Babbage and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2023] AATA 3487 (25 October 2023)
Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2022/2859
2022/3310
Re:Mark Babbage
APPLICANT
AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member O'Donovan
Date:25 October 2023
Place:Melbourne
The Tribunal varies the periods of the applicant’s bans to six years. The decisions under review are otherwise affirmed.
…………………………[sgd]…………………………
Senior Member O’Donovan
CATCHWORDS
TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION - whether to make an order banning a person from providing financial services - whether to make an order banning a person from engaging in credit activities - where the applicant has engaged in serious dishonesty - where the applicant misled public officials - where the applicant fraudulently altered documents - where the applicant made false declarations - whether actions in a private capacity relevant to banning orders - where a ban will have significant personal impact - decisions varied to impose a shorter ban
LEGISLATION
Corporations Act 2001
Emergency Management Act 2005 (WA)
National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009Oaths, Affidavits and Declarations Act 2010 (NT)
CASES
Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Fraser and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2011] AATA 944
HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1803
HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 202
Musumeci v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 525
Secretary to the Department of Justice and Regulation v LLG [2018] VSCA 155
Saffron v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 30 FCR 578Williams and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2018] AATA 2312
SECONDARY MATERIALS
ASIC Regulatory Guide 98
ASIC Regulatory Guide 218
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member O'Donovan
2021 was a remarkable season for the AFL’s Melbourne Demons. The regular season began with 9 straight wins and finished with the club winning its first minor premiership since 1964. In the qualifying final and the preliminary finals Melbourne had wins and the grand final match-up meant that Melbourne was to face the much less fancied Western Bulldogs.
But Melbourne had disappointed its fans in the past. It had not won a grand final since 1964 It is easy to understand the desire of any long-term Melbourne fan to get to the game. A historic win was on the cards and no-one could say that Melbourne supporters were not long suffering.
But for Victorian fans of the club there was a complication. COVID-19 lock-down measures were in place to control the spread of the deadly Delta strain of the virus. As a result, the Grand Final was scheduled to be played in Perth. Entry into WA was tightly regulated. It was impossible for a Melbourne supporter living in Victoria to secure tickets for the Grand Final and then to travel to Perth to watch the game without breaking COVID rules.
The applicant worked as a financial planner and mortgage broker. He was also a Demons supporter. He was approached…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Babbage and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 3487
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant's conduct, which included serious dishonesty, misleading public officials, fraudulently altering documents, and making false declarations, warranted the imposition of banning orders. A key legal issue was whether conduct engaged in by the applicant in a private capacity, rather than in his professional roles as a mortgage broker and financial planner, was relevant to the making of such orders, and how any significant personal impact of a ban should be weighed.
The Tribunal acknowledged that the applicant accepted the preconditions for banning orders were met but argued for no ban or a shorter, more limited one. ASIC contended for a 10-year ban. The Tribunal considered the applicant's arguments that his misconduct was a one-off event, partly explained by declining mental health and the context of COVID-19 lockdowns, and that it occurred in a private capacity and had already been punished by the criminal justice system. Conversely, ASIC argued that the applicant's dishonesty and deliberate disregard for the law, even in a private capacity, demonstrated a lack of moral fortitude and an ongoing risk to the financial services and credit industries, supporting a lengthy ban. The Tribunal noted that conduct outside of regulated roles could still be relevant if it revealed dishonesty and a lack of integrity.
Ultimately, the Tribunal varied the decisions, imposing a shorter ban than ASIC initially sought, acknowledging the applicant's prior compliance record and the personal impact of a ban, while still reflecting the seriousness of the dishonest conduct.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In his letter of apology to the WA Magistrates’ Court the applicant described his actions in the following terms.It was my selfish actions to come and try and enjoy my team’s first win instead of thinking about the consequences of my actions. I let the excitement of a game take over my moral compass. I assure you that I will never be so stupid again and let this behaviour repeat. My sincerest apologies to all the people of Western Australia.CONSIDERATION The applicant accepts that the preconditions for the making of the banning orders are present but contends that either no banning orders should be made or if orders are made, they should be for a period of six months and be in terms which do not prevent the applicant from working in some capacity in the financial services and credit industries. The respondent contends that the reviewable decisions should be affirmed and a ban of 10 years imposed. The parties’ perspectives on the applicant’s conduct are very different. From the applicant’s point of view:(a)He is a person who has worked in the financial and credit industries for a lengthy period without blemish;(b)His misconduct was a one-off event in very unusual circumstances which I can be confident won’t be repeated;(c)The conduct can be explained in part by the applicant’s declining mental health at the time and his need to escape the Victorian lockdowns;(d)The fraud and dishonesty occurred in a private context, not in the context of a service being provided to clients and so is largely irrelevant to the regulation of the credit and finance industries;(e)The conduct has already been harshly punished by the criminal justice system and so there is no need for a further penalty to be imposed to achieve specific and general deterrence. Indeed, legal principle requires that the discretion should be approached on a modified basis in light of the punishments which have already been inflicted. The respondent on the other hand submits:(a)Regard should be had to the Regulatory Guides prepared by ASIC which emphasise that:(i)A person who shows a deliberate disregard for compliance with the law poses a higher risk of further non-compliance than a person who fails to comply due to incompetence;(ii)A person who has acted dishonestly, or has chosen to engage in conduct despite knowing that it could potentially adversely affect others, poses a higher risk than a person who did not realise the potential for adverse consequences;(b)Factors of dishonesty and intent to defraud generally support a banning period of 10+ years;(c)Even though the applicant’s conduct did not occur in his roles as a financial advisor or in the credit industry, the level of deceit involved in his conduct revealed a lack of moral fortitude to act honestly in all circumstances such that banning orders are appropriate to ensure he does not have access to documents and opportunities for deceit which participation in the credit and financial industries provides;(d)The applicant’s submissions and evidence demonstrate a lack of insight into the seriousness of his offending giving rise to a risk of further offending. This lack of insight is demonstrated by the applicant’s focus on the fact that he did not directly use the forged lease created by Mr Burbank in circumstances where he used false documents based on it to enter Western Australia. The applicant’s denials that he travelled solely to Western Australia to attend the Grand Final also suggests a lack of insight. Further, Dr List provides a basis for concluding that the applicant continues to show deficits in relation to his insight into the wrongness of his behaviour;(e)The applicant’s lack of insight means that he presents an ongoing risk to the financial services and credit industries. That risk requires a lengthy ban;(f)It is not the case that the only conduct relevant to a ban is conduct which occurs in the course of carrying on the regulated occupation. In this case the ‘private’ conduct was fraudulent and dishonest which makes it relevant to a banning order. However, the fact that the conduct did not occur while the applicant was performing duties in the regulated industries is relevant and should be taken into account to some degree. Factual and Legal Issues