Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Franklin

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Franklin (liquidator), in the matter of Walton Constructions Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 85

Citation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Franklin (liquidator), in the matter of Walton Constructions Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 85
Appeal from: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Franklin (liquidator), in the matter of Walton Constructions Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 68
Parties: AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v GLENN J FRANKLIN, STIRLING L HORNE, JASON G STONE, WALTON CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (ACN 060 900 218) (IN LIQ) and WALTON CONSTRUCTION (QLD) PTY LTD (ACN 100 833 225) (IN LIQ)
File number: VID 123 of 2014
Judges: JESSUP, ROBERTSON AND WHITE JJ
Date of judgment: 18 July 2014
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – insolvency – winding up – appeal from decision refusing application to remove liquidators – whether judge erred in statement of test for apprehension of bias – whether apprehension of bias arises in circumstances including liquidators needing to investigate transactions involving a corporate group with whom the liquidators have a referral relationship

CORPORATIONS – insolvency – voluntary administration – appeal from decision refusing application for declarations that administrators contravened s 436DA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Legislation:

1            Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 15, 60, 79, 180-184, 436A 436DA, 436E, 439A, 439C, 446A, 491, 497, 499, 503, 588FB, 588FDA, 1311
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 97

Cases cited:

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission v Jurnkurakurr Aboriginal Resource Centre Aboriginal Corp (in liq) (1992) 10 ACSR 121
Accord Pacific Holdings Pty Ltd v Gleeson [2011] NSWSC 1021
Advance Housing Pty Ltd (in liq) v Newcastle Classic Developments Pty Ltd (1994) 14 ACSR 230
Australian National Industries Ltd v Spedley Securities Ltd (in liq) (1992) 26 NSWLR 411
Barnes v Addy (1874) 9 LR Ch App 244
Cabcharge Australia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2010] FCAFC 111
Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Peabody (1994) 181 CLR 359
Domino Hire Pty Ltd v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 496; (2003) 21 ACLC 1,330
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; (2000) 205 CLR 337
McGovern v Ku-ring-gai Council [2008] NSWCA 209; (2008) 72 NSWLR 504
Re Biposo Pty Ltd (1995) 17 ACSR 730
Re Chevron Furnishers Pty Ltd (No 2) (in liq) [1995] 1 Qd R 125
Re Club Superstores Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (1993) 10 ACSR 730
Re National Safety Council of Australia [1990] VR 29
Re Queensland Stations Pty Ltd (in liq) (1991) 9 ACLC 1,341
Webb v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 41

Wood v Targett (1997) 23 ACSR 291

Date of hearing: 5 May 2014
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 132
Counsel for the Appellant: P Crutchfield QC with O Bigos
Solicitor for the Appellant: Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Counsel for the Respondents: N J O’Bryan SC with M J Galvin
Solicitor for the Respondents: Madgwicks Lawyers

IN THE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Franklin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCAFC 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) appeals against the Federal Court’s refusal to remove the respondents as liquidators of Walton Construction Pty Ltd and Walton Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd, and to declare that the respondents contravened s 436DA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). ASIC contends that the primary Judge misstated the test for apprehension of bias and erred in rejecting ASIC’s claim that the respondents were biased. ASIC also contends that the primary Judge erred in concluding that the respondents’ declarations of relevant relationships were sufficient. The respondents cross-appeal against the refusal to declare that they contravened s 436DA.

The appeal requires the Court to determine whether the primary Judge erred in her approach to the question of apprehension of bias. The appeal also requires the Court to determine whether the primary Judge erred in concluding that the respondents’ declarations of relevant relationships were sufficient. The cross-appeal requires the Court to determine whether the primary Judge erred in concluding that the respondents did not contravene s 436DA.

