Ayub v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Ayub v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 79

File number(s): MLG 784 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE CORBETT
Date of judgment: 5 February 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION - Temporary Graduate (Class VC) (Subclass 485) visa – application for judicial review – amendment of application to seek mandamus - failure to accompany visa application with evidence – Regulation 485.215 - whether Tribunal failed to consider all materials available to it – whether Tribunal failed to consider a material fact – error of law - application allowed
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 476(1), 65, 54, 55, 56

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 52

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Sch 2 sub-cls 485.215, 500.215, 485.215(1), 487.216

Cases cited:

Ahmed v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCCA 622

Ahmed v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1416

Anand v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 1050
Berenguel v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) 264 ALR 417; [2010] HCA 8

Evans v The Queen (2007) 235 CLR 521; [2007] HCA 59

FRA18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCCA 2287

Gulati & Anor v Minister for Immigration [2012] FMCA 491

Khan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 85

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] (2024) 418 ALR 152; [2024] HCA 12

Lumbini v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCCA 1142

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18

Nguyen v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection (2016) 310 FLR 339; [2016] FCCA 1523

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs & Anor v Peko-Wallsend Limited & Ors (1986) 162 CLR 24; [1986] HCA 40

Sidhu v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1342

Singh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship & Multicultural Affairs [2022] FedCFamC2G 889

Todhunter v Attorney-General (Cth) (1994) 52 FCR 228

Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 241 FCR 121; [2016] FCAFC 32

Winkler v Director of Public Prosecutions (1990) 25 FCR 79

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 95
Date of last submission/s: 12 December 2024
Date of hearing: 12 December 2024
Place: Melbourne
Solicitor for the Applicant The Applicant appeared in person
Solicitor for the Respondents Mr J Mangos, Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 784 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MOHAMMED AYUB

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE CORBETT

DATE OF ORDER:

5 FEBRUARY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 7.01(1) of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth), the application for judicial review dated 19 March 2019 is amended to seek a writ of mandamus directed to the second respondent, requiring it to determine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ayub v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultur... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of India, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs to refuse his application for a Temporary Graduate (Subclass 485) visa. The central issue in the case was whether the delegate of the Minister was correct in finding that the applicant did not satisfy the primary criteria for the grant of the visa because he did not provide evidence of adequate health insurance at the time he made his visa application. The applicant argued that the Tribunal failed to consider all materials available to it and failed to consider a material fact, namely the evidence of his health insurance that was on the Department’s files at the time of the visa application.

The court held that the Tribunal failed to consider all materials available to it and failed to consider a material fact, and that the Tribunal's decision was therefore flawed. The court found that the Tribunal had not exercised the discretion it possessed to consider the evidence of health insurance that was on the Department’s files at the time of the visa application, and that this was an error of law. The court also found that the Tribunal had failed to consider a material fact, namely the evidence of the applicant's health insurance that was on the Department’s files at the time of the visa application.

The court allowed the applicant's application for judicial review and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The court held that the Tribunal should consider the evidence of the applicant's health insurance that was on the Department’s files at the time of the visa application, and that the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to consider this evidence in determining whether the applicant satisfied the primary criteria for the grant of the visa.

No orders were made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Reference in these reasons to “CB” pages are references to the Court Book that was tendered and admitted as evidence at the hearing before this Court and designated exhibit “R1”. References to the Act are references to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).BACKGROUND The applicant is a citizen of India. He first arrived in Australia in June 2013 as the holder of a (Subclass 500) student visa. The applicant then completed a Master of Management (Engineering) degree from CQ University Australia (CB 19). On 29 January 2018, the applicant applied for the visa (CB 1-21). At the time of his application for the visa the applicant’s Subclass 500 student visa had not expired. On page two of the application form, the applicant was asked the following (CB 2):Health InsuranceDo you and all applicants included in this application hold health insurance? The applicant answered “No” to this question. This was a mistake by the applicant as he did hold health insurance at that time but was confused by the period for which insurance was required to be held. Below the answer, the following note appears on the application form (CB 2):You must attach evidence of adequate health insurance after the lodgement of this application on the “Attach documents to a lodged application” page.Note: To meet the requirements for this visa you must have adequate health insurance. The primary criteria for the grant of a Subclass 485 visa are set out under sub-clause 485 of Sch 2 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (Regulations). Clause 485.215 provides:485.215(1)When the application was made, it was accompanied by evidence that the applicant had adequate arrangements for health insurance.(2)The applicant has had adequate arrangements for health insurance since the time the application was made. On 19 March 2018, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicant the visa (CB 23–7). The delegate found that the applicant did not satisfy cl 485.215 of Sch 2 to the Regulations because the applicant did not provide any additional documentation at the time of the application to indicate he had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance. There was no request by the delegate that the applicant provide further evidence of adequate health insurance before making the decision to refuse the visa and no indication by the delegate that a decision would be made adverse to the applicant based on insufficient evidence. On 8 April 2018, the applicant applied to the Tribunal to review the delegate’s decision (CB 28–9). On 4 May 2018, the applicant obtained confirmation from Bupa that he had the minimum level of health insurance coverage required by the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) from 14 March 2018 onward for the purpose of the visa (CB 48). Prior to that date, the applicant held health insurance coverage with Medibank Private for the period 24 June 2013 to 15 March 2018 for the purpose of the Subclass 500 student visas (CB 47). On 15 January 2019, the Tribunal invited the applicant to attend a hearing to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in relation to the decision under review (CB 35–7).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In Khan, a Full Court of the Federal Court considered the proper construction to cl 485.223 of Sch 2 of the Regulations. In that case, the applicant was required to accompany the application with evidence that the applicant had applied for an assessment of the applicant’s skills for the nominated skilled occupation by a relevant authority. The applicant had not applied for a skills assessment at the time of making the application. He did not do so until two months after lodging the application for the visa. The delegate of the Minister refused to grant the visa. The applicant subsequently obtained the assessment and sought review of the delegate’s decision by the Tribunal. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision. The applicant then sought judicial review and was also unsuccessful. On appeal to a Full Court of the Federal Court, the Court dismissed the appeal. Relevantly Tracey J observed at [20] of his reasons:[20] In the present case, however, the Tribunal did not have any discretion as to whether or not to apply the criterion in cl 485.223 to the appellant. Whether or not a visa application is accompanied by the necessary evidence may involve an evaluation of evidence but it does not involve the exercise of the discretion of the kind that would attract the principles in Li (emphasis added). In Khan, the Full Court also held that the decision of the Tribunal was not unreasonable in the manner identified in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18 (Li). A decision of a decision-maker is not “unreasonable” simply because the result is harsh (see Khan at [21] per Tracey J). Both Anand and Khan involved consideration of different regulations, but in different factual circumstances to those present in this case. The Minister also sought to rely on the decision in Lumbini v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCCA 1142 (Lumbini) per Judge Emmett. In that case, the Court also considered cl 485.215 of Sch 2 of the Regulations. There, the Tribunal accepted that the applicants submitted evidence of adequate arrangements for health insurance after the application was made, however, the Tribunal found that the evidence was not provided at the time of the application “nor in response to the letter from the Department seeking further information from the applicant”. The failure in that case was due to an error by the applicants’ agent. In that case, the Court recorded that the applicants contended that the Tribunal “made a jurisdictional error by not taking into consideration relevant evidence of the applicant and/or refusing to give weight to evidence provided by the applicant (sic) and thereby made an erroneous findings and mistaken conclusion” (see Lumbini at [4] and [6]). Regrettably, the Court did not address this submission in terms of the evidence available to the Tribunal but instead relied on a concession that upon lodging the application for the visa, the applicants’ insurance ceased (see Lumbini at [9]). The Court then considered whether the Tribunal had any residual discretion and held there was none. The Court held that the findings made by the Tribunal were open to it and for the reasons it gave. The facts in that case can also be distinguished from the facts and evidence here. It is to be noted that the delegate in Lumbini sought evidence of insurance cover before making a decision and was not provided with evidence which was available to the applicants at the time of the request.