New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: AVS AUSTRALIAN VENUE SECURITY SERVICES PTY LTD v CRIMINALE [2006] NSWCA 368 HEARING DATE(S): 23 October 2006
JUDGMENT DATE:
15 December 2006JUDGMENT OF: Giles JA at 1; Tobias JA at 7; Basten JA at 8 DECISION: (1) To the extent that AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd requires leave in relation to the matters dealt with in this judgment grant leave to appeal in matter Nos. 40249 and 40765 of 2006.; (2) Dismiss the appeals.; (3) Order AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd to pay the costs of Ricky John Criminale of and incidental to the proceedings 40765 of 2005, 40225 of 2006 and 40249 of 2006 in this Court. CATCHWORDS: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – default judgment in absence of appearance by defendant – District Court Rules 1973 (NSW), Part 11 – standard directions by Registrar to file defence within 28 days – order for judgment obtained prior to expiration of that period – whether Registrar’s direction gave the defendant an unqualified right that the plaintiff take no steps under Part 11 until period in the direction had expired - JURISDICTION – statutory court – District Court Act 1973 (NSW), s 159 – whether District Court had “inherent jurisdiction” to set aside judgment - APPEAL – failure of trial judge to make a finding on a ground relied on by the defendant LEGISLATION CITED: District Court Act 1973 (NSW), ss 4, 68A, 159
District Court Rules 1973 (NSW), O 70, r 1; Part 3 r 2; Part 10 r 1, r 4; Part 11 r 1, r 2, r 3; Part 26 r 3, r 5A; Part 31 r 12A
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss 69, 135, 136
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 46
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 6.1, 6.9CASES CITED: Anlaby v Praetorius (1888) 20 QBD 764
Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No. 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300
Cameron v Cole (1944) 68 CLR 571
Coles v Burke (1987) 10 NSWLR 429
DJL v Central Authority (2000) 201 CLR 226
Grassby v The Queen (1989) 168 CLR 1
Hoskins v van Den-Braak (1998) 43 NSWLR 290
The King v Richmond Confirming Authority; Ex parte Howitt [1921] 1 KB 248
Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte Aala (2000) 204 CLR 82
Reg v Forbes; Ex parte Bevan (1972) 127 CLR 1
Roach v B & W Steel Pty Ltd (1991) 23 NSWLR 110
Smith v Budandan Enterprises (2002) 55 NSWLR 367
Taylor v Taylor (1979) 143 CLR 1
Wentworth v Graham (unrep, 17 April 2003)PARTIES: AVS Security Venue Security Services Pty Ltd - Appellant
Ricky John Criminale - RespondentFILE NUMBER(S): CA 40225/06; CA 40249/06; CA 40765/05 COUNSEL: H. Shore SC - Appellant
K. Andrews/D. Aquilina - RespondentSOLICITORS: CPC Lawyers, Merrylands - Appellant
CMC Laywers, Sydney - RespondentLOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 5166/02 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Karpin DCJ LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 26 August 2005; 14…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd v Criminale and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWCA 368
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Registrar's direction to file a defence within 28 days conferred an unqualified right on the appellant to have no further steps taken by the respondent under Part 11 of the District Court Rules 1973 (NSW) until that period had expired, and whether the District Court possessed inherent jurisdiction to set aside the default judgment. The Court also considered whether the trial judge's failure to make a finding on a specific ground relied upon by the appellant constituted an error.
The Court of Appeal held that the Registrar's direction did not grant an unqualified right to the appellant. It reasoned that the rules governing default judgments were designed to prevent undue delay and that the Registrar's directions were administrative in nature, not creating a substantive right that would prevent a plaintiff from seeking judgment if the defence was not filed within the stipulated time. Furthermore, the Court affirmed that the District Court, as a statutory court, possessed inherent jurisdiction to set aside judgments obtained irregularly or unfairly, but this jurisdiction was not invoked in a manner that would invalidate the default judgment in this instance. The Court found no error in the trial judge's handling of the grounds of appeal.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal where necessary and dismissed the appeals. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the proceedings in the Court of Appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) To the extent that AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd requires leave in relation to the matters dealt with in this judgment grant leave to appeal in matter Nos. 40249 and 40765 of 2006.; (2) Dismiss the appeals.; (3) Order AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd to pay the costs of Ricky John Criminale of and incidental to the proceedings 40765 of 2005, 40225 of 2006 and 40249 of 2006 in this Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case revolves around the interpretation of a standard directions order made under the District Court Rules 1973 (NSW) and the subsequent application to set aside a default judgment. AVS, a security services company, initiated legal proceedings against the defendant for the alleged conversion of its property. The District Court issued a standard directions order, requiring the defendant to file a defence within 28 days. Despite this order, AVS obtained a default judgment against the defendant before the 28-day period had elapsed. The defendant sought to set aside the default judgment, contending that the standard directions order entitled him to an unqualified right that AVS refrain from taking any action under Part 11 until the 28-day period had expired. The trial judge rejected this argument and dismissed the defendant's application. The defendant appealed this decision, arguing that the trial judge did not address his specific ground of appeal. AVS, in turn, cross-appealed, requesting leave to appeal the trial judge's refusal to grant an order for costs. The case thus concerns the interpretation of procedural rules and the appropriate circumstances under which a default judgment may be set aside.
