Australian Manufacturing Workers Union v United Lift Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Australian Manufacturing Workers Union v United Lift Services Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 275  

File numbers: SYG 521 of 2022
SYG 2017 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE D HUMPHREYS
Date of judgment: 17 April 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – Contravention of s 340 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – Applicant exercised a workplace right – complaints – redundancy – contravention of s 346 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – adverse action – compensation – re-instatement – pecuniary penalties – orders made.
Legislation:  Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 50, 340, 342, 361
Cases cited:

Board ofBendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) HCA 32

Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Clermont Coal Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1014

Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 697

Murrihy v VETEZY.com.au Pty Ltd (2013) 238 IR 307

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 223
Date of last submission/s: 12 April 2023
Date of hearing: 27 -28 February 2023
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicants: Ms Doust
Solicitor for the Applicants: Communications Electrical Electronic Energy Information Postal Plumbing And Allied Services Union Of Australia
Solicitor for the Applicants: Electrical Trades Union Of Australia
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Duc
Solicitor for the Respondent: McEvoy Legal

ORDERS

SYG 2017 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN MANUFACTURING WORKERS' UNION

Applicant

AND:

UNITED LIFT SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 082 447 658

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE HUMPHREYS

DATE OF ORDER:

17 April 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.A declaration be made pursuant to s 545 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”) that the respondent contravened ss 50, 340 and 346 of the Act by:

(a)Failing to pay Mr Burton the wages payable to him under the United Lift Services Pty Ltd Installation and Service Division Enterprise Agreement 2021 (“Agreement”);

(b)Failing to pay $79 per week to the redundancy trust PROTECT for and on behalf of Mr Burton as required by the Agreement;

(c)Failing to make arrangements for Rostered Days Off as required by the Agreement in respect of both Mr Burton and Mr Nesbitt;

(d)Failing to consult with employees about the decision to make employees redundant as required by the Agreement;

(e)Dismissing Mr Burton; and

(f)Scoring Mr Nesbitt adversely in the redundancy selection process and dismissing Mr Nesbitt.

2.The matter be listed for Directions at 9:30am on 21 April 2023.

ORDERS

SYG 521 of 2022

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MR DAVID NESBIT

Second Applicant

AND:

UNITED LIFT SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 082 447 658

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE HUMPHREYS

DATE OF ORDER:

17 April 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

3.A declaration be made pursuant to s 545 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”) that the respondent contravened ss 50, 340 and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Manufacturing Workers Union v United Lift Service... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Manufacturing Workers Union v United Lift Services Pty Ltd, the Fair Work Commission was asked to determine whether the respondent had contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by dismissing the applicants on the basis of their protected industrial activities. The applicants, represented by the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union, alleged that the respondent had dismissed them for raising concerns about safety and the use of unlicensed workers, which constituted protected industrial activity under the Act. The respondent, United Lift Services Pty Ltd, denied these allegations and argued that the dismissals were for other reasons.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the dismissals of the applicants were for protected reasons and whether the respondent had contravened specific provisions of the Fair Work Act and the enterprise agreement. The Court had to consider the evidence provided by the applicants and the respondent, particularly the testimonies of the applicants and the respondent's management, to determine the validity of the dismissals and the respondent's compliance with the Act and the enterprise agreement.

The Court found that the evidence of the applicants demonstrated that their dismissals were indeed related to their protected industrial activities, including raising safety concerns and engaging in union activities. The Court held that the respondent had not discharged the statutory presumption under section 361 of the Act that the dismissals did not include protected reasons. Consequently, the Court ruled that the respondent had contravened sections 340 and 346 of the Act by dismissing the applicants for protected reasons. Furthermore, the Court found that the respondent had breached the enterprise agreement by failing to consult with employees about the decision to make them redundant and by not paying the required amount into the PROTECT fund.

