Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PRK Corporation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PRK Corporation Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 715

TRADE PRACTICES – claims of contravention of s 45(2) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – determination of pecuniary penalty under s 76 – parties jointly proposing to Court amount of penalty – need for general and specific deterrence – public interest factors which underlie the non-litigious resolution of enforcement proceedings – Court will have regard to the views of the regulators – whether proposed penalty falls within “permissible range” – pecuniary penalty ordered in terms agreed.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 45, 76, 88

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Limited (2001) ATPR ¶41-815 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 3) (2005) 215 ALR 301 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Midland Brick Co Pty Ltd (2004) 207 ALR 329 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Qantas Airways Ltd (2008) 253 ALR 89 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Industry Holdings Pty Limited (No 3) (2007) ATPR ¶42-185 referred to
Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd (2004) ATPR ¶41-993 applied
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285 applied
Trade Practices Commission v CSR Limited (1991) ATPR ¶41-076 referred to
Trade Practices Commission v Mobil Oil Australia Ltd (1984) 4 FCR 296 referred to
Trade Practices Commission v TNT Australia Pty Limited (1994)] ATPR ¶41-375 referred to

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v  PRK CORPORATION PTY LTD (FORMERLY KNOWN AS PRK CORPORATION LIMITED AND ALSO FORMERLY KNOWN AS TOLL (PRK) LIMITED AND AS PATRICK CORPORATION LIMITED AND AS LANG CORPORATION LIMITED) ACN 008 660 124, PATRICK STEVEDORES HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED ACN 060 462 919, PATRICK STEVEDORES OPERATIONS PTY LIMITED ACN 065 375 840, PATRICK STEVEDORES OPERATIONS NO 2 PTY LIMITED ACN 056 292 687, PLZEN PTY LIMITED ACN 065 905 571,  DP WORLD HOLDINGS (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS P&O AUSTRALIA LTD) ACN 000 282 977, DP WORLD AUSTRALIA LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS P&O PORTS LIMITED) ACN 000 049 301, P&O WHARF MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 100 737 264, AUSTRALIAN AMALGAMATED TERMINALS PTY LIMITED ACN 098 458 229, CHRISTOPHER CORRIGAN, DONALD SMITHWICK, ANDREW BURGESS and TIMOTHY BLOOD

NSD 1703 of 2007

JACOBSON J
3 JULY 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1703 of 2007

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

PRK CORPORATION PTY LTD (FORMERLY KNOWN AS PRK CORPORATION LIMITED AND ALSO FORMERLY KNOWN AS TOLL (PRK) LIMITED AND AS PATRICK CORPORATION LIMITED AND AS LANG CORPORATION LIMITED) ACN 008 660 124
First Respondent

PATRICK STEVEDORES HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED ACN 060 462 919
Second Respondent

PATRICK STEVEDORES OPERATIONS PTY LIMITED ACN 065 375 840
Third Respondent

PATRICK STEVEDORES OPERATIONS NO 2 PTY LIMITED ACN 056 292 687
Fourth Respondent

PLZEN PTY LIMITED ACN 065 905 571
Fifth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PRK Corpora... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 715
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against several respondents, including Patrick Stevedores, P&O, and others, alleging contraventions of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The central issue was whether the respondents engaged in conduct that substantially lessened competition in automotive terminal services markets in Brisbane, Sydney, and Melbourne. The respondents admitted that their conduct likely had the effect of substantially lessening competition, but they did not admit to the actual effect on competition or the purpose of their conduct.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine the appropriate pecuniary penalties to be imposed on the respondents for their admitted conduct. The court had to consider several factors in deciding the penalty, including the gravity of the contravention, the degree of culpability, and the need for deterrence and punishment. The court also needed to consider the agreed submissions on penalty made by the ACCC, Patrick, and P&O, which emphasized the importance of deterrence and the lack of any punitive element due to the absence of flagrant or wilful contravention.