The matter before the court originated in the District Court of New South Wales where AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd filed a claim against Ricky John Criminale. Following the issuance of proceedings, Criminale failed to appear or file a defence within the 28-day period stipulated by the Registrar under the District Court Rules 1973 (NSW), Part 11. Consequently, AVS obtained a default judgment against Criminale. Criminale subsequently sought to set aside the default judgment, arguing that the Registrar's direction did not unequivocally entitle AVS to proceed without further notice to Criminale until the 28-day period had lapsed. Criminale also challenged the District Court's jurisdiction to set aside the judgment, contending that the court lacked the inherent jurisdiction to do so under section 159 of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW). The matter then progressed to an appeal, wherein AVS contested Criminale's grounds for setting aside the judgment, specifically focusing on the trial judge's failure to address one of the defendant's arguments.
The appeal raised critical procedural questions regarding the interpretation and effect of the Registrar's directions, the court's inherent jurisdiction to set aside judgments, and the adequacy of the trial judge's findings. AVS argued that the trial judge's omission to consider a particular ground put forward by Criminale was a significant procedural error. The court of appeal examined these procedural contentions, including whether the trial judge's failure to address a specific ground warranted the setting aside of the default judgment. Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed, with the court affirming the original judgment and awarding costs against AVS for the proceedings in both the District Court and the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Registrar's direction under District Court Rules 1973 (NSW) Part 11 confer an unqualified right upon the defendant to prevent the plaintiff from taking any steps until the 28-day period for filing a defence had expired?
2. Is the District Court a statutory court with inherent jurisdiction under s 159 of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW) to set aside a default judgment?
3. Was the trial judge required to make a finding on each ground relied upon by the defendant for setting aside the default judgment, and if not, does this omission constitute a ground for appeal?
4. In what circumstances may the court grant leave to appeal when the appeal is otherwise dismissed on the merits?
5. Is the defendant entitled to an order for costs against the plaintiff under the circumstances of this case?
Held
1. The Registrar's direction under District Court Rules 1973 (NSW) Part 11 did not confer an unqualified right upon the defendant to prevent the plaintiff from taking any steps until the 28-day period for filing a defence had expired.
2. The District Court is not a statutory court with inherent jurisdiction under s 159 of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW) to set aside a default judgment.
3. The trial judge was not required to make a finding on each ground relied upon by the defendant for setting aside the default judgment, and this omission does not constitute a ground for appeal.
4. The court may grant leave to appeal when the appeal is otherwise dismissed on the merits under certain circumstances, as outlined in the judgment.
5. The defendant is not entitled to an order for costs against the plaintiff under the circumstances of this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd v Criminale, the court addressed several significant procedural and jurisdictional issues pertinent to the administration of justice in the District Court of New South Wales. The first issue considered was whether the Registrar's direction under the District Court Rules 1973 (NSW) Part 11 conferred an unqualified right on the defendant to prevent the plaintiff from taking any steps until the 28-day period for filing a defence had expired. The court held that the Registrar's direction was procedural in nature and did not confer an unqualified right on the defendant. Instead, it served as a guideline for the orderly conduct of proceedings, and the court retained the discretion to manage its own processes. The court emphasized that the direction was not intended to prevent the plaintiff from pursuing remedies in the event of non-compliance by the defendant.
Secondly, the court examined whether the District Court possesses the statutory jurisdiction under s 159 of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW) to set aside a default judgment. The court concluded that, as a statutory court, the District Court does indeed have the inherent jurisdiction to set aside a default judgment where there is a satisfactory explanation for the failure to defend. This inherent jurisdiction allows the court to correct its own errors or injustices that may arise from procedural defaults. The court relied on established case law which supports the notion that statutory courts have the inherent power to manage and regulate their own procedures to ensure justice is served.
The third issue pertained to the obligations of the trial judge when setting aside a default judgment. Specifically, the court considered whether the trial judge was required to make a finding on each ground relied upon by the defendant for setting aside the default judgment, and if the omission of such findings constitutes a ground for appeal. The court found that while it is preferable for a trial judge to address each ground for setting aside a default judgment, the absence of explicit findings on each ground does not necessarily invalidate the overall decision if the court’s reasoning is clear and the decision is justified. The omission of such findings does not constitute a ground for appeal if the overall decision is sound.
The fourth issue addressed the circumstances under which the court may grant leave to appeal when the appeal is otherwise dismissed on the merits. The court held that leave to appeal may be granted in exceptional cases where the appeal raises significant questions of law or procedure that warrant further examination by a higher court. In this case, the court granted leave to appeal to AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd to consider the broader issues of procedural fairness and jurisdictional authority, despite dismissing the appeal on its merits.
Finally, the court considered whether the defendant is entitled to an order for costs against the plaintiff under the circumstances of this case. The court found that the defendant, Ricky John Criminale, was not entitled to such an order. The court reasoned that the plaintiff had acted reasonably and in accordance with the procedural directions, and any costs incurred by the defendant were a consequence of the defendant’s own failure to comply with the court’s directions. Therefore, the court ordered AVS Australian Venue Security Services Pty Ltd to pay the costs of Ricky John Criminale of and incidental to the proceedings.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while the Registrar’s direction under the District Court Rules is procedural and does not confer an unqualified right on the defendant, the District Court has inherent jurisdiction to set aside a default judgment under s 159 of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW). Additionally, while it is preferable for a trial judge to address each ground for setting aside a default judgment, the omission does not necessarily invalidate the decision if it is otherwise sound. Finally, the court may grant leave to appeal in exceptional cases despite dismissing the appeal on the merits, and the defendant is not entitled to an order for costs against the plaintiff when the plaintiff has acted reasonably.