FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Goel [2020] FCA 1369
File number: WAD 221 of 2020 Judgment of: JACKSON J Date of judgment: 18 September 2020 Date of publication of reasons: 23 September 2020 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - ex parte application for interim asset preservation and travel restraint orders - Australian Securities and Investments Commission investigation into potential violations of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) and Criminal Code Act 1913 (WA) - interim orders made Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12DB
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1041G, 1041I, 1323
Criminal Code Act 1913 (WA) s 409
Sentencing Act 1995 (WA) s 117
Cases cited: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2001] NSWSC 451; (2001) 38 ACSR 266
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hawley [2008] FCA 1423
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Ivey (1998) 29 ACSR 391
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Johnston [2009] FCA 1276
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Ostrava Equities Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 425; (2015) 106 ACSR 332
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Secure Investments Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 639
Australian Securities and Investments Commission; In the Matter of Richstar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Carey (No 3) [2006] FCA 433; (2006) 232 ALR 577
Australian Securities and Investments Commission; In the Matter of Richstar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Carey (No 14) [2007] FCA 310; (2007) 158 FCR 92
Division: General Division Registry: Western Australia National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 35 Date of hearing: 18 September 2020 Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr J Moore QC with Ms L Black Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Counsel for the Defendants: The defendants did not appear ORDERS
WAD 221 of 2020 BETWEEN: AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Plaintiff
AND: RAHUL GOEL
First Defendant
AR WEALTH AND FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 614 732 802)
Second Defendant
ORDER MADE BY:
JACKSON J
DATE OF ORDER:
18 SEPTEMBER 2020
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Video hearing
1.For the purposes of today's interlocutory hearing, and pursuant to s 47B of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), counsel for the plaintiff is permitted to deliver oral submissions by way of video link.
Ex parte hearing and service
2.Service of the interlocutory application, originating process and supporting affidavit at any time before service of these orders on the defendants is dispensed with.
3.The originating application and interlocutory application are returnable before the court on an ex parte basis at 3.00 pm on Friday, 18 September 2020.
4.The plaintiff must serve on the defendants as soon as possible:
(a)these orders;
(b)the originating process;
(c)the interlocutory application;
(d)the affidavit of Ms Jessica Seymour dated 18 September 2020; and
(e)the plaintiff's written submissions dated 18 September 2020.
Interim asset preservation
5.Paragraphs 6, 7, and 8 of the following orders have effect until 8.00 pm on Thursday 24 September 2020 or such…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Goel and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCA 1369
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court determined that it was appropriate to grant the interim asset preservation and travel restraint orders, acknowledging the substantial impact these orders would have on the defendants' liberty. The court was cautious about making such orders, given the significant intrusion into the defendants' private rights. However, the potential for harm to the aggrieved persons, combined with the risk of asset dissipation and flight, justified the making of these interim orders. The court found that the level of dishonesty and impropriety alleged, and the significant amount of evidence supporting the allegations, increased the likelihood of asset dissipation and flight, which the proposed orders would guard against. Additionally, the ease with which the defendants could transfer assets out of the jurisdiction and Mr Goel's history of transferring cash overseas further supported the need for these orders. The court also noted that Mr Goel had few ties to Australia and could easily relocate, which added to the risk of flight.
The court made the following interim orders: the defendants were restrained from removing, selling, or disposing of their assets, and Mr Goel was prohibited from leaving Australia without the court's consent. Mr Goel was also required to surrender his passports and airline tickets. The defendants were further ordered to disclose detailed information about their assets, liabilities, income, and financial accounts to ASIC. The court granted ASIC leave to notify relevant authorities and financial institutions of the orders. The hearing was adjourned, and costs were reserved.
Orders
Orders of the court
Video hearing
1. For the purposes of today's interlocutory hearing, and pursuant to s 47B of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), counsel for the plaintiff is permitted to deliver oral submissions by way of video link.
Ex parte hearing and service
2. Service of the interlocutory application, originating process and supporting affidavit at any time before service of these orders on the defendants is dispensed with.
3. The originating application and interlocutory application are returnable before the court on an ex parte basis at 3.00 pm on Friday, 18 September 2020.
4. The plaintiff must serve on the defendants as soon as possible:
(a) these orders;
(b) the originating process;
(c) the interlocutory application;
(d) the affidavit of Ms Jessica Seymour dated 18 September 2020; and
(e) the plaintiff's written submissions dated 18 September 2020.