The court found that the respondents' conduct, which lasted for 14 months and involved forming a joint venture to operate automotive terminals, was openly conducted and known in the market. The respondents admitted that their conduct likely had the effect of substantially lessening competition. The court noted that the respondents had cooperated with the ACCC, made significant admissions, and supported the authorisation process for their joint venture, resulting in savings in court time and resources. The court also considered the financial circumstances of the respondents, their culture of compliance, and the lack of any prior contraventions of the Act.

Based on these considerations, the court imposed penalties on the respondents. Patrick Stevedores and P&O were ordered to pay a total penalty of $1.9 million each, to be paid in instalments. The court also ordered a contribution towards the ACCC's costs. The proceedings against certain other respondents were dismissed with or without prejudice. The court did not make any findings regarding the actual effect on competition or the purpose of the conduct, as these matters were to be determined in the authorisation process.

Orders

Orders of the court

FIRST TO FIFTH RESPONDENTS

1. The Second Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia in four equal instalments within 1 month, 6 months, 12 months and 18 months of the making of this order respectively, a pecuniary penalty in the total amount of $1,900,000 in respect of contraventions of sections 45(2)(a)(ii) and 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“Act”), in that the Second Respondent between September 2001 and November 2002 made and gave effect to an arrangement with a competitor in the markets for automotive terminal services which contained provisions that:

(a) they would seek to establish and operate automotive terminals jointly in certain ports in Australia; and

(b) to that end, they would form an incorporated joint venture, which subsequently became known as Australian Amalgamated Terminals Pty Ltd,

(“Arrangement”) which provisions were, as at November 2002, likely to have had the effect of substantially lessening competition in such markets, within the meaning of sections 45(2)(a)(ii) and 45(2)(b)(ii)of the Act.

2. The First to Fifth Respondents collectively pay to the Applicant in four equal instalments, at the time of the payments under Order 1 of these orders, a contribution towards its costs of and incidental to these proceedings, in the total amount of $100,000.

3. The proceedings be dismissed against the First to Fifth Respondents.

The Court notes that:

4. The First to Fifth Respondents make no admissions regarding, and the Court makes no findings in respect of, the actual effect on competition in any market of the provisions of the Arrangement referred to in Order 1.

SIXTH TO EIGHTH RESPONDENTS

5. The Seventh Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia, within twenty eight (28) days of the making of this order, a pecuniary penalty in the total amount of $1,900,000 in respect of contraventions of sections 45(2)(a)(ii) and 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act, in that the Seventh Respondent between September 2001 and November 2002 made and gave effect to an arrangement with a competitor in the markets for automotive terminal services which contained provisions that:

(a) they would seek to establish and operate automotive terminals jointly in certain ports in Australia; and

(b) to that end, they would form an incorporated joint venture, which subsequently became known as Australian Amalgamated Terminals Pty Ltd,

(“Arrangement”) which provisions were, as at November 2002, likely to have had the effect of substantially lessening competition in such markets, within the meaning of sections 45(2)(a)(ii) and 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.

6. The Seventh Respondent pay to the Applicant at the time of the payment under Order 5 of these orders, a contribution towards its costs of and incidental to these proceedings, in the total amount of $100,000.

7. The proceedings be dismissed against the Sixth to Eighth Respondents with prejudice to the Applicant’s rights in relation to all contraventions alleged against the Sixth to Eighth Respondents in these proceedings.

The Court notes that:

8. The Sixth to Eighth Respondents make no admissions regarding, and the Court makes no findings in respect of, the actual effect on competition in any market of the provisions of the Arrangement referred to in Order 5.

