CITATION: BBB Constructions Pty Limited v Catherine J Burn & Ors [2008] NSWSC 356 HEARING DATE(S): 08/04/08, 09/04/08
JUDGMENT DATE :
9 April 2008JUDGMENT OF: Hoeben J DECISION: The plaintiff’s motion of 8 April 2008 is dismissed.
Costs are reserved.
The matter is stood over for final hearing to 10am on Thursday, 10 April 2008.CATCHWORDS: Injunctive relief - developer seeks order restraining entry onto land by police under State Emergency and Rescue Management Act 1989 - developer not acting quickly enough to deal with emergency situation - balance of convenience - pre-eminence of requirement that state instrumentality enter development site to address emergency. LEGISLATION CITED: State Emergency and Rescue Management Act 1989 PARTIES: BBB Constructions Pty Limited - Plaintiff
Catherine J Burn - First Defendant
John Lee - Second Defendant
New South Wales Police Force - Third DefendantFILE NUMBER(S): SC 30036/2008 COUNSEL: Mr N Nicholls - Plaintiff
Mr J Giles - DefendantsSOLICITORS: Colin Biggers & Paisley - Plaintiff
Minter Ellison - Defendants
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST
HOEBEN JWednesday, 9 April 2008
30036/2008 – BBB CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED v Catherine J BURN & Ors
Nature of ProceedingsJUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: The plaintiff is a developer. The first defendant is an Assistant Commissioner in the NSW Police Service. The second defendant is the Director General of the NSW Department of Commerce. The plaintiff by summons seeks a declaration that the direction given by the first defendant purportedly pursuant to s 61(1)(c) of the State Emergency and Rescue Management Act 1989 (SERM Act) dated 4 April 2008 (the direction) to the second defendant is invalid. It also seeks a declaration that the direction was outside the scope of the power contained in s61(1)(c) of the SERM Act. It seeks orders restraining the defendants from implementing the direction.
2 By way of notice of motion the plaintiff seeks orders restraining the defendants until 4pm on 10 April 2008 from entering premises at 64-68 McEvoy Street, Alexandria (also known as 222 Botany Road, Alexandria) (the site) and taking any steps or actions towards the carrying out of any of the works described in the direction. The plaintiff seeks an order that the defendants immediately deliver up possession of the site to the plaintiff.
3 The matter came before me as a matter of urgency as Duty Judge in the Common Law Division. I gave leave for the summons, notice of motion and supporting affidavits to be filed in court.
4 The reason for the urgency in the application emerges from the background facts.
Factual background
5 In October 2007 the plaintiff entered into a contract with Baseline Constructions Pty Limited (Baseline) for Baseline to perform certain work in the construction of a project comprising 128 residential units and associated car-parking, commercial and retail space at the site. As part of the project secant walls were constructed along the boundary of the site. Following construction of the perimeter secant walls…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BBB Constructions Pty Limited v Catherine J Burn & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWSC 356
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court had to determine included the appropriate balance of convenience in granting the injunction and whether the requirement for the state to address the emergency situation took precedence over the developer's rights. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and the common law principles regarding the issuance of injunctions in emergency situations. The court also weighed the rights of the developer against the public interest in addressing the emergency.
The court held that the balance of convenience favoured allowing the police to enter the site to address the emergency situation. The court found that the requirement for the state to enter the development site to address the emergency was of greater importance than the developer's rights. The court emphasised the pre-eminence of the public interest in ensuring that emergency situations are addressed promptly and effectively. The court therefore refused to grant the injunction sought by the applicant. The court considered that it was in the public interest for the police to be able to enter the site to address the emergency, and that this outweighed the developer's rights to prevent the police from entering the site. The court did not grant the injunction sought by the applicant, and the police were allowed to enter the site to address the emergency.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was brought before the court by way of an application for an interlocutory injunction. This application was filed by BBB Constructions Pty Limited, seeking to restrain the police from entering the construction site to conduct an emergency rescue operation. The case had not proceeded to a final hearing, and the focus was on the preliminary issue of whether an injunction should be granted to prevent the police from entering the site to address the emergency situation. The court considered the urgency and the balance of convenience in determining the application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should grant an injunction to restrain the police from entering the land to conduct an emergency rescue operation.
2. What is the balance of convenience between the developer's right to exclude entry onto their property and the requirement for state instrumentality to enter the site to address the emergency.
Held
1. The court held that it would not grant an injunction to restrain the police from entering the land to conduct an emergency rescue operation under the State Emergency and Rescue Management Act 1989.
2. The court found that the balance of convenience favoured the requirement for the state instrumentality to enter the development site to address the emergency, over the developer's right to exclude entry onto their property.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the statutory framework of the State Emergency and Rescue Management Act 1989, which provides for the entry of state instrumentalities onto private property to address emergencies. The court noted that the Act's purpose was to protect human life and safety, and that this objective outweighed private property rights in emergency situations. In this case, the developer had not acted quickly enough to deal with the emergency situation, which justified the police's entry onto the property to address the emergency. The court considered the balance of convenience, which favoured the state's ability to enter the site to address the emergency, over the developer's right to exclude entry onto their property. The court held that the developer's right to exclude entry was not absolute and could be overridden in circumstances where an emergency required immediate action to protect human life and safety. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the requirement for state instrumentalities to enter private property to address emergencies takes precedence over the developer's right to exclude entry, when balancing the competing interests. The court followed the principle established in earlier cases that the protection of human life and safety is a paramount consideration in emergency situations.