Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Trading Post Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Trading Post Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1086

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Trading Post Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1086
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v TRADING POST AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 821 156) and GOOGLE INC
File number: NSD 1323 of 2007
Judge: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 22 September 2011
Corrigendum: 10 October 2011
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – on-line advertising – where provider of internet search engine published advertisements in the form of “sponsored links” displayed on search results page in response to search queries – whether provider of internet search engine engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive by failing to adequately distinguish between advertisements and organic search results – consideration of expression “sponsored link” –  whether provider of internet search engine made implied  representations that sponsored links were not advertisements – whether provider of internet search engine made implied  representations that sponsored links were organic search results – whether provider of internet search engine made implied representations that position of sponsored links on search results page was the result of their relative relevance to search queries as determined by the search engine – consideration of layout of search results page – consideration of relevant class of consumer – consideration of impact on ordinary and reasonable members of relevant class of consumer

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – on-line advertising – where advertisers sought to promote their goods or services by means of sponsored links on search results pages – where headline of sponsored link replicated third party’s business name, trade mark or website address – whether advertiser made implied representations of association or affiliation – consideration of relevant class of consumer – consideration of impact of sponsored links on ordinary and reasonable members of relevant class of consumer – whether representations conveyed were misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – whether search engine provider also made implied representations of association or affiliation by publishing sponsored links or by adopting or endorsing representations conveyed – significance of “keyword insertion” when used to generate headline which replicated terms of search query

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – on-line advertising – where provider of internet search engine published advertisements in the form of “sponsored links” displayed on search results pages in response to search queries – where sponsored links conveyed misleading and deceptive representations – whether search engine provider had a defence under s 85(3) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (the Act) – whether advertisements in the form of sponsored links were advertisements received by the search engine provider in the ordinary course of business – whether search engine provider knew or had reason to suspect that publication of advertisement would amount to contravention of s 52 of the Act – whether search engine provider could discharge onus of proof without showing that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Trading Pos... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1086
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against Trading Post Australia Pty Ltd and Google Inc, alleging misleading and deceptive conduct in the form of online advertising. The ACCC claimed that Google failed to adequately distinguish between sponsored links and organic search results, thereby misleading consumers into believing that sponsored links were organic results. The dispute centred on whether Google's conduct constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court had to determine if Google made implied representations that the sponsored links were not advertisements, that they were organic search results, and that their position on search results pages reflected their relevance to the search queries. The court also needed to consider the impact of Google's conduct on ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class of consumers.

The court found that Google did not contravene section 52 of the Trade Practices Act by failing to sufficiently distinguish advertisements from organic search results. The court held that ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class of consumers were likely to understand that sponsored links were advertisements, and therefore the positions of these links were determined by commercial arrangements between Google and advertisers. The court also found that Google did not make implied representations that the sponsored links were organic search results or that their positions reflected their relevance to search queries. The court further found that Trading Post contravened section 52 of the Act by publishing misleading and deceptive advertisements, including the Kloster Ford advertisement. Trading Post also contravened section 53(d) of the Act by falsely representing that it had an affiliation with Kloster Ford.

The court dismissed the case against Google and ordered Trading Post to pay a declaration and costs. The ACCC was ordered to pay Google's costs of the proceeding. The court also made orders to ensure that its reasons for judgment could be published without contravening any non-publication orders previously made.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. The fourth further amended application filed 1 April 2010 be otherwise dismissed.

4. The first respondent pay $28,000 to the applicant by way of agreed contribution to the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

5. The applicant pay the second respondent’s costs of the proceeding.

6. None of the orders previously made in this proceeding under s 50 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) shall prevent any person from publishing the whole or any part of these reasons for judgment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