The Court made a declaration that the respondent had contravened the Fair Work Act and the enterprise agreement by dismissing the applicants for protected reasons. It also found that the respondent had contravened section 50 of the Act by breaching the enterprise agreement. The matter was stood over for further directions regarding the penalties and compensation to be imposed on the respondent. The applicants also sought reinstatement, which will be considered during the next proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Generally, it will be extremely difficult to displace the statutory presumptions in s 361 of the Act if no direct testimony is given by the decision maker acting on behalf of the employer: Barclay at [45] per French CJ and Crennon J.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The following material is uncontroversial. In 2019, the respondent was the target of an enterprise bargaining campaign by the CEPU and AMWU. A key claim of the bargaining was for a 36 hour week, an improvement on the existing 38 hour week. In March 2021, after agreement having been reached with United, the Agreement was put to a ballot of employees who voted in favour. The Fair Work Commission approved the Agreement commencing on 20 May 2021. The Agreement provided for a minimum ordinary hourly wage rate, at clause 11 and schedule 1, including a grade 1 technician rate of $44.59 per hour. It also required United to make payments of $79.00 per week on behalf of its employees into the PROTECT fund. The agreement provided for a presumptive 36 ordinary hour week. Different ordinary hours could be agreed between United and an employee. Absent such an agreement, an employee was to accrue an RDO each four week work cycle by working eight hours each day, being paid 7.2 hours and accruing 0.8 of an hour towards an RDO. The agreement contained a consultation provision at clause 7. It applied where there had been “a definite decision to introduce a major change to production, program, organisation, structure, or technology in relation to its enterprise that is likely to have a significant effect on employees”. Clause 7(9) of the Agreement provides (relevantly) as follows:(9) in this term, a major change is likely to have a significant effect on employees if it results in:a)the termination of employment of employees (emphasis added); orb)major change the composition, operational size of the employer’s workforce or the skills required of employees.orc)the elimination or diminution of job opportunities (including for promotion or tenure): or …g)the restructuring of jobs. On behalf of Mr Burton and Mr Nesbitt it was submitted the clause:a. Required employers to whom it applied to notify the employees affected of the change of the decision to introduce major change;b. Entitled employees to appoint a representative for the purpose of the procedures in the clause;c. Obliged the employer to provide in writing to the employees who may be affected by the change “all relevant information” about the change including the nature of the change proposed, information about the expected dates of the change on the employees and any other matters likely to affect the employees; and d. Obliged the employer to give prompt and genuine consideration of matters raised about the major change to employees.THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCEEvidence of David Nesbitt Mr Nesbitt swore two Affidavits, the first dated 3 August 2022 and the second dated 4 November 2022. Mr Nesbitt is a licensed electrician and now works at Schindler Elevators Australia. From 23 March 2020 to 28 July 2021, Mr Nesbitt was employed by United in the construction division. His work included major lift repairs, and the modernisation or renovation of existing lifts and the installing of new lifts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On behalf of Mr Burton and Mr Nesbitt it was submitted the clause:a. Required employers to whom it applied to notify the employees affected of the change of the decision to introduce major change;b. Entitled employees to appoint a representative for the purpose of the procedures in the clause;c. Obliged the employer to provide in writing to the employees who may be affected by the change “all relevant information” about the change including the nature of the change proposed, information about the expected dates of the change on the employees and any other matters likely to affect the employees; and d. Obliged the employer to give prompt and genuine consideration of matters raised about the major change to employees.THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCEEvidence of David Nesbitt Mr Nesbitt swore two Affidavits, the first dated 3 August 2022 and the second dated 4 November 2022. Mr Nesbitt is a licensed electrician and now works at Schindler Elevators Australia. From 23 March 2020 to 28 July 2021, Mr Nesbitt was employed by United in the construction division. His work included major lift repairs, and the modernisation or renovation of existing lifts and the installing of new lifts. On 20 March 2020, Mr Nesbitt became a member of the CEPU. Mr Nesbitt’s direct supervisor was Mr Ben Osborne, the NSW Construction Manager for United. Mr Osborne in turn reported to Mr Ellis. Mr Nesbitt deposes that he was the employee with an electrical license within the construction division. From about August 2020, he began to raise serious issues in relation to the way work is being performed by United. He claims that unlicensed persons were performing electrical work, including installing, testing, tuning and commissioning lifts. This complaint included United directing fitters to perform electrical work. Mr Nesbitt claims that when he first started for United, he was paired with an employee named Reagan. Reagan did not have an Australian electrical license, but