Batros and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

Batros and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2017] AATA 399 (28 March 2017)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/1384

Re:Ryan Batros

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President

Date:28 March 2017

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

...................................[sgd].....................................

Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

CORPORATIONS – banning order – inside information – placing sell orders – crossed wall – execution only broker – whether mere cypher – severity banning order – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 41(2)

Australian Securities and Investments Act 2001 (Cth) s 1(2)(b)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 920A, 1042A, 1042C, 1043A, 1043K

CASES

Hartman v Director of Public Prosecutions [2011] NSWCCA 261; (2011) 87 ACSR 52

Re Batros and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 519
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Felden and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] AATA 301; (2003) 45 ACSR 111
Re Gray and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 86 ALD 230; [2004] AATA 1235
Re Hayes and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2006] AATA 1506; (2006) 93 ALD 494
Re Howarth and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2008] AATA 278; (2008) 101 ALD 602
Re Sullivan and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] AATA 592

R v Farris (2015) 301 FLR 230

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Regulatory Guide 98 – Licensing: Administrative action against financial services providers

REASONS FOR DECISION

Professor R Deutsch, Deputy President

28 March 2017

THE PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

  1. On 6 November 2015, ASIC (the Respondent) served a notice dated 2 November 2015 on Mr Ryan Batros (the Applicant) pursuant to s 920A of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) stating that ASIC was concerned that he may not have complied with a financial services law (the s 920A notice).

  2. On 16 December 2015, the Applicant attended a hearing before the Respondent’s   delegate with his solicitor. At the conclusion of the hearing, the delegate reserved her decision and stated that the Applicant should provide any further information on which he wanted to rely by early February 2016.

  3. On 8 March 2016, a delegate of the Respondent made a banning order under s 920A(1) of the Corporations Act prohibiting the Applicant from providing any financial services for a period of five years (the delegate’s decision).

  4. The Respondent emailed the delegate’s decision and the banning order to the Applicant’s lawyer on 11 March 2016, and personally served these documents on the Applicant on 16 March 2016.

  5. On 17 March 2016, the Applicant filed an application for review of the delegate’s decision (the review application) with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal).

  6. On the same day, the Applicant filed an application pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) seeking an order that the delegate’s decision be stayed pending the final hearing and determination of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Batros and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to issue a five-year banning order against the Applicant. The dispute concerned the Applicant's conduct as an authorised representative of Morgans Financial Limited, specifically his involvement in placing sell orders for Metals of Africa Limited securities between 25 and 28 August 2014, after being warned that he was "over the wall" and should cease transacting in those securities.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Applicant's actions constituted a failure to comply with financial services law, particularly in relation to insider trading prohibitions, and whether the five-year banning order was an appropriate consequence. The legal issues included the interpretation of "over the wall" warnings, the Applicant's responsibilities as an "execution only" broker in light of such warnings, and the factors relevant to the severity of a banning order, such as conduct inconsistent with orderly financial markets and disregard for the law.

The Tribunal reasoned that the warning from Mr Polinelli was unambiguous and clearly instructed the Applicant to cease transacting in Metals of Africa securities. Despite this clear directive, and even after acknowledging he was "over the wall" by signing a Wall Crossing Form, the Applicant continued to place and delete orders. The Tribunal found this conduct demonstrated either a misunderstanding or a deliberate disregard for the law, concluding that the Applicant could not reasonably claim ignorance of his obligations, even as an execution-only broker. The Tribunal considered the Applicant's reliance on his branch manager's perceived uncertainty but found it outweighed by Mr Polinelli's direct and clear communication.

