CITATION: Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Macdonald (No 7) [2008] NSWSC 1367 HEARING DATE(S): 16 December 2008 JUDGMENT OF: Gzell J EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 16 December 2008 DECISION: As the probative value was slight since the witness was unable to remember any of the matters put during the voir dire and unfair prejudice was established by the possible use of the evidence as going to credit, an order was made under s 135 of the Evidence Act not admitting the evidence on the voir dire as evidence in the proceedings. CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - Admissibility and Relevancy - Transcript of evidence volunteered by 5th defendant to plaintiff under a protocol containing a provision that it would not be tendered in evidence against the 5th defendant in a proceeding for the imposition of a penalty against him - Civil penalty proceedings - Plaintiff ordered to provide transcript to other parties in the proceedings - 1st defendant sought to cross-examine on the transcript - 1st defendant not bound by the protocol or s 68(3) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) - Whether 1st defendant bound by confidentiality - Whether equity would grant an injunction - Whether prevented from cross-examining by s 127(1)(a) of Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act or by the Evidence Act 1995, s 26, s 29, s 42, or s 44 - Voir dire held under s 189 to determine whether, in terms of s 135, the 5th defendant would be unfairly prejudiced by the admission of the cross-examination LEGISLATION CITED: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995PARTIES: Australian Securities and Investments Commission (Plaintiff)
Peter Donald Macdonald (First Defendant)
Peter James Shafron (Second Defendant)
Phillip Graham Morley (Third Defendant)
Michael Robert Brown (Fourth Defendant)
Michael John Gillfillan (Fifth Defendant)
Meredith Hellicar (Sixth Defendant)
Martin Koffel (Seventh Defendant)
Geoffrey Frederick O'Brien (Eighth Defendant)
Gregory James Terry (Ninth Defendant)
Peter John Willcox (Tenth Defendant)
ABN 60 Pty Ltd (Eleventh Defendant)
James Hardie Industries NV (Twelfth Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1490/07 COUNSEL: Mr A Bannon SC/ Mr R Beech-Jones SC/ Ms D Hogan-Doran/ Ms S Pritchard / Ms J Single/ Mr A Kuklik (Plaintiff)
Mr S Finch SC/ Mr D Studdy SC/ Mr D Mackay (First Defendant)
Mr B Walker SC/ Mr M Holmes QC/ Mr R Lancaster/ Mr N Owens (Second Defendant)
Mr B Oslington QC/ Mr R Dick/ Mr N Bender (Third Defendant)
Mr T Bathurst QC/ Mr R Whitington QC/ Mr R Hollo/ Mr R Hardcastle/ Mr I Colquhoun (Fourth to Seventh Defendants)
Mr P Wood/ Mr M Henry (Eighth Defendant)
Mr R McHugh SC/ Mr S Nixon (Ninth Defendant)
Mr T Jucovic QC/ Mr R Scruby (Tenth Defendant)
Mr I Pike (Eleventh Defendant)
Mr A Meagher SC/ Ms K Morgan (Twelfth Defendant)SOLICITORS: Clayton Utz (Plaintiff)
Minter Ellison (First Defendant)
Middletons (Second Defendant)
Henry Davis York (Third Defendant)
Atanaskovic Hartnell (Fourth to Seventh Defendants)
Arnold Block Leibler (Eighth Defendant)
Blake Dawson (Ninth Defendant)
Kemp Strang (Tenth Defendant)
Baker…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Macdonald (... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2008] NSWSC 1367
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Federal Court of Australia recently heard a case involving the Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC) and several defendants, including Macdonald. The primary dispute in this case concerned the admissibility of a transcript of evidence provided by the fifth defendant to ASIC, under a protocol which stated it would not be tendered against the fifth defendant in penalty proceedings. The first defendant sought to cross-examine the fifth defendant on this transcript. The court was tasked with determining whether the first defendant was bound by the confidentiality provisions of the protocol and whether equity would grant an injunction to prevent such cross-examination. The court also considered whether the first defendant's ability to cross-examine was restricted by sections of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 or by provisions of the Evidence Act 1995.
The court's reasoning began with the interpretation of the protocol's confidentiality clause. The court noted that the first defendant was not party to the protocol and thus was not bound by its terms. The court also examined whether equity would provide relief by way of an injunction, finding that the first defendant's ability to cross-examine was not restricted by the confidentiality provision. Furthermore, the court scrutinised whether statutory provisions in the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 or the Evidence Act 1995 hindered the cross-examination. The court held that the first defendant's right to cross-examine was not constrained by these provisions, concluding that the confidentiality clause did not apply to the first defendant.
The court's decision allowed the first defendant to cross-examine the fifth defendant on the transcript, rejecting the argument that the confidentiality clause should prevent such examination. The court emphasised that the first defendant, being a separate party to the proceedings, was not bound by the confidentiality agreement. The court also held that equity would not grant an injunction to prevent the cross-examination, and that statutory provisions did not restrict the first defendant's right to examine the fifth defendant. Consequently, the first defendant was permitted to proceed with the cross-examination, notwithstanding the confidentiality protocol.
The court's reasoning began with the interpretation of the protocol's confidentiality clause. The court noted that the first defendant was not party to the protocol and thus was not bound by its terms. The court also examined whether equity would provide relief by way of an injunction, finding that the first defendant's ability to cross-examine was not restricted by the confidentiality provision. Furthermore, the court scrutinised whether statutory provisions in the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 or the Evidence Act 1995 hindered the cross-examination. The court held that the first defendant's right to cross-examine was not constrained by these provisions, concluding that the confidentiality clause did not apply to the first defendant.
The court's decision allowed the first defendant to cross-examine the fifth defendant on the transcript, rejecting the argument that the confidentiality clause should prevent such examination. The court emphasised that the first defendant, being a separate party to the proceedings, was not bound by the confidentiality agreement. The court also held that equity would not grant an injunction to prevent the cross-examination, and that statutory provisions did not restrict the first defendant's right to examine the fifth defendant. Consequently, the first defendant was permitted to proceed with the cross-examination, notwithstanding the confidentiality protocol.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi