Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 3

EVIDENCE – legal professional privilege – communications including documents placed by applicants or their servants and agents with their legal advisors for the purpose of receiving legal advice on tax and financial matters – principles applicable to claim – objections to affidavit evidence – liberty to file supplementary affidavits of servants and agents in relation to hearsay the subject of objection – opportunity not taken – no discharge of onus on applicants to establish the privilege

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 135
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 263

Allen Allen and Hemsley v Commissioner of Taxation (1989) 20 FCR 576
AWB Limited v Honourable Terrence Rhoderic Hudson Cole (No 5) [2006] FCA 1234
AWB Limited v Honourable Terrence Rhoderic Hudson Cole [2006] FCA 571
Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Pratt Holdings Pty Ltd (2005) 225 ALR 266
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
Kennedy v Wallace (2004) 142 FCR 185
Mitsubishi Electric Australia Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (2002) 4 VR 332
Packer v District Commissioner of Taxation (Qld) [1985] 1 Qd R 275
Waugh v British Railways Board [1980] AC 521

JOHN ERIC BARNES and JUDITH ANGELA BARNES v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
WAD 26 OF 2006

NICHOLSON J
9 JANUARY 2007
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 26 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

JOHN ERIC BARNES
JUDITH ANGELA BARNES
Applicants

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 JANUARY 2007

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants claim of legal professional privilege in respect of the documents in the schedule to the within reasons for judgment be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the application, including any costs arising from the issue of the writ of summons in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.



IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 26 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

JOHN ERIC BARNES
JUDITH ANGELA BARNES
Applicants

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLSON J

DATE:

9 JANUARY 2007

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicants seek a declaration that legal professional privilege attaches to certain communications constituted by or disclosed in documents listed in a schedule, to the details of which reference will later be made. 

  2. The issue arose in the following circumstances. By notice dated 6 June 2005 issued pursuant to s 263 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (the Notice), the respondent sought and was afforded access to all buildings, places, books, documents and other papers related, either directly or indirectly, to inter alia:

    (1)Barnes Development Pty Ltd;

    (2)Barnes Family Trust;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicants sought to prevent the Commissioner of Taxation from inspecting certain documents as part of an audit. The central dispute was whether the documents in question were protected by legal professional privilege. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The applicants argued that the documents were privileged and should not be disclosed to the Commissioner. The Commissioner, on the other hand, contended that the applicants had failed to prove that the documents were privileged.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether the applicants had successfully demonstrated that the documents were created for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice, thereby qualifying them for legal professional privilege. The court had to consider the applicants' affidavits and the lack of detailed evidence regarding the creation and purpose of each document. The applicants needed to establish that the documents were produced with the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice, as per the established legal principles.

The court found that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the documents were created for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice. The applicants' affidavits lacked specifics about the creation and purpose of each document, and there was no evidence from the applicants' solicitors or accountants to clarify these points. The court held that the applicants had failed to discharge the onus of proving that the documents were privileged. Consequently, the court dismissed the applicants' claim of legal professional privilege.