The appeal against the decision to refuse to remove the respondents as liquidators succeeds. The primary Judge misstated the test for apprehension of bias. The primary Judge said (at [2]) that a liquidator may be disqualified from acting where the hypothetical fair-minded observer would perceive a lack of independence or impartiality on the part of the liquidator in the discharge of his or her functions, even where independence and impartiality have in fact been maintained. That is not the correct statement of the test. The test requires a logical connection between the matters which, it is said, may impede or inhibit the liquidator from acting impartially and the feared deviation from discharging his or her duties and responsibilities impartially. A fair-minded observer, appropriately informed, might reasonably apprehend that the respondents would not bring an impartial and unprejudiced mind to the investigation of the pre-administration transactions and would favour interests associated with the Mawson Group at the expense of the interested creditors, whether consciously or not.

The appeal against the decision to refuse to declare that the respondents contravened s 436DA fails. The primary Judge was correct to conclude that the respondents’ declarations of relevant relationships were sufficient. The declarations were made in good faith and were not misleading. The cross-appeal fails for the same reason. The respondents did not contravene s 436DA.

The Court orders that ASIC be given leave to appeal against the fourth and fifth respondents; that the parties are to confer and, by no later than close of business on 22 July 2014, to file and serve minutes of the orders necessary to give effect to the conclusion that the respondents be removed as liquidators of Walton Construction Pty Ltd and Walton Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd; and that otherwise, the appeal be dismissed. The parties are to bear their own costs of the appeal and of the cross-appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission be given leave to commence the appeal against the fourth and fifth respondents.

2. The parties are to confer and, by no later than close of business on 22 July 2014, to file and serve minutes of the orders necessary to give effect to the conclusion that Messrs Franklin, Horne and Stone be removed as liquidators of Walton Construction Pty Ltd and Walton Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd; and as to costs.