The High Court’s statement of the test to be applied in determining whether a misleading or deceptive representation has been made to the general public or a section of the general public has been considered in a number of Full Court decisions: see, for example, National Exchange Pty Ltd v Australian Securities and Investment Commission (2004) 49 ACSR 369, Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd v .au Domain Administration Ltd (2004) 139 FCR 215. Those decisions recognise, consistently with what the High Court said, that the class of persons by reference to which the effect of the relevant conduct is to be assessed may be quite large. In particular, the relevant class may cover a wide range of people whose personal capacity, knowledge and experience may vary quite significantly. Nevertheless, all members of the relevant class are presumed to take reasonable care to protect their own interests and the behaviour of those who do not may be disregarded. What steps they may be expected to take in order to protect their own interests will depend upon the circumstances of the particular case. SOME BACKGROUND FINDINGS The principal witness called by Google was Mr Daniel Dulitz who has been employed by Google since 2000. His current job description is “Group Product Manager”. From 2000 to 2006 Mr Dulitz, who has academic qualifications in computer science, was involved with the computer programs that allow Google to generate automated search results. Since 2006 his responsibilities have included the “user interface” and “user experience” in relation to sponsored links appearing on search results pages that may appear along with organic search results in response to a search query. Mr Dulitz was cross-examined mostly, as I perceived it, with a view to having him explain or amplify aspects of his evidence. It is fair to say that his evidence was not the subject of any significant challenge. In any event, I found him to be an acceptable witness who was highly knowledgeable about the matters which were the subject of his evidence and quite careful in the way he went about giving it. Most of his evidence was uncontroversial. The following matters which, unless otherwise indicated, represent findings made by me, are largely based upon evidence given by Mr Dulitz. Google’s search engine The World Wide Web (web) is the vast system of linked documents accessed via the internet. It is difficult to provide an accurate estimate of the size of the web but it is likely to be made up of many billions of pages generated by millions of people and organisations across the world. Pages on the web vary substantially in content and nature. A person wishing to make available documents on the web specifies an address known as a “Uniform Resource Locator” (URL), which appears on the address window of a browser at the top of the screen. A browser is the software used to navigate the web (e.g. Microsoft Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox and Google Chrome). This software reads the address to locate the information made available by a website operator and deliver it to an end user.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Google also objected to evidence tendered by the ACCC which was relied upon by the ACCC in support of the allegation made in para 14(a) of the statement of claim which asserted that Google “… purported to rank search results on its results pages according to relative relevance …”. This evidence (the 14(a) evidence) is identified in Appendix I to the ACCC’s outline of closing submissions. The 14(a) evidence was received into evidence subject to Google’s objection that it was inadmissible hearsay and that, if not rejected on that basis , it should be rejected under s 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The 14(a) evidence included transcripts of recordings of statements made in 2000 by Sergey Brin, one of the two founders of Google, on the US game show “To Tell the Truth” and statements made by other senior officers and employees of Google during the course of various seminars and presentations. During the course of his appearance on “To Tell the Truth” Mr Brin apparently said that the reason why the Google search engine is so much better than its competitors is that “you find the best things first – the best answer is on top” and “we really return the most relevant results very quickly.” Statements by other officers and employees of Google that were relied upon by the ACCC included “users expect from Google that we give them the exact right thing every time” and “to be Google is to deliver the fastest answer to every question and be right.” The ACCC argued that the 14(a) evidence was not hearsay but that if it was then it was admissible under s 81 of the Evidence Act as evidence of statements that were admissions. The former argument was not developed in submissions but in relation to s 81 the 14(a) evidence was said to be “evidence of an admission in any circumstances where Google wishes to take the position that the statement is not correct or true”. In my opinion the 14(a) evidence is inadmissible as hearsay unless it is within the exception provided for in s 81. Whether or not it is within that exception depends, among other things, upon whether the relevant statements are adverse to Google’s interest in the outcome of this proceeding. Section 88 of the Evidence Act provides:For the purpose of determining whether evidence of an admission is admissible, the court is to find that a particular person made the admission if it is reasonably open to find that he or she made the admission. Since the 14(a) evidence has been received subject to Google’s objection there is no longer any advantage to be gained by asking whether it is reasonably open to me to find that Mr Brin or any of the other officers or employees made admissions. What I will do is admit the 14(a) evidence unconditionally but explain why I do not consider that it is of any assistance in determining whether or not Google contravened s 52 of the Act by failing to adequately distinguish sponsored links from organic search results. In closing submissions the ACCC made it clear that the search results referred to in para 14(a) are organic search results. It argued that the 14(a) evidence when read in conjunction with the evidence of Mr Dulitz would:… allow the Court to find that Google does purport to rank organic search results in order of relative relevance as pleaded by the ACCC and further achieves a remarkable degree of success in achieving same.Accepting that Google purports to rank organic search results in order of relative relevance, I cannot see what difference this could make to the outcome of the first part of the ACCC’s case. If Google purports to rank organic search results according to “relative relevance” it does not follow that sponsored links will be ranked according to “relative relevance” or that ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class would understand that they were ranked according to “relative relevance”. Once it is accepted that ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class are likely to understand that sponsored links are advertisements then it may be inferred that they will also understand that the positions occupied by sponsored links on results pages will be determined in whole or part by commercial arrangements between Google and the advertiser. CONFIDENTIALITY

