Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 811

File number: NSD 1040 of 2019
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 12 June 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — two applications for disqualification on the basis of apprehended bias by reason of judge’s involvement in hearing a previous proceeding between the applicants and the first and second respondents in the present proceeding — where judge rejected the first and second respondents’ previous challenge to the impartiality of an expert witness whom gave evidence in the previous proceeding and whom is likely to give evidence in the present proceeding — where judge also construed claims in the patent in the previous proceeding in a manner consistent with the construction advanced by the expert witness — where the proper construction of claims in a patent is a question of law — whether a fair-minded lay observer might reasonably apprehend that judge might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the issues in the present proceeding — whether an apprehension of bias arises by reason of the applicants’ use of the term “workaround” in a letter to the Court
Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 122
Cases cited:

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1839

Cavar v Green Gate Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1179

Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; (2000) 205 CLR 337

Expectation Pty Ltd v PRD Realty Pty Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 392; (2006) 151 FCR 160

Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd v Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd [2019] FCAFC 162; (2019) 145 IPR

Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 90; (2005) 222 ALR 155

Livesey v New South Wales Bar Association [1983] HCA 17; (1983) 151 CLR 288

Michael Wilson & Partners v Nicholls [2011] HCA 48; (2011) 244 CLR 427

Oxworks Trading Pty Ltd v Gram Engineering Pty Ltd [2019] FCAFC 240

Re JRL; Ex parte CJL [1986] HCA 39; (1986) 161 CLR 343

Vakauta v Kelly [1989] HCA 44; (1989) 167 CLR 568

Bodkin C, Patent Law in Australia (3rd ed, Lawbook Co, 2019)  

Date of hearing: 8 April 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 64
Counsel for the Applicants: Ms F St John
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr A Ryan SC with Mr A Fox
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Watermark Intellectual Property Lawyers
Solicitor for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Bird & Bird

ORDERS

NSD 1040 of 2019
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN MUD COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 009 283 416)

First Applicant/Cross-Respondent

REFLEX INSTRUMENTS ASIA PACIFIC PTY LTD (ACN 124 204 191)

Second Applicant

AND:

GLOBALTECH CORPORATION PTY LTD (ACN 087 281 418)

First Respondent

GLOBALTECH PTY LTD (ACN 086 012 393)

Second Respondent

BOART LONGYEAR LIMITED (ACN 123 052 728) (and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Globaltech Corporation Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 811
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd and Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd have brought an action against Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd, Globaltech Pty Ltd, Boart Longyear Limited, and Boart Longyear Australia Pty Ltd, alleging infringement of a patent for "Core Sample Orientation." In response, the respondents have filed two interlocutory applications seeking the disqualification of the judge, Justice Besanko, on the grounds of apprehended bias. The basis for these applications is the judge's prior involvement in a previous proceeding between the applicants and some of the respondents. The applicants had raised concerns about the judge’s impartiality due to his previous rulings and the anticipated re-involvement of an expert witness from the earlier proceeding.

The legal issues before the court were whether the judge's prior involvement in the previous proceeding, including his rejection of a challenge to the impartiality of an expert witness and his construction of patent claims, could give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias in the current proceeding. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the use of the term "workaround" in a letter from the applicants to the court could contribute to such an apprehension.

The court dismissed the applications for disqualification, finding no reasonable apprehension of bias. The judge noted that the proper construction of patent claims is a question of law and that there was no evidence to suggest the judge had prejudged the matter or would not bring an impartial mind to the current proceeding. The use of the term "workaround" was considered to be a rhetorical flourish rather than evidence of bias. The court concluded that the respondents had not established a case of apparent bias, and thus, the applications were dismissed.

In light of the dismissal of the applications, the court indicated that it would hear the parties on costs and make interlocutory orders to progress the case to trial. The court also suggested an exchange of Position Statements on Infringement and verification of the Product Description to avoid any uncertainties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Interlocutory application of the first and second respondents dated 20 December 2019 and the Interlocutory application of the third and fourth respondents dated 20 December 2019 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

