Australia Securities and Investments Commission v Prakash

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australia Securities and Investments Commission v Prakash [2024] FCA 321  

File number(s): QUD 168 of 2024
Judgment of: MEAGHER J
Date of judgment: 28 March 2024
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – investigations by Australian Securities and Investments Commission – ex parte application for appointment of receivers, asset preservation, disclosure and travel restriction orders – where ASIC suspects contraventions of s 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act); ss 911A, 912A and 1041G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and s 408C of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) – whether it is necessary or desirable that orders be made – interim orders made
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001(Cth) ss12, 13

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 192A, 911A, 912A, 1041, 1323(1)

Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) s 408C

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s35

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 32
Date of hearing: 28 March 2024
Counsel for the Plaintiff: S M Derrington
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Australian Securities and Investments Commission

ORDERS

QUD 168 of 2024
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Plaintiff

AND:

SUNNY MAHENDRA PRAKASH

First Defendant

PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL SERVICE PTY LTD

Second Defendant

SELF-MANAGED SUPER PTY LTD (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

MEAGHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 MARCH 2024

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

1.Property: means property defined under section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Ex Parte / Short Service Orders

1.The Plaintiff have leave to file:

(a)its outline of written submissions dated 28 March 2024 (Submissions); and

(b)a further affidavit of Mr Brett Jamal Crawford sworn on 28 March 2024 in support of the Plaintiff’s application (Second Affidavit).

2.In the first instance, service of this Originating Process be dispensed with and the prayers for interim relief at paragraphs 9, 11 to 18 and 20 to 22 of the Originating Process be made returnable instanter.

3.The time for service of this Originating Process and the affidavit of Brett Jamal Crawford sworn 27 March 2024 (Supporting Affidavit) be abridged to 5:00 pm on 3 April 2024.

4.This Originating Process be returnable before the Commercial and Corporations Duty Judge or List Judge at a date convenient to the Court.

Non-Publication

5.Pursuant to section 37AF(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the grounds set out in section 37AG(1)(a), the following details of the any clients of the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants, referred to in the proceeding:

(a) their names;

(b) their postal or residential addresses;

(c) their email addresses;

(d) their telephone numbers;

(e) their dates of birth; and

(f) any account details associated with them,

be prohibited from publication.

Non-Party Access

6.Any application made by a non-party pursuant to rule 2.34 of the Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) to inspect the following documents:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australia Securities and Investments Commission v Prakash and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australia Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) filed an application in the Federal Court against Mr Prakash and four companies in which he has an interest, relating to suspected breaches of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act), the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld). The Commission is investigating suspected misappropriation of client funds and unauthorised share trading. The application sought ex parte orders for the appointment of receivers, asset preservation, disclosure and travel restriction orders in relation to the five respondents. The primary legal issue the court had to determine was whether it was necessary and desirable to make the orders ASIC had applied for. ASIC submitted that the investigation was in its early stages and that the respondents were aware of the allegations against them. ASIC was concerned that the respondents would dissipate their assets, which would prejudice the outcome of the investigation.

The court found that it was necessary and desirable to make the orders sought. ASIC had shown that there were reasonable grounds to suspect that the respondents had engaged in conduct that would constitute contraventions of the ASIC Act, the Corporations Act and the Criminal Code Act. The respondents had not provided any evidence to rebut the suspicions raised by ASIC’s investigation. The court found that it was necessary to restrain the respondents from removing assets from Australia and to preserve their assets, as ASIC had demonstrated that it was likely that the respondents had dissipated their assets in the past and would do so again if not restrained. The court also found that the respondents should be required to disclose detailed information about their financial dealings and assets. The court further found that it was necessary to prevent the first respondent from leaving Australia as there was a significant risk that he would do so if not restrained.

The court made the orders ASIC had applied for. It restrained the respondents from removing, selling or otherwise dealing with their assets, and ordered them to provide detailed information about their financial dealings and assets. The court also prohibited the first respondent from leaving Australia and ordered him to surrender his passports and travel documents to the court. The court further ordered that ASIC could serve its originating process on third parties without prior service on the respondents and that it could provide the respondents with copies of its affidavits and court transcripts within a short time frame.

Orders

Orders of the court

Ex Parte / Short Service Orders

1. The Plaintiff have leave to file:

(a) its outline of written submissions dated 28 March 2024 (Submissions); and

(b) a further affidavit of Mr Brett Jamal Crawford sworn on 28 March 2024 in support of the Plaintiff’s application (Second Affidavit).

2. In the first instance, service of this Originating Process be dispensed with and the prayers for interim relief at paragraphs 9, 11 to 18 and 20 to 22 of the Originating Process be made returnable instanter.

3. The time for service of this Originating Process and the affidavit of Brett Jamal Crawford sworn 27 March 2024 (Supporting Affidavit) be abridged to 5:00 pm on 3 April 2024.

