Barthel and Australian National University (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Barthel and Australian National University (Compensation) [2019] AATA 769 (30 April 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2584

Re:Nadine Barthel

APPLICANT

AndAustralian National University

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member

Date:30 April 2019

Place:Canberra

The decision under review is set aside. As of 11 February 2016 to the date of this decision, subject to claim, Ms Barthel is entitled to compensation under s 16 and s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) in respect of her accepted injury.

........................................................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

COMPENSATION – accepted injury – carpal tunnel syndrome – file review - decision to deny present liability in respect of incapacity for work and medical treatment expenses without determining specific claim – weight to be given to neutral evaluation report – implied issues of credit - doctor shopping not made out – consideration of effects of ‘injury’ - carpal tunnel syndrome resolved with surgery – persistence of symptoms during post-surgical recovery – extent of liability – ‘disease’ and ‘injury (other than a disease)’ not exclusive – expert evidence – effects of ‘injury’ continuing – denial of present liability not consistent with evidence – liability persists - no unmet claim for compensation for incapacity for work or medical treatment expenses – entitlement to be assessed on the merits of claims made – decision set aside

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 5A, 5B, 7, 14, 16, 19, 37

Cases

Abrahams v Comcare [2006] FCA 1829
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143
Sellick v Australian Postal Corporation [2009] FCAFC 146
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

April 2019

  1. Nadine Barthel developed carpal tunnel syndrome performing repetitive duties involving pipettes when employed as a research technician by the Australian National University (the University). She claimed and was paid compensation by Comcare, including for surgical treatment. Subsequently, Comcare decided that it had no present liability to pay compensation for incapacity for work and medical treatment expenses as Ms Barthel no longer suffered the effects of injury. This decision was affirmed on reconsideration. Ms Barthel applied for review by the Tribunal. She maintains that she experiences continuing symptoms and liability in respect of her injury has not come to an end.

  2. The respondent in the proceedings is presently the University, having assumed direct responsibility from Comcare.

    RELEVANT FACTS

  3. The relevant facts arising from the materials follow.

  4. On 30 June 2014, Dr Harcourt, a general practitioner, diagnosed bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome, noting numbness in the thumb, index and middle fingers and a positive phalens test on the left.[1]

    [1] T7.

  5. On 1 July 2014, Ms Barthel completed an Incident Report recording that she suffered carpal tunnel syndrome on 30 April 2014 as a result of repetitive pipetting in the course of employment.[2]

    [2] T8.

  6. On 24 July 2014, Ms Barthel lodged a claim for compensation in respect of bilateral carpal tunnel…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barthel and Australian National University (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 769
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms Barthel against a decision by Comcare (now represented by the Australian National University) to deny her compensation for medical treatment expenses and incapacity for work. Ms Barthel had lodged a claim for compensation for bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome, which was accepted by Comcare as an employment-related injury with a deemed date of injury of 30 June 2014. Following surgery in Germany and subsequent medical assessments, Comcare determined that Ms Barthel had no present entitlement to compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth).

The primary legal issues before the Member were whether Ms Barthel was entitled to compensation for medical treatment expenses and incapacity for work from 11 February 2016 onwards, and whether her departure from Australia impacted these entitlements. The University argued that Ms Barthel's removal from Australia in December 2014 hindered its ability to engage in rehabilitation and control her return to work.

The Member reasoned that while difficulties with rehabilitation might affect an employee's entitlements at certain times, this did not negate the threshold issue of liability. The Member further held that the University had the opportunity to engage Ms Barthel in rehabilitation, and that an employee's obligation to comply with a rehabilitation program does not cease simply because they are outside Australia. The Member concluded that Ms Barthel's departure from Australia did not invalidate her rehabilitation obligations.

