Australian National Airways Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
71 CLR 115

AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL AIRWAYS PRO-

PRIETARY LIMITED

THE COMMONWEALTH AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS. DEFENDANTS, High Court-Appeal to Privy CouncilDecision as to limits inter se of constitutional

powers of Commonwealth and States-What constitutes-Certificate that question ought to be determined by Privy Council-Grounds for granting-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. C. 12), 88. 51 (i.) (xxxix.), 74, 92, 122-Australian National Airlines MELBOURNE, Act 1945 (No. 31 of 1945).

The plaintiff company, desiring to appeal to the Privy Council from the decision of the High Court (ante, p. 29) in SO far as it did not accede to the plain- tiff's claim that the Australian National Airlines Act 1945 was wholly invalid, applied to the High Court for a certificate under S. 74 of the Constitution that, so far as it was a question as to the limits inter se of the powers of the Commonwealth and the States, the question whether the provisions of the Act which had not been declared invalid were within the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament under S. 51 (i.) and (xxxix.) of the Constitution was one which ought to be determined by His Majesty in Council. In support of the application the company contended, first, that the decision was one of great importance, and second, that if their Lordships of the Privy Council should see fit to grant special leave to appeal it would be very desirable that all the issues in the case should be open for decision.

Held (1) that the question for which the certificate was sought raised a question as to the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Common- wealth and the States within the meaning of S. 74 of the Constitution (2) that the application should be refused.

Jones v. Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration, (1917) A.C. 528; 24 C.L.R. 396, applied.

71 CLR 116

Australian National Airways Pty. Ltd. desired to appeal to His Majesty in Council from the decision of the High Court (1) in

SO far as it did not declare that the Australian National Airlines Act 1945 was wholly invalid. It now applied to the High Court for an order " certifying under section 74 of the Constitution the following question SO far as it is a question as to the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and those of [No. 2].

any State or States is one which ought to be determined by His Majesty in Council, namely :- Whether the provisions of the Australian National Airlines Act 1945 (so far as the same have not already been declared by the judgment of this court dated the 14th day of December 1945 to be invalid) are within the legislative power of the Parliament of the Commonwealth under section 51 (i.) and (xxxix.) of the Constitution.' "

Coppel K.C. (with him Sholl), for the applicant. The order made on the demurrer in the action in which the present applicant was plaintiff was a final judgment completely disposing of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian National Airways Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1946] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian National Airways Pty Ltd sought a certificate from the High Court of Australia under section 74 of the Constitution. The company wished to appeal to the Privy Council against the High Court's decision concerning the validity of the Australian National Airlines Act 1945. Specifically, the company sought a certificate that the question of whether certain remaining provisions of the Act were within the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament under sections 51(i) and 51(xxxix) of the Constitution ought to be determined by His Majesty in Council. The dispute arose from the High Court's earlier judgment, which had declared some provisions of the Act invalid for infringing section 92 of the Constitution but upheld the validity of other provisions, including the establishment of a national airline corporation.

The High Court was required to determine two principal matters. Firstly, whether the question for which the certificate was sought constituted a "question as to the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and those of any State or States" within the meaning of section 74 of the Constitution. Secondly, if it did, whether there were sufficient special reasons to justify granting the certificate, thereby allowing an appeal to the Privy Council on that specific question. The company argued that the matter was of great importance and that it would be desirable for all issues to be open for decision by the Privy Council if special leave to appeal were granted.

The High Court, in dismissing the application, held that the question concerning the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament under section 51(i) of the Constitution, in relation to the Australian National Airlines Act, did indeed raise a question as to the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States. This was based on the principle established in *Jones v. Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration*, where a decision affirming the existence of a Commonwealth power that extended over an area of potential State power was considered to involve an "inter se" question. The Court found that the importance of the question alone was not a sufficient special reason to grant a certificate, and the argument that all issues should be open for Privy Council determination was based on an unfulfilled hypothesis, as special leave to appeal had not yet been sought or granted.

The application for the certificate was refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Australian National Airways Pty Ltd (ANA) sought to appeal to the Privy Council from the High Court's decision in which the Court did not declare the Australian National Airlines Act 1945 wholly invalid. ANA applied to the High Court for a certificate under section 74 of the Constitution that the question whether the provisions of the Act which had not been declared invalid were within the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament was one which ought to be determined by the Privy Council. The Court held that the question for which the certificate was sought raised a question as to the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States within the meaning of section 74 of the Constitution. However, the application was refused. The Court held that the question whether the Commonwealth had power to create a trading corporation was one the answer to which would not enlarge or diminish the powers of the States. The applicant's contention, though it raised an inter se question, was not directly concerned with any conflict of powers, and no special reason for granting a certificate had been shown.

Australian National Airways Pty Ltd sought to appeal to the Privy Council from the decision of the High Court, which did not fully support their claim that the Australian National Airlines Act 1945 was invalid. The company applied to the High Court for a certificate under section 74 of the Constitution, asserting that the question of the validity of the Act was one of significant importance and ought to be determined by the Privy Council. The High Court held that the application should be refused, determining that the matter at hand was of purely Australian concern and was the special function and responsibility of the High Court to decide. The Court found that the interpretation of section 51(i) of the Constitution was ample enough to warrant the majority of the Act, except for parts relating to airline services with Territories of the Commonwealth. The Court held that the invalid provisions were severable, and the entire Act was not vitiated. The application was dismissed with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the proposed question for the Privy Council's determination involve the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States within the meaning of Section 74 of the Constitution?
2. Are there any special reasons to grant the certificate under Section 74 of the Constitution for the proposed question to be determined by the Privy Council?

Held
1. Does the proposed question for the Privy Council's determination involve the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States within the meaning of Section 74 of the Constitution?
- The Court concluded that the proposed question did involve the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States within the meaning of Section 74 of the Constitution.

2. Are there any special reasons to grant the certificate under Section 74 of the Constitution for the proposed question to be determined by the Privy Council?
- The Court concluded that there were no special reasons to grant the certificate under Section 74 of the Constitution for the proposed question to be determined by the Privy Council.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia was asked to certify a question to the Privy Council under Section 74 of the Constitution, which pertains to the limits of constitutional powers between the Commonwealth and the States. Australian National Airways Pty Ltd sought a certificate to appeal to the Privy Council regarding the interpretation of the Australian National Airlines Act 1945. The court determined that the question raised did involve the limits inter se of the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States, as it pertained to the validity of the Act and the powers conferred by Sections 51(i) and (xxxix) of the Constitution. The court applied the legal principles established in Jones v. Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration, which held that any decision extending a Commonwealth power that impacts upon State power involves a question of the limits inter se.

However, the court refused to grant the certificate under Section 74 of the Constitution. The court noted that the importance of the case was not a special reason to grant the certificate, as decisions concerning the limits inter se are inherently important. The court also rejected the applicant's argument that it would be desirable to have all issues open for decision if the Privy Council granted special leave to appeal. The court held that it would not abdicate its special function and responsibility under the Constitution to determine questions of the limits inter se. The court's decision was based on the precedent set in Flint v. Webb, which emphasized the importance of the High Court resolving conflicts between Federal and State power.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the High Court has the responsibility to determine questions concerning the limits inter se of constitutional powers of the Commonwealth and the States, and it should not grant a certificate under Section 74 of the Constitution unless there is a special reason to do so. The court's decision followed the precedent set in Jones v. Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration and Flint v. Webb, which emphasized the importance of the High Court resolving conflicts between Federal and State power.