4. This Originating Process be returnable before the Commercial and Corporations Duty Judge or List Judge at a date convenient to the Court.

Non-Publication

5. Pursuant to section 37AF(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the grounds set out in section 37AG(1)(a), the following details of the any clients of the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants, referred to in the proceeding:

(a) their names;

(b) their postal or residential addresses;

(c) their email addresses;

(d) their telephone numbers;

(e) their dates of birth; and

(f) any account details associated with them,

be prohibited from publication.

Non-Party Access

6. Any application made by a non-party pursuant to rule 2.34 of the Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) to inspect the following documents:

(a) any affidavits filed by ASIC, including the Supporting Affidavit and Exhibit BJC-1 to the Supporting Affidavit; and

(b) the Submissions,

and for which access is not otherwise permitted under rule 2.32(2) be considered only after notice of the application has been given to the parties and they have been given a reasonable time to respond.

Asset Preservation Orders

7. Subject to paragraph 8 below, until further order, the First, Second, Third, Fourth and Fifth Defendants, by themselves or their agents and employees are restrained from:

(a) removing, or causing or permitting to be removed from the State of Queensland and from Australia all or any of their Property;

(b) selling, charging, mortgaging or otherwise dealing with, disposing of and/or diminishing the value of all or any of their Property;

(c) causing or permitting to be sold, charged, mortgaged, or otherwise dealt with, disposed of, or diminished in value, all, or any of their Property;

(d) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (c) above, incurring liabilities including, without limitations, liabilities incurred either directly or indirectly, through the use of a credit card, a credit facility, a drawdown facility, or a re-draw facility; and

(e) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) above, withdrawing, transferring, or otherwise disposing of any monies available in any account with any bank, building society, cryptocurrency exchange or other financial institution, in which the Defendant has legal or equitable interest.

8. Order 7 above does not prevent:

(a) the First Defendant from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for ordinary, bonefide and properly incurred living and operating expenses up to an amount of eight hundred dollars ($800) per week;

(b) the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for costs reasonably incurred in these proceedings and any criminal proceedings arising from the Plaintiff’s investigation into the affairs of the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants; and

(c) any bank, building society or financial institution from exercising any right of set-off which it may have in respect of a facility afforded by it to the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants prior to the date of these Orders.

Disclosure Orders

9. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after the date of service of these Orders, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the First Defendant setting out, to the best of the First Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at

(a) which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the First Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email address, if known) of any person or persons indebted to the First Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(c) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email address, if known) of any clients of the First Defendant;

(d) an itemised inventory of the First Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(e) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the First Defendant or in which the First Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(f) in respect of any of the Property of the First Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

10. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after the date of service of these Orders, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Second Defendant setting out, to the best of the Second Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Second Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email address, if known) of any person or persons indebted to the Second Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(c) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email address, if known) of any clients of the Second Defendant;

(d) an itemised inventory of the Second Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(e) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Second Defendant or in which the Second Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(f) in respect of any of the Property of the Second Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

11. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 day after the date of service of these Orders, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Third Defendant setting out, to the best of the Third Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Third Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email

address, if known) of any person or persons indebted to the Third Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(c) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email address, if known) of any clients of the Third Defendant;

(d) an itemised inventory of the Third Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(e) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Third Defendant or in which the Third Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(f) in respect of any of the Property of the Third Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

12. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after the date of service of these Orders, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Fourth Defendant setting out, to the best of the Fourth Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Fourth Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email

address, if known) of any person or persons indebted to the Fourth Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(c) an itemised inventory of the Fourth Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(d) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Fourth Defendant or in which the Fourth Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(e) in respect of any of the Property of the Fourth Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and he debt so incurred.

13. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 day after the date of service of these Orders, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Fifth Defendant setting out, to the best of the Fifth Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Fifth Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) the name and contact details (including address, telephone number and email

address, if known) of any person or persons indebted to the Fifth Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(c) an itemised inventory of the Fifth Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(d) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Fifth Defendant or in which the Fifth Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(e) in respect of any of the Property of the Fifth Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

14. In the event that the First, Second, Third, Fourth or Fifth Defendants wish to object to compliance with Orders 9 to 13 above, on the basis that compliance may tend to incriminate the Defendant or make the Defendant liable to a civil penalty, the relevant

Defendant must, in accordance with section 128A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth):

(a) prepare, file, and serve on the Plaintiff an affidavit disclosing so much of the information required to be disclosed by Orders 9 to 13 which no objection is taken;

(b) prepare an affidavit containing so much of the information required to be disclosed by Orders 9 to 13 to which objection is taken and deliver it to the Court in a sealed envelope; and

(c) prepare, file, and serve on the Plaintiff a separate affidavit setting out the basis of the objection.

Travel Restraint Orders

15. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, in the first instance until further order, the First Defendant be prohibited from leaving Australia or attempting to leave Australia.

16. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act, within five (5) days of the date of service of these Orders, the First Defendant deliver up to the Queensland registry of this Court:

(a) all passports in his name which are in his possession, custody, or control;

(b) any tickets in his name concerning any international travel arrangements made for the twelve (12) month period commencing from the date of these Orders; and

(c) any copy in his possession, custody, or control of any application in his name for a passport, replacement passport, or other document permitting international travel made to the authorities of any country on or after the date of these Orders.

17. The documents delivered up to the Queensland Registry pursuant to Order 16 above be held by the Court pending the determination of the relief in paragraphs 17 to 20 of the Originating Process and in the first instance until further order.

18. In the event that the First Defendant cannot locate any passport or other document permitting international travel, he promptly:

(a) give notification to the Australian Passport Office, or other relevant authorities responsible for the issue and control of Australian passports or travel documents, or, in the case of a foreign passport or travel document, the relevant authority responsible for the issue and control of such passports or travel documents, confirming that he has lost his passport or travel document; and

(b) file and serve an affidavit stating that fact and exhibiting a copy of the above notification sent.

19. Pursuant to section 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1974 (Cth) that, in the first instance until further order, the First Defendant may not apply for the issue of any passport.

Service of Orders on Third Parties

20. To the extent necessary, the Plaintiff has leave to give to:

(a) the relevant authorities that record, control, and regulate the ownership of real property;

(b) the relevant authorities that record, control, and regulate the ownership of motor

(c) vehicles;

(d) the relevant authorities that record, control, and regulate the ownership of maritime vessels and craft;

(e) any bank, building society, cryptocurrency exchange or other financial institution through which, to the best of the Plaintiff’s belief, any of the Defendants operates any account;

(f) any other person or entity, holding or controlling Property, which, to the best of the Plaintiff’s belief, belongs to any of the Defendants;

(g) the relevant authorities that issue and control of passports; and

(h) the Australian Border Force,

notice of these Orders, by delivering a copy of a minute of the Orders to a person apparently in the employ of that entity or person.

General Orders

The Plaintiff is to provide the First, Second, Third, Fourth and Fifth Defendants with a copy of the Second Affidavit and the transcript of the interlocutory hearing before 5:00 pm on 3 April 2024, or if a copy of such transcript is not available by that time, as soon as reasonably practicable after a copy of the transcript becomes available.

22.Costs be reserved.

23. An order that there be liberty to any party to apply to the Commercial and Corporation

List Judge on reasonable notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The concerns raised by CommSec were as to the manner in which the defendant’s invested money on behalf of the clients, movements of money between clients’ accounts and those of the defendants, including Mr Prakash’s personal accounts and those of other defendants, and as to whether Mr Prakash was investing client funds for his own purposes. CommSec have suspended the defendants’ accounts until 2 April 2024. Thereafter, CommSec proposes to close the defendants’ suspended accounts.BACKGROUND ASIC’s concerns relate to misappropriation of client funds and unauthorised share trading. They are therefore conducting investigations into the first and second defendants pursuant to section 13 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act), with respect to suspected contraventions of section 12CB of the ASIC Act, sections 912A and 1041G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and section 408C of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld). ASIC are also investigating suspected contraventions of section 911A of the Corporations Act and the conduct of the third, fourth and fifth defendants. The basis of the investigations is that the first defendant provides financial services as an authorised representative of the second defendant and conducts his business through the third defendant. Further, the fourth and fifth defendant are entities of the first defendant. While the investigation was initially limited to the first and second defendant, on 22 March 2024, ASIC widened its investigation to include the third, fourth and fifth defendant. ASIC noted additional concerns raised by the conduct of the fourth defendant in which ASIC was alerted to the fact that one of the first defendant’s clients holds a $1 million term deposit with the fourth defendant, but ASIC has been unable to identify it in the bank accounts of any of the defendants. In that regard, ASIC submitted that the client may have been misled as to the nature of the investment. The investigations are at an early stage. Mr Prakash first became aware of them when ASIC executed a search warrant at his home and the business premises of the corporate defendants on 27 March 2024. The investigation is likely to take at least nine months. In conducting its investigation, ASIC has undertaken searches of its databases, interrogated information obtained pursuant to section 30 of the ASIC Act from financial institutions and had communications with either clients of Mr Prakash or representatives of those clients, who have assisted by providing information. According to Mr Crawford’s affidavit, the investigations so far undertaken by ASIC, including detailed financial analysis of the defendants’ bank accounts and statements, show that funds have been transferred from clients’ Commonwealth Direct Investment Account or CommSec accounts into a bank account or CommSec account of the defendants. In some instances, the funds stayed in those accounts, and in others they were transferred to the account of another client, often on the same day.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established