review of decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) – subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa – whether primary judge erred in finding that the appellant had not been denied procedural fairness – whether primary judge erred in concluding that the relocation test in relation to the complementary protection provisions in s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) had been correctly applied – Held: appeal dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to amend to add new ground of jurisdictional error – tendency to undermine the appellate process in circumstances where no adequate explanation why ground not raised before the primary judge or earlier in the conduct of the appeal, the appellant having legal representation throughout – Held: application refused

Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2)(aa), 36(2A), 36(2B)(a), 57(2)(b), 473DA(1), 473DC(3), 476(4)(c)
Cases cited:

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH [2015] HCA 40; 256 CLR 326

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1990) 52 FCR 437

SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] HCA 40; 233 CLR 18

SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCAFC 46; 174 FCR 415

Sun v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 52; 243 FCR 220

Date of hearing: 23 February 2017
Date of last submissions: 28 February 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 86
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr J Hyde with Mr AM Cheema
Solicitor for the Appellant: Norton Rose Fulbright
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Mills Oakley Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The second respondent submitted save as to costs

ORDERS

NSD 1856 of 2016
BETWEEN:

BBO16

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON  J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 MARCH 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appellant have leave to amend ground 1 in the form of the proposed amended notice of appeal filed on 24 February 2017.

2.Leave be refused to the appellant to add ground 5 in the form of the proposed amended notice of appeal filed on 24 February 2017.

3.The appeal be dismissed.

4.The appellant pay the costs of the first respondent, as agreed or assessed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

ROBERTSON J:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from orders of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia made on 30 September 2016 dismissing an amended application for judicial review of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bbo16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, a Shia Muslim from Pakistan, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse him a Safe Haven Enterprise visa under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The appellant argued that he would be at risk of serious harm or death if returned to Pakistan due to his religious beliefs and that the decision-maker did not properly consider his personal circumstances. The Federal Circuit Court dismissed the appeal, and the appellant now seeks review by the Full Court of the Federal Court.

The central legal issues were whether the primary judge erred in finding that the appellant had not been denied procedural fairness and whether the primary judge correctly applied the relocation test in relation to the complementary protection provisions in s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act. The appellant argued that the decision-maker failed to give him a reasonable opportunity to address the issue of relocation within Pakistan and did not adequately consider his personal circumstances.

The Full Court found that the appellant had not demonstrated any error by the primary judge. The Court held that the decision-maker did provide the appellant with an opportunity to address the issue of relocation and that the appellant's arguments about his personal circumstances had been considered. The Court also found that the decision-maker correctly applied the relocation test under s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act. The appeal was therefore dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the respondent.

Additionally, the Court refused the appellant's application to amend the grounds of appeal to include a new ground of jurisdictional error. The Court found that the application tended to undermine the appellate process as the appellant had not provided an adequate explanation for why the new ground was not raised before the primary judge or earlier in the appeal process, despite having legal representation throughout.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellant have leave to amend ground 1 in the form of the proposed amended notice of appeal filed on 24 February 2017.

2. Leave be refused to the appellant to add ground 5 in the form of the proposed amended notice of appeal filed on 24 February 2017.