There are two interlocutory applications dated 20 December 2019 before the Court. The first application is brought by the first and second respondents, and the second by the third and fourth respondents. In both applications, an order is sought that I disqualify myself in this proceeding and that the proceeding be referred to another judge of the Court for case management and the hearing and determination of the claims made by the parties. The broad basis of the applications is that an apprehension of bias arises by reason of my involvement in hearing a previous proceeding between the applicants and the first and second respondents in this proceeding.THE FACTS The applicants in this proceeding are Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd and Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd, and the respondents are Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd, Globaltech Pty Ltd, Boart Longyear Limited and Boart Longyear Australia Pty Ltd. The proceeding involves a claim by the applicants that the respondents have infringed claims in Australian Standard Patent No 2010200162 entitled “Core Sample Orientation” (the Patent). The fourth respondent, Boart Longyear Australia Pty Ltd, has brought a cross-claim in which it alleges that the Patent is invalid. Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd and Globaltech Pty Ltd (the Globaltech respondents) are represented by one firm of solicitors (Watermark Intellectual Property Lawyers), and Boart Longyear Limited and Boart Longyear Australia Pty Ltd (the Boart Longyear respondents) are represented by a different firm of solicitors (Bird & Bird). However, on these applications, all four respondents were represented by the same counsel. I have previously considered a claim by the applicants against the Globaltech respondents that they have infringed claims in the Patent and a cross-claim by the Globaltech respondents that the Patent is invalid (the previous proceeding). On 26 November 2018, I delivered reasons in which I indicated that I had reached the following conclusions: (1) the Priority Date of the claims in suit is 3 September 2004 and the claims in suit are valid; (2) each of the respondents has infringed the claims in suit; and (3) the applicants are not entitled to additional damages under s 122(1A) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1839 (the previous reasons)). I made orders in the previous proceeding on 14 December 2018 and those orders were as follows:THE COURT DECLARES THAT:1.The respondents and each of them have infringed claims 1-4, 7-10, 16-17, 21‑24, 27-28, 33-40, 46-48, 54 and 65 of Australian Standard Patent No. 2010200162 entitled “Core Sample Orientation” (the Patent).2.Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd, the second applicant, is the exclusive licensee of the Patent.THE COURT CERTIFIES THAT:3.Pursuant to s 19 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), the validity of each of claims 1-4, 7-10, 16-17, 21-24, 27-28, 33-40, 46-48, 54 and 65 of the Patent was questioned in this proceeding.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:4.The respondents and each of them be permanently restrained, whether by themselves, their directors, officers, servants, agents or however otherwise from infringing the Patent in Australia during the term of the Patent, including without limitation by, without licence of the applicants:(a)making, hiring, selling or otherwise disposing of, offering to make, hire, sell or otherwise dispose of, using, importing, exporting, or keeping for the purpose of doing any of those things, any core sample orientation tool or system according to any of claims 33-40, 46-48, 54 or 65 of the Patent, including without limitation the core sample orientation tools developed and sold under the names “Orifinder v3A”, “Orifinder v3B”, “Orifinder v5” or “TRUCORE” (the Orifinder Tools);(b)using any method of providing an indication of the orientation of a core sample according to any of claims 1-4, 7-10, 16-17, 21-24, 27-28 or 65 of the Patent;(c)supplying or offering to supply any core sample orientation tool or system capable of being used in a method of providing an indication of the orientation of a core sample according to any of claims1-4, 7‑10, 16-17, 21-24, 27-28 or 65 of the Patent; (d)doing the acts referred to in sub-paragraph (c) above together with the giving of, or the publication of advertisements containing, instructions or inducements for the use of such a core sample orientation tool or system in a method of providing an indication of the orientation of a core sample according to any of claims 1-4, 7-10, 16-17, 21-24, 27-28 or 65 of the Patent; or(e)authorising, procuring, inducing or joining in a common design with any person to do any act referred to in sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) above.5. The first respondent’s Cross-Claim filed on 24 August 2016 be dismissed.6.Subject to orders 14 to 16 below, within 28 days each of the respondents, or their nominated agents, are to destroy all Orifinder Tools, and any other core sample orientation tools or systems referred to in orders 4(a) and (c) above, and all advertising, instructional and promotional material relating thereto or referred to in order 4(d) above, in the possession, custody, power or control of the respondents. 7.By 4pm on 25 January 2019, the first respondent is to file an affidavit (by an officer with sufficient knowledge of the affairs of the company) setting out the total number of Orifinder Tools that the respondents have sold or supplied (including by way of export) to date, annexing supporting documents.8.There be an inquiry as to damages or profits in respect of the respondents’ infringement of the Patent by the Orifinder Tools, such inquiry to be listed for directions before Justice Besanko on a date and time to be fixed at the convenience of the Court. 