UPON THE MAKING OF ORDERS 1 – 3 AND 5 – 7 ABOVE:

TENTH TO THIRTEENTH RESPONDENTS

9. The proceedings against each of the Tenth to Thirteenth Respondents be dismissed.

10. The Applicant and each of the Tenth to Thirteenth Respondents bear their own costs of the proceedings.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Nor is any penalty proposed against Mr Corrigan and the other directors in respect of their alleged involvement in the contraventions. The proposed orders in respect of the individual respondents is that the proceedings against them will be dismissed, so long as I am prepared to make the orders for pecuniary penalties against the relevant corporate respondents in the amounts stated above.THE AGREED STATEMENT OF FACTS AND JOINT SUBMISSION I have been provided with a document entitled “Agreed Statement of Facts and Joint Submission between the Applicant and the First to Eighth Respondents”. The Statement of Facts was provided to me in accordance with s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The facts which are agreed to in the document, and the admissions made in it, are agreed to have been made for the purpose of these proceedings only. The substance of the Agreed Statement of Facts is that Patrick and P&O admit that from about August 2001, they made various plans to provide access to each other’s automotive terminal services at the ports of Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne and to form a joint venture for the shared conduct of those facilities at the three ports, as well as others in Australia. Patrick and P&O also admit that during the period of about 14 months in which the arrangements between them were in place, they took steps to give effect to their plans. In particular, in October 2001, they jointly lodged a tender on behalf of the proposed joint venture to lease land at Glebe Island, in the port of Sydney, for the purpose of operating an automotive terminal from that land. The joint tender was successful and, in December 2002, AAT entered into a ten year lease of the land at Glebe Island. In [4] of the Agreed Statement of Facts, Patrick and P&O admit, for the purpose of these proceedings, that the conduct they engaged in, as described in more detail in the document, had the likely effect of substantially lessening competition in automotive terminal services markets in Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne. However, no admissions are made by either Patrick or P&O as to the purpose or actual effect on competition of their conduct. AAT now operates terminals in Melbourne, Brisbane and Port Kembla. The parties have agreed that any effect on competition of the continuing conduct of AAT, and any public benefit arising from that conduct, is to be dealt with through the authorisation process under Part VII of the Act. The Agreed Statement of Facts contains a description of the companies comprising the Patrick Respondents and the P&O Respondents. It includes brief details of the takeover in 2006 of the First Respondent (then known as Patrick Corporation Limited) by Toll Holdings Limited (“Toll”) and the subsequent restructure of Toll. The effect of the restructure of Toll has some bearing on this matter because the second to fifth respondents are now a subsidiary of Asciano Limited (“Asciano”). Confidential evidence was tendered before me as to the financial pressures affecting Asciano in order to explain the instalment regime for the pecuniary penalty to be paid by Patrick Stevedores.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JACOBSON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JACOBSON J