Interim asset preservation
5. Paragraphs 6, 7, and 8 of the following orders have effect until 8.00 pm on Thursday 24 September 2020 or such extended time as is ordered by the court.
6. Subject to paragraph 7 below, and pursuant to s 1323(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act, each of the defendants, by themselves and their servants, agents and employees is restrained from:
(a) removing, or causing or permitting to be removed from Australia all or any of the property (as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act) of the defendants (Property);
(b) selling, charging, mortgaging or otherwise dealing with, disposing of and/or diminishing the value of all or any of the Property;
(c) causing or permitting to be sold, charged, mortgaged or otherwise dealt with, disposed of, or diminished in value, all or any of the Property;
(d) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (c) above, incurring new liabilities including, without limitation, liabilities incurred either directly or indirectly, through the use of a credit card, a credit facility, a drawdown facility or a re-draw facility; and
(e) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) above, withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of or dealing with, any monies available in any account with any bank, building society or other financial institution (in Australia and elsewhere), in which the defendants have any legal or equitable interest.
7. The orders in the preceding paragraph do not prevent:
(a) the first defendant from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for ordinary living expenses up to $800 per week or such greater sum as may be set by the court;
(b) each of the defendants from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for costs reasonably incurred in these proceedings and any criminal proceedings arising from the plaintiff's investigation into the affairs of the each of the defendants; and
(c) any bank, building society or financial institution from exercising any right of set-off which it may have in respect of a facility afforded by it to each or any of the defendants prior to the date of these orders.
Travel restraint
8. Pursuant to s 1323(1)(k) and s 1323(3) of the Corporations Act, the first defendant is prohibited from leaving or attempting to leave Australia without the consent of the Court.
9. Pursuant to s 1323(1)(j) and s 1323(3) of the Corporations Act, the first defendant must deliver up forthwith to the Registry of this Court, to be held by the Registry until further order:
(a) any and all passports held by him, or otherwise in his possession, custody or control;
(b) any visa entitling him to enter, visit or reside in any country other than Australia; and
(c) any and all airline tickets concerning any travel arrangements made for the period commencing on the making of these orders and ending at noon on 17 March 2021.
10. Pursuant to s 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act and s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act, in the event that the first defendant cannot locate any Australian passport within one day of the making of these orders, he must file an affidavit stating that fact and annexing a copy of a written notification sent by him to the Department of Home Affairs or the Australian Passport Office informing them of the same.
Disclosure
11. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or privilege against civil penalty is made, each of the defendants must deliver or cause to be delivered to the plaintiff by Friday 2 October 2020, a full and detailed affidavit sworn, in the case of the first defendant by himself, and in the case of the second defendant by the first defendant on its behalf, setting out:
(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the defendant, together with the number of such account, the name of such account and the balance of that account;
(b) the name and address of any person or persons indebted to the defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;
(c) an itemised inventory of the defendant's assets and liabilities;
(d) an itemised inventory of any and all Property which, for the avoidance of doubt, must be real or personal property whether owned or controlled by the defendant and any property in which the defendant has any legal or beneficial interest;
(e) in respect of any Property which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred; and
(f) the sources and amount of any income, wages, earnings or other payments received by the defendants in the last 12 months and expected to be received by the defendants in the next 12 months.
12. If a defendant wishes to object that compliance with the orders in the preceding paragraphs may tend to incriminate that defendant or make that defendant liable to a civil penalty, that defendant must, in accordance with s 128A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth):
(a) prepare, file and serve on the plaintiff an affidavit disclosing so much of the information required to be disclosed by paragraph 11 to which no objection is taken;
(b) prepare an affidavit containing so much of the information required to be disclosed by paragraph 11 to which objection is taken and deliver it to the court in a sealed envelope; and
(c) prepare, file and serve on the plaintiff a separate affidavit setting out the basis of the objection.
Notice of orders to third parties
13. To the extent necessary, the plaintiff has leave to give to:
(a) the relevant authorities (domestic and overseas) that record, control and/or regulate the ownership of real property;
(b) the relevant authorities (domestic and overseas) that record, control and/or regulate the ownership of motor vehicles;
(c) the relevant authorities and entities (domestic and overseas) that record, control and/or regulate the ownership of securities;
(d) any bank, building society or other financial institution (domestic and overseas) with which, to the best of the plaintiff's knowledge and belief, any of the defendants operate any account;
(e) the relevant authorities that issue and control the use of passports; and
(f) any other person or entity (domestic and overseas), holding or controlling property which, to the best of the plaintiff's knowledge and belief, belongs to any of the defendants
notice of these orders, by delivering a copy of a minute of the orders to that entity or person and/or any person apparently in the employ of that entity or person.
