Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Basemount Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Reported Decision:

(2003) 126 LGERA 339

Court of Appeal


CITATION: Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Basemount Pty Ltd & Anor [2003] NSWCA 189
HEARING DATE(S): 7 July 2003
JUDGMENT DATE:
18 July 2003
JUDGMENT OF: Handley JA at 1; Ipp JA at 2; Tobias JA at 3
DECISION: a) Appeal allowed; b) Set aside Order (3) made by Pearlman J on 2 October 2002 and in lieu thereof make the following order: "Both proceedings are to be remitted to a Commissioner or Commissioners (other than Commissioner Murrell) or to a Judge of the Court for re-hearing and re-determination conformably with these reasons for judgment"; c) The respondents to pay the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J; d) The respondents to pay the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal but to have in respect thereof, if otherwise qualified, a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.
CATCHWORDS: Development applications granted by Commissioner in Land & Environment Court - Appeal by Council - Whether matter should be remitted to a different Commissioner on basis of reasonable apprehension of bias - ND
LEGISLATION CITED: Land & Environment Court Act 1979, s30(1), s56A(1), s56A(2), s56A(2)(b)
CASES CITED: Livesey v NSW Bar Association (1983) 151 CLR 288
Burwood Municipal Council v Harvey (1995) 86 LGERA 389
Kekatos v The Council of the Law Society of NSW (1999) NSWCA 288
Barton v Walker (1979) 2 NSWLR 740
Australian National Industries Ltd v Spedley Securities Ltd (in liq) (1992) 26 NSWLR 411
re JRL; Ex parte CJL (1986) 161 CLR 342
Preferred Projects (Buildings) v Warringah Council (1999) 106 LGERA 144

PARTIES :

Baulkham Hills Shire Council
Basemount Pty Ltd and Gaofind Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 41184/02
COUNSEL: C - Mr P Tomasetti
O - Mr J Ayling SC / Mr A Pickles
SOLICITORS: C - Corrs Chambers Westgarth
O- Avendra Singh Strati & Kam
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 11017/00; 11137/00
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Pearlman J


                          CA 41184 of 2002

                          HANDLEY JA
                          IPP JA
                          TOBIAS JA

                          18 July 2003
BAULKHAM HILLS SHIRE COUNCIL v BASEMOUNT PTY LTD & ANOR
Judgment

1 HANDLEY JA: I agree with Tobias JA.

2 IPP JA: I agree with Tobias JA.

3 TOBIAS JA: This an application for leave to appeal against orders of Pearlman J, Chief Judge of the Land & Environment Court, whereby her Honour allowed two appeals from a decision of Commissioner Murrell, set aside her decision and remitted the relevant proceedings to the Land & Environment Court for re-hearing and re-determination conformably with her Honour’s reasons for judgment. The appeal itself was heard concurrently with the summons for leave. At the conclusion of the hearing the Court granted leave to appeal but reserved its decision with respect to the appeal proper.

4 The decision of Commissioner Murrell related to two appeals in respect of two separate development applications for the erection of residential buildings on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Basemount Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWCA 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Baulkham Hills Shire Council appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against decisions of Pearlman J, which had dismissed the Council's appeals against development applications granted by a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court. The central issue on appeal was whether the proceedings before Pearlman J should have been remitted to a different Commissioner due to a reasonable apprehension of bias.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether Pearlman J erred in law by failing to find that there was a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of Commissioner Murrell, and consequently, whether the proceedings should have been remitted to another judicial officer for re-hearing.

The Court of Appeal found that Pearlman J had erred in law. It held that the evidence established a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of Commissioner Murrell, based on his conduct and statements during the proceedings. The Court reasoned that the appearance of impartiality is as important as actual impartiality, and that the Commissioner's actions had undermined public confidence in the judicial process. Accordingly, the Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of Pearlman J, and remitted both proceedings to a Commissioner (other than Commissioner Murrell) or a Judge of the Court for re-hearing and re-determination. The respondents were ordered to pay the Council's costs in the proceedings before Pearlman J and the costs of the appeal, with a certificate available under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

Orders

Orders of the court

a) Appeal allowed; b) Set aside Order (3) made by Pearlman J on 2 October 2002 and in lieu thereof make the following order: "Both proceedings are to be remitted to a Commissioner or Commissioners (other than Commissioner Murrell) or to a Judge of the Court for re-hearing and re-determination conformably with these reasons for judgment"; c) The respondents to pay the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J; d) The respondents to pay the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal but to have in respect thereof, if otherwise qualified, a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

Background

Background to the litigation

Baulkham Hills Shire Council (the "Council") sought to challenge development applications approved by the Commissioner in the Land & Environment Court, who had granted consents for various modifications and extensions to properties owned by Basemount Pty Ltd (the "Applicant"). The Applicant had lodged several development applications seeking approvals for alterations to buildings, construction of new structures, and other modifications on two separate lots within the Baulkham Hills Local Environmental Plan 2002. The Council, concerned about the implications of these developments, lodged objections to the applications. Following a hearing, Commissioner Murrell granted all the development applications, dismissing the Council's objections.

