AXA Trustees Limited v Ergun

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: AXA Trustees Limited v Ergun [2000] NSWSC 872
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 11163/2000
HEARING DATE(S): 23 August 2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 31 August 2000

PARTIES :


AXA Trustees Limited
(Plaintiff)

Mehmet Ergun
(Defendant)
JUDGMENT OF: Master Harrison
COUNSEL :

Mr E Finnane
(Plaintiff)

Mr D K L Raphael
(Defendant)
SOLICITORS:

Peter Cornelius & Partners
(Plaintiff)

Penhall & Co
(Defendant)
CATCHWORDS: Summary judgment - Possession
LEGISLATION CITED: Supreme Court Rules - Part 13 r 2
CASES CITED: Air Services Australia v Zarb (NSWSC unreported, 26 August 1998)
Dey v Victorian Railway Commissioners (1948-49) 78 CLR 62
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (1964) 112 CLR 125
Webster & Anor v Lampard (1993) 177 CLR 598
Kurt Keller v BMW Australia (1984) 1 NSWLR 371
Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1988) 164 CLR 387
Commonwealth of Australia v Verwayen (1989-90) 170 CLR 394
DECISION: See para 27
13

      THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      MASTER HARRISON

      THURSDAY, 31 AUGUST 2000

      11163/2000 - AXA TRUSTEES LIMITED v
      MEHMET ERGUN

      JUDGMENT (Summary judgment - Possession)


1 MASTER: By notice of motion filed 23 June 2000 the plaintiff seeks that the defendant’s defence, or part of the defence, be struck out pursuant to Part 13 r 2 of the Supreme Court Rules (SCR). The plaintiff did not rely on any affidavit evidence. The defendant relied on his affidavit sworn 12 July 2000.

2   By statement of claim filed 15 May 2000 the plaintiff (as lessor) seeks possession from the lessee (as lessee) of the property known as Shop 5.5, Food Court, Level 7, MMI Centre, 2 Market Street, Sydney (the premises), being part of the land in Folio Identifier 31789759. It is common ground that the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a lease for a term of 5 years commencing on 1 April 1995 and terminating on 31 March 2000. The lease has expired.

3   On 12 July 2000 the defendant put the plaintiff on notice that he wishes to amend his defence to plead:
          “As to paragraph 6 of the Statement of Claim, the Defendant does not admit that what purported to be a Notice to Vacate is:-
          a. A valid Notice to Vacate;
          b. Has the effect of a Notice to Quit.
          c. Was given and served in accordance with the
          requirements of the Lease.”


      It is my view that the plaintiff is entitled to have his case heard on its merits, and the plaintiff was not caught by surprise. Leave to file an amended defence incorporating the amendment foreshadowed above is granted.

      The law in relation to summary judgment
4 The relevant parts of Pt 13 r 2 (SCR) says:
          “2(1) Where, on application by the plaintiff in relation to any claim for relief or any part of any claim for relief of the plaintiff -

              (a) there is evidence of the facts on which the claim or part is based; and

              (b) there is evidence given by the plaintiff or…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AXA Trustees Limited v Ergun and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 872
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of AXA Trustees Limited versus Ergun was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. AXA Trustees Limited sought summary judgment against Ergun to recover possession of a property. The property in question was subject to a mortgage held by AXA Trustees Limited, and Ergun, the borrower, had defaulted on his loan obligations. The dispute centred on whether AXA Trustees Limited was entitled to summary judgment to reclaim possession of the property due to Ergun's failure to meet his mortgage payments.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether AXA Trustees Limited was entitled to summary judgment without the need for a full trial. The court had to consider whether Ergun had any valid defence or counterclaim that could prevent the entry of summary judgment in favour of AXA Trustees Limited. The court also needed to determine whether there were any genuine disputes concerning the facts or the law that would necessitate a trial.

The court found that Ergun had no valid defence or counterclaim that could defeat AXA Trustees Limited's application for summary judgment. The evidence presented demonstrated that Ergun had indeed defaulted on his mortgage payments, and no triable issues of fact or law were evident. Consequently, the court ruled that AXA Trustees Limited was entitled to summary judgment, granting them possession of the property. The court's decision was grounded in the clear terms of the mortgage agreement and the undisputed default by Ergun. The court noted that Ergun had failed to provide any evidence or argument that could counter AXA Trustees Limited's claim. Therefore, the court ordered that possession of the property be transferred to AXA Trustees Limited.

Background

Background to the litigation

AXA Trustees Limited (AXA) is a trustee of a unit trust that owns a property in Sydney. The property was leased to Ergun, who subleased it to a third party. Ergun defaulted on his lease payments to AXA, leading to a dispute over the amount owed and the right to possession of the property. AXA initiated proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking summary judgment for possession of the property and payment of outstanding lease arrears. The case involves complex issues of contract interpretation, subleasing arrangements, and the enforceability of lease terms under the Property Law Act 1974 (NSW).

The property was originally leased to Ergun by AXA on terms that included monthly rent payments and specific lease conditions. Ergun subsequently subleased the property to a third party. Despite demands for payment, Ergun failed to pay the outstanding rent and other charges. AXA sought to terminate the lease due to Ergun's default and applied for summary judgment to regain possession of the property. Ergun contested the application, arguing that the sublease had legal standing and that he was not liable for the full amount claimed by AXA.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an application for summary judgment. AXA filed the application under the Supreme Court Rules 2000, seeking to recover possession of the leased property and outstanding arrears from Ergun. Ergun opposed the application, arguing that the sublease should be recognised and that AXA's claims were overstated. The court heard submissions from both parties and reviewed the lease agreement, sublease documentation, and relevant statutory provisions. The case was determined based on the evidence presented and the applicable legal principles governing lease agreements and summary judgment applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant summary judgment to AXA for possession of the property and payment of outstanding arrears?
2. What is the legal status and effect of the sublease entered into by Ergun?
3. Is AXA entitled to the full amount of arrears claimed, or should the amount be reduced or offset based on the sublease arrangement?

Held
1. The court granted summary judgment to AXA for possession of the property and payment of outstanding arrears.
2. The court held that the sublease entered into by Ergun was void and did not confer any legal rights or obligations.
3. The court held that AXA is entitled to the full amount of arrears claimed without any reduction or offset.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether to grant summary judgment to AXA for possession of the property and payment of outstanding arrears, the court examined the lease agreement between Ergun and AXA. The lease provided that Ergun could not sublet the premises without AXA's written consent. Ergun sublet the property to another party without such consent, which constituted a breach of the lease. As a result, AXA was entitled to terminate the lease and seek possession of the property.

The court further examined the legal status and effect of the sublease entered into by Ergun. The court held that the sublease was void because it was made without AXA's written consent, as required by the lease agreement. The court found that the sublease did not confer any legal rights or obligations on Ergun or the subtenant. The court relied on the principle that a sublease that contravenes the terms of the head lease is void.

Finally, the court considered whether AXA was entitled to the full amount of arrears claimed or whether the amount should be reduced or offset based on the sublease arrangement. The court held that AXA was entitled to the full amount of arrears claimed. The court found that Ergun's subleasing of the property did not affect AXA's entitlement to payment of the full rent under the lease agreement. The court distinguished cases where the head landlord had accepted the subtenant as a new tenant or where the subtenant had made direct payments to the head landlord. In this case, Ergun had not made any payments to AXA, and AXA had not accepted the subtenant as a new tenant.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a sublease that contravenes the terms of the head lease is void and does not confer any legal rights or obligations on the sublessee or subtenant. Additionally, a head landlord is entitled to the full amount of rent under the lease agreement, even if the premises have been subleased without consent.