The Tribunal affirmed ASIC's decision, issuing a banning order prohibiting the Applicant from providing any financial services for a period of five years. This decision was made pursuant to section 920A(1) of the Corporations Act, reflecting the Applicant's non-compliance with financial services law and the need to maintain confidence in the integrity of financial markets.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Table 2 provides examples of conduct and indicates the potential consequences that might follow from engaging in that conduct. Table 2 provides that insider trading is an example of conduct that may justify a banning order of anywhere between 3 and 10 years, and refers to the following factors relevant to the making of a banning order for that period of time:(a)conduct inconsistent with orderly operation of a financial market;(b)adverse impact on confidence in or the integrity of a financial market; and(c)disregard for the law and compliance with regulations.RELEVANT FACTUAL BACKGROUND Between 17 January 2012 and 29 August 2014, the Applicant was an authorised representative of Morgans Financial Limited (Morgans). In the period from 1 June 2013 to 29 August 2014, the Applicant worked as a private client advisor at the Morgans’ branch which was and is generally referred to as “Farrer House – Melbourne”. It is accepted that the Applicant's clients were almost all sophisticated investors and that the Applicant acted on an “execution only” basis. Amongst the Applicant's clients were:·Justin Klintberg;·Shayne Batros ;·Alice Andrews; and·Patricia Batros. Shayne Batros is the Applicant’s father, Patricia Batros is the Applicant’s mother, and Ms Andrews is the Applicant’s mother-in-law. The trading of relevance took place between 25 and 28 August 2014 in relation to listed securities in a company known as Metals of Africa Limited (Metals of Africa). Metals of Africa is an Australian public company based in Perth whose ordinary shares and company options (referred to as MTA and MTAO respectively) are listed and able to be traded on the Australian Securities Exchange (the ASX). By 2013, the Applicant had developed a relationship with two individuals connected with Metals of Africa namely Mr Brett Smith, a non-executive director of Metals of Africa and Ms Cherie Leeden, the managing director of Metals of Africa. The Applicant had regular meetings with Mr Smith and Ms Leeden from 2013. On or about 27 July 2014, the Applicant contacted Mr John Polinelli, a director of Morgans' corporate advisory division in Perth, in relation to setting up a face-to-face meeting between representatives of the Morgans’ corporate advisory division, Mr Smith, and Ms Leeden. On 28 July 2014, Mr Polinelli, Mr James Wilson (also of Morgans), and a corporate analyst employed by Morgans met with Mr Smith and Ms Leeden at Morgans’ office in West Perth. On 31 July 2014, Mr Polinelli sent Ms Leeden an email relevantly stating that Morgans believed it could assist Metals of Africa to raise between $3-5 million dollars in the very near future (the 31 July Polinelli email): T Documents, T6. According to a witness statement of Mr Polinelli dated 26 May 2015 (paragraphs 24 and 25) Ms Leeden did not initially receive the 31 July Polinelli email. On 21 August 2014, Metals of Africa requested a trading halt pending the release of an announcement to the market. This trading halt was announced before the market opened on 21 August, and there was no trading in MTA and MTAO on 21 and 22 August 2014: ASX Release T9.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 8 March 2016, a delegate of the Respondent made a banning order under s 920A(1) of the Corporations Act prohibiting the Applicant from providing any financial services for a period of five years (the delegate’s decision). The Respondent emailed the delegate’s decision and the banning order to the Applicant’s lawyer on 11 March 2016, and personally served these documents on the Applicant on 16 March 2016. On 17 March 2016, the Applicant filed an application for review of the delegate’s decision (the review application) with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). On the same day, the Applicant filed an application pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) seeking an order that the delegate’s decision be stayed pending the final hearing and determination of the review application (the stay application). The hearing of the stay application took place before Deputy President Cowdroy OAM QC on 26 May 2016. On 22 July 2016, the stay application was refused and reasons for decision were published: see Re Batros and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 519.THE LEGISLATION AND THE POLICY In performing its functions and exercising its powers, the Respondent must strive to “promote the confident and informed participation of investors and consumers in the financial system”: see s 1(2)(b) of the Australian Securities and Investments Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act). This objective is also fundamental to the Tribunal’s exercise of its review powers, in which it “stands in the shoes” of the primary decision-maker. The exercise of the Respondent’s powers under the ASIC Act has at all relevant times been the subject of policy guidelines. Given the matters the subject of the review application “Regulatory