General
14. Any party has liberty to apply to the court on 48 hours' notice.
15. The originating application and interlocutory application are adjourned to Thursday 24 September 2020 at 10.15 am AWST.
16. Costs reserved.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In relation to orders imposing travel restrictions, the court will be reluctant to make orders which impose restrictions on a person’s freedom of movement. The right to travel freely is an important private right which ought not be lightly interfered with. However, the public interest may outweigh that private right and justify an interference with it: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Johnston [2009] FCA 1276 at [8] (Siopis J); and Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Secure Investments Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 639 at [40] (Derrington J).Consideration In considering whether to make the orders that ASIC sought on an interim basis, I was conscious that freezing orders of the kind sought, and orders prohibiting travel, were substantial incursions into the liberty of the defendants and should not be made lightly. I was also conscious that ASIC was seeking the orders on an ex parte basis so that if the orders were made, that would occur before the defendants had an opportunity to oppose the orders. Nevertheless, I determined that it was appropriate to make the order sought for the following reasons:(1)The relevant precondition to the orders is satisfied here. ASIC is conducting an investigation into the conduct of the defendants. The conduct may involve contraventions of the Corporations Act, including s 1041G, which prohibits dishonest conduct in relation to a financial product of a financial service. It may also involve contraventions of the ASIC Act, including s 12DB, which prohibits the making of false and misleading representations in connection with the supply or possible supply of financial services. ASIC is also investigating whether the defendants' conduct involved breaches of the Criminal Code Act 1913 (WA), including s 409, which concerns fraud as an offence.(2)The conduct alleged against the defendants is at a high level of dishonesty and impropriety. It involves a pattern of identifying vulnerable members of the community who may be susceptible to the suggestion that they can obtain early access to superannuation funds, and inducing those persons to apply for that access without regard to their actual interests. The manner in which it is alleged that the applications were conducted may have involved impersonating the putative clients without their authority, using email accounts set up in the clients' names without their authority for the purposes of making the applications, forging signatures on application forms, and having money withdrawn from superannuation funds paid into the personal bank accounts of Mr Goel or associates. While money may have then been paid out to the putative clients, that was not without the deduction of substantial fees, which may not have been agreed with or authorised by the clients.(3)It goes without saying that if this conduct is established then, to the extent that it was carried out under the rubric of a financial advisory licence, it would fall grossly short of the standards of propriety to be expected of the authorised representatives of such a licensee, including many of the standards imposed by law.(4)ASIC's investigations into these matters are advanced, so while they are unproven allegations, they are not speculative and in some cases are based on specific evidence from aggrieved persons and objective evidence from reliable sources such as banks and AUSTRAC. In the ASIC examination Mr Goel partially confirmed the allegations, although he put a different complexion on them.(5)In those circumstances the level of dishonesty and impropriety alleged is significant to the risk assessment which the court must undertake. It increases the likelihood of dissipation of assets and flight against which the proposed orders would guard.(6)The number of aggrieved persons is large and the conduct alleged is likely to be important to those persons. While each putative fee which Mr Goel, AR Wealth and associates may have obtained from those persons might not be a large sum of money when considered alone, it is likely to be of substantial importance to at least some of the aggrieved persons given their individual circumstances. In the case of Mr M, for example, the alleged fee appears to have been around a quarter of the total sum withdrawn from his superannuation and in the case of Ms C it was nearly 20%.(7)The dishonesty involved in the alleged conduct, and the manner in which it resulted in the aggrieved persons, gives rise to a real possibility that Mr Goel and AR Wealth are liable to compensate those persons for the moneys that have been appropriated or otherwise account to them. For example, if a breach of s 1041G is established, then any person who suffered loss as a result of conduct engaged in contravention of that section may recover the amount of the loss or damage from the contravenor: Corporations Act s 1041I(1).(8)The assets of the defendants in Australia which have been identified are comprised of cash which would be easy to transfer out of the jurisdiction or otherwise put out of the reach of creditors. Mr Goel has a history of transferring cash overseas.(9)Mr Goel has appears to have few ties to Australia. Relocating to India, the country in which he was borne and where he still has family, would seem to be a practicable option for him. He has an aeroplane ticket and an exemption to leave the country which would enable him to do so at any time.