The decision under review was set aside. The Member ordered that, subject to claim, Ms Barthel was entitled to compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the Act in respect of her accepted injury from 11 February 2016 to the date of the decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent in the proceedings is presently the University, having assumed direct responsibility from Comcare. RELEVANT FACTS The relevant facts arising from the materials follow. On 30 June 2014, Dr Harcourt, a general practitioner, diagnosed bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome, noting numbness in the thumb, index and middle fingers and a positive phalens test on the left.[1][1] T7. On 1 July 2014, Ms Barthel completed an Incident Report recording that she suffered carpal tunnel syndrome on 30 April 2014 as a result of repetitive pipetting in the course of employment.[2][2] T8. On 24 July 2014, Ms Barthel lodged a claim for compensation in respect of bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome.[3][3] T12. On 2 October 2014, Dr Andrews (a neurologist) conducted nerve conduction tests and, on 3 October 2014, reported carpal tunnel syndrome, mild on the left and moderate on the right.[4][4] T24. On 10 October 2014, Comcare accepted liability for Ms Barthel’s carpal tunnel syndrome as an employment-related injury under s 14 of the SRC Act, with a deemed date of injury of 30 June 2014.[5][5] T2. In November 2014, Ms Barthel returned to Germany, where she consulted Dr Junger (a general practitioner) about her bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome. Dr Junger referred her to Dr Mitzscherling (an orthopaedic and hand surgeon). On 8 December 2014, Ms Barthel’s employment contract with the University came to an end. Dr Mitzscherling carried out carpal tunnel syndrome release surgery on the left median nerve in January 2015 and on her right median nerve on 4 March 2015. On 16 March 2015, Dr Mitzscherling reported that the healing process was “uncomplicated”.[6][6] T164. Ms Barthel was referred for physiotherapy. She says she continued to experience symptoms in her wrists and reduced function in her hands, especially with weight bearing, hand writing and similar activities. On 21 January 2016, Ms Barthel again consulted Dr Mitzscherling, who subsequently reported that –Her complaint was unspecific pain in her left hand. This was diagnosed as a persistent pain after she has had Surgery in my clinic due to carpal tunnel syndrome in March 2015.She was referred for neurological evaluation. After this appointment she did not present herself in my clinic again.[7] [7] Report of Dr Mitzscherling, 8 September 2016. On 10 February 2016, Dr Lutze (a neurosurgeon) examined Ms Barthel and noted bilateral wrist pain but not sensory deficit in her hands or fingers. He issued a medical certificate and arranged further nerve conduction testing. On 11 February 2016, Comcare determined that Ms Barthel had no present entitlement to compensation for medical treatment expenses under s 16 of the SRC Act and incapacity for work under s 19.[8] [8] T187. Ms Barthel requested reconsideration of this decision. On 9 March 2016, Comcare affirmed its determination in a reconsideration decision.[9][9] T198. On 15 March 2016, Dr Horaczek (a neurologist) conducted nerve conduction studies and reported –“Die neurographischen Befunde sprechen fur ein diskretes Carpaltunnelsyndrom rechts und ein leichtes Carpaltunnelsyndrom links”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The University argued that Ms Barthel removed herself from Australia in or about December 2014 and, in so doing, she denied the University opportunity to engage in rehabilitation and exert some control over her return to work in suitable employment. There are two things to say about this submission. Firstly, difficulties with rehabilitation may bear upon an injured employee’s entitlements to compensation from time to time, but this is unlikely to go to threshold issues of liability. Secondly, if the University wanted to engage Ms Barthel in rehabilitation, it was open for it to do so. While it may be accepted that rehabilitation may be more difficult if the injured employee is outside Australia, it does not follow that rehabilitation obligations must be dispensed with in those circumstances. If a rehabilitation authority determines a rehabilitation program for an injured employee, the employee is obliged to comply whether they are in Australia or not – rehabilitation is not void simply because the employee leaves Australia.Decision The decision under review is set aside. As of 11 February 2016 to the date of this decision, subject to claim, Ms Barthel is entitled to compensation under s 16 and s 19 of the Act in respect of her accepted injury.I certify that the preceding 53 (fifty-three) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Member Simon Webb.……………………………………………………AssociateDated: 30 April 2019Date of Hearing: 4 April 2019Applicant: Self-RepresentedCounsel for the Respondent: Ms Kristy KatavicSolicitor for the Respondent: McInnes Wilson Lawyers

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Barthel and Australian National University (Compensation), the primary issue before the court was whether the respondent, Australian National University (ANU), had a duty to engage in rehabilitation with the applicant, Ms Barthel, after her injury was accepted as an employment-related injury. The court held that if ANU wished to engage in rehabilitation with Ms Barthel, it was open to them to do so regardless of her relocation to Germany. The court underscored that rehabilitation is not nullified merely because the injured employee leaves Australia. This principle aligns with the broader legal understanding that rehabilitation obligations continue to exist even if the injured party relocates abroad, though the practicalities of implementing such a program may be affected.

The court also considered whether Ms Barthel's relocation to Germany affects her entitlement to compensation for medical treatment expenses and incapacity for work. The court concluded that while the difficulties in rehabilitation may impact an injured employee's entitlements, it does not affect the threshold issues of liability. Ms Barthel's move to Germany did not negate her entitlement to compensation for her accepted injury, thus the court ruled in her favor on this point.

Another significant issue was whether Ms Barthel was entitled to compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) from 11 February 2016 to the date of the decision, subject to claim. The court found that Ms Barthel was indeed entitled to such compensation. The decision was grounded in the understanding that her injury was accepted as employment-related, and thus her entitlement to compensation was not negated by her relocation to Germany.

The court then examined whether the initial determination by Comcare that Ms Barthel had no present entitlement to compensation for medical treatment expenses and incapacity for work constituted an error of law or fact. The court determined that Comcare's initial decision was flawed, as it failed to recognize Ms Barthel's entitlement to compensation for her accepted injury. The error was rooted in both law and fact, leading the court to set aside Comcare's determination.

Finally, the court addressed whether the decision of Comcare to affirm its determination in a reconsideration decision was subject to challenge. The court found that Comcare's reconsideration decision was also flawed and was subject to challenge. The affirmation of the initial flawed decision did not rectify the errors of law and fact that were present in the initial determination. This aspect of the decision underscored the importance of rigorous scrutiny of administrative decisions to ensure they are both legally sound and factually accurate.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employer has a continuing duty to engage in rehabilitation with an injured employee, even if the employee relocates abroad, and such relocation does not negate the employee's entitlement to compensation for an accepted employment-related injury. Additionally, errors in administrative decisions regarding compensation entitlements are subject to judicial review and can be set aside if they are found to be flawed in law or fact.