held Chinese electrical qualifications. In about December 2020, Mr Nesbitt stated that he was doing electrical work at a job at Queens Street, Newtown. Another United employee, George Tam, attended the job to certify and check his electrical work as well as test and commission the lift. Mr Nesbitt claims he spoke to Mr Osborne with words to the effect of:Nesbitt:I don’t think it is safe or fair that someone without qualifications is doing the job they were doing.Osborne: Don’t worry about it. It is what it is. Mr Nesbitt complains that he raised these concerns at least once a month with Mr Osborne saying words to the effect of “I don’t know how you guys are okay with having someone test and commission and do electrical work without having the proper license to do so”. Around 12 October 2020, Mr Nesbitt states that he received a text message from Mr Burton about a conversation he had with Mr Osborne on the weekend of 10-11 October 2020. The text message, which is attached to Mr Nesbitt’s Affidavit, states that Mr Osborne said to Mr Burton that “I would not want to be a union representative as it doesn’t get me anything other than a target on my back”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Court does not accept the evidence of Mr Ellis and Mr Hermus that the protected complaints and industrial activity of Mr Nesbitt and Mr Burton did not form a substantial and operative reason for their dismissal which constitutes adverse action within the meaning of s 342 of the Act. United has not discharged the presumption under s 361 of the Act that the dismissals of Mr Burton and Mr Nesbitt did not include protected reasons, including their industrial activity. CONCLUSION Accordingly, the Court is satisfied that United contravened ss 340 and 346 of the Act and makes the declaration sought in this regard. The Court makes the declarations sought that United also contravened the relevant Agreement and in so doing contravened s 50 of the Act. Having determined the issue of liability against United, the matter will be stood over for further directions as to the filing and serving any evidence on the matter of the appropriate penalties to be imposed and the issue of compensation to Mr Nesbitt and Mr Burton. The Court notes Mr Nesbitt also seeks reinstatement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court does not accept that Mr Hermus was supportive of staff working a 36 hour week. The Court finds he was actively opposed to a 36 hour week and took steps to dissuade employees for opting for a 36 hour week. The Court is satisfied that he had a significant involvement in all human resources decisions and was aware that Ms Nguyen told staff in the New South Wales branch, that if they wished to work on a 36 hour week basis, they needed to speak directly to Mr Hermus. The Court does not accept that Ms Nguyen would have sent such a text unless she was under instructions from Mr Hermus to do so.CONSIDERATIONContraventions under s 50 of the Act Section 50 of the Act states that a person must not contravene a term of an enterprise bargain. The applicants allege four breaches of this section, namely:a. Failing to pay Mr Burton the wages payable to him under the Agreement as set out in Schedule 1;b. Failing to pay $79.00 per week into the Redundancy Trust RESPECT for and on behalf of Mr Burton as required by clause 18 of the Agreement;c. Failing to make arrangements for RDOs as required by Clause 15 of the Agreement in respect of both Mr Nesbitt and Mr Burton; andd. Failing to consult with employees about the decision to make employees redundant as required by clause 7 of the Agreement. The respondent has admitted to the first breach in underpaying Mr Burton $0.50 per hour, but claims this arose as a result of a payroll oversight. The respondent has also admitted the second breach in not paying $79.00 per week into the RESPECT Trust in relation to Mr Burton. Again, the respondent claims this was inadvertent. The respondent states, and it is not disputed, that both these breaches have been rectified. As this claim was not progressed in the applicants’ submissions, the respondent submitted that the Court should infer that it was no longer pressed. The Court does not accept this submission. The claim was not pursued with vigour by the applicants as it was conceded by United. In relation to the third alleged breach of failing to accrue RDOs, as required under clause 15 of the Agreement in respect of Mr Burton and Mr Nesbitt, the applicants allege that both Mr Nesbitt and Mr Burton elected their preference for a 36 hour week. Mr Nesbitt was informed that no action would be taken until the matter was discussed with Mr Hermus. The applicants submit that no steps were taken for such a discussion to occur. The respondent submits that the applicants were given the opportunity to indicate whether they wished the clause to apply to them. The respondent claims they had a verbal agreement with the Unions as to the operation of the clause. As to what that verbal agreement was and when it was made is not clear form any of the evidence. It was submitted that the applicants have suffered no loss or damage as a result of this alleged contravention. Clause 15 (1) and (2) of the Agreement provided for a presumptive 9 day fortnight with two RDOs per four week cycle. Provision existed for employees to apply to United for one RDO per month. It is common ground that employees were all given a document that required them to elect either one or two RDOs per month. The respondent submitted that who initiated the election was not relevant to the operation of this clause. Mr Nesbitt gave evidence that when the form was handed out to employees to sign, either Mr Ellis or Mr Osborne stated in words to the effect that if employees did not elect one RDO per month they (United) would employ others that would.