Baird v The Coroner of the Northern Territory & Puruntatameri & Puruntatameri v Northern Territory Coroner and Baird

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

CITATION:Baird v The Coroner of the Northern Territory & Puruntatameri & Puruntatameri v Territory Coroner & Baird [2020] NTSC 67

PARTIES:Baird, Rosemary Therese

v

The Coroner of the Northern Territory

and

Puruntatameri, Constance May

ANDPuruntatameri, Constance May

v

The Territory Coroner

and

Baird, Rosemary Therese

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NOS:2020-02678-SC and

2020-02763-SC

DELIVERED ON:  13 October 2020

HEARING DATE:  25 September 2020

JUDGMENT OF:  Barr J

CATCHWORDS:

HEALTH LAW – Burial rights – Deceased 15 year old youth – Dispute between biological mother and adoptive mother/kinship carer – Right to arrange funeral and bury the deceased – Cultural considerations – Practical considerations – Order that body of the deceased be delivered to adoptive mother/kinship carer for funeral and burial  

Administration and Probate Act 1969, s 22

Coroners Act 1993, s 3, s 17 (1)

Calma v Sesar and anor (1992) 2 NTLR 37, 106 FLR 446; Smith v Tamworth City Council (1997) 41 NSWLR 680, considered

Gilliott v Woodlands [2006] VSCA 46, distinguished.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Rosemary Baird:  JCA Tippett QC

Constance Puruntatameri:           L Nguyen

NT Coroner:  B Wild

Solicitors:

Rosemary Baird:  Maley Barristers and Solicitors

Constance Puruntatameri:           North Australian Aboriginal Family Legal Service

NT Coroner:  Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Bar2006

Number of pages:  25

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Baird v The Coroner of the Northern Territory & Puruntatameri & Puruntatameri v Territory Coroner & Baird [2020] NTSC 67
No. 2020-02678-SC and 2020-02763-SC

BETWEEN:

ROSEMARY THERESE BAIRD

Plaintiff

AND:

THE CORONER OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

First Defendant

AND:

CONSTANCE MAY PURUNTATAMERI

Second Defendant

AND BETWEEN:

CONSTANCE MAY PURUNTATAMERI

Plaintiff

AND

THE TERRITORY CORONER

First Defendant

AND

ROSEMARY THERESE BAIRD

Second Defendant

CORAM:    Barr J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 13 October 2020)

  1. Rosemary Therese Baird (“Rosemary”) and Constance May Puruntatameri (“Constance”) have both applied for orders giving them the right to dispose of the body of R who was born on 27 March 2005 and who died at the age of 15 on 19 May 2020. I will refer to the deceased as “R” or “the deceased”.

  2. Rosemary and Constance are both Aboriginal women. Constance is the biological mother of the deceased.

  3. With the consent of Constance, Rosemary undertook the primary care and responsibility for R from when he was five months old, and remained his principal and probably sole caregiver throughout his life. She assumed the role of mother and treated R as her son. She undertook his school enrolments each year, from Grade 1 at Gray Primary School, to Grade 7 at Rosebery Middle School, to Grade 9 at Palmerston Senior College. She attended school appointments with teachers, school functions, school graduations and presentations, as well as all school sports events in which R was involved. When his schooling fell behind, which happened on more than one occasion in the several years prior to his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baird v The Coroner of the Northern Territory & Puruntatamer... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NTSC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute over the burial rights of a deceased 15-year-old youth between his biological mother, Rosemary Baird, and his adoptive mother/kinship carer, Constance Puruntatameri. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory. The primary issue before the court was to determine who had the right to arrange the funeral and bury the deceased, considering the cultural and practical factors involved.

The court had to decide whether the biological mother or the adoptive mother/kinship carer should be granted the right to arrange the funeral and bury the deceased. The court examined the relevant legislation, specifically the Administration and Probate Act 1969, and considered the cultural considerations and practical factors in this case. The court concluded that the biological mother, Rosemary Baird, should be granted the right to arrange the funeral and bury the deceased based on the matters outlined in the court's reasons.