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was evidence in this case that was, and remains, the subject of non-publication orders made under s 50 of the Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth). Having come to the view that it would be necessary for me to refer to parts of that evidence in my reasons (though not necessarily in detail), I gave the parties an opportunity to make submissions in relation to a form of order I proposed that would ensure that these reasons for judgment could be published by others without risk of contravening any of the s 50 orders previously made. The parties had no difficulty with me making the proposed order except in so far as it related to one matter which Google argued should be included in a confidential annexure to my reasons. Having considered Google’s arguments and further evidence from Mr Dulitz in relation to that matter, I am not persuaded that there will be any prejudice to the administration of justice in allowing the relevant evidence to be published in the manner provided for by the terms of the proposed order. CONCLUSION I am satisfied that there should be a declaration that Trading Post contravened s 52(1) of the Act by, in trade or commence, engaging in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive by publishing the Kloster Ford advertisement. This is on the basis that by publishing the Kloster Ford advertisement Trading Post made various representations which were misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in the respects that I have identified. I am also satisfied that Trading Post contravened s 53(d) of the Act by representing, contrary to the fact, that it had an affiliation with Kloster Ford. I will make declarations to that effect in appropriate terms. The case brought against Trading Post based upon its publication of the Charlestown Toyota advertisement has failed due to the evidentiary deficiencies that I have previously identified. I am not satisfied that Google contravened s 52 of the Act by failing to sufficiently distinguish advertisements (sponsored links) from organic search results on its search results pages. Nor am I satisfied that Google contravened s 52 of the Act by making any of the representations that the ACCC alleged Google made by the publication of the Kloster Ford advertisement, the Charlestown Toyota advertisement or any of the other advertisements about which the ACCC complained in this proceeding. There will be an order for costs as between the ACCC and Trading Post in the amount agreed between them before the trial. The ACCC should pay Google’s costs of the proceeding. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the principles and authorities regarding misleading or deceptive conduct as articulated in various Full Court decisions. The court determined the relevant class of consumers and assessed the impact of the advertisements on ordinary and reasonable members of that class. The court examined the distinction between sponsored links and organic search results, the use of expressions like "sponsored link", and whether Google made implied representations about the nature and ranking of sponsored links.

The court found that Trading Post engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by publishing the Kloster Ford advertisement, as it made various misleading or deceptive representations. The court found that Trading Post did not engage in misleading or deceptive conduct by publishing the Charlestown Toyota advertisement due to evidentiary deficiencies. The court held that Google did not contravene s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) by failing to sufficiently distinguish sponsored links from organic search results on its search results pages. The court also held that Google did not make the representations that the ACCC alleged it made by the publication of the Kloster Ford advertisement, the Charlestown Toyota advertisement or any of the other advertisements about which the ACCC complained.

The court considered whether Google had a defence under s 85(3) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and found that Google did not have such a defence. The court also examined the admissibility of certain evidence tendered by the ACCC, concluding that it was not of assistance in determining whether Google contravened s 52 of the Act.

The binding legal principle established by the decision is that the class of consumers by reference to which the effect of misleading or deceptive conduct is assessed may be quite large and that the behaviour of those who do not take reasonable care to protect their own interests may be disregarded. The court distinguished between sponsored links and organic search results and found that ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class would understand that sponsored links are advertisements and their positions on results pages are determined in whole or part by commercial arrangements between Google and the advertiser.