HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
HAYNE J
Matter No C17/2013
THE AUSTRALIAN ELECTORAL COMMISSION PETITIONER
AND
DAVID JOHNSTON & ORS RESPONDENTS
Matter No P55/2013
ZHENYA WANG PETITIONER
AND
DAVID JOHNSTON & ORS RESPONDENTS
Matter No P56/2013
SIMON MEAD PETITIONER
AND
DAVID JOHNSTON & ORS RESPONDENTS
Australian Electoral Commission v Johnston
Wang v Johnston
Mead v Johnston[2014] HCA 5
18 February 2014
C17/2013, P55/2013 & P56/2013
ORDER
1.The questions of law which, on 13 December 2013, were ordered to be tried separately be answered as follows:
1.Did the loss of the 1,370 ballot papers between the fresh scrutiny and the re‑count mean that the 1,370 electors who submitted those ballot papers in the poll were "prevented from voting" in the Election for the purposes of s 365 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) ("Act")?
Answer:Yes.
2.Is the Court of Disputed Returns precluded by s 365 or otherwise from admitting the records of the fresh scrutiny, or original scrutiny, that bear on the 1,370 missing ballot papers as evidence of the way in which each of those voters intended to vote, or voted, in the Election for the purposes of each of the petitions filed in the matter, including in so far as those petitions seek relief under ss 360 and 362?
Answer:The Court of Disputed Returns is precluded by s 365 from admitting the records of the fresh scrutiny and the original scrutiny that bear on the 1,370 missing ballot papers for the purpose identified in the proviso to s 365, namely, determining whether the loss of the ballot papers did or did not affect the result of the election. Further, the records of the original scrutiny and the fresh scrutiny that bear on those missing ballot papers are not admissible for the purpose of the Court determining that it should declare any candidate duly elected who was not returned as elected.
3.On a proper construction of the Act, including the re‑count provisions, is any further inquiry regarding the manner in which the Australian Electoral Officer for Western Australia dealt with the ballot papers reserved for decision pursuant to s 281:
(a)permitted under any, and if so which, provision of the Act;
(b)relevant to the disposition of any, and if so which, petitions before the Court of Disputed Returns;
(c)necessary to the disposition of any, and if so which, petitions before the Court of Disputed Returns?
Answer:(a) Yes, s 281(3).
(b)No.
(c)No.
2.Costs of the trial of separate questions reserved.
3.Stand over further hearing of petitions to Thursday, 20 February 2014 at 12 noon in Melbourne.
Representation
J T Gleeson SC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth and A S Bell SC with P Kulevski for the petitioner in C17/2013, for the eighth respondent in P55/2013 and for the ninth respondent in P56/2013 (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
S P Donaghue SC with D W Bennett for the first, third and fourth respondents in each matter (instructed by…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Electoral Commission v Johnston Wang v Johnston M... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] HCA 5
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether the loss of the 1,370 ballot papers meant that the electors who cast them were "prevented from voting" for the purposes of section 365 of the Act. The Court also had to consider whether section 365 precluded it from admitting evidence of records made during earlier counts concerning these lost ballot papers, specifically when determining if the election result was likely to have been affected. Finally, the Court needed to ascertain whether it possessed the power to declare a candidate duly elected by combining the results of the re-count with records of the lost ballot papers from earlier counts.
Hayne J answered the questions of law posed. His Honour determined that the loss of the 1,370 ballot papers did mean that the electors who submitted them were "prevented from voting" within the meaning of section 365. Furthermore, the Court was precluded by section 365 from admitting records of the fresh scrutiny or original scrutiny pertaining to the lost ballot papers for the purpose of determining whether the loss affected the election result. The Court was also precluded from using these records to declare a candidate duly elected who had not been returned as elected. The Court found that a further inquiry regarding the handling of ballot papers by the Australian Electoral Officer for Western Australia was permitted under section 281(3) but was neither relevant nor necessary for the disposition of the petitions before the Court.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The questions of law which, on 13 December 2013, were ordered to be tried separately be answered as follows:
1. Did the loss of the 1,370 ballot papers between the fresh scrutiny and the re‑count mean that the 1,370 electors who submitted those ballot papers in the poll were "prevented from voting" in the Election for the purposes of s 365 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) ("Act")?
Answer: Yes.