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 February 2019, the applicant provided a “Further Written Submission” to the Tribunal (CB 57–61). In that submission, reliance was placed upon two cases, Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 241 FCR 121; [2016] FCAFC 32 (Waensila) and Berenguel v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) 264 ALR 417; [2010] HCA 8 (Berenguel), as authority for the proposition that the Tribunal should conclude that there was substantial compliance with cl 485.215 of the Regulations and that there was at all material times evidence of valid health insurance (CB 62-93).TRIBUNAL DECISION On 8 March 2019, the Tribunal provided the applicant with a written Statement of Decision and Reasons in which the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate to refuse to grant the visa (Decision) (CB 97–103). In the Decision, the Tribunal identified the issues to be determined as follows (CB 98 [10]):The applicant is seeking to satisfy the primary criteria for a Subclass 485 visa in the Post-Study Work stream, which criteria include cl.485.215 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. The Tribunal then identified the criteria in cl 485.215 of the Regulations, noting that the visa application be accompanied by evidence that the applicant had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance and that the applicant had such arrangements since the time the application was made (CB 98 [11]). The Tribunal identified the two issues to be determined as follows (CB 98-9 [12]);(a)When the visa application was made, was it accompanied by evidence that the applicant had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance? And, if so, (emphasis added)(b)Had the applicant had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance since the time the application was made? The Tribunal considered the applicant’s explanation as to why he had answered “no” to question two on the application form (CB 99 [13]-[14]). That included his explanation that he had misunderstood the question and the period for which insurance was required at the time of making the application for the visa. The Tribunal then considered the submissions made on behalf of the applicant by his migration agent (CB 99 [18]). The Tribunal accepted that one of the requirements for the grant of a Subclass 500 visa was that “the applicant had given evidence of adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance during the period of the intended stay in Australia (cl.500.215)”. The Tribunal further found that it was “likely that information provided to the Department at the time of the applicant’s student visa application included evidence showing that the applicant had health insurance arrangements up until 15 March 2018, therefore covering the date of the Subclass 485 visa application” (CB 100 [21]). At paragraph [25] of the Decision, the Tribunal held (CB 100 [25]):[25] The Tribunal accepts that the applicant had likely, for the purposes of a previous student visa application, provided the Department with evidence of him having health insurance until 15 March 2018. The Tribunal now has evidence before it that the applicant continued to have that insurance at the time of the visa application on 29 January 2018. However, although the Department had likely previously been provided with evidence of the applicant holding health insurance until 15 March 2018, it does not follow that at the time of the visa application that health insurance was still current (i.e. had not been cancelled at the time of the visa application or otherwise). The requirement of cl.485.215(1) is very specific and there is no discretion allowed. The visa application was required to be accompanied by evidence that the applicant had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance at that time. There is no discretion that can be exercised.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submitted that the Minister should have considered his health insurance documents that were on the Department’s files. When he applied for the visa, he completed the application himself and attempted each question to the best of his ability, however, the applicant did not meticulously read the Regulations. Had the applicant known he was required to submit his health insurance documents at the time of the application, he would have done so at the time. He again submitted that his incorrect response to question two of the application form was merely human error. CONSIDERATION The facts in this case are similar to (but not the same as) those in Ahmed v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCCA 622 (Ahmed No 1) per Judge Humphreys and on appeal in Ahmed v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1416 (Ahmed) per Rares J, both of which were decided after the Decision and were not cited in submissions in this case. In those cases, a Judge of the Federal Circuit Court (as it then was) and a Justice of the Federal Court considered the application by the Tribunal of cl 485.215 of Sch 2 of the Regulations to an application for a Temporary Graduate (Subclass 485) visa, where the applicant did not provide evidence of adequate health insurance until after the delegate’s decision not to grant the visa. Both Courts considered Anand and the decision of Judge Burchardt in Nguyen v Minister for Immigration andBorder Protection (2016) 310 FLR 339; [2016] FCCA 1523 (Nguyen) (which was cited by the Tribunal in the Decision). In Ahmed No 1 and Ahmed, the applicant applied for a Temporary Graduate (subclass 485) visa on 14 February 2017. In answer to question two on the application form, “Do you and all applicants included in this application hold health insurance?”, the applicant said “no”. On 18 April 2017, the Department wrote to the applicant requesting he provide further information. The information sought included that the applicant provide evidence that he held adequate health insurance from the time of lodgement of his application and that those arrangements were still in place. The applicant did not respond to that request. On 25 May 2017, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicant a visa on the basis that the applicant did not meet cl 485.215 of Sch 2 of the Regulations. The applicant then sought review by the Tribunal. In Ahmed No 1 and Ahmed, the applicant provided evidence to the Tribunal on 31 August 2018 (almost 18 months after the delegate’s decision) showing that he held health cover from 31 March 2017 (which was not at the time of the application). The Tribunal considered the decisions in Anand and Nguyen and concluded that there was no “temporal connection” between the application and the provision of evidence of insurance. The application for the visa was not accompanied by evidence of adequate arrangements for health insurance under cl 485.215(1). At first instance, Judge Humphreys dismissed the applicant’s application for judicial review and found that there was no jurisdictional error by the Tribunal.