In answering that question, it is open to me to commence with the amount of the proposed penalties and then determine whether they fall within the permissible range. Alternatively, it would be permissible to address the appropriate range independently and then determine whether the proposed penalty falls within that range: Mobil Oil (2004) ATPR ¶41-993 at [54].THE PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONS ON MATTERS RELEVANT TO CONSIDERATION OF PENALTY It is convenient to set out in full the content of [55] – [58] and [76] – [106] of the Joint Submissions.55.As noted at paragraph 5 above, an important component of the proposed resolution of these proceedings is the lodgement by AAT of the authorisation application pursuant to s88 of the Act. This is the first occasion on which a court has been required to decide upon the appropriate penalty in such circumstances. In the unusual circumstances of this case, the Commission, Patrick and P&O jointly submit that the primary reason for imposition of the penalty sought in this case is, by way of general deterrence, to deter corporations from risking contraventions of the Act which may otherwise obtain the benefit of an authorisation from the Commission, whether with or without conditions.56.Patrick and P&O could have sought authorisation for the Arrangement during the relevant period. Patrick and P&O accept that they ought to have sought an authorisation from the Commission for the Arrangement so as to avoid risking contravention of the Act. On the other hand, the Commission accepts that, whilst the terms of the Arrangement were not provided to it for scrutiny in the context of an application for authorisation, it is relevant on the issue of penalty that the conduct did not result from a secret, collusive agreement. 57.In these circumstances, general deterrence will be served by the penalty proposed to be imposed upon the Second and Seventh Respondents, who were directly involved in the conduct at the relevant time.58.It is submitted that no punitive element is warranted in the penalty awarded by the Court, as there has been no flagrant or wilful contravention of the Act by Patrick, P&O or any related body corporate.…76.The conduct which is subject to penalty was engaged in by Patrick and P&O over a period of 14 months, approximately seven to eight years ago. It comprised an agreement between Patrick and P&O to rationalise automotive terminal infrastructure, including by the formation of a joint venture company to provide automotive terminal services in each of the three ports. The three ports constitute the main Australian destinations for importation of motor vehicles.77.Patrick and P&O intended to make the Arrangement, proceeded to do so and to give effect to it. 78.The volume of commerce, measured by gross sales revenue over the relevant period in the markets affected by the conduct in question, cannot be accurately calculated by Patrick by reference to its audited accounts for the relevant period because Patrick compiled those accounts on an aggregated basis for its whole stevedoring business of which automotive stevedoring was a small proportion. On the basis of the aggregated information contained in its management accounts for the financial year 2001/2002 for its automotive, bulk and general stevedoring division, Patrick estimates that total gross revenue for automotive stevedoring services in the three ports did not exceed approximately $15 million for that financial year.79.Similarly P&O did not during the relevant period keep accounting records which adequately identified revenues from its automotive stevedoring businesses for each of the three ports. No accounts were kept separately for “automotive terminals” or “automotive stevedoring” businesses. For the years ended 31 December 2001 and 31 December 2002 P&O estimates that total revenues from its automotive terminal and stevedoring businesses for the three ports were $14 million and $15 million respectively. 80.Whilst the conduct had the likely effect of substantially lessening competition in the relevant terminal services markets, the Commission accepts, for the purpose of these proceedings only, that the objectives of Patrick and P&O in entering the Arrangement were likely to have included increasing efficiencies by gaining access to scarce port land and the superior terminal in each port, and improving utilisation of that land. The increased capacity of the joint venture to invest in infrastructure, due to the increased volume of business, was also harnessed. In this respect, regard was had by Patrick and P&O to the desire of the Sydney Ports Corporation and the Port of Brisbane Corporation to have one automotive terminal only, with a view to achieving such efficiencies.81.The Commission’s case was that the conduct of Patrick and P&O, including the creation of AAT, led to a substantial lessening of competition in terminal services markets in each of the three ports. 82.On this issue, the Commission’s position was (and remains) that whether the impugned conduct led to the gaining of efficiencies or other public benefits is irrelevant to whether or not there had been a substantial lessening of competition in relevant terminal services markets for the purposes of s45 of the Act. Rather, those matters are only able to be brought to account in the context of an authorisation application made under Part VII of the Act. 83.On the other hand, Patrick and P&O proposed to lead evidence that the relevant markets were no less competitive in future with the impugned conduct than without the impugned conduct, and argue that the operations of AAT resulted in increased efficiencies to customers, being shipping lines and importers, and stevedores (including potentially third party stevedores). Further, they contend that, to the extent such efficiencies could be established, they should be taken into account in the determination of whether or not there had been a substantial lessening of competition in the relevant terminal services markets. 