2. Is the Court of Disputed Returns precluded by s 365 or otherwise from admitting the records of the fresh scrutiny, or original scrutiny, that bear on the 1,370 missing ballot papers as evidence of the way in which each of those voters intended to vote, or voted, in the Election for the purposes of each of the petitions filed in the matter, including in so far as those petitions seek relief under ss 360 and 362?
Answer: The Court of Disputed Returns is precluded by s 365 from admitting the records of the fresh scrutiny and the original scrutiny that bear on the 1,370 missing ballot papers for the purpose identified in the proviso to s 365, namely, determining whether the loss of the ballot papers did or did not affect the result of the election. Further, the records of the original scrutiny and the fresh scrutiny that bear on those missing ballot papers are not admissible for the purpose of the Court determining that it should declare any candidate duly elected who was not returned as elected.
3. On a proper construction of the Act, including the re‑count provisions, is any further inquiry regarding the manner in which the Australian Electoral Officer for Western Australia dealt with the ballot papers reserved for decision pursuant to s 281:
(a) permitted under any, and if so which, provision of the Act;
(b) relevant to the disposition of any, and if so which, petitions before the Court of Disputed Returns;
(c) necessary to the disposition of any, and if so which, petitions before the Court of Disputed Returns?
Answer: (a) Yes, s 281(3).
(b) No.
(c) No.
2. Costs of the trial of separate questions reserved.
3. Stand over further hearing of petitions to Thursday, 20 February 2014 at 12 noon in Melbourne.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: HAYNE J
If it were proper to take account of the information about the number of first preference votes given for each candidate and the total number of ballot papers rejected as informal which, following the fresh scrutiny, the relevant Divisional Returning Officers transmitted to the AEO in accordance with s 273(5)(d), and treat that information as accurately recording the effect properly to be given to those ballot papers which should have been, but were not, scrutinised in the re‑count, the AEC calculates that Mr Bow would have been one vote ahead of Mr van Burgel at the 50th exclusion point. (Mr van Burgel would have had 23,531 votes and Mr Bow 23,532.) Declaration and return of the writ On 4 November 2013, the AEO declared, under s 283(1)(a) of the Act, that the first to sixth respondents to the AEC petition were elected in that order. The declaration reflected the results revealed by the re‑count, which had been conducted without the 1,370 lost ballot papers. That is, the result which was declared depended upon excluding Mr Bow at the 50th exclusion point. On 6 November 2013, the AEO returned the writ for the election of senators for Western Australia to the Governor of Western Australia. Powers of the Court of Disputed Returns Section 360 of the Act gives the Court of Disputed Returns power to declare[37] that any person who was returned as elected was not duly elected and to declare[38] any election absolutely void. These powers may be exercised[39] "on the ground that illegal practices were committed in connexion with the election". "Illegal practice" is defined[40] to include "a contravention of [the] Act". That expression means[41] a failure to comply with a provision of the Act. The Court also has the power to declare[42] any candidate duly elected who was not returned as elected. But it could not exercise that power in this case without first declaring that someone returned as elected was not duly elected. [37]s 360(1)(v).[38]s 360(1)(vii).[39]s 360(3).[40]s 352(1).[41]Sue v Hill (1999) 199 CLR 462 at 512 [124] per Gaudron J; [1999] HCA 30.[42]s 360(1)(vi). Section 362(3) of the Act places two conditions on the exercise of the Court's power to declare an election void, and the Court's power to declare that a person returned as elected was not duly elected, on the ground of certain illegal practices. The Court must be satisfied[43], first, "that the result of the election was likely to be affected" (scil by one or more of the illegal practices alleged) and, second, "that it is just that the candidate should be declared not to be duly elected or that the election should be declared void". The "result of the election" means the result as it was declared. And "result" in the Act means[44] the return of a particular candidate, not the number of the candidate's majority. [43]s 362(3).[44]Kean v Kerby (1920) 27 CLR 449 at 458 per Isaacs J. Section 365 of the Act places limits on the evidence the Court may admit to determine whether the result of an election was affected by certain illegal practices. If any elector was prevented from voting in an election on account of an error of, or omission by, an officer, the section prohibits the Court from admitting, for the purpose of determining whether the error or omission affected the result of the election, any evidence of the way in which the elector intended to vote in that election. Illegal practices and ss 362(3) and 365