3. The appeal be dismissed.

4. The appellant pay the costs of the first respondent, as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The essential argument on behalf of the appellant is that, first, the delegate’s interview process miscarried because the appellant was not given a reasonable opportunity to say to where he ought or ought not be relocated within Pakistan. Secondly, the Immigration Assessment Authority decided that it would be reasonable for the appellant to relocate to Islamabad, but did so without asking him why was it reasonable or not reasonable for him to be relocated to Islamabad specifically. Thirdly, because of the approach it took, the Immigration Assessment Authority was not able to be properly informed about the personal circumstances of the appellant for the purposes of s 36(2B)(a) of the Migration Act.The facts in summary As explained by the delegate, the appellant claimed that if he returned to Pakistan he would be “seriously harmed or killed” by the militant group Lashkari Jhangawi (LeJ) for the reason of his religion as a Shia Muslim. The appellant claimed he could not find protection in his country because “the government is complicit in the attacks and killings of Shia Moslems. Although paramilitaries… paid by the state have been posted around the Shia area of Quetta to protect the community, killings have continued.” He also claimed he would be unable to safely live in another part of Pakistan because “Shia Muslims cannot live safely anywhere in Pakistan. The Lashkari Jhangawi is killing Shia Muslims throughout the country…”The procedure On 7 July 2015 the appellant was sent a letter by the Department of Immigration and Border Protection which stated:There have been changes to the laws about the protection application process for certain illegal maritime arrivals (IMAs). In December 2014, the Government passed the Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Act 2014. The department has now started considering protection claims under the new Fast Track Assessment process.The Fast Track Assessment process is different from the previous process in the areas of review rights and timeframes for notification. This will allow protection claims to be assessed efficiently and ensure a more robust approach to protection assessments. It will be used for certain individuals such as certain IMAs who arrived and entered Australia on or after 13 August 2012, but before 1 January 2014, and who have not been taken to a regional processing country.You were previously invited to apply for a Temporary Protection visa (TPV) only. However, Safe Haven Enterprise visas (SHEV) are now also available. Therefore, you are invited to lodge an application for either a subclass 785 Temporary Protection visa (TPV) or a subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa (SHEV). It is up to you which visa you would like to apply for, but you cannot validly apply for both visas. By application dated 14 August 2015, the appellant applied for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa.The hearing before the delegate Before the delegate, the appellant attended an interview in which, relevant to the present appeal, the following was asked and answered (transcript pages 21 and 22):Delegate OK. And is there anywhere that you could safely live in Pakistan?Interpreter No, Shia people don’t have any security in all of Pakistan.DelegateIs there any other reason why you think you couldn’t safely live anywhere else in Pakistan?Interpreter First of all I was born there in my area. I grew up in that area. I’m familiar with that area but to me to move from my own area to the other part of that country, so it will be very hard for me to settle myself first of all to the new area and secondly they will identify me as a new arrived people and they will recognise me and I will not be safe in the new area.Delegate Why wouldn’t you be safe in another area? Interpreter As I said Shia is not safe in any area.DelegateSo did you ever consider moving to a different part of Pakistan before leaving the country such as Islamabad where there is also a Shia population?Interpreter How should we go there? As you probably aware that they are stopping the bus when the people travel into Iran and kill them all because of their religion so now how can I take my family and my belongings to the bus and go to other city?DelegateAnd is there any other reason besides your religion why someone would target you?Interpreter I was targeted because the reason that I belong to the Shia religion so what other reason are you looking for?DelegateWell I’m not looking for a particular reason, I’m just giving you the opportunity to let me know if there are any other reasons.Interpreter No I don’t have any other issue and my life is obviously at risk because of my religion. DelegateAnd why couldn’t the authorities protect you in any other part of Pakistan?Interpreter As I mentioned before they have influence through the police into the government authority. They have a really strong connection by them or wherever I go to start new life they will recognise me and they will recognise me that I belong to this religion and I will be targeted by them.Delegate So who would recognise you? Interpreter Lashkar-e.DelegateSo if they weren’t able to find you in your own home, why would they be able to find you in another city?Interpreter So they are very active organisation and they are active in every city. While they know that I am living in that area for sure, they will find me but when I was inside of my home or when I’m outside of my home here, clearly they know that I’m not in that area.Delegate How would they know that?Interpreter They are very strong organisation and they a lot of people who working with them in this part for them, this intelligence information they are very active.DelegateSo there are some country information reports that support the ability of Shias to relocate within Pakistan to areas such as large cities where there is a mixture of ethnicities and low levels of religious violence. Do you have any comment about those particular reports?Interpreter So the danger or the risk is this, my life is in risk and danger whether I live in a small city or a big city. Because of this life risk I was afraid and flee from the country.DelegateAnd do you have any further comments about why you couldn't live in any other part of Pakistan?Interpreter So every part of Pakistan there is risk, there is life risk for the Shia people. The bomb blasting among ceremony or demonstration on the mosque or ?? that the Shia people going for praying and this sort of risk is everywhere in every corner of Pakistan. And just in the last ? ceremony there was a bomb blasting in the small town called ? inside of the mosque, Shia mosque.The decision of the delegate