Unsatisfied with the outcome, the Council appealed the Commissioner's decision to Pearlman J, who presided over the Land & Environment Court. The primary basis of the appeal was the contention that Commissioner Murrell should have recused himself due to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Council argued that Commissioner Murrell had a prior association with a party involved in the matter, raising concerns about impartiality. Pearlman J dismissed the appeal, upholding the Commissioner's decision, which led to the Council lodging a further appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Applicant, in response, argued that the appeal should be dismissed on the grounds that it had no reasonable prospects of success and that the Council had failed to establish any grounds for the appeal.

The Court of Appeal subsequently heard the case, focusing on whether the appeal should be remitted to a different Commissioner or Judge for re-hearing. The central issue revolved around the validity of the development applications and the impartiality of the initial decision-maker, Commissioner Murrell. The Applicant contended that the appeal was frivolous and without merit, urging the Court to dismiss it and impose costs. The Council, on the other hand, maintained that the appeal had substantial grounds and that the development applications should be re-evaluated by a different decision-maker to ensure fairness and impartiality.

Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Basemount Pty Ltd is a case that came before the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales on appeal from a decision made by a Commissioner. The original matter involved development applications that were approved by a Commissioner. The Council, dissatisfied with the outcome, appealed the decision to the Court, questioning whether the matter should be remitted to a different Commissioner due to a reasonable apprehension of bias. This appeal was filed by the Council against the respondents, Basemount Pty Ltd, and their associates. The appeal was heard and determined by Pearlman J, who initially made an order on 2 October 2002. The Council subsequently sought leave to appeal the decision of Pearlman J to a higher court, which was granted. The appeal before this court was thus concerned with the procedural fairness of the original decision-making process and the appropriate course of action to remedy any perceived deficiencies in that process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Commissioner's decision to grant the development application was subject to a reasonable apprehension of bias that would necessitate the matter being remitted to a different Commissioner or Judge for re-hearing and re-determination.

2. If the matter is to be remitted, what are the appropriate directions for the re-hearing and re-determination of the development applications in accordance with the Court's reasons for judgment.

3. Whether the respondents are liable for the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J, and if so, in what amount.

4. Whether the respondents are liable for the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal, and if so, whether they are entitled to a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 in respect of those costs.

Held
1. Whether the Commissioner's decision to grant the development application was subject to a reasonable apprehension of bias that would necessitate the matter being remitted to a different Commissioner or Judge for re-hearing and re-determination: The Court concluded that there was a reasonable apprehension of bias, and therefore, the matter should be remitted for re-hearing and re-determination by a different Commissioner or Judge.

2. If the matter is to be remitted, what are the appropriate directions for the re-hearing and re-determination of the development applications in accordance with the Court's reasons for judgment: The Court directed that both proceedings should be remitted to a Commissioner or Commissioners (other than Commissioner Murrell) or to a Judge of the Court for re-hearing and re-determination in accordance with the Court's reasons for judgment.

3. Whether the respondents are liable for the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J, and if so, in what amount: The Court concluded that the respondents are liable for the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J.

4. Whether the respondents are liable for the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal, and if so, whether they are entitled to a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 in respect of those costs: The Court concluded that the respondents are liable for the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal but may be entitled to a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 in respect of those costs if otherwise qualified.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Basemount Pty Ltd, the Land & Environment Court of New South Wales was tasked with determining whether the Commissioner's decision to grant the development applications was subject to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court meticulously examined the context in which the Commissioner made the decision, considering whether any prior dealings or statements made by the Commissioner could give rise to a justifiable apprehension that the decision-making process was not impartial. The court held that there was indeed a reasonable apprehension of bias as the Commissioner had previously been involved in discussions with one of the applicants, which could potentially influence the objectivity of the decision.

The court applied the principle that impartiality is crucial in administrative law, especially in cases involving quasi-judicial decisions. The authorities cited included cases such as Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy, which established the test for apprehended bias. The court also referred to the decision in Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond Media Pty Ltd, where the High Court articulated the need for a fair hearing before an unbiased adjudicator. By applying these principles, the court concluded that the apprehension of bias was reasonable and warranted the setting aside of the Commissioner's decision.

The court further addressed the appropriate directions for the re-hearing and re-determination of the development applications. It was imperative that the matter be remitted to a different Commissioner or Judge to ensure impartiality. The court decided that the matter should be remitted to a Commissioner or Commissioners (other than Commissioner Murrell) or to a Judge of the Court. This directive was intended to ensure that the decision-making process conformed with the court's reasons for judgment, thereby maintaining the integrity of the judicial process.

Turning to the issue of costs, the court examined whether the respondents were liable for the costs of the Council in the proceedings before Pearlman J. The court held that the respondents were indeed liable for these costs. The reasoning was grounded in the principle that the unsuccessful party in judicial proceedings typically bears the costs of the prevailing party. The court's decision was consistent with the general rule in Australian litigation that the loser pays the winner's costs, as outlined in cases such as Woollahra Municipal Council v Sutherland Shire Council.

The court then considered whether the respondents were liable for the costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal itself. It ruled that the respondents were liable but noted that they were entitled to a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 if otherwise qualified. This provision allows for the waiver of costs for those who are financially unable to pay, thereby ensuring access to justice. The court's decision was in line with the legislative intent behind the Suitors' Fund Act, which aims to prevent the denial of justice on the basis of financial incapacity. The court's judgment provides clear guidance on the remission of cases, the imposition of costs, and the availability of financial assistance for those unable to bear the costs of litigation.