3. Otherwise, the appeal be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the conduct of its case, ASIC gave greater attention to the second aspect and the primary Judge addressed the case on that basis. The Judge dismissed both parts of ASIC’s application: Re Walton Construction Pty Ltd (in liq); ASIC v Franklin [2014] FCA 68. ASIC now appeals to this Court against that decision.Background WCPL was involved in the construction industry in Victoria and New South Wales, and WCQPL in the construction industry in Queensland. At material times, Craig Walton has been the sole director and secretary of each company. It was Mr Walton who, in his capacity as director, appointed the respondents as administrators of the two companies on 3 October 2013. At the first creditors’ meeting of each company (held separately but contemporaneously on 15 October 2013), the respondents as administrators reported that the two companies had faced financial difficulties in the previous 18 months and that, in about March or April 2013, each company had retained the Mawson Group to provide advice about its options. The Mawson Group provides, amongst other things, business advisory and restructuring services. Mawson Group Holdings Pty Ltd (MGH) is the holding company in the group. Its wholly owned subsidiaries include Mawson Business Advisory Pty Ltd (Mawson Advisory) and Mawson Restructures and Workouts Pty Ltd (Mawson Restructures). The directors of MGH at relevant times were Julian Kirzner, Stephen Knapp and Patrick McCurry. They were also the directors of Mawson Advisory and Mawson Restructures. Mr Phillip Spry was, at relevant times, an employee in the Mawson Group. Shortly before the appointments of the administrators, WCPL and WCQPL entered into a number of transactions with entities created, owned and/or directed by persons connected with the Mawson Group. Those transactions included:(1)An Asset Sale Agreement (ASA) dated 20 September 2013 by which Lewton Asset Services Pty Ltd (Lewton) acquired a significant portion of WCPL’s business, including construction contracts. The effective consideration provided by Lewton was the assumption of some of WCPL’s liabilities. Lewton was incorporated on 6 August 2013. Its director is a Mr Daniel Casey and its office and registered place of business the same as those of the Mawson Group. Lewton is wholly owned by RIU Pty Ltd. The evidence did not disclose the owners of the shares in RIU Pty Ltd.(2)An ASA dated 30 September 2013 by which Tantallon Constructions Pty Ltd (Tantallon), then known as Peloton Builders Pty Ltd, acquired a significant part of WCQPL’s business, including construction contracts. Again, the consideration provided by Tantallon was the assumption of some of WCQPL’s liabilities.Tantallon was incorporated on 27 June 2012 and its registered office is the same as that of the Mawson Group. Its sole director is Mr Kirzner. He was replaced as a director on 24 September 2013 (shortly before the ASA was executed), but resumed that office on 13 November 2013 (shortly after the second creditors’ meeting of WCQPL).Tantallon is majority‑owned by RZL-Holdings (Qld) Pty Ltd (RZL). RZL’s sole director is Mr McCurry, but Mr Spry was a director from 5 August 2013 to 12 November 2013. RZL is a wholly owned subsidiary of Mawson Beneficiary Pty Ltd (Mawson Beneficiary), whose directors are Mr Kirzner, Mr Knapp and Mr McCurry.40% of the shares in Mawson Beneficiary are owned by Staple Elements Pty Ltd, the sole director and shareholder of which is Mr Kirzner; 40% by Peemac Corporation Pty Ltd (Peemac), the sole director and shareholder of which is Mr McCurry; and 20% by Stenala Pty Ltd (Stenala), the sole director and shareholder of which is Mr Knapp.(3)A Deed of Arrangement dated 18 September 2013 by which an inter-company debt of $18.9 million said to be owed by WCPL to WCQPL was assigned, for a consideration of $30,000, to QHT Investments Pty Ltd (QHT).QHT, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Providence Growth Solutions Pty Ltd (Providence Growth), has as its sole director Mr McCurry. The directors of Providence Growth are Mr McCurry and Mr Knapp. Peemac and Stenala own 80% and 20% respectively of the shares in Providence Growth.(4)A Deed of Assumption, and Specific Security Deeds, dated 23 September 2013 between WCPL, WCQPL, Lewton Maintenance Services Pty Ltd (LMS) and Lewton Maintenance Services (Queensland) Pty Ltd (LMSQ).Lewton is the sole shareholder in LMS, which was incorporated on 6 August 2013. Mr Casey is also the director of LMS. The registered office and principal place of business of LMS are the same as those of the Mawson Group.Tantallon is the sole shareholder in LMSQ (which was incorporated on 5 August 2013) and Mr Casey its sole director (although Mr Kirzner was a director from 5 August 2013 until 12 September 2013). The registered office and principal place of business of LMSQ are the same as those of the Mawson Group.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLENN J
Secondly, ASIC emphasised the evidence indicating that some at least of the creditors of WCPL and WCQPL had raised concerns about the independence and impartiality of the respondents in acting as liquidators of the companies.The decision of the Judge The primary Judge rejected ASIC’s claim concerning bias. The Judge considered that a fair-minded observer, appropriately informed, would be aware that it is the statutory duty and responsibility of liquidators to discover whether any transactions are voidable, whether there was unlawful conduct, and whether there was conduct giving rise to civil or criminal liability (at [8]). The Judge also considered that a fair-minded observer, appropriately informed, would know that LDD is commonly referred voluntary administrations and other insolvency work by solicitors, business advisers and accountants; that this was the nature of the firm’s relationship with the Mawson Group; that the Mawson Group is a business advisory firm providing corporate restructuring advice to troubled companies; that its relationship with WCPL and WCQPL was “a professional one”; and that there was nothing about the conduct of other insolvencies referred by the Mawson Group to LDD which brought the firm’s independence and impartiality into question (at [9]). The primary Judge concluded at [9] that, with this imputed knowledge, the fair-minded observer “may reasonably conclude” that the respondents would discharge their statutory duties and responsibilities impartially and as required by law, uninfluenced by their relationship with the Mawson Group. The Judge also rejected the submission that any deficiencies in the DIRRIs provided by the respondents to creditors would have given rise to a “heightened” apprehension of bias (at [9]).An error in approach? ASIC submitted that, in reaching her decision concerning the alleged apprehension of bias, the primary Judge had misstated the principle to be applied and had thereby erred. The Judge commenced her consideration of ASIC’s submission by saying (at [2]):It is settled law that a liquidator may be disqualified from continuing to act in the winding up of a company where the hypothetical fair-minded observer would perceive a lack of independence or impartiality on the part of the liquidator in the discharge of his or her functions, even where independence and impartiality have in fact been maintained.(Emphasis added)Later, at [6], the Judge said:The test for determining whether a hypothetical fair minded observer would apprehend a lack of independence and impartiality requires the articulation of a logical connection between the matters which, it is said, may impede or inhibit the liquidators from acting impartially in the interests of all creditors in the discharge of their duties and the feared deviation from discharging their duties and responsibilities impartially …(Emphasis added)Earlier, at [4], the Judge said:ASIC argued that these circumstances give rise to a reasonable perception or apprehension that the liquidators would not bring an impartial and unprejudiced mind to the investigation of the pre-administration transactions, and would favour interests associated with the Mawson Group at the expense of the interested creditors, whether consciously or not …(Emphasis added)The passage at [4] is, in my opinion, less significant for present purposes because the Judge was reciting, accurately, the terms of one submission made by ASIC’s then counsel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLENN J