The court's reasoning was based on the fact that the deceased did not have a spouse or de facto partner, and there was no evidence that he had any assets. As a result, the court found that Constance Puruntatameri was unlikely to be considered the deceased's "next of kin" within the meaning of the Administration and Probate Act 1969, as there was no estate in which she would be entitled to take an interest. Furthermore, the court found that the cultural considerations and practical factors in this case favoured Rosemary Baird. The court ordered that the body of the deceased be delivered to Rosemary Baird to arrange the funeral and burial. The lawyers acting for Rosemary Baird were directed to submit draft orders for the court's consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As things turned out, legal proceedings were commenced by both Rosemary and Constance. Moreover, the coroner appeared by counsel at the commencement of the hearing in this Court and indicated that he would abide this Court’s decision. In all the circumstances, even if (contrary to my finding) the coroner had made a determination, it would now be irrelevant. Conclusion and orders In my judgment, culture is a strong consideration in this case but the matters referred to in pars [3] – [5], [22], [23], [29], [30], [36] and [37] determine the outcome in favour of Rosemary. I propose a formal order as follows: After issue of the certificate referred to in s 17 (1) Coroners Act 1993, the body of the deceased be delivered into the possession of Rosemary Therese Baird to arrange the funeral and burial of the deceased. The matter should be listed for mention as soon as possible. I will then make a formal order in accordance with [52], and any further orders which may be sought, consistent with these Reasons. The lawyers acting for Rosemary should submit draft orders for the Court’s consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Administration and Probate Act 1969, s 22, specifies to whom administration may be granted:- 22To whom administration may be granted(1) Subject to this section, the Court may grant administration of the estate of an intestate person to:(a)the spouse or de facto partner of the deceased person;(b)one or more of the next of kin;(c)the spouse or de facto partner conjointly with one or more of the next of kin; or(d)such person, whether a creditor or not of the deceased person, as the Court thinks fit.(2) The Court shall not grant administration to a person who is not the spouse or de facto partner or one of the next of kin of the deceased unless:(a)there is no such spouse or de facto partner or next of kin;(b)there is no such spouse or de facto partner or next of kin within the jurisdiction who is, in the opinion of the Court, fit to be trusted; or(c)there is no such spouse or de facto partner or next of kin who, when duly cited, appears and prays for administration. The deceased did not have a spouse or de facto partner, and a preliminary reading of s 22 would suggest that his biological mother would be awarded administration on the basis that she is “next of kin”, who (on the assumption that she is “fit to be trusted”) would be preferred to a person such as is referred to in s 22 (1)(d) as a result of the application of s 22 (2) of the Act. However, the definition of “next of kin” in s 6 (1) of the Act is “… those persons, other than a spouse or de facto partner of the deceased person, who would be entitled to take an interest in the estate of the deceased person if he or she had died intestate”. There is no evidence that the deceased had any assets and so it is unlikely that Constance would be considered the deceased’s “next of kin” within the meaning of the Administration and Probate Act 1969, because there is no estate in which she would be entitled to take an interest. More fundamentally, if there is no estate, then there is nothing in respect of which the Court may grant administration pursuant to s 22 (1) of the Act. In Smith v Tamworth City Council,[26] Young J reviewed a number of authorities and referred to the situation where the deceased does not leave an estate, as follows: It can be seen from the cases that where the person has named an executor, that named executor has the primary privilege of burying the deceased’s body. Where there is no executor named, and the deceased leaves an estate, the person entitled to administration is usually the person who is responsible for the burial of the body and for the payment of the funeral expenses. That person may recoup such expenses out of the estate. As the burial usually takes place before there is a grant of administration, one looks to see the person who is most likely to get the grant of administration. As the grant follows interest, In the estate of Slattery [citations omitted], the person with the largest interest will normally be the person who is the one expected to bury the body.Where the deceased does not leave any estate, then it would seem that the duty is still on the person under whose roof the deceased dies to arrange the burial, though if it can be said that there is a legal duty on another person to bury the body, then that other person will be subject to a restitutionary action at the suit of the householder who arranges the burial. The first part of the proposition I have just enunciated is supported by the decision of the Full Court of the King’s Bench in R v Stewart.