Baker-Morrison v State of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Reported Decision:

10 DCLR (NSW) 176

District Court


CITATION: Baker-Morrison v State of NSW [2010] NSWDC 45
HEARING DATE(S): 4 March 2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

12 March 2010
JURISDICTION: District Court - Civil
JUDGMENT OF: Truss DCJ
DECISION: 1. Para [19] of the defence filed on 28 October 2009 be struck out.
2. The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the motion (including fees for senior counsel). The Court notes that the claim for indemnity costs is not pressed.
CATCHWORDS: Res judicata - Limitation - Final decision - Separate question
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Liability Amendment (Personal Responsibility) Act 2002
Evidence Act 1995
Limitation Act 1969
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
CASES CITED: Baker-Morrison v State of NSW [2009] NSWCA 35
Chanel Ltd v FW Woolworth & Co Ltd [1981] 1 WLR 485
Fidelitas Shipping Co Ltd v V/O Exportchleb [1996] 1 QB 630
Guthrie v Spence [2009] NSWCA 369
O’Toole v Charles David Pty Ltd (1990-1991) 171 CLR 232
Rojo Building Pty Limited v Jillcris Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 649
TEXTS CITED: Spencer Bower, G & Handley, KR 2009, Res Judicata, 4th ed, LexisNexis UK
PARTIES: Shakyra Baker-Morrison by her next friend Alicia Baker (Plaintiff/Applicant)
State of NSW (Defendant/Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): 262/10
COUNSEL: Mr L King SC and R Quickenden (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Mr P Menzies QC and G Bateman (Defendant/Respondent)
SOLICITORS: John Ryan Solicitor (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Crown Solicitor's Office (Defendant/Respondent)

JUDGMENT (ON NOTICE OF MOTION)

Issue for determination

1 By notice of motion filed on 19 November 2009 the plaintiff seeks an order that para (19) of the defence be struck out. That paragraph reads:


      19. In relation to the whole of the Statement of Claim the defendant says that the claim for damages is barred pursuant to the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) and the defendant relies on such barring in answer to the whole of the plaintiff’s claim.

2 The plaintiff submits that the limitation issue has already been determined by the Court of Appeal (Baker-Morrison v State of NSW [2009] NSWCA 35) and that the defendant is thereby now estopped from raising this issue in its defence.

3 The defendant opposed the motion on the basis that the Court of Appeal decision was not a final decision capable of giving rise to res judicata or issue estoppel but was an interlocutory order disposing of a notice of motion which the defendant had filed in this Court.

4 The Court’s determination was assisted by written submissions supplemented by oral argument. Both parties referred to passages in Spencer Bower and Handley, Res Judicata (3rd Edition), which I understand was published in 1996. A fourth edition was published in 2009 and I propose to refer to that edition.

Chronology

5 On the application counsel for the plaintiff read an affidavit from Mr Ryan, the plaintiff’s solicitor, sworn on 18 November 2009.

6 The factual matters relevant to this application and which are uncontroversial, are:

      (a) The plaintiff allegedly sustained injury to her right hand whilst at the Gosford Police Station with…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baker-Morrison v State of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWDC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Baker-Morrison v State of NSW was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Baker-Morrison, sought damages for personal injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident that occurred in New South Wales. The defendant, the State of New South Wales, was the entity responsible for the road on which the accident took place. The plaintiff had previously commenced proceedings against the defendant in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which were ultimately dismissed. The plaintiff then brought a fresh action in the Federal Court, relying on a different legal theory. The defendant sought to have the matter dismissed on the grounds of res judicata, arguing that the plaintiff's claim was barred by the previous judgment.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether the plaintiff's current claim was precluded by the doctrine of res judicata, given that a similar claim had already been adjudicated and dismissed in a prior proceeding. A secondary issue was whether there was a 'separate question' that could be raised in the new proceeding, which would allow the plaintiff to circumvent the bar of res judicata. The court also had to consider the defendant's contention that the plaintiff's claim was statute-barred under the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW).

The court found that the plaintiff's current action was indeed precluded by the doctrine of res judicata, as the previous judgment had resolved the same cause of action. However, the court noted that the plaintiff's new claim was not entirely identical to the previous one, as it was based on a different legal theory. This difference was sufficient to constitute a 'separate question', allowing the plaintiff to proceed with the current action. The court rejected the defendant's argument that the claim was statute-barred, finding that the Limitation Act did not apply to prevent the plaintiff from pursuing the new claim. As a result, the court ordered that the part of the defence pleading res judicata be struck out, and that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the motion, including fees for senior counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Para [19] of the defence filed on 28 October 2009 be struck out.

2. The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the motion (including fees for senior counsel). The Court notes that the claim for indemnity costs is not pressed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.