9.The respondents pay the applicants’ costs of the proceeding to date, including any reserved costs, as agreed or assessed.10.The applicants file any interlocutory application and supporting affidavits seeking a lump sum costs order by 19 January 2019.11.The respondents file and serve any affidavits in answer to the affidavits of the applicants by 1 February 2019.12.The parties file and serve any written submissions (which are not to exceed 5 pages in length) in respect of any interlocutory application filed in accordance with Order 11 by 8 February 2019.13. There be liberty to restore on 3 days’ notice in writing.THE COURT NOTES THE FOLLOWING UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:A.The Respondents undertake to quarantine and hold proper and discrete accounting records for revenue made from the sale of the 16 Orifinder v5 kits currently on order, as well as any further orders the Respondents receive, between 11 December 2018 and 23 January 2019 or, if an application for a stay is made in accordance with paragraph 16, the end of the period referred to in paragraph 16.THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:14. Orders 4 and 6 be stayed until 4pm on 23 January 2019.15.On or before 4pm on 23 January 2019, the respondents are to file and serve any application for a stay pending appeal of these orders, together with evidence in support of that application. 16.Orders 4 and 6 be stayed until the determination of respondents’ application for a stay pending appeal, provided that the application for a stay is made on or before 4pm on 23 January 2019. The orders in paragraphs 4 and 6 above were stayed until 4 pm on 23 January 2019. The Globaltech respondents did not seek to stay the orders beyond that date.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This proceeding was commenced by Originating application dated 27 November 2019. THE EVIDENCE ON THE APPLICATION Ms Leanne Michelle Oitmaa is a solicitor and the principal of Watermark Intellectual Property Lawyers. She swore an affidavit in support of the Interlocutory application brought by the Globaltech respondents. In that affidavit, she outlines the history of the previous proceeding, including the trial on the issue of liability, the appeal to the Full Court of this Court and the Application for Special Leave to Appeal to the High Court made by the Globaltech respondents. That application had not been heard and determined at the time Ms Oitmaa swore her affidavit. Ms Oitmaa refers to the application for preliminary discovery dated 24 June 2019. She annexes to her affidavit an email sent to my associate on 24 June 2019 by the solicitors for the applicants. The email attached a letter to the Registrar of the Court with copies to my associate and to the solicitors for the Globaltech respondents and the Originating application for preliminary discovery and affidavit of Professor Tapson affirmed on 20 June 2019. The email sent to my associate contained the following passage:As set out in the attached letter to the Registrar, the Prospective Applicants seek preliminary discovery to determine the manner of working of a “workaround” tool that was introduced to the Australian market by the Prospective Respondents after the final orders made by his Honour in NSD 1089/2016 on 14 December 2018. In their letter to the Registrar, my associate and the solicitors for the Globaltech respondents, the solicitors for the applicants state, inter alia, the following:We observe that it was previously an administrative requirement that a filing party inform the Court in writing of any apparently related proceedings of which that party is aware that might be suitable to be listed before the same docket Judge. We write as a courtesy to the Court to observe that the parties to the Interlocutory Application are also involved in Federal Court Proceeding NSD 1089/2016 before Besanko J (NSD 1089/2016 Proceeding). In that matter, questions of liability were determined late last year, and the proceeding continues in relation to quantum. Ms Oitmaa makes the point that this proceeding involves two other respondents, namely, the Boart Longyear respondents. Ms Oitmaa also says the following in her affidavit:I am instructed that Globaltech is concerned the Current Proceedings have been allocated to the docket of Besanko J, who will hear and determine the Current Proceedings. I am instructed that Globaltech’s principal concern is that, given Besanko J heard and determined the Earlier Proceeding adversely to Globaltech (which was affirmed by the Appeal Judgment) and given that Globaltech has sought special leave to appeal that decision (having regard to the proposed grounds of appeal in the Special Leave Application), the Current Proceedings ought be determined by a different Judge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Even if the word had a sinister connotation, it seems to me that it should be treated no differently from a rhetorical flourish by counsel in the course of submissions.CONCLUSION The respondents have not established a case of apparent bias and their respective interlocutory applications must be dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs. I will make interlocutory orders to progress the matters to trial. There were two differences between the parties about the appropriate interlocutory orders at this stage, one in relation to whether there should be an exchange of Position Statements in accordance with the Intellectual Property Practice Note, and the other concerned a Product Description. The particulars of infringement in the Statement of Claim are sparse and I think there should be an exchange of Position Statements on Infringement. I also consider that to avoid any uncertainty, the Product Description should be verified. I will give the parties the opportunity to agree the appropriate interlocutory orders in light of these intimations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established