Bai and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2013] AATA 612 

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2010/4191-4194

Re

Tao Bai

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S E Frost

Date 29 August 2013
Place Sydney

The Tribunal decides:

(a)to vary the objection decisions in respect of the 2003 and 2005 years, so as to take account of the Commissioner's concessions as set out in [18] and the Tribunal's conclusions at [52] of the reasons that follow;

(b)to set aside the objection decisions in respect of the 2004 and 2006 years and substitute a decision in each case that the objection is allowed in part, to take account of the Commissioner's concessions as set out in [18] and the Tribunal's conclusions at [52] of the reasons that follow;

(c)to affirm the objection decisions in relation to penalty at 50 per cent of the shortfall amount, but reduced in quantum so as to reflect the adjustments at (a) and (b) above.

........[sgd]........................................................

Deputy President S E Frost

CATCHWORDS

INCOME TAX – amended assessments for four income years – Commissioner's opinion in respect of each year that there was evasion – administrative penalty imposed at 50 per cent for recklessness – taxpayer's burden of proof – Tribunal not satisfied that there was no evasion – objection decisions set aside and varied so as to allow objections in part – administrative penalty at 50 per cent upheld – no remission

LEGISLATION

Taxation Administration Act 1953, s 14ZZK

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, s 170

CASES

Gauci v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1975] HCA 54; 135 CLR 81

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Dalco [1990] HCA 3; 168 CLR 614
Danmark Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation; Forestwood Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1944) 7 ATD 333
Nguyen and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 544
Commissioner of Taxation v SNF (Australia) Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 74
Davis v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2000] FCA 44
Imperial Bottleshops Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 91 ATC 4546

McCormack v Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 143 CLR 284

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S E Frost

29 August 2013

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant in this case is one of four taxpayers who are, or were, connected in some way with one or more companies in the High Trade group, including:

    ·High Trade Company Pty Ltd (High Trade Company);

    ·High Trade Constructions Pty Ltd (Constructions);

    ·Resort Hunter Valley Pty Ltd.

  2. This particular applicant, Tao Bai, was married to one of the other taxpayers, Li Zhang.  Mr Zhang was a director and, it seems, the controlling mind of the companies in the High Trade group.  The remaining two taxpayers are Lian Zhang, who is the brother of Li Zhang; and Song Chang, who was an employee of the High Trade group. 

  3. Following tax audits that commenced in 2007, the Commissioner formed the view that the taxpayers had understated their income over a period of years.  He made a number of amended assessments in relation to each of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bai and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 612
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bai and Commissioner of Taxation involves a dispute over amended tax assessments issued by the Commissioner of Taxation. Ms Bai, the taxpayer, contests the assessments for four income years, asserting that they are excessive. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining whether Ms Bai's objections to the assessments were valid and whether any administrative penalties imposed for recklessness were justified. Ms Bai had the burden of proving that the assessments were excessive under section 14ZZK of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (TAA). The AAT found that Ms Bai had not demonstrated that the shortfall in her tax liabilities did not result from recklessness, leading to the upholding of the penalties.

The central legal issues before the AAT were twofold: firstly, whether Ms Bai had successfully argued that the amended assessments were excessive, and secondly, whether she was liable for administrative penalties. The AAT needed to consider Ms Bai's evidence and arguments regarding her business transactions and income to determine the validity of the objections. Additionally, the AAT had to assess the Commissioner's imposition of administrative penalties under the TAA and decide if the penalties were justified based on Ms Bai's conduct.

In its decision, the AAT concluded that Ms Bai's objections should have been allowed in part for each of the relevant years. For the years 2003 and 2005, the AAT varied the Commissioner's decisions to reflect the concessions made by the Commissioner and its own conclusions. For the years 2004 and 2006, the AAT set aside the Commissioner's decisions to disallow the objections and allowed them in part, again considering the Commissioner's concessions and its own findings. The AAT found that Ms Bai had not proven that her shortfall did not result from recklessness, thus upholding the administrative penalties imposed by the Commissioner. Consequently, no remission of the penalties was justified.

The AAT set aside and varied the Commissioner's decisions regarding the objections to the amended assessments for the relevant years, allowing the objections in part. The AAT upheld the administrative penalties at 50 per cent, finding no basis for any remission. This decision clarified the extent of the objections allowed and affirmed the penalties imposed, reflecting the findings on Ms Bai's conduct and the merits of her case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The main question for the Tribunal is whether Ms Bai has shown that the amended assessments are excessive. This is the burden that she bears under s 14ZZK of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (TAA). A subsidiary question, which will arise if her case falls short to any extent, is whether she is liable to administrative penalties.BACKGROUND Ms Bai married Li Zhang some time prior to her migration to Australia in 1997. They are now separated. She claims that from December 1994 to August 1996 (that is, before she migrated to Australia) she transferred AUD800,000 to Australia for business purposes[1]. At least some, and perhaps all, of that money had come from Brightfull International Ltd, a company that she and her former husband had incorporated in Hong Kong in 1992. She claims that all of the funds that came from Brightfull were beneficially owned by her[2]. The funds were described as having been transferred to “High Trade/Li Zhang”, to “High Trade”, or to “Li Zhang’s Westpac account”[3].[1] Affidavit affirmed 2 April 2012 (Exhibit A2-1), [48][2] Exhibit A2-1, [46][3] Exhibit A2-1, [46] The purpose of these transfers was, she said[4]:… in order to build up our business in Australia, especially the Resort Hunter Valley project. My husband dreamed to build a resort to an internationally high standard. Resort Hunter Valley is managed by Crown[e] Plaza Hotel and brings hundreds of local jobs. It made our dream come true, but we suffered huge financial pressure from building it. My husband and I and many family members and friends loaned large sum of money in order to finish this project. The project was undertaken by High Trade Company Pty Ltd …[4] Exhibit A2-1, [44] For at least part of the period from July 2002 to June 2006 (this is the period with which these applications are concerned – the “relevant years”), Ms Bai was employed by one or other of the companies in the High Trade group. She was also a shareholder and a director of some of those companies. She moved around from one company to another, but her duties remained roughly the same. She said she was an “office manager”[5], she was involved in “market research”[6], she would “look at the prospects of development”[7] of a particular site, or she would “gather all the information and then report this information to the company”[8]. She was, however, quite unspecific as to the particular activities that any of the companies carried on.[5] Transcript, P-240, line 6[6] Transcript, P-240, lines 42-43[7] Transcript, P-241, lines 5-6[8] Transcript, P-241, lines 13-14 Her tax returns, as lodged for the relevant years, disclose the following: Notices of assessment issued, in respect of each of those years, in accordance with the returns as lodged. However, after the Commissioner’s audit, Ms Bai’s taxable income was re-assessed to the following amounts:·For the 2003 year – $261,332[13];·For the 2004 year – $272,313[14];·For the 2005 year – $1,183,398[15];·For the 2006 year – $1,178,027[16].[13] T25-213[14] T26-214[15] T27-215[16] T28-217

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Bai has not satisfied me that her shortfall amount did not arise as a result of recklessness, and there is no basis on which any remission of the penalty is justified.DECISION In each of the relevant years I have concluded that the objection should have been allowed in part. Since the objections for 2003 and 2005 were allowed in part by the Commissioner, but I have concluded that they should have been allowed to a greater extent, I will vary those two objection decisions to take account of the Commissioner’s concessions, referred to in [18] of these reasons, and the conclusions that I have reached in [52]. The objections for 2004 and 2006 were disallowed by the Commissioner. I will set aside those objection decisions and substitute a decision in each case that the objection is allowed in part, so as to take account of the Commissioner’s concessions, referred to in [18] of these reasons, and the conclusions that I have reached in [52].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established