The relevant part of s 60 was in the following terms:60 Declaration of relevant relationshipsAdministrator(1)In this Act, a declaration of relevant relationships, in relation to an administrator of a company under administration, means a written declaration:(a)stating whether any of the following:(i)the administrator;(ii)if the administrator’s firm (if any) is a partnership—a partner in that partnership;(iii)if the administrator’s firm (if any) is a body corporate—that body corporate or an associate of that body corporate;has, or has had within the preceding 24 months, a relationship with:(iv)the company; or(v)an associate of the company; or(vi)a former liquidator, or former provisional liquidator, of the company; or(vii)a person who is entitled to enforce a security interest in the whole, or substantially the whole, of the company’s property (including any PPSA retention of title property); and(b)if so, stating the administrator’s reasons for believing that none of the relevant relationships result in the administrator having a conflict of interest or duty. The definition of “associate” on which ASIC relied was in the following terms:15 General(1) The associate reference includes a reference to:(a)a person in concert with whom the primary person is acting, or proposes to act; and(b)a person who, under the regulations, is, for the purposes of the provision in which the associate reference occurs, an associate of the primary person; and(c)a person with whom the primary person is, or proposes to become, associated, whether formally or informally, in any other way;in respect of the matter to which the associate reference relates.(2)If the primary person has entered, or proposes to enter, into a transaction, or has done, or proposes to do, any act or thing, in order to become associated with another person as mentioned in an applicable provision of this Division, the associate reference includes a reference to that other person. The DIRRIs were in the following terms:i. Circumstances of AppointmentMr Franklin had one meeting with Mr. C. Walton, the company’s director, on 27th September 2013 for the purposes of discussing the financial position of the company and the insolvency options available.We received no remuneration for this advice.This does not affect our independence for the following reasons:• The courts and the IPA’s Code of Professional Practice specifically recognise the need for practitioners to provide advice on the insolvency process and the options available and do not consider that such advice results in a conflict or is an impediment to accepting the appointment.• This meeting … set out the insolvency options available, the process involved in each option and the ramifications under alternative options. The advice will not influence our ability to be able to fully comply with the statutory and fiduciary obligations associated with the voluntary administration of the company in an objective and impartial matter [sic].ii. Relevant relationships (excluding professional services to the insolvent)…iv. No other relevant relationships to discloseThe [companies were] referred by Mr. P. McCurry of Mawson Group, who refers us insolvency type matters from time to time. Referrals from solicitors, business advisors and accountants are common place and do not impact on our independence in carrying out our function as Administrators.Other than this, there are no other known relevant relationships, including personal, business and professional relationships, from the previous 24 months with the company, an associate of the company … that should be disclosed.