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before the delegate, the appellant attended an interview in which, relevant to the present appeal, the following was asked and answered (transcript pages 21 and 22):Delegate OK. And is there anywhere that you could safely live in Pakistan?Interpreter No, Shia people don’t have any security in all of Pakistan.DelegateIs there any other reason why you think you couldn’t safely live anywhere else in Pakistan?Interpreter First of all I was born there in my area. I grew up in that area. I’m familiar with that area but to me to move from my own area to the other part of that country, so it will be very hard for me to settle myself first of all to the new area and secondly they will identify me as a new arrived people and they will recognise me and I will not be safe in the new area.Delegate Why wouldn’t you be safe in another area? Interpreter As I said Shia is not safe in any area.DelegateSo did you ever consider moving to a different part of Pakistan before leaving the country such as Islamabad where there is also a Shia population?Interpreter How should we go there? As you probably aware that they are stopping the bus when the people travel into Iran and kill them all because of their religion so now how can I take my family and my belongings to the bus and go to other city?DelegateAnd is there any other reason besides your religion why someone would target you?Interpreter I was targeted because the reason that I belong to the Shia religion so what other reason are you looking for?DelegateWell I’m not looking for a particular reason, I’m just giving you the opportunity to let me know if there are any other reasons.Interpreter No I don’t have any other issue and my life is obviously at risk because of my religion. DelegateAnd why couldn’t the authorities protect you in any other part of Pakistan?Interpreter As I mentioned before they have influence through the police into the government authority. They have a really strong connection by them or wherever I go to start new life they will recognise me and they will recognise me that I belong to this religion and I will be targeted by them.Delegate So who would recognise you? Interpreter Lashkar-e.DelegateSo if they weren’t able to find you in your own home, why would they be able to find you in another city?Interpreter So they are very active organisation and they are active in every city. While they know that I am living in that area for sure, they will find me but when I was inside of my home or when I’m outside of my home here, clearly they know that I’m not in that area.Delegate How would they know that?Interpreter They are very strong organisation and they a lot of people who working with them in this part for them, this intelligence information they are very active.DelegateSo there are some country information reports that support the ability of Shias to relocate within Pakistan to areas such as large cities where there is a mixture of ethnicities and low levels of religious violence. Do you have any comment about those particular reports?Interpreter So the danger or the risk is this, my life is in risk and danger whether I live in a small city or a big city. Because of this life risk I was afraid and flee from the country.DelegateAnd do you have any further comments about why you couldn't live in any other part of Pakistan?Interpreter So every part of Pakistan there is risk, there is life risk for the Shia people. The bomb blasting among ceremony or demonstration on the mosque or ?? that the Shia people going for praying and this sort of risk is everywhere in every corner of Pakistan. And just in the last ? ceremony there was a bomb blasting in the small town called ? inside of the mosque, Shia mosque.The decision of the delegate

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate found, at [126], that it would be reasonable for the appellant to relocate to another city such as Lahore where he would be supported by the Shia community. She found that it would be reasonable for the appellant to relocate as outlined in s 36(2B)(a) of the Migration Act.The Immigration Assessment Authority The appellant’s case was automatically referred to the Immigration Assessment Authority, an independent office within the Migration and Refugee Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The then solicitors for the appellant made a written submission to the Immigration Assessment Authority dated 24 March 2016. The solicitors submitted that sectarian attacks and violence, albeit less serious, still constituted a real chance of persecution for Shias, including the appellant, in Lahore and throughout Pakistan. It was submitted that targeted violence, albeit unreported or underreported, still constituted a real chance of persecution for “low-profile” Shias, including the appellant, in Lahore and throughout Pakistan. The solicitors submitted that the appellant, as a Shia who attended mosques and processions, was at heightened risk of being targeted and killed in Lahore and throughout Pakistan. The solicitors referred to a 2015 decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in relation to a Hazara Shia from Quetta, the decision being that it would not be reasonable for that applicant to relocate because he would be recognised as a Hazara Shia on the basis of his appearance, his language, his accent, his identity documents and that he was likely to reside in a Hazara community. The solicitors submitted that it would not be reasonable for the appellant to relocate because there was no evidence that he would be supported by the Shia community in Lahore or anywhere else in Pakistan. The solicitors submitted that the appellant, with a high school education, was unlikely to get a job in Lahore or anywhere else in Pakistan. The solicitors submitted that the delegate failed to consider the availability of family connections. In response to a DFAT statement that “in practical terms, internal relocation of Shias occurs with relative frequency due to family connections and employment opportunities in [Lahore and Islamabad]”, the solicitors said that the appellant had stated that his parents were dead and he was not in contact with his siblings; his wife’s mother was dead and her father was sick; and he had no real extended family in Pakistan. He had no family connections in Lahore or anywhere else in Pakistan. The solicitors submitted that it would not be reasonable for the appellant to relocate because he had limited funds, education, and work experience, and no family connections in Lahore or anywhere else in Pakistan. Attached to the solicitors’ submission was a statutory declaration of the appellant. He stated that the Department rejected his protection claim, saying that he would not be persecuted on account of his Shia religion throughout Pakistan, and that he could safely, legally, and reasonably relocate to another area of Pakistan, such as Lahore. He stated, amongst other things, that he had never been to Lahore; that Shias were a religious minority in Lahore and throughout Pakistan; Sunni Muslim extremist groups had organised attacks against Shias and other religious minorities in Lahore and throughout Pakistan; if he moved to Lahore or elsewhere in Pakistan, he believed that Sunni Muslim extremist groups would identify him; even if he were able to survive in Lahore or elsewhere in Pakistan it will be very difficult for him to support himself and his family as he did not have enough qualifications to get a good job and he did not have enough money to start another business; he believed that Shias in Lahore and elsewhere in Pakistan were just struggling to survive and support themselves; and if he had believed that he and his family could live in Lahore or elsewhere in Pakistan he would not have come to Australia.