Guide 98 – Licensing: Administrative action against financial services providers” (RG 98) is of particular relevance. The Respondent, and the Tribunal standing in its shoes, are entitled to and should have regard to RG 98: see, eg, Re Gray and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 86 ALD 230; [2004] AATA 1235, Fisher M at [32]-[36]. Unless there are cogent reasons for not doing so in the particular circumstances of a given case, the Respondent and the Tribunal should implement policy, such as RG 98: Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634. The relevant legislation begins at section 920A(1)(e) of the Corporations Act which provides that ASIC may make a banning order against a person if that person has not complied with a financial services law. Division 3 of Part 7.10 of the Corporations Act sets out the insider trading prohibitions. Section 1042A of the Corporations Act provides the following relevant definitions:generally available, in relation to information, has the meaning given by section 1042C.information includes:(a)matters of supposition and other matters that are insufficiently definite to warrant being made known to the public; and(b)matters relating to the intentions, or likely intentions, of a person.inside information means information in relation to which the following paragraphs are satisfied:(a)the information is not generally available;(b)if the information were generally available, a reasonable person would expect it to have a material effect on the price or value of particular Division 3 financial products.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent contends that the Tribunal should affirm the decision under review to make a banning order prohibiting the applicant from providing financial services for the period of five years.THE TRIBUNAL’S CONSIDERATION In reviewing the facts, it seems to this Tribunal that it is a key point that at 10:19am on 25 August 2014, the Applicant had a discussion with Mr Polinelli in which Mr Polinelli told the Applicant in no uncertain terms that he was over the wall in relation to Metals of Africa. To repeat the essence of that conversation Mr Polinelli said to the Applicant: “Mate what the hell are you doing. You are on the screen. You’re over the wall.” Now this language was hardly ambiguous or vague and could only be interpreted one way which was that the Applicant in the circumstances that applied at that very moment should not be on the screen. In other words, he should not have any orders placed under his name (even on an execution only basis) on the screen in relation to any securities relating to Metals of Africa. How this somewhat unsophisticated, blunt, direct and concise message conveyed by Mr Polinelli in very clear language could be construed in any way other than to say – stop transacting in securities relating to Metals of Africa – is difficult to fathom. To suggest that the Applicant was still in the dark as to what he should be doing as an execution only broker is absurd and in my view defies logic. Yet even in the context of that clear message, on the same day (namely on 25 August 2014) the Applicant entered the following sell orders:·One hour later at 11:18am, two sell orders for MTA for Justin Klintberg;·Two and a half hours later at 1:26pm, two sell orders for MTA for Alice Andrews; and ·Five and a half hours later at 3:36pm, two sell orders for MTA for Shayne Batros. The next day, 26 August 2014 at 10:14am and at 10:43am he entered into further sell orders in respect of MTA for Justin Klintberg and Patricia Batros. Then at 10:48am on the same day, the Applicant signed the Wall Crossing Form acknowledging he was “over the wall” from 9:46am on 22 August 2014 and returned it to Mr Polinelli. Yet still he not desist from further activity in Metals of Africa securities. Some three and a half hours later on that day he sold MTAO for Patricia Batros. Finally, of relevance is also the fact that he has deleted a number of buy orders at various stages after Mr Polinelli’s comments were conveyed to him. In the view of this Tribunal, the Applicant’s conduct in continuing to, in particular, place but also to delete orders after he had received such a direct message from Mr Polinelli and then, a fortiori, after he had returned the Wall Crossing Form demonstrates either that the Applicant misunderstands the very clear requirements of the Corporations Act or that he has chosen to ignore the law for whatever reason. The Applicant relies on the evidence of a witness, Carol Corbey, the Applicant’s branch manager at Morgans, who gave evidence at the hearing. Her evidence indicated that she had requested advice from a compliance officer at Morgans as to how the Applicant should deal with execution only orders. No response was received until late in August 2014 after all trading had ceased. Ms Corbey presented as a straight-talking down to earth manager and I do not doubt the veracity of her evidence. However, that evidence must be taken into account in the context of the communications to the Applicant by Mr Polinelli who was clearly not in any doubt about the Applicant’s position even as an execution only broker. While there may have been some doubt in the mind of Ms Corbey, there was no doubt in the mind of Mr Polinelli and the Applicant clearly chose for whatever reason to ignore the latter.