In its final orders, the court dismissed the applicants' claim of legal professional privilege in respect of the documents in question and ordered the applicants to pay the respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants claim of legal professional privilege in respect of the documents in the schedule to the within reasons for judgment be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the application, including any costs arising from the issue of the writ of summons in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, I will admit as exhibit A the affidavit of the first named applicant, other than the second sentence of [8] and [11]. APPLICANTS’ EVIDENCE The effect of that evidence is that it establishes that the applicants became residents of Australia in July 1996 or thereabouts. They have been business people for many years, always consulting lawyers and accountants concerning financial and tax planning matters. In accordance with that long standing practice, when they came to Australia they consulted lawyers and accountants. In particular, they consulted Mr Calder (a solicitor) of the applicants’ solicitors and Mr Tayler (an accountant) of Paul M Tayler & Co. In the course of briefing Mr Calder concerning their financial tax matters they provided him with a number of documents. The applicants depose:‘5.In the course of briefing Mr Calder about our financial and tax matters, my wife and I provided him with a number of documents such as immigration papers, financial documents and copies of letters of advice from accountants and lawyers whom we had previously briefed.6.My wife and I also sent letters and facsimiles to Mr Calder concerning our tax and financial affairs and he in turn wrote to us providing advice about our tax and financial matters.7.I am aware that Mr Calder usually made notes of his conversations when he saw my wife and I.’ In the affidavit the applicants stated that they were formally the owners of two properties in the United Kingdom, namely, Field House and Rockhead Farm. In November 1997 they sold the two properties to Sanderstead Limited. The sale price was ₤415 000 for Rockhead Farm and ₤85 000 for Field House. They stated that the sale price was in accordance with valuations which they obtained at the time and which are in the possession of the respondent. At the time of the transfer the two properties were only a small part of their asset portfolio. They sought advice from Mr Calder regarding the sale, although that was only one element of the matters on which they sought his advice. A large number of documents to which the respondent seeks access are not related to the two properties or to the Pantheon Trust. The two properties have a small holding income but otherwise have always been loss making. Neither of the applicants have any legal interest in Sanderstead Limited or the Pantheon Trust, not being directors, owners, beneficiaries or trustees. This is relevant in relation to whether the documents fall within the scope of the Notice. This point was not effectively argued.APPLICABLE LEGAL PRINCIPLES The onus of establishing that legal professional privilege applies to the documents or the communications they evidence is on the applicants: Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674 (Grant v Downs 135 CLR) at 689; Mitsubishi Electric Australia Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (2002) 4 VR 332 (Mitsubishi Electric 4 VR). A document created for the ‘dominant purpose’ of obtaining legal advice attracts privilege: Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 (Esso 201 CLR) at 73, at [61]. The ‘dominant purpose’ test is that expressed by Barwick CJ in Grant v Downs 135 CLR at 677:‘… a document which was produced or brought into existence either with the dominant purpose of its author, or of the person or authority under whose direction, whether particular or general, it was produced or brought into existence, of using it or its contents in order to obtain legal advice or to conduct or aid in the conduct of litigation, at the time of its production in reasonable prospect, should be privileged and excluded from inspection.’The dominant purpose may be described as the ruling, prevailing, paramount or most influential purpose: see Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 at 416; and Mitsubishi Electric 4 VR at 336-337. It is not the same as the ‘primary’ or the ‘substantial’ purpose, which do not describe the true basis of the privilege: Grant v Downs 135 CLR at 678.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

In order to apply these principles to the applicants’ claim it is necessary to address each of the documents in question. CONSIDERATION OF DOCUMENTS It is important to observe that the evidence of Mr Barnes does not state precisely how each of the documents was created. This is also the case with regard to copies. His statement in [5] that he provided copies of letters of advice to Mr Calder does not make apparent whether the copy came into existence for the purpose of advice, whether a pre-existing copy was sent to Mr Calder or whether the copy before the Court was made by Mr Calder’s office. The absence of such evidence permeates the resolution of his claim for privilege. For example, there is no evidence enabling an understanding to be reached concerning the possibility that any particular faxed copy was created by the applicants for the dominant purpose of seeking the legal advice of Mr Calder. There is no evidence of what the fax number of the applicants was on each particular occasion (other than their names as a notation at the top of the document) or what the phone number of the recipient was and whether it was the number of Mr Calder. The Court is therefore unable to determine whether the faxed endorsements are referrable to some occasion prior to the applicants sending documents to Mr Calder for legal advice. Additionally, it cannot be inferred from the fact that the documents were found in the possession of Mr Calder that they were created as originals or copies for the requisite dominant purpose in each case. Likewise there is no evidence to explain why some of the documents bear the fax name of the applicants’ accountant or whether the accountant created the copy. There are some documents which on their face appear to be facsimile transmissions from the applicants to their solicitors. However, the copy in question appears to be a further copy of the facsimile transmission because it displays a photocopy of a punchmark, unlikely to be on the original. In the absence of specific evidence pertaining to each such document it cannot be said that the applicants have discharged the onus resting upon them. Even where documents appear to be file copies of correspondence from the applicants’ solicitors to the applicants, they also appear with a punch-hole suggesting they are further copies, the creation of which is unexplained by any evidence from the applicants’ solicitors. There are some documents apparently being copies of handwritten letters from the first named applicant to his solicitors. One is notated with writing indicating the date of its receipt by the solicitors. That suggests the original (or the copy original) has been recopied, possibly by the solicitors. However, there is no evidence to explain the creation of the copy. The Court doubtless would have been greatly assisted by affidavit evidence from each applicant on each document and affidavits from Mr Calder and the applicants’ accountants. However, when the opportunity was offered to the applicants to file such evidence, no additional evidence was tendered.