84.The resolution of the proceedings in the manner the Commission, Patrick and P&O propose leaves to the authorisation process currently underway the determination of the question of whether any lessening of competition arising from the operations of AAT (at least in the future) is outweighed by any public benefits able to be established (including any efficiencies). There is no dispute between the Commission, Patrick and P&O that these matters can properly be raised in the authorisation process.85.Patrick and P&O do not admit that the conduct in fact affected competition in contravention of the Act. Rather it has been admitted that the conduct had the likely effect of affecting competition substantially, as at November 2002. In the proposed resolution of these proceedings, the other allegations in the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim will be dismissed, and accordingly it is not necessary for the Court to consider the purpose or actual effect on competition in any market of the conduct, nor any conduct occurring after November 2002.The Amount of Loss or Damage Caused86.The Commission, Patrick and P&O jointly submit that it is not possible to determine whether any quantifiable loss or damage was caused by the impugned conduct. 87.P&O and Patrick admit only that the Arrangement was likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in the terminal services market and do not admit that it had the effect of causing loss or damage. The Circumstances in which the Conduct took Place88.The conduct was not clandestine. It was openly conducted between the parties, and was known in the market to have occurred, by customers of Patrick and P&O, the relevant ports corporations, and competitors, such as Toll. Customers were informed of the Arrangement at the time the Arrangement was first contemplated by Patrick and P&O.Degree of power, market share and ease of entry into the terminal services markets89.Approximately 70% of motor vehicles sold in Australia were imported and 85% of those imported motor vehicles were delivered through the three ports.90.In the ports of Sydney and Brisbane, Patrick and P&O were the sole providers of automotive terminal services. In the port of Melbourne, Patrick and Toll were the main providers of automotive terminal services.91.As noted at paragraph 17 above, there were substantial barriers to entry into each of the terminal services markets.The size and financial circumstances of the Contraveners92.The Second Respondent is a subsidiary of Asciano, a publicly listed company of some size and repute.93.The Second Respondent has made a separate submission, which includes some confidential material, which relates to the financial circumstances of the corporate group of which the Second Respondent is a member.94.The Sixth to Eighth Respondents are each ultimate subsidiaries of DP World Ltd which is a substantial listed company in Dubai conducting a container terminal business worldwide.Participation of Senior Management95.The conduct admitted by Patrick and P&O was carried out by senior management employed at the relevant time. None of the individual executives involved in the conduct remain in the employ of Patrick, or any of the Asciano owned group of companies, or any of the P&O companies owned by DP World. None of the current directors of Asciano were directors of Patrick at the relevant time.96.Asciano’s ownership of Patrick arose from a hostile public company take-over by Toll, and accordingly Toll was not in a position to perform due diligence on the target companies, the First to Fifth Respondents, or to satisfy itself about the compliance with the Act of any of the terms of any arrangements entered into by those companies. 97.It is acknowledged that some shareholders in Asciano may have held shareholdings in the Respondents during the relevant period. For the most part however, the current shareholders in Asciano are public shareholders, whose investment in Asciano would be diminished by reason of the award of any substantial penalty against Patrick.98.The shareholders of P&O are now completely different to those at the relevant time as set out in paragraphs 11 to 13 above.Culture of Compliance with the Trade Practices Act99.Asciano retains specialist external legal counsel to conduct trade practices training with its staff on an annual basis and requires all relevant staff, including managers and directors, to attend such training. Training materials are supplied to staff which includes material relevant to compliance with Part IV of the Act generally, as well as in relation to the type of conduct the subject of these proceedings and the availability of authorisation under s88 of anti-competitive conduct on public interest grounds.100.The DP World group had no involvement in these alleged contraventions or knowledge about them prior to the Commission commencing its investigation of the matter. 101.The DP World corporate respondents, and the DP World Group generally, have taken considerable steps to co-operate with the Commission and have sought to deal with the Commission in an open manner. For example, DP World proactively approached the Commission to bring to a close the long standing Section 155 investigation regarding the container terminal landside interface. DP World has since made considerable efforts to advise the Commission of developments in the container terminal landside interface bearing in mind the various State Government and Port Authority initiatives.102.The DP World respondents have a corporate culture conducive to compliance with the Act. This is evidenced by DP World providing training to both senior management and compliance training at each of its terminals in 2008 for all personnel likely to be involved in those areas considered appropriate (especially the landside interface). DP World’s senior management and its worldwide legal counsel have made it clear to DP World in Australia they wish DP World to engage with the Commission to improve the level of communication.Co-operation and Contrition103.These admissions have been made well before hearing of the matter, and accordingly will result in a significant saving in court time, and costs and expense to the Commission in continuing to pursue the matter through the courts.104.Patrick and P&O, as shareholders in AAT, support AAT pursuing its application for authorisation of AAT pursuant to section 88 of the Act, and will incur further costs during that process.105.The Commission accepts that the decision of Patrick and P&O to agree to resolve these proceedings in this way has saved considerable Court time and Commission resources. Similar Conduct in the Past106.The Court has not previously found that any of Patrick, Asciano, P&O or DP World have contravened the Act. CONSIDERATION