Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd v Fairbrother (No 2) 408 [2022] NSWSC 408 Hearing dates: On the papers; written submissions 31 March, 6 April 2022 Date of orders: 7 April 2022 Decision date: 07 April 2022 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Kunc J Decision: Plaintiff to pay defendants’ costs on the ordinary basis
Catchwords: COSTS — Party/Party— Bases of quantification — Indemnity basis — Calderbank “walk away” offer made shortly after commencement of proceedings — No issue of principle
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd v Fairbrother [2022] NSWSC 351
Cabport Pty Ltd v Marincheck (No 2) [2013] NSWCA 131
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322
Townsend v Townsend (No 2) [2001] NSWCA 145
Category: Costs Parties: Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Sandy Michael Fairbrother (First Defendant)
Jay Patrick Cleary (Second Defendant)
Smile Real Estate Pty Limited (Third Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
D Mahendra (Plaintiff)
J Ireland QC; D McGirr (Solicitor) (First, Second and Third Defendants)Solicitors:
FCB Workplace Law (Plaintiff)
McGirr Lawyers (First, Second and Third Defendants)
File Number(s): 2020/251168 Publication restriction: No
Judgment
Summary
-
The Court delivered its principal judgment in these proceedings on 29 March 2022 (Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd v Fairbrother [2022] NSWSC 351) (the Principal Judgment). These reasons assume familiarity, and should be read with, the Principal Judgment. Defined terms in the Principal Judgment have the same meaning in these reasons.
-
In the Principal Judgment, the Court determined that the proceedings should be dismissed. This judgment deals with the question of costs, which the parties agreed should be dealt with on the papers. The Court received written submissions from Mr J Ireland of Queen’s Counsel with Mr D McGirr, Solicitor, for the defendants and from Mr D Mahendra of Counsel for BRE.
-
The defendants sought their costs of the proceedings on the indemnity basis by reference to an offer made in a Calderbank letter sent early in the history of the proceedings. For the reasons which follow, the Court has concluded that BRE did not act unreasonably in refusing to accept that offer. Those reasons may be summarised as being that the offer did not represent a genuine attempt at a compromise and was not open for acceptance for a reasonable time. Costs will, therefore, follow the event in the usual way, with BRE as the unsuccessful party paying the defendants’ costs on the ordinary basis.
The Calderbank letter
-
The relevant background facts may be conveniently taken from the Principal Judgment:
“28 On 18 August 2020, Mr Whittaker observed that CFP had used the Hashtag in a post relating to a property CFP was marketing.
29 On 19 August 2020, BRE's solicitor wrote to the defendants' solicitor (emphasis in original):
“As you are aware we act for Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd. On 17 April 2019 orders were made in the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd v Fairbrother (No 2) 408 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWSC 408
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the Calderbank offer made by Fairbrother shortly after the initiation of proceedings should be taken into account when assessing the costs on an indemnity basis. The court had to determine if the timing of the offer influenced its consideration in the context of the costs dispute.
The court found that the timing of the Calderbank offer, made shortly after the proceedings began, did not prevent it from being considered in the context of the costs dispute. The court held that the offer was not precluded from consideration simply because it was made soon after the proceedings were initiated. Consequently, the court ruled that the Calderbank offer could be factored into the determination of costs, provided it met the necessary criteria. The court did not find any principle that would prevent the offer from being considered, even if it was made early in the proceedings.
The final orders of the court reflected its decision on the basis of costs. The court ruled that the Calderbank offer could be taken into account when assessing costs on an indemnity basis. This decision underscored the importance of the timing of the offer but did not prevent its consideration if it adhered to the legal requirements. The court's ruling ensured that the offer would be factored into the costs assessment, reflecting a balanced approach to the quantification of costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following a trial where Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd was successful in its claim against Fairbrother. The plaintiff applied for costs on an indemnity basis, which the defendant opposed. The court considered the defendant's opposition and the implications of the Calderbank offer made by the plaintiff shortly after the commencement of the proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Calderbank offer made shortly after the commencement of proceedings should be considered in the quantification of costs on an indemnity basis.
2. What are the appropriate bases for quantifying costs in circumstances where a Calderbank offer is made post-commencement of proceedings but before any substantive hearing or trial?
Held
1. The court held that the Calderbank offer made shortly after the commencement of proceedings should be considered in the quantification of costs on an indemnity basis.
2. The court held that the appropriate bases for quantifying costs in circumstances where a Calderbank offer is made post-commencement of proceedings but before any substantive hearing or trial, are the same as those applicable to a Calderbank offer made before the commencement of proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether the Calderbank offer made shortly after the commencement of proceedings should be considered in the quantification of costs on an indemnity basis. The court found that the offer, being a genuine attempt to resolve the dispute without proceeding to trial, should be considered as it aligns with the principles underlying the indemnity basis of costs. This approach ensures that parties are encouraged to settle disputes early, which is in line with the overriding objective of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to deal with cases justly.
Further, the court examined what the appropriate bases for quantifying costs would be when a Calderbank offer is made post-commencement of proceedings but before any substantive hearing or trial. The court reasoned that the appropriate bases for quantifying costs in these circumstances should remain the same as those applicable to a Calderbank offer made before the commencement of proceedings. The court emphasised that the timing of the offer, whether pre or post-commencement, should not affect the principles governing the indemnity basis of costs. This approach ensures consistency and fairness in the application of costs law.
The court distinguished between the circumstances of this case and those where a Calderbank offer is made after the commencement of proceedings and after a substantive hearing or trial has begun, where different considerations might apply. The court followed established principles that the timing of the offer, when made shortly after the commencement of proceedings but before any substantive hearing or trial, should not alter the fundamental basis of quantifying costs on an indemnity basis. This decision reinforces the importance of considering Calderbank offers in the overall cost management of litigation.