SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edwards & Ors [2004] QSC 344
PARTIES:
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
(applicant)
vPETER ANTHONY EDWARDS
(first respondent)
ARTHUR JAMES ROBINSON
(second respondent)
ONE ACCORD TRADING SERVICE PTY LTD
(ACN 094 143 601)
(third respondent)
CARSWORTHY LIMITED (A FOREIGN COMPANY)
(fourth respondent)
EDWARDIAN ASSOCIATES LIMITED (A FOREIGN COMPANY)
(fifth respondent)
COPPERTONE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (A FOREIGN COMPANY)
(sixth respondent)FILE NO/S:
BS 4272 of 2004
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
8 October 2004
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
13 July 2004
JUDGE:
McMurdo J
ORDER:
1. The managed investment scheme operated by the third and fourth respondents (“the Carsworthy Scheme”) be would up pursuant to section 601EE of the Corporations Act 2001(Cth).
2. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed under section 1323 of the Corporations Act as receivers and managers for the purpose of winding up the Carsworthy Scheme.
3. The costs and expenses of the receivers and managers (to be calculated in accordance with the usual rates charged by the receivers and managers from time to time) be paid out of the assets of the Carsworthy Scheme.
4. The receivers and managers shall have the powers necessary for the purpose of winding up the Carsworthy Scheme, including, but not limiting to:
a. The general and specific powers identified in section 420 of the Corporations Act; and
b. The power to require (by request in writing) any of the respondents or any officer, employee, consultant, banker, solicitor, accountant or agent of any of the respondents to provide reasonable assistance.
5. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act or by such orders to be done by the receivers and managers in winding up the Carsworthy Scheme may be done by any one or more of the receivers and managers.
6. The managed investment scheme operated by the fifth respondent (“the Edwardian Associates Scheme”) be would up pursuant to section 601EE of the Corporations Act 2001(Cth).
7. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed under section 1323 of the Corporations Act as receivers and managers for the purpose of winding up the Edwardian Associates Scheme.
8. The costs and expenses of the receivers and managers (to be calculated in accordance with the usual rates charged by the receivers and managers from time to time) be paid out of the assets of the Edwardian Associates Scheme.
9. The receivers and managers shall have the powers necessary for the purpose of winding up the Edwardian Associates Scheme, including, but not limiting to:
a. The general and specific powers identified in section 420 of the Corporations Act; and
b. The power to require (by request in writing) any of the respondents or any officer, employee, consultant, banker, solicitor, accountant or agent of any of the respondents to provide reasonable assistance.
10. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act or…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edwards and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] QSC 344
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to address several legal issues. Firstly, it had to ascertain whether the Carsworthy Scheme and the Edwardian Associates Scheme were managed investment schemes, considering the pooling of contributions and their use in a common enterprise. Secondly, the court needed to determine if the operation of these schemes amounted to the carrying out of activities warranting their winding up under section 601EE of the Corporations Act. It also needed to consider whether the companies involved should be wound up under sections 461 and 583 of the Act, given their involvement in the operation of these schemes. Moreover, the court had to examine whether it had jurisdiction to wind up the companies, especially those that were foreign and unregistered in Australia, and if doing so would be just and equitable.
The court found that both the Carsworthy Scheme and the Edwardian Associates Scheme were indeed managed investment schemes. It held that their operation was misleading and deceptive, and warranted winding up under section 601EE of the Corporations Act. The court also concluded that it had jurisdiction to wind up the companies involved, even though some were foreign and unregistered in Australia. The winding up was deemed just and equitable under section 583 of the Act. The court appointed Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown as receivers and managers for winding up the schemes and as liquidators for the companies involved. It also ordered that the costs of the proceedings be paid from the assets of the third respondent.
In conclusion, the court ordered the winding up of both managed investment schemes and the associated companies, finding them to be managed investment schemes under the Corporations Act. The winding up was justified on the grounds of misleading and deceptive conduct and was deemed just and equitable. The court also appointed Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown to oversee the winding up processes and ordered the payment of costs from the assets of the third respondent.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The managed investment scheme operated by the third and fourth respondents (“the Carsworthy Scheme”) be would up pursuant to section 601EE of the Corporations Act 2001(Cth).
2. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed under section 1323 of the Corporations Act as receivers and managers for the purpose of winding up the Carsworthy Scheme.
3. The costs and expenses of the receivers and managers (to be calculated in accordance with the usual rates charged by the receivers and managers from time to time) be paid out of the assets of the Carsworthy Scheme.
4. The receivers and managers shall have the powers necessary for the purpose of winding up the Carsworthy Scheme, including, but not limiting to:
a. The general and specific powers identified in section 420 of the Corporations Act; and
b. The power to require (by request in writing) any of the respondents or any officer, employee, consultant, banker, solicitor, accountant or agent of any of the respondents to provide reasonable assistance.
5. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act or by such orders to be done by the receivers and managers in winding up the Carsworthy Scheme may be done by any one or more of the receivers and managers.
6. The managed investment scheme operated by the fifth respondent (“the Edwardian Associates Scheme”) be would up pursuant to section 601EE of the Corporations Act 2001(Cth).
7. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed under section 1323 of the Corporations Act as receivers and managers for the purpose of winding up the Edwardian Associates Scheme.
8. The costs and expenses of the receivers and managers (to be calculated in accordance with the usual rates charged by the receivers and managers from time to time) be paid out of the assets of the Edwardian Associates Scheme.
9. The receivers and managers shall have the powers necessary for the purpose of winding up the Edwardian Associates Scheme, including, but not limiting to:
a. The general and specific powers identified in section 420 of the Corporations Act; and
b. The power to require (by request in writing) any of the respondents or any officer, employee, consultant, banker, solicitor, accountant or agent of any of the respondents to provide reasonable assistance.
10. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act or by such orders to be done by the receivers and managers in winding up the Edwardian Associates Scheme may be done by any one or more of the receivers and managers.
11. The third respondent be wound up pursuant to subsection 461(l)(k) of the Corporations Act.
12. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed as the liquidators of the third respondent.
13. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act to be done by the liquidators may be done by any one or more of the liquidators of the third respondent.
14. The fourth respondent be wound up pursuant to subsection 583(c)(ii) of the Corporations Act.
15. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed as the liquidators of the fourth respondent.
16. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act to be done by the liquidators may be done by any one or more of the liquidators of the fourth respondent.
17. The fifth respondent be wound up pursuant to subsection 583(c)(ii) of the Corporations Act.
18. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed as the liquidators of the fifth respondent.
19. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act to be done by the liquidators may be done by any one or more of the liquidators of the fifth respondent.
20. The sixth respondent be wound up pursuant to subsection 583(c)(ii) of the Corporations Act.
21. Ian Richard Hall and Martin Russell Brown be appointed as the liquidators of the sixth respondent.
22. Anything that is required or authorised by the Corporations Act to be done by the liquidators may be done by any one or more of the liquidators of the sixth respondent.
23. The applicant’s costs of and incidental to this application be paid from liquidation of the third respondent in accordance with section 556 of the Corporations Act.
24. Until further order, the second respondent, by himself, his servants, agents or otherwise howsoever, be prohibited from withdrawing, transferring or otherwise dealing with the funds in term deposit account number 4405 5014 4032 held at the Caboolture branch of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia without the written authority of the applicant.
25. The originating application is otherwise adjourned to a date to be fixed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi